Two of three rebellious Democratic legislators were expelled from the Tennessee legislature. The two who were expelled are Black. The third, who survived, is a white woman. This is an unprecedented sanction for defying the majority and speaking without permission, on behalf of gun control. Expulsion in the past was reserved for criminal behavior or sex scandals, not dissidence. The two legislators were expelled for breaking House rules of decorum.
It was an outrageous, undemocratic decision.
The vote to expel the second legislator, Gloria Johnson, a special education teacher, failed by one vote. When asked why Rep. Jones was expelled but she was not, she responded, “It might have something to do with the color of our skin.”
The Republican Party in Tennessee gerrymandered legislative districts to give themselves a supermajority. Democrats are powerless. Governor Bill Lee is a hard right ideologue.
After the murder of three children and three staff members at the Coventry School in Nashville, parents and students surrounded the Statehouse demanding gun control, which will never happen in this state so long as the state is solidly owned by the GOP.
Instead of enacting gun control, the legislators passed a law to arm teachers and “harden” schools.
NASHVILLE, Tennessee — Voting has begun in Nashville, where the Republican-controlled Tennessee state House of Representatives have already agreed to oust one of the three Democratic lawmakers in what marks the first partisan expulsion in the state’s modern history.
State Rep. Justin Jones, the first lawmaker expelled when lawmakers voted to adopt HR65, called the resolution “a spectacle” and “a lynch mob assembled to not lynch me, but our democratic process.”
“We called for you all to ban assault weapons and you respond with an assault on democracy,” Jones said during his 20-minute opening statement.
Earlier in the Thursday session, the legislature passed HB322, a bill that requires schools to implement a number of safety plans and security systems, over the objections of the three members who face expulsion.
“This bill is not about school safety that will not make our students safer,” Jones said, adding the move to “make our schools militarized zones” is borne out of refusal “to address the real issue, which is easy access to military grade weapons, which is easy access to weapons of war on our streets.”
State Rep. Gloria Johnson, a former teacher, decried the possibility of “gun battles at our schoolhouse door,” and state Rep. Justin Pearson, the last of the trio, argued that “the root cause that each of us have to address is this gun violence epidemic do the due to the proliferation of guns.”
“We don’t need a solution that says if you don’t lock a door or get someone with a gun, we need a solution that says people shouldn’t be going to schools and to houses and to neighborhoods with weapons of war,” Pearson added.Protesters gathered both inside — in the gallery, where they were told to remain silent — and in large groups outside, in apparent support of the three Democratic lawmakers.
Jones, Johnson and Pearson are facing expulsion resolutions for allegedly violating the chamber’s rules of decorum by participating in a gun control protest at the state Capitol last week. The demonstration came in the wake of the deadly Covenant School shooting in Nashville on March 27, where a former student fatally shot three children and three adults, police have said.
Republican leaders said that by siding with the large crowd of peaceful parents and students the three legislators had encouraged an “insurrection,” and some (the House Speaker) said it was even worse than the January 6 events when thousands of people broke into the Capitol and sent members of Congress hiding for their lives.
The courageous “Tennessee Three” were subject to expulsion for defending the lives of the innocent while the Republicans cower before the NRA.
Moments after voting to expel Jones, the House took up a resolution to expel Rep. Gloria Johnson.
Johnson brought two attorneys, former state Reps. John Mark Windle and Mike Stewart, to represent her. Windle spoke first on her behalf, pointing out specific accusations in the resolution of actions that Johnson specifically did not commit.
“It is an absolute falsehood that has been perpetuated on this body,” Windle said. “This woman did not shout – and that’s the first particular that they charged.”
Windle noted that Johnson did not bang on the House podium or become disorderly.
“Do you know who Gloria Johnson is? Does anybody know her? Is she a boogie man?” Windle asked. “Gloria Johnson is a school teacher. A special education teacher.”
“Today is Maundy Thursday, the day of betrayal,” he said. “Isn’t it fitting these allegations are made during Holy Week?”
During his remarks, Stewart argued that expulsion of a member for decorum violations is unprecedented in the House body.
“I haven’t heard anybody on this floor cite a single example of somebody being expelled from a legislative body based on these sort of flimsy charges,” Stewart said. “This is not just unprecedented in the state of Tennessee, and has no precedent in the United States of America.”
Rep. Gloria was not expelled, although she acted in concert with the other two legislators, both of whom are Black men, the youngest in the legislature at 27.
Then the legislature took up the case of the 3rd Democrat—Rep. Justin Pearson—who protested inaction on gun control. Like Rep. Jones, Rep. Pearson was expelled.
The two representatives can run for their seats again, but their districts will currently have no representation.
