Kate McGee of the Texas Tribune writes that Lt. Governor Dan Patrick has threatened to kill tenure in Texas universities to compel compliance with his wish to stop any teaching about race or racism, which he calls “critical race theory.”
Dan Patrick is a phony Texan. He wears boots, but he was born and raised in Baltimore. His birth name was Dannie Scott Goeb. He was the little Rush Limbaugh of Texas until he entered politics. He has never abandoned the politics of hatred and division that have made him successful. He has advocated for teaching creationism in the schools and backed legislation last year to prevent public schools from requiring that students read writings by prominent civil rights figures, such as Susan B. Anthony, Cesar Chavez, and Martin Luther King Jr., when covering women’s suffrage and the civil rights movement in social studies classes.” He is a 21st century Know-Nothing.
McGee writes:
Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick said Friday that he will push to end professor tenure for all new hires at Texas public universities and colleges in an effort to combat faculty members who he says “indoctrinate” students with teachings about critical race theory.
“Go to a private school, let them raise their own funds to teach, but we’re not going to fund them,” said Patrick, who is running for reelection. “I’m not going to pay for that nonsense.”
Patrick, whose position overseeing the Senate allows him to drive the state’s legislative agenda, also proposed a change to state law that could make teaching critical race theory grounds for revoking tenure for professors who already have it. His announcement tees up the next major fight at the Texas Capitol over how college students learn about the history of race and racism in the United States.
Tenure is an indefinite appointment for university faculty that can only be terminated under extraordinary circumstances. Academics said Friday that tenure is intended to protect faculty and academic freedom from exactly the kind of politicization being waged by Patrick.
“This kind of attack is precisely why we have faculty tenure,” said Michael Harris, a professor at Southern Methodist University studying higher education, who likened tenure to lifetime appointments given to federal judges. “The political winds are going to blow at different times, and we want faculty to follow the best data and theory to try to understand what’s happening in our world.”
Patrick on Friday also proposed making tenure review an annual occurrence instead of something that takes place every six years. At the press conference, he said his proposals already have the support of state Sen. Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe, who chairs the Senate Higher Education Committee…
Patrick’s plan drew swift condemnation from the American Association of University Professors, the body that helped develop the 1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure that has been adopted by universities and colleges nationwide.
“There’s always been attempts to interfere in higher education, but I have never seen anything as egregious as this attack,” said Irene Mulvey, president of the AAUP. “This is an attempt to have government control of scholarship and teaching. That is a complete disaster. I’ve never seen anything this bad…”
Patrick said his latest priority is in response to the UT-Austin Faculty Council after it passed a nonbinding resolution Monday to reaffirm instructors’ academic freedom to teach on issues of racial justice and critical race theory.
“Legislative proposals and enactments seek to prohibit academic discussions of racism and related issues if the discussion would be ‘divisive’ or suggest ‘blame’ or cause ‘psychological distress,’” the resolution stated. “But fail to recognize that these criteria … chill the capacity of educators to exercise their academic freedom and use their expertise to make determinations regarding content and discussions that will serve educational purposes.”
One day after the resolution passed, Patrick signaled on Twitter that he would continue the fight against teaching the discipline in the next legislative session.
“I will not stand by and let looney Marxist UT professors poison the minds of young students with Critical Race Theory,” Patrick wrote on Twitter. “We banned it in publicly funded K-12 and we will ban it in publicly funded higher ed. That’s why we created the Liberty Institute at UT.…”
The proposal to end tenure would fundamentally change the way Texas universities operate in terms of hiring, teaching and research. Faculty members warn it’s likely to impose major challenges for Texas universities to recruit and retain researchers and scholars from across the country…
Harris said even the headlines to propose ending tenure could hurt Texas universities that are hiring faculty members for next year who might think twice about whether to take a job at a public university.
A few strategic phone calls from public university presidents to their alumni in the state legislature could shut down Dan Patrick mighty quick. He is an embarrassment to the state of Texas.
The citizens of Texas should do a recall Vote of no confidence .
He is elected and took and oath to treat will citizens equal .
He should not be racist and perpetuate a white supremacist attitude and an elected position that he said playing that he has the property of all voters vote for the best interest of the citizens of Texas.
Citizens of Texas do a recall and show him the people control his elected position .
Amen
Dang right. Clifford Hardwick.
To be an embarrassment to the state of Texas is a mighty tall order.
One of my very favorite movie scenes is from Nurse Betty as hitmen, played by Morgan Freeman and Chris Rock, pursue Betty across the country. When their car breaks down in Texas, Freeman says, “I can’t believe I’m stuck in the middle of purgatory with you.” To which the Chris Rock character responds, “It’s worse than that, you’re in Texas.”
