On August 20, the New York Times published a story about how Ron DeSantis joined the “ruling class” but now campaigns against it. His story is shot through with hypocrisy. He paints himself as the public school kid from middle-class Dunedin, Florida, surrounded by snobs from private schools who looked down on him. Yet now as governor, he treats public schools and their teachers with contempt and expanded vouchers to pay billions of taxpayer dollars for kids to go to private schools, including high-income families.
Why is he, the public school kid, subsidizing private and religious schools? Why is he so hostile to public schools? He complains that public schools indoctrinate their students yet he’s willing to send kids to religious schools whose purpose is indoctrination. Why does he subsidize the tuition of rich kids who go to private schools? Aren’t those the kind of kids who treated him with condescension?
Early last year, Gov. Ron DeSantis nestled into his chair onstage in Naples, Fla., to explain to an audience of the would-be conservative elite his journey through the reigning liberal one they hoped to destroy. His host was Larry P. Arnn, the president of Hillsdale College, a small Christian school in southern Michigan that has become an academic hub of the Trump-era right. His subject was Yale University, where Mr. DeSantis was educated and where, as he tells it, he first met the enemy.
The story begins:
“I’m a public school kid,” Mr. DeSantis told the audience, unspooling a story that he has shared in recent years with aides, friendly interviewers, donors, voters and readers of his memoir, “The Courage to Be Free.” “My mom was a nurse, my dad worked for a TV ratings company, installing the metering devices back then. And I show up in jean shorts and a T-shirt.” The outfit “did not go over well with the Andover and Groton kids” — sometimes it is Andover and Groton, sometimes it is Andover and Exeter, sometimes all three — who mocked his lack of polish.
Worse than Yale’s snobbery was its politics: College was “the first time that I saw unadulterated leftism,” he told the Republican Jewish Coalition this March. “We’re basically being told the Soviet Union was the victim in the Cold War.” Teachers and students alike “rejected God, and they hated our country,” he assured the audience in Naples. “When I get people that submit résumés,” he said, “quite frankly, if I got one from Yale I would be negatively disposed.”
Then there are the parts of the story he doesn’t tell: How his new baseball teammates at Yale — mostly fellow athletic recruits from the South and West who likewise viewed themselves as Yale outsiders — were among those who teased him about his clothes, and how he would nevertheless adopt their insular culture as his own. How he joined one of Yale’s storied “secret societies,” those breeding grounds of future senators and presidents, but left other members with the impression that he would have preferred to be tapped by a more prestigious one. How he shared with friends his dream of going to Harvard Law School — not law school, Harvard Law School — and successfully applied there, stacking one elite credential neatly onto another, and co-founded a tutoring firm that touted “the only LSAT prep courses designed exclusively by Harvard Law School graduates.” How his Yale connections helped him out-raise rivals as a first-time candidate for Congress, and how he featured his Ivy credentials — “a political scarlet letter as far as a G.O.P. primary went,” Mr. DeSantis likes to say — on his campaign websites, sometimes down to the precise degree of honors earned. And how that C.V. helped sell him to an Ivy-obsessed President Donald J. Trump, whose 2018 endorsement helped propel Mr. DeSantis to the governor’s office in Florida, where his Yale baseball jersey is displayed prominently on the wall next to his desk…
For Mr. DeSantis and his allies, the culture wars are the central struggle of American public life, and schools are the most important battleground where they will be fought. “Education is our sword,” Mr. DeSantis’s then education commissioner, Richard Corcoran, explained to a Hillsdale audience in 2021. And Mr. DeSantis is the man to wield it — a self-made striver who was “given nothing,” as he told the audience attending his campaign kickoff in Iowa in May. “These elites are not enacting an agenda to represent us. They’re imposing their agenda on us, via the federal government, via corporate America and via our own education system.”
DeSantis has aggressively taken political control of Florida’s schools and universities, passing laws that limit or eliminate what may be taught about gender and race. He has encouraged parent vigilantes to scour classrooms and libraries for books on controversial topics and ban them. His ally, radical conservative Chris Rufo, is quoted in the article:
“The goal of the university is not free inquiry,” Christopher Rufo, a conservative activist and one of the new trustees [of New College], said during a recent appearance in California. Instead, he argued, conservatives need to deploy state power to retake public institutions wherever they can.
