The Pitt is an award-winning series on cable about daily life in an emergency room in Pittsburgh. Each episode represents the traumas and rhythm of one hour in one day. It’s gripping and sometimes so gory in its realism that I divert my eyes.
Two articles recently gave the program the highest praise. One, which appeared in Fortune, said that The Pitt exemplifies DEI in action and demonstrates how it saves lives. Patients in extremis often need someone who looks like them to communicate candidly.
But race, color, ethnicity, gender are beside the point. What matters most is saving lives, expressing empathy for people who are in pain and often terrified.
The cast is white, Black, Indian, Hispanic, Filipino, Christian, Jewish, Muslim, male, female, and even includes a staff member in a wheelchair. It is the quintessence of DEI, and none of it is frivolous. It’s just who they are: trained doctors, nurses, psychologists, social workers: people who have chosen to work in a high-pressure emergency room.
The article in Fortune by Robert Raben reminds us of why DEI is valuable.
As diversity, equity, and inclusion programs are under relentless attack, HBO’s medical drama The Pitt offers a masterclass in what DEI truly looks like when these values are woven into the fabric of an institution and put into practice. And how DEI benefits all of us.
There is nothing artificial about “The Pitt.” It is a gripping drama of everyday life in an urban emergency room.
Frank Bruni writes in The New York Times that The Pitt is the most patriotic show on television.
“It’s an empathy exam. It’s a civics lesson. Above all, it’s a study of people under intense pressure — as they are when a pulse is fading, or when a nation is fraying — and the importance of muddling through and making things better, no matter the odds, no matter the obstacles…”
It makes an argument for diversity that’s smart and true, looking beyond the usual dividing lines — race, religion, gender — to less politically charged differences. A brand-new doctor who grew up on a farm in rural America draws on a sensibility that peers lack. A medical student suggests a way to lessen an uninsured patient’s financial distress that her co-workers didn’t think of. It occurred to her not because she’s Asian American but because she grew up in a family with limited means and daunting medical bills, so she was schooled in impediments and options…
There’s a war in America between erudition and improvisation, science and superstition, head and heart. The Pitt might be expected to come down unconditionally on the side of expertise. But it doesn’t, not exactly. While it routinely and rightly exalts medicine’s wondrous advances, it also suggests that experts can be hidebound, timid. And it understands that the wiring of people and of societies demands room for both proper procedure and imagination.
One of the great things about The Pitt is that the executive producer–Dr. Joe Sachs– is an emergency room doctor who also has a degree in cinema. Every episode is overseen by medical specialists and expert nurses. Every word, every procedure is medically accurate.

Last week’s episode, ripped from the headlines, brought two ICE agents, masked, into the ER with an injured Hispanic woman. Chilling….
And just as The West Wing (unfortunately) humanized the Presidency to the benefit of George W. Bush, this time around The Pitt may have the opposite effect and make lots of ordinary Americans recognize the cold inhumanity of the Trump Presidency.
(From my fingertips to God’s ears….)
LikeLike
Anyone who does not see that the attack on DEI is pandering to the worst fears of humanity is either asleep or complicit in the obvious attempt to discriminate against the “other” by any means possible including lying.
LikeLike
My wife and I always are so engaged when it ends, we go, “I knew it would end, but I didn’t want it to. Dang!”
Just last night my doctor called (I have a blood clot in my leg — superficial) and we were discussing The Pitt. She told me it is so accurate as I wondered what doctors thought of these shows. She said she worked in East LA ER and this show is tremendous. And yes, in the real world, this is how community works. This is what made our country great with all people. I mean, this is the way I grew up, and really knew no other way.
LikeLike
Rick,
I watched a one-hour discussion of “The Pitt” between a doctor and the executive producer, also a doctor. The latter went into great detail about the steps the production company takes to make every episode true to life.
Be careful with that blood clot. It could turn into a pulmonary embolism or deep vein thrombosis. Both are serious. You should be taking a blood thinner like Xarelto or Eluquss.
LikeLike
Although I agree with the basic premise . Can the Times just ask Bruni to go back to being a restaurant critic. “It occurred to her not because she’s Asian American but because she grew up in a family with limited means and daunting medical bills, so she was schooled in impediments and options…” Is that not the ultimate WOKE ! What ever you do Frank don’t say that those with the most limited means are frequently in a Minority group. Huckleberry may be from farm country but is Bruni asserting that growing up in farm County is why he has “sensibility that peers lack” . Remind me to go to Nebraska the next time I need Medical care. I don’t think America is deficient in portraying Rural America as Gods country and real Americans. Bruni is typical of the 3rd way democrats that caused millions of Democrats to skip the 2024 election. While Trump doubled and tripled down on the hate bringing out more of his base. Democratic leaning voters who voted for Biden in 2020 stayed home in droves. The 30 % swings in public opinion since the election might cause one to question whether the common pundit interpretations of the 2024 loss are grounded in any fact . Do people really change that fast ? If they did I suspect the DNC would not be hiding the autopsy report . Back to the Pit a little less gore would be better for my stomach .
