In this post, Tom Ultican focuses on the advance of Christian nationalism. This is the belief that the U.S. is a Christian nation and that the Founders supported that idea.
In response to Christian nationalists, states are passing laws to require the posting of The Ten Commandments in classrooms, to allow public money to be spent in religious schools, to eviscerate separation of church and state, and to hire religious leaders to act as guidance counselors in public schools.
Separation of church and state has been an honored tradition in American life and law for generations. That separation protects the churches by freeing them from state oversight; it also protects the state by preventing religious zealots from interfering in the workings of government.
We are a nation of many religions. Freedom of religion is best protected by keeping the hands of the state far from all religious groups and to prevent religious groups from exercising state power.
Yet here come the Christian nationalists, eager to assert their control over the entire nation, over Catholic Churches, over Muslim mosques, over Jewish synagogues, over the many and diverse religions of our nation, as well as all those who are affiliated with no religion. .
The Constitution does not say that the U.S. is a Christian nation. It says in the First Amendment that there must be freedom of religion for all and that Congress must pass no laws establishing a state religion. The Constitution also says that there must be no religious test for those who hold public office.
If the Founders wanted the U.S. to be a Christian nation, they would have said so. They didn’t.
But we live in a New Age, one where Christian Nationalists are front and center.
Ultican writes:
Since 2024, Louisiana, Arkansas and Texas have passed laws requiring ten commandment posters in all classrooms. These kinds of laws come to us courtesy of a single Christian “bill mill,” Project Blitz. Dozens of other state bills in fidelity with Project Blitz’s proposed legislation were also passed. In 2021, they distributed 74 pieces of model legislation of which 14 passed into law including “Parental Review and Consent for Sex Education” and “Religious Freedom Day” promoting Mark Keierleber, reporting for The 74, wrote, “Among the architects of Project Blitz is the Barton-founded influence machine, WallBuilders.”
The WallBuilders home page claims to be, “Helping Americans Remember and Preserve the True History of Our Great Nation …” Unfortunately; it is in reality a propaganda site posting lies about American history in order to advance a Christian Nationalist agenda. Texas preacher and amateur historian, David Barton, founded WallBuilders and has become the most quoted man in the realm of Christian Nationalism. The organization’s name is an Old Testament reference to rebuilding the walls of Jerusalem.
The Speaker of the House, Mike Johnson, told an audience at the ProFamily Legislators Conference, which was being hosted by WallBuilders, Barton’s teachings have had “a profound influence on me, and my work, and my life and everything I do.” It is widely held that the Speaker is a Christian Nationalist. President Trump has cultivated their support. In March, he hosted David Barton in the oval office.

David Barton and Trump in the Oval Office this March
David Barton
Barton was born in Fort Worth, Texas. When he completed junior high, his family moved to the small Texas town of Aledo about 40 miles west of Fort Worth. After graduating third in his high school class, he attended Oral Roberts University, the evangelical Christian college in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Barton came to Oral Roberts on a math and science scholarship but ended up with a degree in religious education.
His parents started a Bible study group in Aledo which became a fundamentalist church and a K-12 school. David taught math and science, coached basketball, and became the school’s principal.
Barton became an amateur historian. In her first book, The Good News Club, Katherine Stewart claimed, “Pseudo-historian David Barton—a Texas-based darling of the Religious Right and founder of the Christian Nationalist organizations WallBuilders and the Black Robe Regiment—seems to have no problem fictionalizing the history.” (Page 67)
H“In a broader sense, Barton’s work is reminiscent of nineteenth-century historians like Charles Coffin and Parson Weems, scholars who wrote from an unabashedly Christian perspective at a time when there was no culture of objectivity among historians. Weems was best known for his biography of George Washington, in which he did his best to claim Washington for the Christians, despite his well-known reputation as a Deist. In a brief, credulous treatise called The Bulletproof George Washington, Barton resurrected an old Weems-era tale about the supposed divine protection of Washington during the French and Indian War.”
