Students at New College in Sarasota, Florida, conducted their own, alternative commencement in response to Governor DeSantis’ takeover of the board of the small, progressive public college. He replaced board members who believed in the college’s mission of a self-directed liberal education with new board members who were allied with the DeSantis brand of Christian nationalism.The board replaced the president of the college—an academic—with a rightwing politician who has no qualifications for the position.
In this post, which appears on Tumblr, a New College graduate explained what is happening. The commencement speaker invited by the new regime was Scott Atlas, Trump’s coronavirus advisor (who is not an epidemiologist). The students invited their own speaker, Neil Gaiman, a Bard College professor, whom you will see if you open the link. 
everentropy writes:
Hi, I’m a New College alum. I have been following this closely, so I can give you a run-down…Background: New College of Florida is a small liberal arts college in Sarasota. It has around 800 students, and probably less next year. It does not have grades, it instead has narrative evaluations. There are no required classes beyond what is legally required for Common Core. As an Honors College, everyone is required to do an undergraduate thesis and defend it in front of a Baccalaureate Committee. I studied Environmental Science and I was able to create my own major (known as an Area of Concentration). I even designed an Independent Study Project that went in-depth on cholera.
As for what is happening now, the simple answer is that Governor DeSantis appointed a bunch of conservatives to the Board of Trustees (or BoT). One of these is Chris Rufo, the guy behind the CRT scare. They have been trying to systematically tear down the college. This has included things like firing the president and trying to change the school’s curriculum and entrance requirements, with a conservative evangelical Christian angle.
For a more in-depth answer, here is a list of things they have done or are currently planning on doing. (i had it under a readmore but it looks like that fucks up the formatting) They fired the previous president, even though she was ACTUALLY solving many of the issues including enrollment and bringing in donors. By every measure she was doing a great job. Of course, you can’t hire DeSantis’s cronies if someone else is in the position! They fired a queer librarian a week before finals. They denied five professors tenure, including two from the “woke” specialization of… organic chemistry. They are currently trying to change the school mascot. It is, according to the student government constitution { }, AKA the null set. They want a mascot to be more marketable, not because students are asking for it. Most insultingly, they sent out a survey asking for students’ “opinions” and one of the options they had was the Conquistadores. It’s 2023, it’s hilariously out of touch. They removed the “DEI Department”. Which didn’t exist. Diversity, Equity and Inclusion was part of the admissions and outreach department. New College isn’t even big enough to have staff dedicated to that. They couldn’t even fire anyone so they made a stupid show of “eliminating it” that did nothing. They are trying to use the CLT, a Christian-based entrance exam, instead of the SAT. (Several alums have started adding an I after the CL.) Also, the formerly student-run cafe is now being run by a local business that has put (misspelled) bible verses on the cups. They want to have a “classics” education, and require students to take specific courses. New College already teaches from “the greats” for many classes, but they don’t actually know what the New College curriculum is. It will also almost certainly be from a Christian, western perspective, rather than the broader one that students currently get. New College teaches you HOW to think, it doesn’t tell you to think a specific way.
They are trying to put in both a baseball and basketball team. That doesn’t sound that bad on the surface but New College has barely enough students for ONE team, and that would have to be co-ed. It’s a school of around 800 students. (Probably less next year). There’s no way they qualify for competitive sports. It’s a grift meant to give positions to friends of the BoT through cronyism. I genuinely feel sorry for any student transferring because they were promised a sports career.
Also, New College doesn’t have sports and is proud of that fact. It’s an attempt to ruin our culture by attracting students that didn’t come here solely for learning. We even have a motto that our football team is “undefeated” (because we don’t have one). They also want to make this a pipeline for students from Inspiration Academy specifically and are trying to make it easier to enter. Finally, the cherry on top of the cake, and the reason that Mr. Gaiman gave this speech in the first place, is that they asked Scott Atlas to be speaker for commencement. He was one of the members of former President Trump’s COVID taskforce and actively downplayed the threat of COVID. His speech was not about how students have a bright future and how they will do great things. No, it was full of self-congratulations, name-dropping, and lies about COVID. If I hadn’t known what it was I would never guessed that it was a commencement speech. The only thing even remotely about the students was about standing up for your beliefs, even when people tell you you’re wrong. The people watching literally turned their backs on him and started chanting “Wrap it up!” which was pretty funny honestly. I enjoyed that. I’m pretty sure most people who attended did so to protest him. Also, the current president of the college didn’t make a speech or hand out diplomas, probably because he knew how disliked he is. Make no mistake, this is meant to be a test case. And when they are done here they will move on to other colleges, and conservatives will bring this to other states as well. That’s why resisting is so important. I will say a bright spot in all of this is the outpouring of support we have received. Thank you everyone who has reblogged this with a message of support. We appreciate it. Please feel free to message me if you have any questions and I’ll do my best to answer them.