The GOP is a party that opposes democracy. In state after state, it is going full fascist.
Outrageous! Despicable! The republican party is no longer a party, it’s a cult of fascist worshipers! No reasonable person could any longer claim to be a Republican. Shame, shame, shame on them and the whole Republican party!
agreed
Michael Merrifield
Is this something new. Are you too young to remember the John Birchers at the 64 convention booing Nelson Rockefeller off the stage in San Fransisco when Rocky warned about extremism in the party.
Perhaps you think Mitch, Kevin and company are cowards for not confronting Trump and the wack jobs. Or Cruz even after Trump called his wife ugly and accused his father of being in on the plot to kill Kennedy.
Did Eisenhower confront McCarthy?
The Republican Party has been devoid of any policy to improve the lives of most Americans for at least 4 decades.
Joel,
Many, if not most of us, believed that our country was moving—by fits and starts—towards social progress. Until Trump was elected, that hope seemed justified. Since 2016, white nationalism, Christian nationalism have become the core of the GOP. That’s scary.
The John Birchers are no match for the likes of Donald bin Laden. January 6, 2021 is a day of infamy right up there with September 11, 2001 and December 7, 1941.
dianeravitch
I deleted the long version. The short version, the reaction to Obama and the behavior of Republicans from inauguration day on tells you all you need to know.
We are watching our democracy being destroyed from within. This is why we must continue to teach students to think critically.
A disgusting attack on democracy and destroying the will of the people in those districts. It scares me for what’s to come.
Tennessee’s GOP Legislature is a shame and an embarrassment. Rep. Gloria Johnson spoke from the heart about her experience as a teacher while she answered questions. The expelled Reps. Justin Jones and Justin Pearson aren’t going away. They’re young and very talented. We’ll all be seeing a lot more of them.
When I was a child, I had a book of illustrated fairy tales. It was old and many of the pictures were frightening, as many of those stories were meant to be morality lessons. One that remains quite clear more than 60 years on is of a girl of about 7 or 8. It is a drawing of her face, but where her nose ought to be is a gushing torrent of blood. Cutting off your nose to spite your face.
The youngs, who are the best of us, are coming and the GOP is in mortal danger. With the indulgence of our host, here are links to the eloquent, calm, powerful, cadences of these two representatives now expelled by foolish politicians in Tennessee.
And this from Gloria Jones, their companion in this action; she was not expelled by a single vote. Questioned, she said the different outcomes were likely due to race.
It of course is accidental that of the two black and one white reps, not the white one was expelled.
I saw this succinct explanation:
Oust all three representatives: fascism.
Oust two of three: fascism plus racism.
Gloria Jones was not expelled by one vote. Justin Pearson, before his expulsion, voted in her favor.
Here’s what Gloria Jones thought of the process.
Curmudgeon back. My momentary optimism from yesterday has disappeared already. Let’s not forget that the Wisconsin Supreme Court race may be negated by a cult supermajority in the state senate. Or at least it will try to maintain the status quo. And now this. Wonder why the two Black members are kicked out and the white one wasn’t…NOT!
By my count, these are now 22 de facto fascist controlled states in the United States: Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Missouri, Mississippi, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia, and Wyoming. Twelve states are closer than we think: Alaska, Arizona, Georgia, Kentucky, Maine, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New York, North Carolina, and Wisconsin. That’s 34 states where fascist beliefs are dominant or threatening to be so at any time. Is it any wonder they see the existence of the electoral college as existential? Is it any wonder that republicans are pushing the line that we are not a democracy but a constitutional republic? Is it any wonder that the term democratic-republic had never been uttered by any republican? Ever?
Liberals/progressives always seem to invest too much meaning in the few electoral victories they experience. The list of states above (we can quibble about the 12, but not about the 22) should sober them (us) up a bit.
Gloria Johnson, the Tennessee legislator who was not expelled, was asked on CNN what happens next. She smiled and said the vacancy in the two districts that lost their representatives would be filled by local officials. She said that they would most likely reappoint the two Justins who were expelled. There might be a legal battle on the claim that they couldn’t rejoin this session. But they will certainly be re-elected. And maybe reappointed sooner.
I’m confused. Aren’t legislators even in Tennessee elected by the people? How can they be expelled by the other party?
The only times that legislators were expelled in TN in the past were for gross sexual impropriety and accepting bribes. Breaking the rules should have brought a referral to the ethics committee, not expulsion.
Because the GOP has a supermajority, they can do whatever they want.
