When Broad-trained military man Mike Miles was superintendent of the Dallas Independent School District, the district experienced a mass exodus of teachers in response to Miles’ top-down style of management. Houston is experiencing the same phenomenon, the Houston Chronicle reported.
More than 4,000 employees left Houston ISD in June, bringing the total departures since the state takeover to over 10,000.
The record number is three times higher than the June departure average for the past five years, according to a Houston Chronicle analysis of district employment records. Over 75% of the departures were recorded as “voluntary,” including retirements and resignations.
Teachers accounted for more than 2,400 of the employees who left in June, with the monthly tally exceeding the total number of teachers who typically leave HISD over an entire school year, according to the analysis. About 4,700 of HISD’s roughly 11,000 teachers left the district during the 2023-24 school year.
Some teachers cited state-appointed Superintendent Mike Miles’ strict new reforms and sudden class assignment changes as the reasons they left. June’s bloated number of departures includes job cuts and terminations linked to job status notices.
Jackie Anderson, president of the Houston Federation of Teachers, called the teacher departures “unprecedented.”
June’s HISD staff departures surged to three times the average
Over 4,000 staff members left the district this June. The record number of departures was more than triple the average for the past five years….
Bellaire High School teacher Brady Mayo, who taught business law and International Baccalaureate business management, said he chose to retire after seeing teachers hesitate to use time off and deal with new district-mandated policies, such as requiring classroom doors to stay open, at the campus he loved.
There was a culture of fear under new district leadership, he said, even though his campus was not a school in Miles’ New Education System.
“I mean, nobody asked me to leave. But I felt run off, just like most teachers. And nobody ran me off. It’s just the way I felt,” the 33-year educator said. “I felt like Mike Miles was going to put his teachers in place, whether they’re certified or not, his yes men.”
Askew Elementary School teacher Karen Calhoun said the district-imposed strategies did not allow teachers to use techniques that they knew worked for students. Calhoun, who retired in June ahead of Askew formally becoming an NES school this fall, said many “top-tier” teachers left the school. She had never seen turnover like this in her 40 years at the school.
“I decided to retire because I could see the change happening,” Calhoun said. “It’s obvious. People come in all the time (for classroom observation). They don’t identify themselves when they come in. You don’t know who they are. They take notes, they go back and they talk to the principal. You don’t even know what’s going on….”
School staff felt micromanaged, said Lea Mishlan, former principal of West Briar Middle School. Mishlan was told to resign by the district or face board termination.
“We were constantly — I mean, even the last week of school, we were expected to be in their rooms,” the 20-year educator said. “And so they just felt like they were being nitpicked. And so every time I had to present something to them, it was just like, what? Like, again? Like, another change? So, the morale was horrible, and it was really hard to maintain positivity throughout the craziness.”

I used to think that the denigration of teachers was going to backfire on the “so-called conservatives.” Now I understand that it is part of the plan. As teachers leave horrific school districts in droves, those “edu-reformers” will get to: lower standards for what constitutes a “qualified teacher,” replace competent teachers with loyal hacks, lower standards to make sure parents don’t complain about how poorly their kids are preforming, and so on.
I am, now, puzzled by the support of these assholes for big-time testing. Such tests will only show that their schools are being run into the ground and doing a lousy job. Maybe that just gives them more ammunition for their voucher programs.
Despicable, the whole lot of those assholes. (Excuse my French.)
LikeLike
What is happening in Houston is an example of authoritarian overreach. Abbott creates a rigged system that allows him to takeover a B rated district on the basis of the scores of one school. Then, he appoints an unqualified former military dictator that runs the district like a gulag. The result is a mass exodus of teachers that are tired of the abuse. It is a recipe for failure, which may well be all part of the devious extremist agenda.
LikeLike
The problem is that a guy like Miles sees these departures as a win.
LikeLike
You have correctly identified the problem. Mass teaching positions open takes years to stabilize even if the administration has the best interests of the school at heart. The present administration is obviously antagonistic to the good of the students in this system. This does not bode well.
LikeLike
“The morale was horrible.” Consider me shocked, shocked.
LikeLike
The sooner they can get rid of quality public schools the sooner they can get rid of public education.
LikeLike
That’s the plan:
to get dedicated, professionally trained teachers to leave so the MAGA Christian nationalist cult can replace them with convicted felons and/or pedophile Bible thumpers to program the next generation to grow up as obedient, rabid fascists.
Just like Traitor Trump who wants to replace our military’s generals and admirals with race car drivers and coaches.
LikeLike
When top* adminimals have a policy based in “my way or the highway”, many take the highway to get as far away from that adminimal as possible.
*By top I mean in the hierarchy, not quality.
LikeLike
“It’s obvious. People come in all the time (for classroom observation). They don’t identify themselves when they come in. You don’t know who they are.“
Not in my class they wouldn’t have. I’d have escorted them out and locked them out. Those folks are worse than the ones who mandate such shit. . . Not by much.
LikeLike
“So, the morale was horrible, and it was really hard to maintain positivity throughout the craziness.”
And the students know what is going on. They know that they are just pawns in the adults’ power trips-that they are being used. Wonderful atmosphere in which to learn, eh!
LikeLike
I don’t recall revenge politics like this before recent years, this destructive phenomenon where a mayor, governor, or president appoints a Gordon Gekko like Mike Miles to run a public service and strip it for parts because the people there voted for the other candidate in the election. It boggles the mind how it’s come to this, such low, impractical dullards running for office and being elected public servants, rule of the unfit.
Governor Abbott too is weird. And the hostile takeover was illegitimate. Not only do the teachers in Houston not deserve such retributive punishment, the students and don’t deserve it, and the city doesn’t deserve it. Hard to watch without getting upset.
LikeLike
LCT,
You are exactly right. Gov. Abbot is getting his revenge on Houston by damaging their schools. What a horrible man he is. He has no heart, no soul.
LikeLike
Meanwhile Beto is going around Texas registering voters. Democrats need to send bilingual outreach folks to the border to bring Latinos back to the Democrats. They should do that nationally.
LikeLike
The Broad training instills a business mindset. Frankly, business is not the solution to our educational problems; business is the problem.
LikeLike
Businessmen have been interfering in public education for over a century. If you haven’t read Callahan’s work please do. “Education and the Cult of Efficiency” tells the history of that interference from the end of the 19th century up to the 1960s when he wrote the book.
LikeLike
Duane,
That’s an excellent book and one of my favorites. It’s so good to be on here with others who enjoy the same classic education literature! It was written in the ’60s, but concerns itself mostly with the 1930s. Yet it is amazing how relevant it continues to be. One part that always stood out to me was the debating on whether students should take Latin or bookkeeping, and bookkeeping was deemed to have more (financial) value.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad to hear that you have read the book.
Latin vs Bookkeeping. Same debate these days just different subjects. . . with that predominant capitalist mode of “more financial value” still being the deciding factor today.
LikeLike
This article is SPOT ON. It is a disgrace the way truly dedicated teachers were made to feel.
LikeLike