NBC News reported on the takeover of Woodland Park, Colorado, by rightwing extremists. Woodland Park is a mostly white district with 8,000 residents. Colorado is a bluish state. The governor is a Democrat, as are the two Senators. But the state, like other states, has deep red districts. The new board wasted no time in pushing their ideological agenda, which apparently concerns even some Republicans.
WOODLAND PARK, Colo. — When a conservative slate of candidates won control of the school board here 18 months ago, they began making big changes to reshape the district.
Woodland Park, a small mountain town that overlooks Pikes Peak, became the first — and, so far, only — district in the country to adopt the American Birthright social studies standard, created by a right-wing advocacy group that warns of the “steady whittling away of American liberty.” The new board hired a superintendent who was previously recalled from a nearby school board after pushing for a curriculum that would “promote positive aspects of the United States.” The board approved the community’s first charter school without public notice and gave the charter a third of the middle school building.
As teachers, students and parents began protesting these decisions, the administration barred employees from discussing the district on social media. At least two staff members who objected to the board’s decisions were later forced out of their jobs, while another was fired for allegedly encouraging protests.
These rapid and sweeping shifts weren’t coincidental — instead it was a plan ripped from the MAGA playbook designed to catch opponents off guard, according to a board member’s email released through an open records request.
“This is the flood the zone tactic, and the idea is if you advance on many fronts at the same time, then the enemy cannot fortify, defend, effectively counter-attack at any one front,” David Illingworth, one of the new conservative school board members, wrote to another on Dec. 9, 2021, weeks after they were elected. “Divide, scatter, conquer. Trump was great at this in his first 100 days.”
The leaders of the Woodland Park School District are enacting an experiment in conservative governance in the middle of a state controlled by Democrats, with little in the way so far to slow them down. The school board’s decisions have won some praise in heavily Republican Teller County, but opposition is growing, including from conservative Christians and lifelong GOP voters who say the board has made too many ill-advised decisions and lacks transparency.
“I think they look at us as this petri dish where they can really push all their agenda and theories,” said Joe Dohrn, a Woodland Park father who described himself as a staunch Republican and “very capitalistic.” “They clearly are willing to sacrifice the public school and to put students presently in the public school through years of disarray to drive home their ideological beliefs. It’s a travesty.”
Teachers grew particularly alarmed early this year when word spread that Ken Witt, the new superintendent, did not plan to reapply for grants that covered the salaries of counselors and social workers.
At Gateway Elementary School in March, Witt told staff members he prioritized academic achievement, not students’ emotions. “We are not the department of health and human services,” he said, as teachers angrily objected, according to two recordings of the meeting made by staff members and shared with NBC News.
Someone in the meeting asked if taxpayers would get a say in these changes, and Witt said that they already did — when they elected the school board.
Over the past two years, school districts nationwide have become the center of culture war battles over race and LGBTQ rights. Conservative groups have made a concerted effort to fill school boards with ideologically aligned members and notched dozens of wins last fall.
In Colorado, conservatives started making gains earlier because school board elections are held in off years. Woodland Park offers a preview of how quickly a new majority can move to reshape a district — and how those battles can ripple outward into the community. Some longtime residents say that the situation has grown so tense, they now look over their shoulder when discussing the school board in public to avoid confrontation or professional consequences.
David Rusterholtz, the board’s president, believes that chasm predates his election in November 2021.
“This division is much more than political — this is a clash of worldviews,” Rusterholtz said at a board meeting in January. He concluded his remarks with a prayer for the district: “May the Lord bless us and keep us, may His face shine upon us and be gracious to us…”
When asked to respond to criticism from school personnel and parents, Illingworth, the board’s vice president, replied in an email: “I wasn’t elected to please the teacher’s union and their psycho agenda against academic rigor, family values, and even capitalism itself. I was elected to bring a parent’s voice and a little common sense to the school district, and voters in Woodland Park can see I’ve kept my promises.”
As the school year winds down, many of the Woodland Park School District’s employees are heading for the exit, despite recently receiving an 8% raise. At least four of the district’s top administrators have quit because of the board’s policy changes, according to interviews and emails obtained through records requests. Nearly 40% of the high school’s professional staff have said they will not return next school year, according to an administrator in the district.
