Archives for category: Students

Sheila Kaplan’s organization “Education New York & Information Policy Watch” is zealously devoted to protecting the privacy rights of students.

In response to a post about whether the U.S. Department of Education was overreaching with the latest expansion of its regulatory power, she sent the following comment:

The US Department of Education is overreaching in more than one area. This is why EPIC is suing US ED under APA. EPIC v US ED:http://educationnewyork.com/files/1-main.pdf EPIC v US ED motion:http://educationnewyork.com/files/11-main_epic_USED.pdf

What is this about? The U.S. Department of Education unilaterally rewrote the regulations governing the release of information about individual students. Their right to privacy was eroded, the lawsuit says, without Congressional hearings or legislation or oversight.

As Kaplan writes on her website, “EPIC has filed a lawsuit under the Administrative Procedure Act against the Department of Education. EPIC’s lawsuit argues that the agency’s December 2011 regulations amending the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act exceed the agency’s statutory authority, and are contrary to law. The agency issued the revised regulations despite the fact that ‘numerous commenters . . . believe the Department lacks the statutory authority to promulgate the proposed regulations.'”

What’s with this administration? What’s their goal? How does it improve education if student information is made available to marketers and snoopers? Why the obsession with data? Why doesn’t Congress rein in this out-of-control federal agency?

Our education leaders are in love with ideas that are proven not to work and they ignore evidence that their preferred strategies don’t work.

After a decade of No Child Left Behind, Congress won’t admit that it failed. There are still many millions of children left behind–not “no child”–yet Congress can’t bring itself to ditch its failed program. 

Every day brings new evidence that the policies of Race to the Top are hardly different from those of NCLB. They rely on the same strategies of testing, punishment, and choice, with an added dollop of privatization. Why is a Democratic administration so devoted to a Republican policy agenda? Why is a Democratic administration even more devoted to privatization than NCLB?

If we ever come to our senses, there is a better way. Our policymakers decided to treat schools as totally separate from society, to ignore the social and economic conditions that affect student performance. This is wrong. Here is a nice summary of policies that have worked wherever they were tried, but are ignored by our leaders. The formula is simple: Improve the lives of children, and their academic performance will improve.

When will they wake up? When will Arne Duncan and President Obama and the governors and legislators and state chiefs and mayors wake up? When will Stand for Children start standing for children? When will StudentsFirst actually put students first, not teachers last? When will the education reformers realize that schools and society are intertwined?

I have posted a few times about the importance of stability. This is because we have public officials in Washington and in the states, as well as think tank pundits, who think it is a good idea to close schools, open schools, repeat again and again, fire teachers and principals and call it a “turnaround.” They disregard the issue of stability. They think that churn of staff and disruption of schools are “reforms.” That’s because they think of students as cogs or widgets or inanimate objects that can be moved about at will.

Another teacher explains why stability matters to his students:

“…my students need stability.”  And so do mine, especially when they come from home environments and situations that are in a constant state of insecurity over the basic necessities of food, clothing, shelter, medical care, and legal and/or custody issues.  For many of my students, school provides an oasis of caring that makes it possible for them to learn, and may just be the best seven hours of their day.  At school they are assured of breakfast, lunch, access to school-based health care, and supervision and instruction from a committed faculty and staff with deep roots in the community, from the time the bus picks them up in the morning until they are safely returned in the afternoon.  Along with knowing all the established routines and unwritten subtleties that go into operating our school on a daily basis, we also know our children – their strengths, needs, personalities, families, who they can or can’t work with, what strategies do or don’t work for them, and we monitor and adjust as necessary to promote their continued growth while ensuring their safety and stability.  We are a village and we’re doing a pretty good job raising our children to become competent and caring citizens because we know and value the difference between human capital and human beings.

A reader sent the following notice. I often correspond with Nikhil Goyal, whom I met on Twitter.

If these young people raise their voices and rally their peers, they can drive the conversation and stop the obsession with testing and the monetizing of schooling.

Please join the Webinar to talk to them and give them encouragement.

I am glad to see students participation in the education process because after all, it is THEIR future.  I believe the students in America’s schools deserve a much stronger voice in their own education.

Today, teacher moderators will host the Save Our Schools Student Voice Webinar entitled:

Elevating Student Voices: Sparking the Movement for OUR Future.