Nate Blakeslee in an article for the Texas Monthly observed:
In her second book, The Power Worshippers, Stewart noted:
“The historical errors and obfuscations tumbled out of Barton’s works fast and furious. Intent on demonstrating that the American republic was founded on ‘Judeo-Christian principles,’ Barton reproduced and alleged quote from James Madison to the effect that the Ten Commandments are the foundation of American civilization. Chuck Norris, Rush Limbaugh, Duck Dynasty star Phil Robertson, and countless other luminaries of the right recycled the quote in so many iterations that it has become a fixture of Christian nationalist ideology. Yet there is no evidence that Madison ever said such a thing.” (Page 133)
An NPR article from 2012 provides a good example of what Blakeslee and Stewart are writing about. While most of us learned that the Constitution was a secular document, Barton disagrees and says it is laced with biblical quotations:
‘“You look at Article 3, Section 1, the treason clause,’ he told James Robison on Trinity Broadcast Network. ‘Direct quote out of the Bible. You look at Article 2, the quote on the president has to be a native born? That is Deuteronomy 17:15, verbatim. I mean, it drives the secularists nuts because the Bible’s all over it! Now we as Christians don’t tend to recognize that. We think it’s a secular document; we’ve bought into their lies. It’s not.”
“We looked up every citation Barton said was from the Bible, but not one of them checked out. Moreover, the Constitution as written in 1787 has no mention of God or religion except to prohibit a religious test for office.”
In 2012, Barton’s bestselling book “The Jefferson Lies: Exposing the Myths You’ve Always Believed About Thomas Jefferson” was pulled by its Christian publisher, Thomas Nelson, because they “lost confidence” in the book. Senior Vice President Brian Hampton noted, “There were historical details — matters of fact, not matters of opinion, that were not supported at all.”
The 1792 Aitken Bible was the first Bible ever printed in the USA. Barton claims it was published and paid for by Congress. This was another one of his proofs that the United States was founded on Christian principles. The bible was not published by congress; it was published and paid for by printer Robert Aitken. At the time, there was an embargo on biblesfrom England. Responding to Aitken’s request, Congress agreed to have its chaplains check the Bible for accuracy.
From 1997 to 2006, Barton was vice chairman of the Texas Republican Party.

Barton Speaking at a 2016 Cruz Rally in Henderson, Nevada
The Henderson rally was hosted by Keep the Promise PAC which Barton was running. Besides Cruz, he was also joined on stage by Christian Nationalist pundit Glenn Beck. Barton maintains a relative low profile but his influence is massive.
The Christian Nationalists have a level of power in the Republican Party that is shocking.

Unfortunately, there is a strong possibility that the State of Missouri will take over St Louis Public Schools. The only reason that they have not yet done so, is likely because they are too busy taking over the police department.
Once the legislature finishes approving the Governor’s nominees for the police board, the school district will likely be next.
LikeLike
Frances, that’s very sad. St. Louis Public Schools have been experimented on for many years. I remember that the district was run by a management consulting firm called Alvarez & Marsal, more than 20 years ago. They disrupted everything, collected millions, then left town.
I just googled. The St. Louis board hired A&M in 2003. They put the former CEO of Brooks Brothers (a luxury clothing store) in charge. He closed schools, laid off 1,400 employees; after a year, A&M collected $4.8 million, left town. The district continued its downward slide, as the mayor opened charter schools, drained enrollment and did nothing to help the public schools. Competition didn’t make them better. It drained away students and resources.
https://share.google/50MpySaNWPJgFWh1y
LikeLike
Don’t forget about Rudi Crew and McConnel, Jones, Lanier & Murphy, who worked with Alvarez and Marsal.
The current Mayor of St Louis is an ally of Vince Schoemehl who was the elected school board member who proposed bringing in the corporate restructuring firm. She sends her child to a charter school.
LikeLike
Funny that Rudy Crew advised A&M in St. Louis. He was not successful as Chancellor of Schools in NYC.
LikeLike
In the end, Rudi Crew didn’t want to be named Superintendent of SLPS at the end of the Alvarez and Marsal year. He was supposed to become Superintendent in 2004.
He was smart enough to recognize that he would have had a horrible time since nobody trusted him after collaborating with Schoemehl, Alvarez and Marsal, etc.
