The Hasidic bloc of voters wields unusual political power in New York City and New York state, because the community tends to vote as a bloc. Rare is the elected official willing to challenge their large stream of public funding for their orthodox religious private schools. The New York Times has written previously about the significant flow of public money to their private schools (more than $1 billion over the past four years), and about the abysmal performance of students in those schools on the rare occasion when they take state tests. Many such schools do not teach in English and do not teach secular subjects, in blatant violation of state law.
The New York Times recently wrote in detail about the misuse of public money collected for special education services in Hasidic schools.
Less than a decade ago, New York City drastically changed the way it provided special education to thousands of children with disabilities.
State law requires cities to deliver those services to students in private schools, even if the government has to pay outside companies to do it. But for years, when parents asked, New York City officials resisted and called many of the requests unnecessary.
In 2014, Mayor Bill de Blasio changed course. Responding to complaints, especially from Orthodox Jewish organizations, he ordered the city to start fast-tracking approvals.
The policy has made it easier for some children with disabilities to get specialized instruction, therapy and counseling. But in Orthodox Jewish religious schools, particularly in parts of the Hasidic community, the shift has also led to a windfall of government money for services that are sometimes not needed, or even provided, an examination by The New York Times has found.
In 2014, New York made it easier for private school students to receive city-funded special education. More than half of legal requests for aid last school year (as of March 14) came from areas with large Hasidic and Orthodox populations.
Dozens of schools in the Orthodox community have pushed parents to get their children diagnosed with disabilities, records and interviews show. At least two schools have sent out mass emails urging families to apply for aid. A third school provided parents with a sample prescription to give their children’s doctors, saying a diagnosis would bring more resources for the school.
Today, at Hasidic and Orthodox schools, which are called yeshivas, higher percentages of students are classified as needing special education than at other public and private schools in New York City, a Times analysis of government data found.
In the fervently religious Hasidic community, where Yiddish is the dominant language, schools focus on teaching Jewish law and prayer, while often providing little secular education in English. The Times found that at 25 of the city’s approximately 160 Hasidic yeshivas, more than half of the students are classified as needing special education. Records show the classifications are routinely justified by citing the students’ struggles with English.
Across all city schools, one in five students is classified as having a disability. There is little research into whether disabilities occur more frequently in the Hasidic community than in others.
With money more easily available, entrepreneurs with few qualifications have made millions providing services in yeshivas. More than two dozen different companies have opened in the past eight years, records show. Some of them now bill more than $200 an hour per student — five times the government’s standard rate — for what is essentially tutoring.
Some companies have been allowed to collect more than $100,000 a year for providing part-time tutoring services to a single student with mild learning challenges, The Times found.
At least 17 companies have employed people with questionable credentials to provide services, often paying them a fraction of the hourly rate that the firms collect from the city. While some companies provide quality services, others rely on programs that quickly churn out graduates with master’s degrees, some of whom are as young as 18.
“There are a lot of kids in the ultra-Orthodox community who have disabilities. The problem is that the community is not serving the students,” said Elana Sigall, a former top city special education official, who now visits yeshivas as a consultant. “They’re accessing tremendous amounts of city resources, but they’re not actually providing special education.”
One of the firms that opened soon after Mr. de Blasio changed the rules, Yes I Can Services, founded by a husband and wife who had scant education experience, now collects tens of millions of dollars a year.
By law, families who want the government to pay a private company to provide services must make their case against the city in a legal proceeding overseen by an impartial hearing officer. But as requests have increased, officials say they have stopped policing them. Families filed nearly 18,000 requests last year — with more than half coming from neighborhoods with large Hasidic and Orthodox populations — but officials waved through most of them.
In all, more than $350 million a year now goes to private companies that provide services in Hasidic and Orthodox schools, The Times found…
“Cases involving nonpublic schools have ballooned so wildly that they have engulfed and hobbled the entire system,” said John Farago, a longtime hearing officer who has overseen thousands of requests. “It’s affected the access to justice of all, and swamped the cases of children who attend public schools.”
The MORE religious = the MORE CORRUPT?
No need for a question mark.