#save new college#savenewcollege#new college of florida#chris rufo#scott atlas#ron desantis#wrap it up!#long post#ask to tag#I’m pretty sure I’m missing things#but yeah that’s most of it#it’s been EXHAUSTING#it’s only been a few months but it feels longer

The Ukrainian-American writer and critic Boris Dralyuk says of Hitler, Stalin, and a Nazi character in Vasiliy Grossman’s novel Stalingrad that they are “self-serious clowns.”
Sound like anyone you can think of? I love how this captures so accurately how these Fascists manage to look, simultaneously, extraordinarily uptight and mean-spirited, on the one hand, and clownish on the other.
LikeLike
cx: Please cut the redundant “simultaneously” from that last sentence.
LikeLike
Gaiman, ofc, is the author of American Gods, Coraline, Sandman, the nonfiction retellings in Norse Mythology, and the superb short fiction collections Fragile Things and Smoke and Mirrors.
LikeLike
Another thing to notice about these Fascists–how crabbed, how twisted, how narrow, how small they are. Think of a Pride parade. Then think of these people. Life versus death.
LikeLike
Bob, all I can think of about these MAGA zombie fascists DeSantis is obsessed with leading into a new dystopian theocratic nightmare of a future is Nazis operating ovens and gas chambers in concentration camps that DeSantis or someone like or worse than him would probably call National Liberation Campuses with no classes, just cages with concrete floors and no roofs. If the “liberals” that were rounde dup and shipped to these “campuses” were fortunate, they might get a paper sleeping bag… or nothing if unlucky. Food, forget it. Just let them starve. Their only liquid would be brackish, toxic water, and there would never be enough.
There would be very loud speakers everywhere blasting revised Bible quotes spouting and supporting hate, nothing but hate.
I won’t say what the fascists would do with attractive women, who might live longer because of the service they’d be forced to provide.
LikeLike
Always this doublespeak from the Fascists. That’s why Orwell invented the term. National Liberation Campuses. That is PRECISELY the kind of name they will create for their camps.
People seem to think that it can’t happen here. Dumb. That’s freaking dumb. NO STATE LASTS FOREVER WITHOUT DRAMATIC CHANGE. The Reich-wing has a small window in which the effect this. The smarter ones among them understand this. The game’s afoot, folks.
LikeLike
You have quite the imagination, Lloyd. LOL.
LikeLike
And all of this constriction and censoring is being done in the name of freedom.
We’re going to be hearing a lot more of that.
Freedom. OMG. Seriously, girl?
Freedumb.
LikeLike
You have to imagine Randy Rainbow saying that “Seriously, girl.”
LikeLike
Dictators have no regard for any traditions and practices in existing institutions. They seek to destroy what existed before and replace the culture with their values and narrow vision. This is the indoctrination that DeSantis accuses public schools of implementing. The right often accuses the left of doing exactly what they plan and set out to do.
Under DeSantis iron fist, Florida is ground zero for testing out regressive, authoritarian policies. If he succeeds in Florida, other red state governors are likely to copy DeSantis’ blueprint for destruction and spreading conservative Christianity in public institutions paid for by public dollars.
LikeLike
Other red state governors are already copying DeSantis’ authoritarian policies, eg book banning, outlawing Black history, banning medical care for the tiny number of trans kids in their state, demonizing drag queens, attacking gays.
LikeLike
Kristi Noem, just like DeSantis, has called for protecting freedom of speech on campus while banning pronoun choice and performances by drag queens. The did all three in the same memo. LOL. What a dolt.
LikeLike
DeSantis clearly indicated that he what he has accomplished in Florida he will accomplish across the United States if he is elected president. He makes no bones about it. The United States will look, feel and test just like Florida current is under Desantis.
What DeSantis has accomplished in Florida, and he is not done yet, amounts to terrorism and he should be considered a terrorist and be held accountable accordingly.