Watch the Tennessee House debate and vote on resolutions to remove Democratic Representatives Justin Jones, Gloria Johnson, and Justin J. Pearson online at C-Span.org:
https://www.c-span.org/video/?527219-1/tennessee-general-assembly-votes-expel-democrats&live&vod
“Tennessee state House of Representatives have already agreed to oust one of the three Democratic lawmakers ”
I think I know why they didn’t dare to kick out Gloria Johnson immediately. My feeling is that Johnson, a Knoxville rep, was not fired because she is too popular, and that would have unpredictable consequences.
I think the reason Lee is doing outrageous things that put him in the National news is to test the waters if he could run for presidency—if not now, next time around. He’s got the same commitment to right-wing issues as DeSantis, but he is more stable with less personal quirks.
Neither Lee nor DeSantis have the charisma of Trump, and to make themselves visible nationally, they need to do outrageously right-wing actions. I think this is very risky for them.
All DeSantis and Lee think about is how to please their own party. That may win them the GOP nomination but alienate the rest of the country which is the majority.
For more than four decades, I worked closely with the Tennessee Legislature, both Republicans and Democrats. Those were the times of great leaders and statesmen, people like Leonard Dunavant, John Bragg, Ned McWherter, Doug Henry, Ray Albright, and many, many more from both sides of the aisle. We didn’t always agree, but we got along. Civility was ever present, as was mutual respect. We viewed our jobs as serious business, and we conducted our business seriously. In short, professionals were in charge.
Since retirement, I’ve rarely returned to the legislative chambers. The last legislative committee meeting I attended was in the spring of 2015. I have no plans to make any return visits.
Why? Simply stated, the Legislature I knew and respected no longer exists. Today, clowns have replaced statesmen, and even when the circus was popular I never cared much for clowns. I often thought they were silly.
Out of curiosity, I watched a bit of yesterday’s expulsion hearing on TV. It confirmed that the circus is still in town.
Sent from my iPhone
I grew up in Chattanooga in the 1960s and 1970s where my dad led the effort to integrate lunch counters, schools, and a variety of businesses. I saw a city that defeated a Bull Connor wannabe replaced with a Republican Fire and Police Commissioner who eventually became a highly regarded Mayor. I saw Albert Gore Sr., Al Gore Jr., and Howard Baker lead a state toward a Southern Renaissance. Now we see a backward state that has fallen in line with other Republican states that reject diversity in any form.
At the door to the Tennesse legislative chamber: Whites enter here, Negroes go to the back of the building. . .
. . . hey now we didn’t say you could enter in the back.
What has played out this week is just the culmination of supression of democractic norms in Tennessee. Fortunately, local press has been on the case. Careful viewers will see some familiar faces.
In the cult classic “Time Bandits”, the Supreme Being arrives in the nick of time to destroy the Evil Genius who wishes to take over the Universe. Once “Evil’ has been destroyed, the Bandits are then tasked to clean up the mess and warned that the carbon material left behind is concentrated evil and should be handled with care. The implication is that evil will find ways to return. The archetypal implications of this movie are repeated again and again through everything from the Old Testament to Harry Potter to the Game of Thrones. The current expulsion of two representatives in the Tennessee House of Representatives is a replay of the antebellum power play of the 1850s that led to the Civil War and the Southern rejection of Reconstruction late in the 19th century that brought about Jim Crow driven by one party rule. The actions of the Tennessee legislature along with that of Florida, Texas, Indiana et al is an open exclamation that 21st Century Republicans do not believe in the idea of a republic, but the autocratic tyranny of one-party rule common in Russia and China. While Republicans bewail the contributions of George Soros to progressive causes, they welcome the contributions of Koch, Devos, Crow, et al to their cause for corporate kleptocracy. The fundamental pillar of American democracy is the embrace of dissent as a means to build a more perfect union. The actions of the Tennessee House of Representatives embodies the rejection of representative government.
You know this, Paul, but I will repeat. George Soros is not the liberal equivalent of Charles Koch or DeVos.
Soros gives money to strengthen democratic institutions. They fund organizations to destroy democratic institutions.
His name is a dog whistle for anti-Semitism.
Gee, I could drive to Indianapolis and attend this fantastically WONDERFUL meeting. /s It’s ONLY 3 hours away and I could hear Trump and Pence speak. [BARF!] Dang. I’m not an NRA member.
Wonder why these Second Amendment gun lovers aren’t demanding that ALL GUNS be allowed in this “most politically significant and popular event in the country” since they keep people safe? Why are they screening everyone? Surely they trust NRA members. My disgusting Senator Braun [R-IN] and Governor Holcomb [R-IN] are attending. I continuously write letters to Braun telling why guns should have stricter controls. He ALWAYS replies that we can’t take away Second Amendment rights.
………………………………………..
