Governor Greg Abbott deployed 1,000 feet of buoys and razor wire on the border with Mexico to deter immigrants. Many migrants have been seriously injured by the razor wire, but Governor Abbott feels that as a Christian, it’s right to inflict maximum pain on immigrants from Mexico. The Biden administration is suing Abbott because he did not ask for approval before obstructing an international border.
The U.S. Justice Department sued Gov. Greg Abbott on Monday after he refused to remove a wall of buoys in the Rio Grande.
The move was expected after Abbott made clear to President Joe Biden in a letter earlier in the day that he would not remove the barriers and blamed the White House for making him have to take action on the border.
“The fact is, if you would just enforce the immigration laws Congress already has on the books, America would not be suffering from your record-breaking level of illegal immigration,” the Republican wrote.
The U.S. Justice Department had given Abbott until Monday to commit to removing the buoy barrier that they say he has illegally deployed into the river to block migrants. The agency filed the civil lawsuit with the U.S. District Court in the Western District of Texas.
The Justice Department says Abbott violated the federal Rivers and Harbors Act, which requires the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ approval before any barriers can be placed in any navigable water in the United States. Abbott and the Texas Department of Public Safety, which has overseen the project, did not get prior approval from the Army Corps of Engineers.
“This floating barrier poses a risk to navigation, as well as public safety, in the Rio Grande River, and it presents humanitarian concerns,” Associate Attorney General Vanita Gupta said in a statement announcing the suit. “Additionally, the presence of the floating barrier has prompted diplomatic protests by Mexico and risks damaging U.S. foreign policy.”
In his letter Monday, Abbott denied that anything Texas has done has violated the Rivers and Harbors Act. And the governor argued that the buoy barrier the state is putting in the river is deterring migrants from entering the Rio Grande.
The threat of legal action comes after a Texas DPS officer sent emails to a supervisor warning of injuries that Abbott’s Operation Lone Star has caused migrants. He detailed finding a pregnant woman having a miscarriage tangled in the state’s razor wire, doubled over in pain. He also described a 4-year-old who girl passed out from heat exhaustion after she tried to go through the razor wire and was pushed back by Texas National Guard soldiers, and a teenager who broke his leg trying to navigate the water around the wire and had to be carried by his father….
Customs and Border Protection has warned internally that Abbott’s use of concertina wire is making it harder to reach at-risk migrants and increasing the risk of drownings. An administration official said Monday that agents are now having to cut through multiple layers of razor wire to respond to medical emergencies. They said that in one week alone, Border Patrol agents reported encountering dozens of migrants with injuries, including broken limbs.
“President Biden’s plan to manage the border through deterrence, enforcement, and diplomacy after the Title 42 public health order lifted has led to the lowest levels of unlawful border crossings in over two years,” said Abdullah Hasan, White House assistant press secretary. “Gov. Abbott’s dangerous and unlawful actions are undermining that effective plan and making it hard for the men and women of Border Patrol to do their jobs of securing the border. The governor’s actions are cruel and putting both migrants and border agents in danger.”

“This floating barrier poses a risk to navigation, as well as public safety, in the Rio Grande River, and it presents humanitarian concerns,”
Humanitarian concerns?
Ya think?
Several members of one family have already DIED because of this — drowned in deeper water trying to go around it.
And what did Abutt expect would happen when he installed not only barrels wrapped in razor wire but razor wire fences hidden under water?
The euphemisms need to stop.
This needs to be called what it is: premeditated murder
LikeLike
Texas companies should be boycotted until this stuff stops.
LikeLike
And a freeze should be put on all federal payments to Tesla , SpaceX and other companies doing business with the Federal government.
LikeLike
Thank you for your pointed comment.
YES, “premeditated murder: sure fits the actions of A…”BUTT.”
Yay for Biden!
LikeLike
I’d like to see Abutt forced to go across his own razor barrier.
Some TV network could televise it as the Abutt Razor Challenge.
It would probably garner a huge viewership.
I know I’d watch it.
LikeLike
They could pit Greg Abutt against Ted Cruz.
And swimming around should not be allowed (underwater mines could be placed to ensure the latter)
LikeLike
Premeditated murder. That is precisely what it is. The DOJ should issue an arrest warrant for this guy. The crime is a federal one, taking place in federal waters.
LikeLike
Yes, Abutt has clearly violated federal law and continues to thumb his nose at the DOJ.
He should be immediately arrested and placed in jail with bail set at 1 trillion dollars.
Or, if he prefers, he can be given the option of taking the Abutt Razor Challenge (described above)
LikeLike
“This needs to be called what it is: premeditated murder”
How does Greg Abbott call himself a Christian?
LikeLike
He’s an extremely dull bulb, A-butt.
LikeLike
“Not everyone who [calls himself a Christian] says “Lord, Lord” will enter the kingdom of heaven”
Jesus
LikeLike
In a humanitarian crisis, why is Biden wasting time to go to court when Abbott is clearly violating more than one law already on the books? I think Biden should assert his authority and bring in The Navy Seals to dismantle Abbott’s inhumane death contraption.
