Archives for category: Teach for America TFA

The Wisconsin legislature allocated $1million to pay Teach for America to send 70 we teachers to Wisconsin schools.

It gets tiresome to say this again and again: Teach for America is a wealthy organization that sends ill-trained recruits to teach in under-resourced districts. These poorly trained young people, with no experience as teachers and no commitment to stay beyond two years, are expected to work wonders. They don’t.

Why does TFA charge districts anything? It has $300 million in assets. Is it renting out the kids? Selling them? Auctioning them off?

In a rare setback for Teach for America, Governor Mark Dayton vetoed an appropriation to fund more TFA recruits in the state. Minnesota has a small number of TFA corps members, but the governor questioned why the state should underwrite the wealthy organization to supply ill-trained teachers who don’t plan to stay on the job.

As Teach for America expands into a global marketplace, EduShyster compares Koppitalism to Late Capitalism. What do they have in common? How hard is it to bring Excellence to everyone in the world?

In this post marking the one-year anniversary of her blog, EduShyster interviews herself.

She answers such pressing questions as:

Do you really consume wine by the box?

Will the education reform movement survive the coming Zombie apocalypse? (I promise you will love this one, especially the illustration.)

If you were an education reform group, which one would you be? (Love the photo.)

Gary Rubinstein was one of a small group of TFA alums invited to meet with the new leaders of the organization, who took over as Wendy Kopp took charge of TFA’s international program.

Gary was surprised to hear that others echoed his criticisms of the organization. Gary believes that the education reform movement is nearing its end, as the public and the media realize that their ideas consistently fail.

A good discussion.

Why did Wendy Kopp hail Philadelphia’s “progress” on the same day that the state-run School Reform Commission slashed the city’s public school budget to the bone, eliminating librarians, arts programs, athletics, and counselors, stripping bare an impoverished district? Maybe she was confused. Or misinformed. Or maybe she meant it.

Kopp quickly apologized but Philadelphia journalist Daniel Denvir thinks it was no accident. He sees the same kind of thinking displayed daily in the acts of PennCAN, the spinoff of the privatization group called ConnCAN, then 50CAN. These groups are “flush with cash,” although the students and families of Philadelphia are not.

He says, “The doomsday budget is morally unacceptable. It must become politically impossible.”

Arthur Goldstein is at his satirical best as he paints a darkly outrageous vision of the future, after the testing and privatization movement has finally achieved all its goals.

All the teachers have been fired (except for the Gates-funded “Educators for Excellence”), charter operators have taken over the New York City school system,, and Walmart happily trains all the students who couldn’t pass those rigorous new tests. And the new mayor eliminates term limits and elections.

Teach for America began with a worthy goal: to supply bright, idealistic college graduates to serve in poor children in urban and rural districts.

But then it evolved into something with grand ambitions: to groom the leaders who would one day control American education.

This article describes the little-known political arm of TFA. TFA alums have begun the long march through the institutions, and the organization’s political goals are clear.

James Cersonsky, the article’s author, foresees “a massive proliferation” of Michelle Rhees, and wonders whether the political arm of TFA might actually be “the Trojan horse of the privatization of public education.”

Leslie T. Fenwick, dean of education at Howard University, argues that what is called school “reform” is really about urban land development, not about improving the lives of disadvantaged minority children. She says, follow the money to understand the “reforms.”

Dean Fenwick doesn’t mince words. She writes:

“The truth can be used to tell a lie. The truth is that black parents’ frustration with the quality of public schools is at an all time righteous high. Though black and white parents’ commitment to their child’s schooling is comparable, more black parents report dissatisfaction with the school their child attends. Approximately 90 percent of black and white parents report attending parent teacher association meetings and nearly 80 percent of black and white parents report attending teacher conferences. Despite these similarities, fewer black parents (47 percent) than white parents (64 percent) report being very satisfied with the school their child attends. This dissatisfaction among black parents is so whether these parents are college-educated, high income, or poor.

“The lie is that schemes like Teach For America, charter schools backed by venture capitalists, education management organizations (EMOs), and Broad Foundation-prepared superintendents address black parents concerns about the quality of public schools for their children. These schemes are not designed to cure what ails under-performing schools. They are designed to shift tax dollars away from schools serving black and poor students; displace authentic black educational leadership; and erode national commitment to the ideal of public education.”

What is needed to change the stagnant status quo? Read the article.

Wendy Kopp stepped aside as CEO of Teach for America and will devote her time to leading the new international arm of TFA, an allied organization called Teach for All.

Teach for All will bring the TFA model to nations around the world.

Here, Gary Rubinstein checks out the personae of her successors.

One he calls the “bad Wendy Kopp,” the other he calls the “good Wendy Kopp.”

Read the tweets he collected. Tweets are often more telling about a person (if he or she writes their own) than long dissertations.