The board’s critics have pinned their hopes on the next election in November — when three of the five school board members are up for a vote — to claw back control of the community’s schools.
“This is an active case study on what will happen if we allow extremist policies to start to take over our public education system,” said David Graf, an English teacher who recently resigned after 17 years in the district. “And the scariest part about it, they knew that this community would bite on it.”
The new board approved the district’s first charter school without any public notice. The approval of Merit Academy was listed on the board agenda as “board housekeeping.”
The district’s teachers union complained in an email to middle school staff that the board’s action was “underhanded, and at worst illegal.” A parent sued, aiming to force the board to follow open meetings law. A trial court judge did not rule on the legality of the board’s actions but ordered the board to list agenda items “clearly, honestly and forthrightly.”
In response to the teachers’ complaints, Illingworth accused the union of attempting to organize a “coup,” and instructed then-Superintendent Mathew Neal to make “a list of positions in which a change in personnel would be beneficial to our kids” and “help the union see the wisdom in cooperation rather than conflict.”
Illingworth’s emails spread after parents obtained them through open records requests. Subsequent board meetings attracted boisterous crowds, as teachers accused board members of creating a hostile environment, while other community members spoke in favor of the board for supporting “school choice” and quoted Scripture. A handful of parents, including some lifelong Republicans, tried to organize a recall, but failed to get enough signatures to force a vote.
The district’s superintendent resigned and was replaced by Ken Witt, who had been active in conservative politics in Jefferson County, CO., schools.
A week before Witt was hired, on Dec. 13, students in a class called Sources of Strength, which is part of a national suicide prevention program, asked their teacher what should they know about him as the sole finalist for the superintendent job.
Sara Lee, a longtime teacher at Woodland Park High School, responded, “You should Google him.”
The students did, and they didn’t like what they learned.
They discovered that Witt, as president of the school board in neighboring Jefferson County, supported a plan in 2014 to ensure the district’s curricula would promote patriotism and not encourage “social strife.” Witt said students who protested the board policies at the time were “pawns” of the teachers union. After he and two other conservative members of the board were recalled, Witt became executive director of an organization that oversees charter, online and other schools and helped launch Merit Academy.
The teacher, Sara Lee, had taught high school for 25 years, 18 of them in the district. The board reassigned her to an elementary school to punish her for sharing information about Witt. She resigned and was promptly hired by another district.
Please open the link and keep reading. The story gets worse. Parents and teachers tried to persuade Witt to reapply for mental health funds to support counselors and social workers. He refused, insisting that such problems should be handled by parents, not schools. The district’s mental health supervisor, unable to persuade him to ask for the funds, submitted her resignation.
To the original author of the piece:
“[O]verlooks Pikes Peak” is an unfortunate choice of expression. LOL. In the shadow of?
Vote the troglodytes out.
It is the GOP strategy to take over school boards, and they are using dark money to back their candidates. Dark money is the enemy of a fully functioning democracy as it can influence elections to the extent that it can easily influence enough uninformed voters to sway elections. The result will be chaos and disruption, and that is the GOP goal. It is mission accomplished when the mayhem starts.
“At Gateway Elementary School in March, Witt told staff members he prioritized academic achievement, not students’ EMOTIONS. ‘We are not the department of health and human services,’ he said, as teachers angrily objected, according to two recordings of the meeting made by staff members and shared with NBC News . . . Teachers grew particularly alarmed early this year when word spread that Ken Witt, the new superintendent, did not plan to reapply for grants that covered the salaries of COUNSELORS and SOCIAL WORKERS.” (My emphases)
Diane That’s one of the most ignorant statements I’ve ever read. For a person in the profession of education, it’s equivalent to a blind person piloting a 747 airplane.