As there is little to lose for Democrats it is Time to shut these schools down . The Ultra Orthodox have been voting Republican for over a decade. A religious cult as vile as any other religious cult. In fact ultra orthodox is a misnomer. Cult is a far more accurate description for Hasidim who are gaming the system like any organized crime syndicate.
If this won’t teach the lesson about why we must separate Church(es) from State(s), then nothing will. I suggest you marinate on that. (Extra credit for anyone who knows the source of that last sentence.)
Spell “correct” of urinate?
The Yeshivas are doing what other privatizers have done before. They are exploiting a highly corrupt, political system. Our major flaw was allowing the wall between public and private to be breached. As a result any quasi-religious group can leech off the public dollar, game the system and send public funds to friends, associates and even family members.
Returning to yesterday’s discussion about economists and efficiency, I think economists in theory should support public education as they are a model of efficiency. They are the very definition of “economy of scale.” There is no profiteering and very little opportunity for fiscal corruption. Privatization is highly inefficient. Frankly, the math does not add up. We cannot pay for a quality public system and a bunch of parasitic private options for the same amount of funds. Either more money will have to be spent, or the quality of the service will decline. Unfortunately, we are allowing our common good to be be usurped by greedy, wasteful privatizers and dishonest religious groups.
Yes, retired teacher,
Your last sentence is so TRUE!
Have worked in school systems where Liaisons and special ed staff were 100% part of the referral, eligibilities and placement for children with disabilities in settings outside of the counties school system. This worked for years until the Privatization Movement and Greed overloaded the school system’s abilities to attend and serve an ever increasing and unbelievable large number of referrals. To maintain the process and personal to serve these students in private schools, charters, religious settings, home schools, psychiatric institutions, hospitals, state facilities, residential facilities, group homes,….an endless lists and costly. The legal identification process, services and personnel ….due process, were followed to the letter of the law.
Also, simultaneously the Social Security Benefits pipeline and the private psychological evaluations pop-up-offices poured money into labeling children with disabilities. Overloading that system.
At times, the truly disabled child and family were having a harder time receiving SSI $ than the psych mills processed children and families.
The original INTENT of all SpEd Law from the 1970s was to provide free & appropriate services, but humans have a way to exploit when so inclined.
BTW, never knew that struggling with English in Yeshivas was considered a disability. Creativity is endless. Ultimately, the stealing of funds hurts the honest and most vulnerable who are not exploiting the systems.
Loopholes in the process to access $M is a lucrative INDU$TRY.
Very disheartening.
“we are allowing”???
Of the People,
By the People,
For the People
As Machiavelli stated,
all of humanity comprises
two groups: the rulers
and the much larger
group, the ruled.
Our so called “democracy”
is predicated on the
idea that the ruled
rule, that is, the
ruled control the rulers
via our elected
“representatives”.
So when it comes to
illusions a group
holds dear we need
to ask who benefits
from these illusions,
who suffers?
Unless contradictions
are brought to a
head, we will remain
the same.
Of the People, By the People, For the People
Kudos to the NYTimes — but this has been known by the state for years. Shame on the state for allowing this. And why? Because the Hasidim are voting blocks. Politics has trumped children on this for years. Hopefully with this dirty secret now in public, the state will be forced to stop the nonsense and the stealing that is happening in this community. I note that I am Jewish – and I am saddened and embarrassed
by the actions of the Hasidim
Due to political clout or just plain influence pedaling or out-right fraudulent practices the ultra orthodox mafia is ripping off the system for hundreds of millions, State Ed is complicit, failing to halt payments and call in the Feds, mayors, from Bloomberg to de Blasio to Adam’s trade for political support, many of the so-called “providers” have deep roots in the Hasidic community, de Santis can learn from them …
If you click the link and look at the New York state map for the results of the 2020 presidential election, you will discover that most of the state’s counties in rural areas voted for Trump and from what I’ve read most if not all of those counties are controlled by elected conservatives, including elected public school boards.
https://www.politico.com/2020-election/results/new-york/
Democrats dominate the state legislature but not those rural counties.
The population in the rural counties continues to decrease and after the court-orders redistricting Democratis still maintain super majorities in both Houses of the state legislature- the ultra orthodox are heavily concentrated in small areas
The only way this theft of public money meant for public schools will stop is through the courts.