LikeLike
I completely agree.
LikeLike
This isn’t a time for “Sit tight and assess,” as mentioned in ‘Don’t Look Up.’
LikeLike
exactly
LikeLike
You nailed it, RT. Biden MUST send in the National Guard.
LikeLike
At some point, this passes over into egregious criminal conduct. Trump and Abbott and DeSantis committed kidnapping when they did their illegal transports of migrants. They should be charged.
And Abbott should be charged for the harm that is done to innocent asylum seekers.
LikeLike
Democrats make a mistake when they ignore the GOP’s provocative, bad behavior.
LikeLiked by 1 person
They do. It’s time to get a lot more aggressive in response.
LikeLike
This has clearly gone far beyond that point.
But unfortunately, it’s not just actions of Abutt that are worthy of criminal prosecution.
The Intercept just reported (and has video documentation of ) the US border patrol holding immigrants (at least temporarily) in cages along the border in 115 degree heat.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My Lord.
LikeLike
The border patrol says they lack the resources, but There is absolutely no excuse for this stuff.
At the bare minimum they could erect air conditioned “tents” to hold people for short periods .
LikeLike
“Trump and Abbott and DeSantis committed kidnapping when they did their illegal transports of migrants.”
I wish it were that simple. If it were, the city I live in would probably have a direct and clean way to stop these transports through litigation. But I think Florida and Texas are being careful to ensure that the migrants are voluntarily boarding these buses and actually want to come to NYC.
LikeLike
They suckered them into these transports with purposefully false documents and other information.
LikeLike
If I lie to your family and tell you that there is free space on my bus to Disneyland and instead take you to the shack where the workers on my beet farm in Florida live, that’s kidnapping.
LikeLike
Right?
LikeLike
Arguably for a period, yes, assuming those facts exist.
I’ve found it difficult to tell what the facts on the ground about this are in Texas and Florida. I’ve made the inference that those aren’t the verifiable facts because I have two assumptions: (1) that Abbott and DeSantis have been careful on this point to bullet-proof the scheme; and (2) that if those facts do exist, the law departments of my Governor and Mayor would have used those facts to sue Texas and Florida a year or more ago. Those assumptions may be wrong. If so, I’m almost as angry at the NY and NYC government as I am at Texas and Florida.
LikeLike
First Alabama goes against the SCOTUS ruling to redraw election maps, now Texas is defying federal law and regulation in an effort to harm individuals it perceived as a threat. Where is the justice for these defiant actions?
LikeLike
You beat me to it.
LikeLike
“ The Biden administration is suing Abbott because he did not ask for approval before obstructing an international border.”
Next time Abutt should just ask “Hey, can I install razor wire across the Rio Grand to catch me some immigrants?
“Sure, no problem. Thanks for asking”
It’s always easier to ask for forgiveness afterward than approval ahead of time.
Everyone knows that.
LikeLike
Confederate states like Texas and Alabama keep defying federal authority these days. Reb states (not a typo) seem simply unable to accept the results of a war which ended way back in 1865. Reb states weaken the United States from within. Dangerous stuff, this.
LikeLike
The more the Democrats ignore the problem and let these aggressions stand the more emboldened red states will be willing to challenge federal laws and authority. They know The Supreme Court is on their side in many cases as well.
LikeLike
The big difference today is that not many (if any) northern states would be willing to fight to keep Texas in the union if they threatened to secede.
In fact, many would say “don’t let the door hit you on the way out”
So Texas might want to fight, but they would have no one to fight with.
LikeLike
There are lots of decent people in Texas and Florida, but the power is in the hands of the wealthy, white patrimony, and they intend to keep it that way.
LikeLike
States don’t need to secede to bring down the Anglo American Empire. Factors that likely influenced the fall of Ancient Rome include: growing decentralized division between East and West, pandemics, climate change, economic crises, economic inequality, food shortages, crumbling roads and bridges, military cruelty against residents and neighbors, political extortion and corruption, the rise of a certain exclusive religious group, tainted water pipes, and even pirates. Sound familiar?
LikeLike
LCT
I think you are right. The question is not if, but when.
The Fall
The writings on the wall
The house is poised to fall
But nothing ever lasts
And saving time has passed
The bridge is out ahead
And light is flashing red
And siren blasts away
But all we do is pray
LikeLike
good riddance
LikeLike
“Before the fall when they wrote it on the wall,
When there wasn’t even any Hollywood,
They heard the call,
And they wrote it on the wall,
For you and me—we understood.”
—-Fagen and Becker
LikeLike
This is a political stunt. Abbott is playing to one loud and sometimes violent segment of the voters, the paranoid MAGA-fascists.
I’m learning this from Pew as I write this comment:
“Illegal immigrants are a quarter of the foreign-born population.”