Parents and teachers were appreciative of his decision to turn them down.
LikeLike
I live in Southern Warren County and taught at the high school for the last 9 years of my teaching career.
On Sunday, I had the opportunity to speak with a couple of nice but very regressive/reactionary faith believers (hardcore tRumpers) one of whom works for the Child Evangelical Fellowship-organization that sponsors the “Good News Clubs” in Warrenton, MO. I showed them one of Katherine Stewart’s books on the reactionary religious christian faith adherents who are trying to turn this country into a christian theofascist one. She recognized the name right away and the hiss was audible.
I will see them most every weekend as they run a little quaint store, Peers Store, that is on the Katy Trail that have free concerts 12-3 pm. They volunteer their time. Again very nice people but their faith beliefs and politics are completely on the other end of the spectrum from mine.
Anyway the CEF is one of the main players in this push for a christian theofascist country. Faith believers, whether religious or political cannot be reasoned with. Mainly because they think that they are doing their god’s or leader’s will.
Will be some interesting conversations in the future, no doubt.
All should look into what Stewart’s work on these christian theofascists exposes.
LikeLike
I’m not sure how the St. Louis saga is in this topic – maybe the release of the State Audit of SLPS prompted it. With a new Board in place, hopefully state takeover blustering in the Capitol will be just that.
As for the background…
That run of six superintendents and the infamous Alvarez group was short-lived. Out of the ashes came stability and getting accreditation. That revolving door period (perfect storm) followed the settlement of the two-decades old voluntary desegregation program; the city schools did not “rebuild” during desegregation in spite of continued payments from the State– hence Alvarez & company coming in to “audit” and then mismanage; and NCLB.
The state takeover was not traditional. The elected board was removed and a three-person board was appointed by the Governor, Mayor, and President of the State Board. The plan was simple: let the three-person board “run” and manage and keep an eye on the funding, resources, and operations. Let the superintendent Lead the district (without the fray of operations).
During the 12 years, the same 4 people (2 did full stints),there was 1 superintendent (got to be a record), and stability. So no revolving door board or superintendent the entire time). (And fortunately the 2016 governor was forced to resign before a right-political board could be appointed).
Some will contend with the word stability. Problems? Headlines? Of course – like other urban districts. However – policies were developed and adhered to. Protocols in operations established. Efforts at curriculum alignment. & earned State Accreditation (multi-faceted including achievement). And, much of this with a charter loving mayor and a superintendent who was from New Orleans so everyone assumed it would be charter conversion. Far from it.
The elected board returned, trained, and operated well. Oversight. Protocols. Public engagement (which include first small step in closing schools). And, getting through covid!
The last two years was practically a hostile takeover.
There’s a new board. The State is too busy with reducing taxes, putting tax dollars into private/religious school vouchers, & the remaining anti-(fill in the blank) culture war issues that some legislators are stuck on. And, in spite of the media industry being what it is, the print media and others ARE watching like hawks.
LikeLike
WHOSE TEN COMMANDMENTS? The official Catholic Ten Commandments are documented in The Catholic Catechism is different from the Ten Commandments in the Bible because it doesn’t condemn the presence of “graven images” in Catholic churches.
If Protestant Ten Commandments are posted in schools, Catholic children could become the objects of taunting and ridicule by their classmates as idol worshipers.
The Catholic perspective is based on the plain fact that in the Hebrew language in which the Ten Commandments were written in the Bible, the word used to refer to “graven images” is “pesel”, which means carvings or images that ARE SPECIFICALLY CREATED TO BE WORSHIPED. On the other hand, the Hebrew word “matzevah” which also means “graven images” is used to refer to carvings and images to commemorate the memory of people who are loved or honored for their good qualities.
The carvings and images in Catholic churches are “matzevah” and are not worshiped, but only serve to commemorate Mary, the Apostles, and Saints for their holy qualities.
Catholics don’t “pray to” Mary, the Apostles, and Saints any more than everyday people “pray” to their friends and relatives when they ask those friends and relatives to pray to God on their behalf.