LikeLike
The Supreme/Extreme Court decisions that just wiped out much of the power of the EPA to regulate air pollution (West Virginia v. EPA) and water pollution (Sackett v. EPA) are just PART of an ongoing, overall effort, begun in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health, to ERASE much of the authority of the United States federal government on the basis of a NOVEL reinterpretation of the Constitution that ELIMINATES THE ABILITY OF THE EXECUTIVE TO EXERCISE UNENUMERATED POWERS–powers not SPECIFICALLY given it by the Constitution. This would reduce the federal government to a SHADOW of its former reach, long a right-wing Holy Grail.
Ron DeSantis just gave a speech in which he discussed precisely this, which he described as the necessity of “Reconstitutionalizing” our government:
“There’s a lot that the executive branch can do, and all I will say when it comes to these agencies… [is] buckle up when I get in there because the status quo is not acceptable, and we are going to make sure that we reconstitutionalize this government, and these agencies are totally out of control. There’s no accountability, and we are going to bring that in a very big way.”
See also DeSantis’s recent comments about doing away with Chevron deference (the legal principle embodied in a Supreme Court decision in Chevron v. National Resources Defense Council, which states that when Congress delegates an area of authority to an executive agency or department, such as regulation of wetlands, the agency or department, and not the courts, becomes responsible for determining the scope and nature of that regulation).
In connection with this envisioned vast overhaul of U.S. governance, DeSantis made this chilling promise:
“Even my worst critics in Florida will acknowledge when I tell people I’m going to do something, I don’t make promises or say I’m going to do something lightly.”
Here’s what I think is happening: Repugnican leaders have recognized that if Jabba the Trump wins the nomination, they will lose again. So, the current plan is to remove Trump by standing aside and letting the judicial process do that for them via the various cases now pending against the Orange Idiot. That way, they can take him out of the picture while not alienating the Trumpanzees from themselves–they can blame the fall of the Glorious Leader on some Deep State conspiracy led by Biden. Then, DeSantis will assume the Orange mantle and carry forward, in the Executive branch, the agenda that the Reich-wing cabal at the head of the Judicial branch has set for itself. (NB: the Orange Idiot Trump was extremely useful to The Federalist Society because he, knowing nothing himself, simply rubber stamped putting those people in place–the ones now reenvisioning U.S. government entirely).
It is worth remembering in this regard that the revolution in Germany that scuttled democratic government there and put the Fascists under Hitler in power took place BY LEGAL MEANS. And so the history we haven’t learned from repeats itself. Couple this legal implementation of the no unenumerated powers theory with the independent state legislature theory also being endorsed by the Extreme Court (a theory that holds that state legislatures, which are predominately Repugnican, can hold do-overs if they don’t like election results) and you get the recipe for the end of democracy and the onset of Fascist governance in the United States.
This is how these traitors overthrow democratic government. In the background, not via some sort of January 6th event.
NB: Someone on this blog recently mentioned the possibility that Ron Ron is clueless about what his policies actually mean. I don’t think so. He is NOT Trump. He knows what he is doing. That makes him a lot more dangereous.
LikeLike
cx: dangerous
LikeLike
Just look at New College. Look at the Florida schoolteachers emptying out their classroom libraries and administrators emptying their libraries. Look at the cities across Florida cancelling their Pride events.
proizvol. n. Russian. Arbitrariness. In particular, the random, capricious, arbitrary use of state power to generate fear as an instrument of command and control; state bullying or terror.
LikeLike
Much will depend on whether Trump is taken out of the picture by being criminally charged for major crimes like the ones in the documents and sedition cases. If Repugnican leaders are smart, they will encourage that, because, OF COURSE, Trump has no chance of winning in 2024. He has lost and lost and lost and lost again. 2024 would be no different.
LikeLike
Although he probably could win the Republican nomination from jail.
LikeLike
That would be quite the thing, huh? Trump running for president from jail, like Eugene Debs and Lyndon LaRouche.
LikeLike
Yes, DeFascist knows exactly what he’s doing.
Unlike Trump, who flails at targets but relies on people like Leonard Leo and Steve Bannon to tell him what to do, DeSantis knows what he is doing. Destroy the federal government.
LikeLike
It’s a chilling vision, but one that cannot be ignored. The radical right wing will take a wrecking ball to the federal government and justify it in a twisted way. What they have done to a woman’s right to choose is merely a preview of what they will impose if DeSantis, with his $200 million dollar war chest, gains control of the country.