🙂
There’s an old, anonymous poem called “Hell in Texas” that provides an origin story for the state. It begins like this:
The devil, we’re told, in hell was chained,
and a thousand years he there remained,
and he never complained, nor did he groan,
but determined to start a hell of his own
where he could torment the souls of men
without being chained to a prison pen.
The poem goes on to describe the ways in which the devil remade the place with thorns, sand fleas, mosquitos, tarantulas, horned toads, etc. And then we get these lines:
The devil then said that throughout the land
he’d manage to keep up the devil’s own brand,
and all would be mavericks unless they bore
the marks and scratches and bites by the score.
The heat in the summer is a hundred and ten,
too hot for the devil and too hot for men.
The wild boar roams through the black chaparral,
it’s a hell of a place he has for hell
Satan’s Last Vacation
He took a short vacation
The one that we call Satan
In Texas, it is said
And Satan now is dead
He couldn’t stand the heat
And couldn’t stand the flame
And Texas did defeat
The Devil at his game
I wonder which white racist organization Patrick belongs to: KKK, Skin Heads, White Supremest, etc. Probably carries a membership card to at least one of organizations.
Totally vile and despicable political grandstanding of the worst sort. It’s a violation of free speech, a suppression of intellectual freedom of thought. Talk about cancel culture, this is thought control and Big Brother authoritarianism designed to intimidate college professors and their students. From the same state that is making abortions illegal. Is there no depth to which Texas GOP ghouls will sink? Obviously not.
As a reader wrote yesterday, Dan Patrick is one of those GOP hypocrites who brays about “freedom” and “liberty” but then takes away women’s right to control their own bodies and wants to silence teachers and professors who discuss topics he opposes. Cancel culture at its worst! He opposes the freedom and Liberty of people who disagree with his bigoted views.
These so-called freedom loving types are actually right wing authoritarians. In theory they don’t want the government interfering with their property rights or livelihood, but they have no problem quashing academic freedom and the free speech of those that do not share their biased opinions. All of them are fake strongmen hypocrites.
It’s Klansel culture
“Dan Patrick is a phony Texan. He wears boots, but he was born and raised in Baltimore. His birth name was Dannie Scott Goeb.”
Oh, that is funny. He actually changed his name?
A lot of media/movie/entertainment folks change their names in order to be more “marketable”.
More “improvements” to public education from ed reformers!
Do any of these people ever do anything positive? Every single day they’re hard at work attacking either K-12 public schools or universities or both.
When’s the last time there has been some positive proposal for a public entity of any kind out of this “movement”? All those think tanks and lobbyists and well-compensated adults and it’s 100% negative.
Couldn’t they “improve” something else for a while and leave public education out of it? Maybe they can destroy libraries or national parks. Give us a break for a year or two.
What can we say about anti-intellectual political activity in American History that has not already been suggested. This country travels with the ball and chain of stupidity slowing its progress.
I learned the clean version about racism that was taught in public education in the 50s & 60s (even in the North), which racists today want to return to, and it was truly awful.
That’s because I already knew the truth about how blacks were treated, since my mom was a civil rights activist and my sister and I spent at lot of time with her in the South throughout my childhood, where she was always VERY vocal about opposing Jim Crow whenever she saw evidence of those injustices. To her credit, my mom took great risks by doing that, when she was all alone with her two little girls, and by having us use everything that was designated for “COLORED Only” and not use what was designated for whites. I recall a standoff she had with a bus driver who wouldn’t drive until we sat in the “Whites Only” section, but my mom refused to move us from the back of the bus. It got very tense and seemed to drag on for quite awhile, but eventually he gave up and my mom won that battle. I developed a lot of empathy from those experiences and, even as a very young child, I knew much more about racism than many high school age kids knew.
Fast forward to college in the early 70s, when I decided to audit a course called “Racism in America,” where what was new to me was what I learned about how Native Americans were treated, such as about how Union soldiers infected them with blankets that had small pox germs on purpose. I was really disgusted that I’d never learned that before college, so it’s very INFURIATING to me to think that there are going to be students who don’t even get a chance to learn the ugly truths about our nation’s past even when they are young adults and go to college! This has got to be stopped!!!
Young people need to learn our history based on truth, warts and all, even if it makes them uncomfortable. Sometimes, discomfort is an opportunity to learn and grow. Professors should have a right to academic freedom without fear of punitive repercussions.
US history without warts is like Texas without fake cowboys
Like Donald Trump without lies.
“Professors should have a right to academic freedom without fear of punitive repercussions.”