Per the U.S. SECRET SERVICE, firearms, firearm accessories, knives, and other items WILL NOT BE PERMITTED in Hall A.
NRA-ILA’s Annual Leadership Forum is one of the most politically significant and popular events in the country, featuring our nation’s top Second Amendment leaders in government, the media, and the entertainment industry.
Join our nation’s top Second Amendment supporters for the 2023 NRA-ILA Leadership Forum on Friday, April 14th.
Event Starts at 2:00 PM – Doors Open at 12:00 PM
Admission is free and will be first come, first served. Tickets are not required but you must be an NRA Member to attend. You may start lining up at 11:00 AM.
IMPORTANT: Security Information for the NRA-ILA Leadership Forum. Please read carefully.
U.S. Secret Service will control security within Hall A of the Indiana Convention Center and require attendees of the forum to be screened through magnetometers before entry. You will be subject to a search of your person and belongings.
Per the U.S. SECRET SERVICE, firearms, firearm accessories, knives, and other items WILL NOT BE PERMITTED in Hall A. For a full list of prohibited items, please click here. Read the list of prohibited items carefully before traveling to the event. You will not be allowed in Hall A with any of the items on this list. Attendees are strongly advised to not bring bags to help with timely security processing.
There is no storage available for firearms.
2023 CONFIRMED SPEAKERS SO FAR:
WAYNE LAPIERRE, NRA EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT
PRESIDENT DONALD J. TRUMP
VICE PRESIDENT MIKE PENCE
SENATOR MIKE BRAUN [R-IN]
GOVERNOR ERIC HOLCOMB [R-IN]
CONGRESSMAN JIM JORDAN
KRISTI NOEM, SOUTH DAKOTA GOVERNOR
CHRIS SUNUNU, NEW HAMPSHIRE GOVERNOR
GOVERNOR ASA HUTCHINSON
VIVEK RAMASWAMY
GOVERNOR RON DESANTIS [video message]
GOVERNOR NIKKI HALEY [video message]
SENATOR TIM SCOTT [video message]
I wonder why this magnificent group of Second Amendment lovers aren’t demanding that EVERYONE be allowed to bring in their gun? They are having everyone screened. WHY? Don’t they fully trust NRA members?
I could drive to Indianapolis in 3 hours. Dang, I’m not an NRA member. Wouldn’t I LOVE to hear Trump and Pence speak? [BARF!]
I continuously write gun protest letters to Senator Braun who ALWAYS responds by saying we can’t take away Second Amendment rights. It doesn’t matter to him how many innocent children and adults get killed. The rights of the gun lovers means more than the rights of people to live.
…………………………………
Per the U.S. SECRET SERVICE, firearms, firearm accessories, knives, and other items WILL NOT BE PERMITTED in Hall A.
NRA-ILA’s Annual Leadership Forum is one of the most politically significant and popular events in the country, featuring our nation’s top Second Amendment leaders in government, the media, and the entertainment industry.
Join our nation’s top Second Amendment supporters for the 2023 NRA-ILA Leadership Forum on Friday, April 14th.
Event Starts at 2:00 PM – Doors Open at 12:00 PM
Admission is free and will be first come, first served. Tickets are not required but you must be an NRA Member to attend. You may start lining up at 11:00 AM.
IMPORTANT: Security Information for the NRA-ILA Leadership Forum. Please read carefully.
U.S. Secret Service will control security within Hall A of the Indiana Convention Center and require attendees of the forum to be screened through magnetometers before entry. You will be subject to a search of your person and belongings.
Per the U.S. SECRET SERVICE, firearms, firearm accessories, knives, and other items WILL NOT BE PERMITTED in Hall A. For a full list of prohibited items, please click here. Read the list of prohibited items carefully before traveling to the event. You will not be allowed in Hall A with any of the items on this list. Attendees are strongly advised to not bring bags to help with timely security processing.
There is no storage available for firearms.
2023 CONFIRMED SPEAKERS SO FAR:
WAYNE LAPIERRE, NRA EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT
PRESIDENT DONALD J. TRUMP
VICE PRESIDENT MIKE PENCE
SENATOR MIKE BRAUN [R-IN]
GOVERNOR ERIC HOLCOMB [R-IN]
CONGRESSMAN JIM JORDAN
KRISTI NOEM, SOUTH DAKOTA GOVERNOR
CHRIS SUNUNU, NEW HAMPSHIRE GOVERNOR
GOVERNOR ASA HUTCHINSON
VIVEK RAMASWAMY
GOVERNOR RON DESANTIS [video message]
GOVERNOR NIKKI HALEY [video message]
SENATOR TIM SCOTT [video message]