LikeLike
Given DeSantis’s overt references to this of late, it seems to be an organized movement, an effort, behind the scenes, by VERY POWERFUL people to bring about a fundamental reenvisioning of the United States.
LikeLike
They are already doing this. Just look where we are. Abortion, almost eliminated. Air and water protections, VASTLY curtailed. I was at an auto dealership recently getting a repair done. The parking lot of the dealership was built around, and with an offset, a wetland area where there were fish and ducks. Why? EPA regs required this. The Supreme Court just eliminated the regs that made the dealership do this. Under the new rules, they could just backfill the wetland because it wasn’t connected to some larger body of water like a lake or a river or the ocean. Say goodbye to wetlands all across America. And to being able to breathe the air. Remember LA in the 1960s? Some of you are old enough. Well, we’re headed back there. Welcome to the Repugnican hellscape. A privileged few living in protected places away from the wasteland, the hellscape, from which they have extracted for their immediate consumption everything of any formerly possibly lasting value.
LikeLike
The EPA does allow for backfill now, if the company or homeowner pays to preserve wetlands elsewhere. We have a community where a lot of backfilling was done, and contractors built homes on it. Now the area constantly floods during a storm.
LikeLike
RT. Well, that’s all moot now. Now, since this Supreme Court decision, they can simply backfill the wetland, completely destroying it, if it is not connected to (as opposed to near or adjacent to) a river, lake, or ocean.
LikeLike
Probably best to not treat anonymous Tumblr posts as news sources.
LikeLike
Again… seriously?
The platform doesn’t matter. This alum could have hammered on it the college president’s door as “theses” – they are still the author’s words.
A letter or commentary to tumblr or Wall Street Journal is the author’s words.
LikeLike
Right but you don’t know who the author is or is what the author is saying is true.
LikeLike
What the anonymous writer wrote tracks with news stories about New College. The students there now are quirky, atypical norm-breakers. They raised money to conduct their own commencement ceremonies. Those who attended the regular commencement turned their back on Scott Atlas. They despise the college president Richard Corcoran, who is a hack politician.
What part of this post strikes you as untrue, FLERP?
LikeLike
“It seems plausible” or “it sounds like something that would be true” aren’t the right standards.
LikeLike
What do you question about the account, FLERP? Every incident has been reported in the media.
LikeLike
I don’t think chatGP or other AI could write something so informative with such informal writing. And – regardless of 100% accuracy or whatever % you’ll accept as factual – the governor is pulling off a dictatorial strategy with the same rubric as 1930s Germany. The small college takeover is easier than a 30,000 student campus. So first the model, then spread it around.
LikeLike
The risk isn’t AI. The risk, or likelihood, is that it’s a person recounting things he or she has heard but which may not be accurate. This shouldn’t need explanation.
LikeLike
The substantive claims made in the post are pretty easily checked, but you have a point, Flerp. Same applies to the anonymous posts on this and other blogs. However, there are many people who are currently teaching who cannot get away with posting on a blog such as this what they really think about a lot of matters like state child abuse via standardized testing and the campaign to allow cognitively challenged neo-Nazi white nationalist sibling spouses the FREEDUMB to decide what books can be in a teacher’s classroom library.
LikeLike
I agree with you, FLERP! Especially when I read this: “. . . It does not have grades, it instead has narrative evaluations. There are no required classes beyond what is legally required for Common Core. As an Honors College,”
Common Core for colleges now???
LikeLike
So the Board of Trustees want to change the mascot of the college for marketability. It is interesting that one of the options they suggested was “Conquistadores”.
Being from New Mexico “Conquistadores” has somewhat of a bad connotation. “Conquistadores” is one of those subject that would be considered “woke” in the minds of DeSantis and those like him. This is one subject that would be banned from school curriculum because it would be considered “woke” and not good for students to know about. It would make them feel bad.
LikeLike
The [ ] mascot is soooooo hilarious!!! I freaking love that. Very postmodern. Very meme-ready.
LikeLike
oops
{ }
The freaking empty set. ROFLMSAO!!! (The “S’ is for “sweet.”)
LikeLike
Say, the Conquistador could feel right at home w. Seton Hall University’s Pirate mascot. I’m not sure why a Catholic university would choose Pirates for its team name & mascot. Not very “Do unto others …”
LikeLike
Said it before and again – The ex-president is self-indulged and just dumb. This guy actually wants the job and is dumb, but not stupid.