“The universities are not overly politicized. The universities are overly ideologized and insufficiently politicized,” Mr. Rufo said. “We should repoliticize the universities and understand that education is at heart a political question.”
At Yale, DeSantis joined Delta Kappa Epsilon (Dekes), which was known for its vicious hazing of pledges. As an upper-class member, DeSantis was known for bullying pledges and forcing them to engage in pranks like dropping their pants and exposing their genitals, while the older members mocked their private parts.
The story says that DeSantis took a course on the Cold War taught by the esteemed scholar John Lewis Gaddis, who was an outspoken critic of the Soviet Union. In other words, DeSantis lied about being exposed to pro-Soviet views of the Cold War.
DeSantis portrayed Harvard Law School, where he studied, as a bastion of left wing thought. But the Dean of the law school when DeSantis arrived belonged to the conservative Federalist Society. And he was not the only member of that group on the faculty.
A 2005 survey of The Harvard Law Review, published in the Federalist Society’s flagship publication, The Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy, found that staff members “identifying themselves as left-of-center did not comprise even a majority.”
DeSantis neglects to mention that he was an active member of the Harvard Law School’s Federalist Society. He prefers to play the victim.
When he ran for Congress and then for governor, he tapped his Yale and Harvard networks to raise money.
But then he discovered there was even more political advantage for him if he played the role of the enemy of the ruling class.
How better to attack the ruling class than to destroy the public schools that enabled him to enter Yale? If this makes no sense, neither does DeSantis’ fable about being victimized at Yale and Harvard.

“The Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy, found that staff members “identifying themselves as left-of-center did not comprise even a majority.””
This encourages me not to advise my kids to go to Harvard. 🙂
LikeLike
“Why is he, the public school kid, subsidizing private and religious schools?”
Because he is now the beneficiary of that subsidizing. All part of Randian Libertarianism that exalts the I,ME,MINE culture.
“Why is he so hostile to public schools?”
Because for the far reich wing, tRumper types, about 30% of the electorate that is what they want to hear.
“He complains that public schools indoctrinate their students yet he’s willing to send kids to religious schools whose purpose is indoctrination. Why does he subsidize the tuition of rich kids who go to private schools?
See answer to the first question.
Aren’t those the kind of kids who treated him with condescension?
Appears so, but hey, he’s a part of them now.
On an opposite tack. . .
Why am I, the K-12 private Catholic school kid, now against those subsidies for private and religious schools?
LikeLike
Duane, great response. Please answer your own last question. I continually try to persuade friends who had a Catholic education that public money should not subsidize their schools.
LikeLike
My concern is that public monies go to religious schools. I don’t believe that we should force someone through taxes or the various other voucher/tax scholarship credit programs to pay for religious institutions. Ya know separation of state and church. Note the state should come first in that phrase.
Hey, if someone wants to fund private or religious schools, more power to them, but they should have to follow certain educational guidelines to insure that the children are learning enough to live in a pluralistic society.
LikeLike
Like you, Duane, I don’t want my taxes to pay for any religious education. Not in any religion, including my own.
LikeLike
But Duane, if Church is supposed to direct the Government, then it’s logical to direct public $ to Churches, and what better way to do that than tapping into the huge budget of public schools.
At least this is my conclusion after listening to the brilliant and unforgettable words of Lauren Boebert
LikeLiked by 1 person
The reactioanary xtian theofascists have been working on turning the US into an xtian theocracy since the 70s. They’ve been in it for the long haul and have a lot of money behind them-see Kochs, DeVoses, etc. . . .
LikeLike
Oh, I do find any and all of Boebert’s word to be quite forgettable. . . not worth listening to although I did watch that clip. A bit of my life. . . gone. . . forever!