LikeLike
Joel,
When the doctors cut into flesh, I look away. Too realistic!
As for why the Dems lost in 2024, no one has the one true answer, just opinion. My opinion is that the Republicans defined Kamala as super-woke. They made it seem that her biggest issue was trans rights. They pulled every culture war smear in the book, when in fact she was not a culture warrior. The Republicans poured a couple hundred million into elevating the trans issue, but she didn’t.
Kamala did not play the race and gender cards. The GOP did. They made her appear as a dangerous ideologue who would push a nightmare WOKE agenda.
They successfully turned her into a caricature.
LikeLike
While I agree that the Republicans put millions into there anti gay, anti woke anti immigrant campaign . Where I differ is whether that gained them many or enough voters who would ever have voted for Harris. Those “deplorable ” attacks brought out every dimwit who was open to Trumps message and seldom showed up at the Polls. Using high tech software to identify and target them with the message. Not just based on their voting patterns but their social media and other habits. …,
Trump never took his foot off the gas no matter how vile or false the assertions. Be it eating dogs or Public Schools forcing Children to have sex change operations . Vance admitting that he was just fine spreading lies in order to win. John Ganz points out in “When the Clock Broke ” that the Trump’s campaigns had much in common with Giuliani’s 93 race against Dinkins. All the pundits across the political spectrum wrote Giuliani off after some horrendous remarks. How did that work out….
The following link details what more and more polls and focus groups are finding. From the NY Times, to YouGov. to Strength In Numbers. .. Harris lost the election to the couch not to Trump . Democratic voters who stayed home were the difference,
The YouGov poll lists about 6 or 7 reasons. Top of the list Harris on Gaza at 29% . The economy is on there . Those upset by immigration; they don’t give a break down whether they were upset about perceived open borders or crack downs came in at 11% . Strangely enough as I commented in response to Edsall’s piece yesterday. Which also highlighted Trans issues . Trans / gay issues in the YouGov poll did not get enough to even register in this group of Democrats who stayed home.
https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/why-2020-biden-voters-sat-out-2024-1235318121/
LikeLike
The people who didn’t vote for Harris because of Gaza got a far worse deal from Trump, who never reined in Netanyahu.
LikeLike
The fact that those 29% of Democratic voters who stayed home over Gaza got screwed worse with Trump is obviously true. But it goes against the narrative that Democrats lost because they were too far left and woke. For wholesome Farm boys like Huckleberry from Nebraska. They never had those voters; possibly since Brown. Yet we keep hearing Democrats have to move right to get them.
LikeLike
Seems to me that many, most actually, Americans take what they see on the boob tube and believe that it is an accurate depiction of life. Was out camping/fishing/being on the Ozark National Scenic Riverways the last couple of weeks and the guys, were all talking about various TV programs as if they were something to be admired for the content. Now, not having any TV for the last decade I found those conversations to be quite boring and and their sense of reality skewed.
Americans have been infantilized by their obsession with television, yes even the supposed reality tv shows.
LikeLike
Duane,
You would enjoy “The Pitt,” also “Landman.”
LikeLike
Duane–
ESPECIALLY “infantilized” by the “supposed reality tv shows!” In defense of SOME tv (& my extremely intelligent & sensitive daughter tells me that I HAVE to watch “The Pitt,” & I will do so), it can make you think (& cry)…&… laugh (&, esp.what we need in these times). &–while we’re talking medical & REALLY good tv–I highly recommend “Nurse Jackie” (started out on Showtime in 2010, I think, & ran for 7 seasons)–now on Netflix (& can be seen on its own channel–“Nurse Jackie” & “Weeds,” & another, Her Sphere–but it runs intermittently. What writing, what acting–a dramedy, a stellar cast: Edie Falco, Merit Weaver. I’ve watched episodes over & over. (Which is, perhaps, why I haven’t yet had time to watch “The Pitt.”)
LikeLike
Retired,
The Pitt is very dramatic. It is not a “supposed reality show.” It was written by an ER doctor and every move and word are scrutinized by a team of doctors and ER nurses for accuracy.
LikeLike
Oh, I know that “The Pitt” isn’t a reality show (I was referring to what Duane said, & I think he was talking about shows like “Survivor” & “The Bachelor,” which are mindless). Like “Nurse Jackie,” “The Pitt” does have MDs, RNs, etc. as advisors–& it is real & vetted.
LikeLike