Of course, Witt is right that children develop all facets of themselves as whole persons at home, long before they get to K-12. This includes social and emotional learning; but also, a sense of inclusion in community and culture, one’s own and others’, the arts, history (their own story and the world’s), physical health care, etc.; but all as a part of the learning curriculum (which I doubt Witt means by “academic”.) All under the careful eye of a qualified and caring teacher who knows WTF they are doing. And if an educator knows what they are doing, they know that “priorities” fluctuate with time and with children’s development; and so, they don’t have to “prioritize” one over the other. Apparently, someone who stacks wood for a living can do better than Witt does with his power in education.
First, the achievement of anything that looks like well-developed whole personhood is a long road (20+ years?); whereas Witt seems to think it ends somewhere around five years old.
Second, Witt is probably a “product” of the same irony that is exposed in contrasting (a) decades-long OVER-emphasis on “academic achievement” (test-taking, etc., and the tacit loss of whole-person needs) and (b) the INCREASING NEED for social and emotional learning for our students. From this view, and though much needed, separate programs for SEL and Social Services can be viewed as a mere band aid for a much deeper “infected” cultural wound.
So now we actually need SEL and Social Services more and more, and the person who has power doesn’t have the developmental horizon for understanding either the need or the cause: hence, there goes the funding.
Third, does Witt address what is supposed to happen to children when they come from dysfunctional homes, or have no home at all, and are placed in his view of an “academic-only” situation? Regardless of cause, it’s only an extremely truncated person who can fail to understand the responsibility of education in the “bigger picture” as an institution, especially as situated in a democratic culture?
Who ARE these people, and what has happened to them? CBK
When Witt was on the Jefferson County school board, he was an agent of chaos.
Diane I’m out of moderation, thank you. Maybe I should avoid using “WXX” in my narrative.
But truly, . . . the frustration I felt while reading that note . . . Cassandra was a “woke” person. CBK
Sorry it took so long for me to get to the comments. I was absorbed by reading about Trump’s NH Town Hall and how he once again took control with the same lies and bluster.
Diane Thanks for responding. FYI, from that same frustration, if I see or hear “Trump,” I cannot reach for the channel changer quick enough. I have reached a new level of loathing.
One thing you can say about Trump, however, is that he IS the embodiment of a kind of freedom, but freedom that is devoid of both authenticity and responsibility . . . and I think that’s part of his “base” attraction . . . attractive to the LCD of quashed and distorted human developmental patterns, to those who love freedom but struggle with or even hate responsibility. Maybe they didn’t learn about it in their early education . . . do you think? and now they have a leader whom they can IDENTIFY with from that horizon of (lack of) learning?
I cannot listen to or watch him. He literally makes me gag. CBK
CBK,
I didn’t watch or listen. I have a gag reflex when I hear his voice. Like many people, I’m shocked that CNN gave him an hour of free prime time to lie.
Diane I don’t know, but my guess is that someone at CNN wants the audience and probably got it . . . why, and what they will do with it is an entirely different question? CBK
I’m hoping they aired it so that moderate Republicans (they are still out there), swing voters, and the voting public in general would get a look at what’s at stake here.
He’s terrible. I think he demonstrated it in spades in that Town Hall. Might’ve gotten the approval of his immediate audience, but I’d bet he turned off a lot more. Not everyone wants to see another Jan 6.
what the hell is happening, these nuts are determined to wreck everything!
Welcome to the United Christian/Catholic States of America.
For insight, read about the Executive Director of the Colorado Catholic Conference. Bishops in Colorado said about her appointment, “We look forward to working with her to build a culture and society…” The new Director said, “Colorado has a vibrant Catholic community and has been a leader in state policy… It’s at the heart of St. John II’s evangelization of America.”
The Executive Director worked for EdChoice in Indiana and on policy research for the Heritage Foundation (Koch). She was a founding director of Catholic Education Partners and she’s a member of the right wing American Enterprise Institute’s ‘s Initiative on Faith and Public Life Council. Frederick Hess has long been at AEI.
The Director’s undergraduate degree is from a Christian university in …and Bible Studies… and, she’s studying for a masters at Holy Apostle College and Seminary.
Conservative Catholics are the majority on the US Supreme Court, courtesy of Leonard Leo, father of 9 and a conservative Catholic who is a leader in the Federalist Society. Leo recently received a donation of more than $1 bil. to spend on his agenda.