The SOS Webinar takes place this evening at 9:00 pm EDT | 6 pm PT.  Folks can register for the webinar and read more about it here:

http://saveourschoolsmarch.com/issues/webinars-featured-future-past/webinar-elevating-student-voices-sparking-movement/

During the webinar three students will share their roles as activists, authors, and speakers about how they are elevating student voices to spark a movement.  The three students include:

Nikhil Goyal • Lobbyist for the Students!

“At age 17, Nikhil Goyal is the author of All Hands on Deck: Why America Needs a Learning Revolution to be published September 6, 2012 by Alternative Education Resource Organization. His articles have appeared in the New York Times, NBC, Huffington Post, and Edutopia. Nikhil has spoken to thousands at conferences and TEDx events around the world from Qatar to Spain.”

Zak Malamed • An Education Reform Leader!

“Zak Malamed is an 18 year old advocate for the student voice in education policy. He considers himself to be both a political and social activist who is passion driven. Recently, he founded the #stuvoice Twitter chat to promote the students’ perspective in education. Zak was president of his high school’s Student Government in and has held many other leadership roles as both a student advocate and a student leader. He looks forward to pursuing a career in public service and hopes to see that track begin as we collaborate to re-imagine the way we learn.”

Stephanie Rivera • A Future Classroom Teacher, Current Cyberspace Teacher

“Stephanie Rivera is a 20 year old student studying English and Education at Rutgers University. She is a high school mentor, teacher assistant, future teacher, and runs her own blog at Teacher Under Construction. Her work includes elevating student voices, working towards recreating a nation where the term “at-risk” is no longer a term associated with the term “school,” and ultimately empowering future world changers.”

In addition, two adults who have activist goals related directly to students will join us.

Robert Applebaum • Founder of Forgive Student Loan Debt

“Robert Applebaum is an attorney from Staten Island, NY and the founder of ForgiveStudentLoanDebt.com. Rob is a 1998 graduate of Fordham University School of Law and, thereafter, he served as an Assistant District Attorney in Brooklyn, N.Y. between 1999 and 2004. After 5 years of service as an ADA, because of his exponentially increasing student loan debt, Applebaum made the unfortunate decision to leave a public service job he loved for the private sector, where he remained for the next 5 years.

In late January, 2009, frustrated with countless bailouts of the very institutions responsible for the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression, news of lavish vacations, exorbitant bonuses and office redecorations, Robert Applebaum authored an essay entitled which he posted to Facebook Group by the same name. Due to the overwhelming popularity of the Facebook group, Mr. Applebaum founded ForgiveStudentLoanDebt.com so as to advocate for both current and former students struggling under massive amounts of student loan debt.

Applebaum’s petition on the White House’s “We the People” site, which garnered over 32,000 signatures, resulted in a direct response from the Obama Administration when they unveiled the “Pay As You Earn” initiative in October, 2011.

Rob’s most recent petition on SignOn.org, in favor of H.R. 4170, The Student Loan Forgiveness Act of 2012, has over 950,000 signatures and is on track to reach a million signatures.

Robert Applebaum has written on the topic of student loan debt for The New York Times, Salon.com, The Guardian and The Hill. He has been featured in BusinessWeek, The Economist, U.S. News & World Report, The Huffington Post, and The Washington Post, Now on PBS, Nightly Business Report, RT America, PBS NewsHour and Default: The Student Loan Documentary.”

Rick Roach •  Orange County School Board Member

“Judge Rick Roach was elected to the Orange County, Florida School Board in November 1998 and was re-elected to a fourth term in 2010. He has been a resident of Orange County for thirty years. He holds a bachelor of science degree in education and master of arts degree in education and educational psychology. Recently, Roach became known for his prowess; he assessed the standardized assessment test, commonly known as the FCAT. Rick’s study led him to ask Are low FCAT Scores the Tests Fault? Roach was a teacher, counselor and coach in Orange County for 14 years. For the last 25 years he has trained over 18,000 educators in classroom management and course delivery skills in six eastern states. Roach serves on the board of the Orange County Foundation.”

These panelists will discuss several topics that impact students in America’s school due to education reform.

Here is what is happening across America: [ co-authored by Susan DuFresne and Stephanie Rivera ]

“Across the globe, students are engaging in activist movements against corporate education reforms: Chile, Spain, Greece, Canada, UK, and now… America.