“What we do with those counts is develop a population estimate for lawful immigrants with standard demographic techniques that account for deaths, departures from the country and new arrivals each year. We’ve built up that estimate with data going back to 1980.”
“In the graphs from your June 2019 estimate of the unauthorized immigrant population, it sure looks like the line showing the population over time goes down from the 10.7 in 2016 to 10.5 million in 2017. So why don’t you say that the numbers went down for that year?”
https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2019/07/12/how-pew-research-center-counts-unauthorized-immigrants-in-us/
This PEW info piece didn’t have more recent estimates, so I found this from CBP.gov dated December 2022. Any changes were small, but numbers can be cherry-picked and presented in ways with loaded and misleading words to infer a doom and gloom scenario for the paranoid and easily to mislead MAGA-fascists that see everything through a lens darkly without bothering to fact check anything they hear from FOX fake news and fascist liars like DeSantis and Abbott.
https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/national-media-release/cbp-releases-december-2022-monthly-operational-update
LikeLike
Things are a bit dull so I’ll say the following:
Let’s ignore, for the moment, the issue of whether Texas is overstepping it’s authority to regulate its international border. (It probably is. But let’s ignore that for the moment.) Let’s assume the federal government is the only actor in question. So there is dispute about who has the authority to act.
In those circumstances, would it be wrong for the federal government to put razor wire fencing on the US border?
LikeLike
I’ll be the first and perhaps only respondent and say that I think it would be acceptable for the U.S. government put razor wire fencing on its borders.
LikeLike
Viktor Orban put razor wire on Hungary’s border to keep migrants from crossing, but at least they could see where it was on land. The Rio Grande is murky and muddy. It is much worse in the Rio Grande with currents pushing people into the wire including children. People have died. Abbott’s actions are even worse than Orban’s, and it violates international law. Abbott is a cruel despot.
LikeLike
What’s the international law it violates?
LikeLike
It violates a treaty the US made with Mexico.
LikeLike
Governor Abbott does not have the authority to conduct foreign policy.
LikeLike
The barrier violates a 1944 International Water Treaty and a 1970 Boundary Treaty, according to Mexico. The boundary treaty states that both countries “shall prohibit the construction of works in its territory which … may cause deflection or obstruction of the normal flow of the river or of its flood flows,” Mexico’s foreign ministry said in a statement.
LikeLike
And, the barriers are in violation of the U.S. Harbors and Rivers Act, which prohibits obstruction of navigable waterways.
LikeLike
Thanks for the good responses, Bob and RT.
LikeLike
Meanwhile:
LikeLike
The unspeakable cruelty and hypocrisy of Texas as dictated by the heinous orders of the governor is well beyond crimes against humanity. Deliberate infliction of pain and suffering as a deterrent to border crossing defies the laws of the land, international responsibility for agreements on humane standards of decency, morality, and rises to the level of crimes against humanity. For the law enforcement involved in the process conducting a refusal to continue to follow orders is appropriate. There are no protections for them or the migrants. Each person has been put in danger from this cruel and wreck induced policy. I guess Texas has no problem spitting on the bible or defying Jesus word of respecting humanity with kindness, caring, etc.
DO NO HARM!! Refusing people water and throwing back people, children, into the water defies any sense or knowing of humanitarian concern.Greg Abbott has shown a desperate rage against people and prejudice of same that should bring him before the international tribunal of law for crimes against humanity. NOW!!!
LikeLike
It is cruel and unusual punishment.
LikeLike
How freaking sick and twisted does someone have to be in order to be able, knowingly, to do this? To knowingly hurt and kill these migrants, many of them children? The mind boggles. This is the action of someone who is literally criminally insane.
LikeLike
Indirectly related- “DeSantis campaign fires speech writer who promoted video with Nazi imagery.” The speech writer is Nate Hochman. Hochman, in a The New Republic article (12-8-2021), is described as expressing the feeling that there’s a lot of pressure for his conversion to a right wing religion
that is not God nor theologically driven but, is motivated by his career progression. Btw- Ohio Sen. JD Vance converted to Catholicism in 2019, after his political ambitions took root.
The title of The New Republic article is, “The Illiberal Upstarts Trying to Reinvent the American Right.” The authors of the article were refreshingly honest, identifying “almost all of the them as right wing Catholics” who aim to promote a shift to a “stuff of hierarchical Catholic inspired culture.”
We are witnessing gaslighting by politicized right wing religious like Hugh Hewlett (cradle Catholic) who wrote in WaPo, you can’t put a religious lens on our political differences.
LikeLike
If you worship the child in the manger but drown the one in the river, you are seriously F—d up.
LikeLike
Please send this to Gov. Abbott:
“If you worship the child in the manger but drown the one in the river, you are seriously F—d up.”
LikeLiked by 1 person
Meme o’ the Day
There is one silent k in “knight.” There are two silent k’s in knick knack. There are three silent k’s in Republican.
LikeLike