So — whose Ten Commandments will be posted in schools?
And whose interpretation of the Bible will be taught? Because Catholics, Episcopalians, Lutherans, United Presbyterians, Methodists, and other Christian denominations all share dogma that says that the stories of creation in Genesis 1 and Genesis 2 are not to be taken literally and that evolution is how the human body was formed.
So — whose interpretation of the Bible will be taught?
There are going to be a great many lawsuits over whose Ten Commandments and whose Bible is taught.
LikeLike
The Old Testament has multiple versions of “the Ten Commandments.”
LikeLike
As long as the Supreme Court decision in Mahmoud stands (and I wish it didn’t, but I am not a Supreme Court justice), it will never be constitutional to make a law requiring the posting of any religious text in classrooms. The Court elevated the Free Exercise Clause in Mahmoud, giving it as much force as the Establishment Clause. You can’t opt out of classroom walls, so the requirement to post the 10 Commandments in a classroom will get shot down, I’m pretty sure. Of course, justices may find a way around it (I wouldn’t put it past them, and I’m not a constitutional lawyer), but I can’t think of one logically.
My argument: https://news.schoolsdo.org/2025/06/scotus-reconfigures-the-religious-liberty-playing-field/
LikeLike
Obviously it should be Roman Catholic version. They are the only legitimate representative of god.
(turn off sarcasm)
LikeLike
“But we live in a New Age”
Needs to be amended to “a New Dark Age.”
LikeLike
Good thing I’m not teaching any longer in Florida, which may be next in pushing religion in public schools. I’m sure I’d be arrested or fired because I would never post the 10 Commandments in my classroom. I’d post the First Amendment, along with multiple quotes by the Founding Fathers regarding their beliefs about keeping religion out of the public square. Then I’d dare officials to tear those down in place of their unconstitutional religious dogma.
LikeLike
While it is true that there is nothing constitutional about Christianity, it is equally true that the prevalence of Protestantism in Early National history was very influential. The nation as a whole was not expressly Protestant, but suggesting that someone was “Romish” was a real and extant insult, and hostility to the various cults that arose during the Jacksonian era had the ring of modern Christian Nationalism. Competition between Protestant sects was vicious, and survived as more lighthearted jokes among the churches into the 20th century.
John Adams, always the intellectual, was obliged to find aid in the personage of William Billings, a lame tailor and hymn writer who was as fond of his religion as he was hostile to bathing. Adams literally held his nose and accepted the support of the eccentric Billings, who wrote Chester, the first of many national anthems (all unofficial for a long time). Benedict Arnold, quite the patriot at the onset of revolutionary hostilities, led a group through Maine on their way to attack the British in Canada, stopping at the tomb of George Whitefield, leader of the First Great Awakening. The soldiers opened the tomb and took good luck charms from the remains of Whiefield.
So there has always been religion, and some of it has been pretty weird. But very little of it has been in the image of the Christian Nationalists.
LikeLike
How long has Jesus Christ been dead? And yet after all that time, these Christian Nationals are trying to reinvent what Christianity means, ignoring what Jesus Christ taught. Some even calling JC too woke.
Christian nationalists focus on national interests and perceived traditional values, potentially creating a conflict with Jesus’ emphasis on a kingdom “not of this world” and a spiritual transformation that transcends earthly boundaries and ethnic groups.
Some Christian nationalist interpretations prioritize themes of authority, order, and even a “militant masculinity” in understanding Jesus, potentially minimizing or even contrasting with aspects of Jesus’ teachings that emphasize compassion, mercy, humility, and care for the marginalized.
In essence, they are hijacking the name Christian, just like Trump used fear to hijack the Republican Party, turning it into. a $$$ faucet for his legal expenses, and is doing the same thing to the federal government, with white Christian Nationalist support.
LikeLike
Always entertaining when Bronze Age mythology becomes the basis for crafting social policy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Many people think the Ten Commandments are just the Ten Commandments but they are actually listed two places in the Bible. And here’s the ringer, Protestants and Jews usually one set and Catholics the other. So just posting them with different numbering and slightly different order actually discriminates.
LikeLike