BINGO (the board has made too
many ill-advised decisions)
Learning has never been limited
to what is offered, or not, in
the class room.
“All over the South the lights of reason and tolerance and moderation began to go out under the resistance demand for conformity. During 1957, 1958, and 1959 a fever of rebellion and a malaise of fear spread over the region. Books were banned, libraries were purged, newspapers were slanted, magazines disappeared from stands, television programs were withheld, films were excluded. Teachers, preachers, and college professors were questioned, harassed, and many were driven from their positions or fled the South. The N.A.A.C.P. was virtually driven underground in some states. Words began to shift their significance and lose their common meaning. A ‘moderate’ became a man who dared open his mouth, an ‘extremist’ one who favored eventual compliance with the law, and ‘compliance’ took on the connotations of treason. Politicians who had once spoken for moderation began to vie with each other in defiance of the government.”
C.Vann Woodward, “The Strange Career of Jim Crow.” (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002), pp 165-166.
Thank you, Mark.
Please note that the book was originally published in 1955. Later updated. Still relevant.
Yes–I should have mentioned that. This is the most recent edition. It’s worth noting here, I think, that Martin Luther King called Woodward’s book “the Bible of the Civil Rights Movement.”
I assume you quote from a subsequent preface in the 2002 edition. Woodward’s study of Tom Watson shows his deep understanding of southern politics
For the central states currently, Mary Jo Mc Conahay’s book, “Playing God…” should share status with the C. Vann Woodward book? It appears that books like Woodward’s are more popular with the public when they look back and, when they focus on institutional racism. Less popular are the books that focus on the loss of rights for women and people who are gay and, that focus on ALEC’s laws that disproportionately harm people who are Black, today. It’s easier to to be pleasing when you’re an author that doesn’t drive home the point about a major religion’s politicized animosity toward women and those who are
homosexual.Religion is scary
for democracy is a hard sell.
It happened also last week at my grandchildren’s school in Grapevine-Colleyville ISD north of Dallas. Teachers and administrators are leaving in droves. Totally destroying the district. The take-over was funded by dark money from some pac called Patriot Mobile.
I think Patriot Mobile is a cell phone service for MAGA, which funnels profits into school board races. I invite any reader to research this one.
What happened there is what’s happening in Florida and other RED states.
The only way to stop elected MAGA RINO majorities from doing this is to vote them out or stop them before they can be elected.
The only way to do that is a major national media campaign (I don’t have much trust in the media to do this) and/or knocking on doors, coast to cast, to teach people what’s happening. Ignorance is the biggest enemy to saving our FREEDOMs we take for granted, and the biggest ally of the MAGA RINO fascists that will do anything they can to take many if not all of our FREEDOMs away from us until the U.S. is a clone of North Korea and Russia.
Maybe assist the “stop” by calling out right wing Catholic politicking? Read the bio of the Executive Director of the Colorado Catholic Conference and the articles about how the bishops, “look forward to working with her to build a culture and society…”
Brief summary of the bio- founding director of Catholic Ed. Partners and, there’s her involvement with EdChoice Indiana, AEI, Heritage Foundation.
Here in NYC, we have the Community (general ed) and Citywide (special ed) Education Councils. A parent can run for a post so long as they have a child/children in the system.
There was a segment on the Brian Lehrer show about the elections. Apparently, less than 2% of those eligible actually voted this past year. (which is a standard turnout). It’s not well advertised at all. Many of those who DID vote were MAGA Republicans who had organized specifically for the purpose of reshaping the educational system.
Took a lot of parents by surprise. I remember one caller saying she was floored. “I mean, this is Brooklyn. Not Florida!”
I wrote to Senator Mike Braun [R-IN] telling him not to allow books in schools to be banned.
He thinks librarians and school teachers are not dimwits who must be controlled by ‘intelligent’ politicians.
In more recent years, topics of a sexual or otherwise age-inappropriate nature have been featured and promoted in school curriculum and children’s spaces. This exposure to sexual content at such a young age is not only harmful to the development and mental well-being of children, but it is also damaging to the rights of parents who should be aware of the content available to their children.
Opps ARE DIMWITS!