There are 40 state colleges and universities (source: the internet).
Why did he pick this one as the poster child? Other had presidents replace – but this one is a full blown cleansing of everything from the president to the mascot to the vendors to the “gotta have sports” nostalgia about “college.”
Why? Because it IS small enough to control EVERY aspect of campus life and school.
He can hold this up as an example of what he can “do for you” – transform your hippie, no grades, sitting under the tree philosophizing, indoctrinating professor universities into bastions of… indoctrination. And Joe and Jane Florida, (no, just Joe, they don’t care what Jane thinks) will not distinguish an 800 student non-traditional college from a state campus with 40,000. “Vote for me, I’ll fix your college, too!”
I’d love to see Disney, Target, Anheuser-Busch, and others all off millions in contributions only to have them rejected.
LikeLike
It doesn’t matter. It just has to be some random target. That’s the thing with proisvol. Any target will do in order to spread fear generally.
LikeLike
And yeah, it’s small enough to blow through it in a few months, wiping everything (except the spirits of the kids; bless them).
LikeLike
No one on the campaign trail is going to know or question how large the school is. And I’d bet he will call it a University, not a College when he talks about it.
Like getting a hole in one at putt putt and saying he did it on the PGA tour. Oh, wait, that’s Santos
LikeLiked by 1 person
Unrelated, but DeSantis-related: a very well-done DeSantis deepfake. I suspect this will be just the first in a series.
LikeLike
Poor kids. Poor college. Oh how I love the “exhibition process” without grades, but proving proficiency through research projects. What a cool place. As a “creative guy” who played sports, but also created safe places for the kids who were not sports kids, but creative types. This all reminds me of Robert Redford in Brubaker when he saw a better way to reform the prison system, but in the end the bureaucratic powers were too much.
Check out Dennis Littky who created the “exhibition schools” way back in the day. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_Littky and here is another great speech by Neil Gaiman. https://jamesclear.com/great-speeches/make-good-art-by-neil-gaiman#:~:text=So%20be%20wise%2C%20because%20the,interesting%20for%20your%20being%20here.
LikeLike
These schools are old news and do quite well – university/colleges and high schools.
Some kids are round pegs in square holes in regular schools. They are lost, swallowed up, completely a mismatch, and usually bored. They are creative, out of the box thinkers, artists, and march to a different drummer. They’re C students with horrible attendance and see right through the trappings that most people love – but not all – in the school spirit, campus life, gotta fit in world.
Every state has them and many districts across the country. And, it’s been years since looking at it but data showed about a third of students were identified as gifted – or on the spectrum.
And, these are kids often bullied by people who sarcastically criticize them because they are different, they learn differently, and they don’t want to sit at the cool kids table.
I am sure if you take a minute to actually think about this you will remember some kids in your high school who fit the profile well – if anyone noticed them.
LikeLike
WW — As the biggest “weirdo,” I worked with all the “misfits” and found their diamonds. Many of these kids whose talents were ignored “stay within the lines, the lines are our friends” are highly successful now. You might enjoy this: https://gilroylife.com/2020/01/31/brownell-students-draw-on-creativity-to-solve-problems-initiate-change/
LikeLike
New College before DeSatnitize sounds like the experience that James Minchner had. Sorry, I cannot recall where he went to college, but it sounded just like this.
The difference is that no one much was listening to the critics of his institution, so the critics were going after other prey.
LikeLike
Michener turned out pretty well, didn’t he?
LikeLike
Swarthmore?
LikeLike
Yes, Swarthmore. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_A._Michener
LikeLike
DeSaster and his ilk need to stop concerning themselves with what books to ban and start reading a few more of them instead.
LikeLike
What an excellent suggestion.
LikeLike
Somehow it is difficult to imagine this guy reading a novel.
LikeLike
DeFascist is now say that Trump (Trump, for crying out loud) has moved too far to the Left.
LikeLike
saying
LikeLike
Callisto,
I like DisAster. Almost as much as DeFascist.
LikeLike
Excellent take on a deplorable undertaking. I’d like to meet this person.
LikeLike
Where is separation of church and state. His “freedom” is not my freedom. It’s like being force fed like the prisoners he tortured. Young people, vote, vote, vote.
LikeLike
DeSantis is free to tell you what to do, read, think.
LikeLike