Students of all ages in America are feeling the pressures of these reforms. With their futures in the hands of corporate reformers, students are realizing they have the power to take it back. Students are waking up and demanding that their voices are heard. It is their education, their lives, their futures, and they are making sure they have a say in it. Thus far in 2012, over 150 student protests have taken place in the United States. Students have protested against standardized testing, loss of teachers, lack of resources, student loan debt—and these are just to name a few.

As America’s students begin their own movement, students are realizing how critical it is to not delay on taking action. They are realizing how imperative it is to come together as one unifying voice. With this awakening, students are on their way to organizing a national movement for their education.

Under the current system, students’ creativity and love for learning is being drowned by the corporate reformer’s demands. Months of their lives are spent either in test-prep or testing in a system designed for failure. Students are losing interest in school, interest in learning, and being discouraged about their future as corporate reformers demand results, looking at students as if they were machines rather than humans.

These demands create disparity among students and future generations, at all levels of education. Students are at loss in determining the value of school. We as humans have an innate drive for knowledge and discovery, if students can’t find these in their classrooms, then where can they? The lowering value of school leads to increase of dropouts, which inevitably leads to minimum-wage jobs, or victims of school-to-prison pipeline. Yet, regardless of the equation that led them there, it is still considered the students’ fault.

Students are labeled failures through high-stakes testing, leaving them with a narrowed curriculum — absent of the arts, sports, electives, or vocational courses. The narrowed curriculum and time spent teaching to the test often leave many students in the dust. Without social studies, civics, and history being taught at every grade level, the very fabric of our democracy is at stake.

In addition, Corporate Education Reformers are pushing for Charter schools, claiming they are the ultimate solution to saving our students. Yet, these schools frequently marginalize students by using a lottery system and selecting out students by race, class, ability, gender, and language creating a two-tiered system of injustice. As a result, our current schools are now more segregated than prior to the 1950′s.

Students are realizing the cause and responsibility of these issues lies squarely on the doorstep of Corporate Education Reformers.

The panel will tell you how you can join us to create a movement that will stop this corporate take-over of public education and lift the burden of student loan debt, all via student activism and partnerships with all stakeholders.

Again, we invite you to join us in our Save Our Schools Webinar: Elevating Student Voices: Sparking the Movement for OUR Future. Never before, have America’s students asked so much of one another. Clearly, now is the time for America’s student to take a part in creating the future of their own educations.

These dynamic guests — in our Save Our Schools Webinar: Elevating Student Voices: Sparking the Movement for OUR Future — ask you to join them to empower and elevate student voices, to spark a movement built by students — for students, and for the future of democracy in America.

Join us for our webinar and join these students in building America’s student movement giving students a voice.”

A reader responds to an earlier post about a school in the Bronx that uses data to help students, not to punish teachers and students, and notes in passing the spurious claim of “reformers” that poverty is “just an excuse” or that great teachers alone can overcome poverty:

This is a great story. We try to do similar things at our school. I know we are not alone, but it is probably not the norm. Sometimes we are successful and sometimes not so much. When you work with students in poverty it becomes a necessity. Its the part that happens behind the scenes, outside of the classroom walls. That’s the part that the Ed deformers don’t discuss. Incarcerated parents, high transiency rates, truancy, students with mental health issues, just to name a few. We collaborate with health care, law enforcement, truancy officers, social services, etc. In this environment of budget cuts, those support systems are becoming more scarce. I rarely have come across parents who don’t care, but many have extremely limited resources. As long as the effects of poverty are excluded from the education reform conversation, the achievement gap will continue to widen along SES lines. We have many students in poverty who are successful, but those who struggle with the family issues mentioned earlier are a huge drain on school resources. Thanks for showing the broader picture that is not told by test scores and value added measures. Teachers in classrooms can be  highly effective, but without a broader support system these students often take the path of the twin brother in the video. These students will continue to show up in our public school classrooms. It is our ethical duty to do our best to keep them in school. We cant just throw them out because they are difficult to teach. Kids are not disposable.

Reporter Jaisal Noor has created a gripping radio documentary about the fight to save neighborhood schools.

He lets the “reformers” have their say. They want to close down the so-called failing schools and replace them with new schools that won’t be failing schools, at least not for a few years. Then they too can be closed and another new school can be opened.

The closing schools serve minority students. They are overcrowded and underresourced. They must be closed. So say the officials.

Jaisal Noor listens to students, teachers, and parents. What a novel idea.

The officials don’t hear students, teachers, or parents. They know what’s best for everyone. And what’s best is to close their school.

Diane