Talk about cheesy! Talk about hypocrisy! Talk about weasels! Talk about betrayal of the public! Talk about disdain for democracy!
The people of Arizona voted overwhelmingly against vouchers, but the Koch-controlled GOP majority in the legislature is promoting a dramatic expansion of vouchers. Voters be damned!
To buy the support of public school parents, the legislators added a big increase in public school funding, but the new funding is available only if the vouchers are enacted.
Arizona has 1.1 million students, but only 11,775 have used vouchers to leave public schools. Now the Republicans want to fund vouchers for every student in the state. Does it matter that multiple academic studies have found that vouchers do not improve education? Of course not.
Do you think these guys know how repellent they are?
Four years after voters rejected a similar move, Republican lawmakers are pushing ahead with a plan to let any of the 1.1 million students in public schools get vouchers to attend private and parochial schools.
And they are holding a plan to boost aid to public schools hostage until they get what they want.
HB 2853, approved Wednesday by the House Ways and Means Committee on a 6-4 party-line vote, would remove all restrictions on who can get what are called Empowerment Scholarship Accounts. Backers say this ensures that parents get to decide what is the best option for their youngsters.
That assertion was disputed by Beth Lewis, executive director of Save Our Schools.
She said that unlike public schools, private schools can pick and choose who they want to accept. Lewis said those schools, many of which are for-profit corporations, accept those who will cost them the least, meaning the highest achievers and students who do not have special needs.
Republicans said they are not ignoring the needs of public schools, voting Wednesday for HB 2854, which would increase state aid to schools by $400 million, above another $250 million additional already planned.
But there’s less there than meets the eye.
First, only half of that additional cash is permanent. And it is weighted so the districts with the most students in financial need would get more.
Beyond that, schools would have to wait until the 2023-24 school year for the one-time $200 million infusion.
And there’s something else.
House Majority Leader Ben Toma, R-Peoria, who crafted both measures, included a “poison pill” of sorts: It says that if the vouchers do not become law, the public schools don’t get any of that $400 million.
That is designed to deter the education community from doing to HB 2853 what they did to a similar voucher expansion measure approved by GOP lawmakers in 2017.
They collected sufficient signatures to put the expansion on the 2018 ballot. And voters overruled the legislation by a margin of close to 2 to 1…
And Lewis told Capitol Media Services that supporters of public education won’t be deterred, vowing to go to the ballot once again if the Republican-controlled legislature approves universal vouchers. She said while that would mean the loss of $400 million — or, really, $200 million of ongoing funds — that is nowhere near the amount that public schools need in Arizona.
She pointed out that voters in 2020 approved Proposition 208 to infuse another nearly $1 billion into public education. That was sidelined after the Arizona Supreme Court ruled the tax could not be levied because it bumped up against a constitutional limit on education spending.
Lewis, the education community and their Democratic allies are not alone in saying schools need more than HB 2854 is offering.
Sen. Paul Boyer, R-Glendale, said he is holding out for an amount close to that $1 billion figure. And with only 16 Republicans in the 30-member Senate, the plan cannot get final approval without his vote.
Wednesday’s votes come as school districts won a significant legal victory, with a judge saying they are entitled to pursue claims that the legislature shorted them billions of dollars.

Utah has done something similar. The state legislature this year brought up “Hope Scholarships” during the session. Came close to passing, too, before an outcry from teachers, parents, and other concerned citizens. Never mind that Utah voters have rejected vouchers–twice. Fortunately our legislative session finished in March, but interim education committee meetings indicate it will be back. So much for representing their constituents.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Confederacy shouldn’t have called it a secession. Surely, the United States would have allowed the South to secede without any trouble if it had been called a Withdrawal Scholarship. See, you just change the name from vouchers to Unicorn Endowments, and viola! All good.
LikeLiked by 1 person
you really understand this game 🙂 🙂
LikeLike
I wonder if there’s a struggle going on behind the scenes to see who ends up controlling the Republican Party and all the RED states between Charles Koch’s ALEC and Traitor Trump’s dangerously dumber than dumb BIG LIE MAGA fascists.
LikeLiked by 1 person
perhaps there will be such infighting that nothing can get organized
LikeLike
Some the red states are emulating DeSantis in Florida. Knowing the voters will support public education in a democratic election, DeSantis has expanded vouchers to those with higher incomes without asking for the public to weigh in. In fact, these authoritarians think they know what is good for the public so they impose rather than put an unpopular issue up to a vote. Bypassing voters is an new Republican strategy.
LikeLike
Just like Ohio, the supporters of charters never stop, they only get promoted and have more power!
LikeLike
Saw that same crap from the GOP here in the Show Me State in regards to right to work (for less). The voters had rejected that nonsense three times and did it a fourth, while electing a Republican majority and governor-guess who? If you guessed Greitens you win a Kewpie Doll. Anyway the very first thing they did, within a day of being in session, they wrote up a Right to Work (for less) bill, passed it and Greitens signed it. So much for the citizens will being satisfied.
LikeLike
The voters repealed that law a year later. Too bad so many don’t realize that it was GOP shenanigans that allowed the bill to pass without voter approval. How often will the MO voters be bitten by the GOP? Far too many from what I can tell.
LikeLike