LikeLike
“far reich wing”
D)
LikeLike
DeSantis is an ambitious opportunist. He will dance to whatever tune he believes will get him attention and votes. He continues to lean into his adolescent tendencies with his attention getting stunts and grandstanding. Playing the victim and constant scapegoating are part of his his fascist agenda. I’ve been observing DeSantis closely since he first campaigned in Florida. The man is a user that will do and say anything that he thinks will enable him to win. He is a also dishonest person that attacks anyone that criticizes him. He operates behind the scenes with his cronies in order to avoid public scrutiny. He would be a disastrous President. He would further divide our fragile, polarized Republic. DeSantis would abandon Ukraine, attack all our social safety nets and make national school choice the law of the land.
LikeLike
I call him “DUH-Satan.”
He’s a total scum with horrible ideas.
LikeLike
DeSantis is not going to be the nominee because both Koch and Catholic power brokers have rejected him (IMO). It’s going to be Youngkin. Catholic power brokers and Koch want to keep cover and a protestant Christian candidate like Youngkin preserves that.
I only write the following to show the bias in media like the NYT that protects the Catholic Church. The magazine, America, reported (5-23-2023) that DeSantis attended Our Lady of Lourdes Catholic school in Dunedin, Fla. What explains the discrepancy /omission in the NYT article by, Nicholas Confessore? America wrote that DeSantis is the nephew of a Catholic priest and the nephew of a Catholic sister. America reported about a Catholic priest at the DeSantis wedding at Disney World. And, they discuss his practicing part of his religion. DeSantis spoke last year at an event that included evangelical protestants and right wing
Catholics that was sponsored by Catholic Vote.
Journalist, Nicholas Confessore, was able to find the word Jewish for his article and, Christian, but couldn’t find Catholic. It’s un-American to protect the Catholic Church from scrutiny in politics particularly when allegations of fascism are lodged against DeSantis and when Leonard Leo is one of the most powerful men in the country.
LikeLike
At least Nicholas Confessore didn’t tailor comments so that it appeared that the Catholic hierarchy was critical of DeSantis while omitting their agreement with him on abortion, school choice, etc. The false notion that the Catholic sect is liberal is perpetrated by other mainstream spinners.
Biden is a Democrat but he is in the minority of Catholics, a group that has no clout within the Catholic hierarchy and that has no influence in directing the Church’s money away from right wing political causes like Issue 1 in Ohio on Aug. 8.
Sixty-three percent of White Catholics who attend church regularly voted for Trump in 2020.
LikeLike
Why does DiSaster attack public schools? That’s easy – he thinks it will get him votes and campaign funding. He’s carrying out what JEB started.(He has no original policies or ideas, at least none that are rational or cogent.) When JEB was elected, he promised his hedge fund financial backers access to FRS funding. I was told by someone who attended the first meeting of the Board that controls FRS that the room was three rows deep with suits salivating over the promise of gaining access to retirees. The Legislature was more evenly GQP/Dem in those days, and it has taken them almost 23 years to gain that access, but now thanks to strategic Board appointments and a GQP majority in the Legislature, the investment plan is now the default for all new hires. So the hedge fundies are happy. Also happy are the for-profit charter companies, private schools, and homeschool voters and donors who now have easy access to taxpayer dollars via ESAs with no income caps. Families with 6 figure incomes can now get even more money with no strings, no accountability and no audit for 3 years. What’s not to like?
LikeLike
Thanks for adding your comment, Donna.
I speculate the reasons you cite are also why Anthony de Nicola, a hedge funder, “huddled” in a 2015 meeting with Gov. Cuomo, Bishop Timothy Dolan and the head of the Catholic Conference’s education dept.. After the meeting, Cuomo sought support for tax credits for Catholic schools (Politico).
Anthony de Nicola is bankrolling the effort in the Milwaukee GOP presidential debate to make school choice a priority issue.
Jefferson’s warning- In every age, in every country, the priest aligns with the despot.
LikeLike
imprint ideas and opinions, in the strict sense of the word, prejudices, on the mind of the child
LikeLike
IF what is known about
the “Players”, somehow
changed the game, would
a “Ruling Class” cease
to function as masters?
Is it the UNKNOWN
about (fill-in), that
makes them a master, or
is it the system that
enables them to function
as a master?
LikeLike
DeSantis may be competing with Ted Cruz to take away his Most Vile and Despicable Award for an elected official.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just goes to show, when you think you’ve met the worst….
LikeLike