Absolutely! I retired recently due to health problems (and soon I’m turning 70) but the first half of my 52 year career I was a teacher in Early Childhood Education (ECE) and the last half I was a professor of ECE. I had taught non-bias curriculum to kids, which included providing a lot of (age appropriate) information about why that was important, and yes, truths about history. Then I taught that to future and current teachers on their level. That’s a huge component of my field, too, because we serve diverse populations and even very young children often bring their families’ prejudices to school…
So now politicians are going to tell us we can’t teach that, either to kids or to teachers? This is really horrendous –especially from the very people who are always claiming to want no government interference in people’s lives!
How awful it is that white supremacists are taking over our country BECAUSE OF TRUMP!!!
Donald Trump without lies?
That would be refreshing. There would be nothing left.
Trump without lies
Trump without lies?
The empty set?
There’d still be flies
A certain bet
Thanks for sharing this, homelesseducation! What a wonderful mother you had. Me, too. She was fired from her job as a waitress at a Woolworth’s lunch counter for telling a black man that he could sit and have his lunch like anybody else. She was a southern girl, but she hated racism and racists.
It does sound like your mom was truly wonderful, too, Bob!
My mom was born in the South & adopted as a baby by a progressive family from the North who raised her up here. I think by reason of her birth though, she always felt a very uneasy connection to the South, because she was truly horrified by the inhumane way they dealt with blacks. She frequently confronted Southerners & said that wasn’t how we treat people in the North, reminded them that the South had lost the war about 100 years earlier & often told them to get over it already and start treating blacks like valued people instead of chattel. They killed civil rights activists too in the South then, so she was really putting herself out there by opposing them so boldly.
Years later, I got a hold of my mom’s adoption record and we were mortified to learn that her birth family had been slave owners. I think she always suspected that she came from those origins and may have felt at least partly responsible…
I have many other stories of my mother, child of the South, and her antiracist work, but I won’t go into those. Alas, the stain of slavery extends to my own family, in its not-so-distant past.
homelesseducator– Your Mom was awesome!
Thanks, bethree5, I think so, too! And I always felt fortunate and very grateful to have her as my Mom.
South Carolina recently passed CRT legislation that applies to all public schools in the state, including universities, and it is set to pass a law abolishing tenure in higher ed as well.
it sounds like they are setting the stage to dismantle public universities or perhaps retool them as institutions of unenlightened education.
YUP. Haven’t checked the Alec site on these matters. Wondering if these are more Alec initiatives. The Republicans are better organized than the Dems are, Alec and CPAC being cases in point.
Abolishing tenure = abolishing academic freedom. SC a swift move ahead of TX’ Dan Patrick: they won’t even have to say what they don’t want taught, just move profs along if it wasn’t ‘politically correct’ [rw version]. Exactly why Nicole Hannah-Jones moved on when UNC made that offer. If TX OK’s this, that starts a trend among rw red states. Serious scholars will be looking elsewhere. Perhaps STEM fields will be safe for now, but those interested in scientific research will think twice: there are areas of research potentially rw-politically incorrect too. And US higher ed will begin reflecting the cultural divide already becoming apparent in national K12. I would say “sad,” even “scary”– or perhaps just view it as Southern colleges slipping back into the backwater from which they emerged. They are like a circular firing squad.
Inequity and racism are the status quo. Teaching that Ignores the political choices that enable(d) it is “indoctrination.” Alternatively, teaching about it is what we call, education.
Reblogged this on What's Gneiss for Education and commented:
Another nutter in Texas working to kill the truth.
“And that’s what’s going to keep happening…” Not just in Texas.
https://crooksandliars.com/2022/02/elie-mystal-kim-potter-judge-chu
Thom Hartmann wrote a very insightful piece on what is going on with many of the very anti-social people in our fascist-at-risk country today due to Donald Trump: “Trump has planted the seeds of extreme antisocial behavior—and it cannot be ignored”
https://www.rawstory.com/trump-has-planted-the-seeds-of-extreme-antisocial-behavior-and-it-cannot-be-ignored/
[…] trying to curtail inquiry and discourse in the classroom. Recently, the Texas lieutenant governor threatened to change state law that “could make teaching critical race theory grounds for revoking tenure for professors who […]
[…] trying to curtail inquiry and discourse in the classroom. Recently, the Texas lieutenant governor threatened to change state law that “could make teaching critical race theory grounds for revoking tenure for professors who […]
[…] trying to curtail inquiry and discourse in the classroom. Recently, the Texas lieutenant governor threatened to change state law that “could make teaching critical race theory grounds for revoking tenure for professors […]
[…] trying to curtail inquiry and discourse in the classroom. Recently, the Texas lieutenant governor threatened to change state law that “could make teaching critical race theory grounds for revoking tenure for professors who […]
[…] trying to curtail inquiry and discourse in the classroom. Recently, the Texas lieutenant governor threatened to change state law that “could make teaching critical race theory grounds for revoking tenure for professors who […]