Steve Nelson, a retired educator, describes the calculated and underhanded effort to destroy public education, a ruse that proceeds by stealth and loaded language.
He begins:
The same fine folks who brought us the Critical Race Theory (CRT) scare tactic to win the Virginia gubernatorial election are now poised to bring our public education system to its knees and then put it out of its misery.
In an alarming New York Times column, Michelle Goldberg recounts an exchange with Christopher Rufo, the manipulative wizard behind the weaponizing of CRT for broad political purposes. Rufo gleefully admits that the CRT gambit, combined with widespread pandemic frustration, provides a perfect storm for completion of the decades-long conservative goal of weakening and effectively eliminating “government schools.”
Conservatives have similarly weaponized the phrase “government schools” as an emotional trigger intended to disingenuously characterize public schools as institutional agents of a sinister plot to indoctrinate children into a socialist, anti-religion agenda that violates parental rights, freedom of choice and traditional values. That none of this is true is of no consequence to the likes of Rufo or other conservatives. An example of Rufo’s propaganda landed on my desktop as I wrote this post, fresh from his Twitter account:
Language tip: school choice advocates should always say “scholarships” instead of “vouchers.” It gives a connotation of opportunity and forces our opponents to take the unenviable position of denying scholarships to families and children.
This calculated campaign gives fresh energy to persistent efforts to divert billions of tax dollars into religious education, voucher schemes and charter schools. Despite all the claims made by charter advocates, study after study shows that public schools do as well or better than charters, even by the relatively meaningless metric of test scores.
The pandemic has turbocharged the school choice movement by also mobilizing anti-mask and anti-vaccine sentiments. In communities all through the nation, efforts to follow public health protocols have subjected school officials to attacks, up to and including death threats. The few school systems that have begun to offer vaccinations are under vicious attack for supposedly sacrificing innocent children to a government campaign to impose unproven medical treatments.
These falsehoods run in tandem with local and state elections for school boards and state legislatures. The evidence is rapidly mounting that this mandate for parental “rights” will spawn new voucher legislation and other school choice measures in unprecedented numbers. Dissatisfaction with pandemic online programs, mask policies and the myth of CRT training has already led to drops of 4-5% enrollment in New York City and other major public school systems. These students are migrating to the charter school of choice, Christian schools, or homeschooling, whichever is most consistent with the parents’ “beliefs,” whether rational, mythical or ignorant.
Inform yourself! Open the link and read the rest.

For added info. about privatization, go to the Southwestern Indiana Catholic Community Newsletter. At the search prompt, type in school choice. Scroll down in the results to April 22, 2021, “An Insider’s Look…”
The Eli Lily Foundation (Eli Lily is the largest corporation in Indiana) was instrumental in the school choice campaign in Indiana. A review of Eli Lily Foundation grants shows the foundation’s focus.
In some states, the state Catholic Conferences co-host with Koch’s AFP, school choice rallies in state capitols.
LikeLike
The synopsis doesn’t include Ryan Girdusky who founded the 1776 PAC . Daily Caller described the PAC as aiding school board candidates across the country to reject introduction of CRT. The Girdusky interview with Pat Buchanan posted at the Buchanan site is a must-read.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“If we lose the public system we may never get it back. Without a vibrant, well-funded system of equitable public education for all, our noble, albeit flawed, experiment in democracy may be doomed.”
A quality public school is essential in a democracy. Public schools provide personal and collective value. They promote strong communities, stability, access and equity that most private organizations will not and do not provide. In our polarized society they bring all types of young people together, and they promote acceptance and understanding that are so much needed today. We must defend our public schools so they will be available to our future generations of young people.
LikeLiked by 1 person
retired teacher,
Again, your words of wisdom resonate!
Thank you.
LikeLike
The right in the US is very much aware that if it must seize control of the schools because it is facing a new generation of young people, soon to be voters, who oppose it on EVERY ISSUE by overwhelming margins. The solution? Replace public schools with religious schools paid for with vouchers that will indoctrinate kids in a jingoistic, nationalist mythology. History classes will be much simpler in the new era because history can be reduced to slogans like “American exceptionalism” and “a shining city on a hill.”
Interestingly, the phrase co-opted by Reagan’s speechwriter comes from a speech given by John Winthrop aboard the ship the Arabella in 1630 in which Winthrop explained that given the harsh conditions that they would be facing, the colonists would have to take care of one another, keeping no surfeit to themselves but sharing their resources equitably. So, the right co-opted the phrase and then gave it a meaning precisely the opposite of the original meaning, which was that the whole world would be watching to see whether these people of God would show Christian charity to one another. Winthrop, btw, took the phrase from the Sermon on the Mount and used it as Christ did.
The right in the US, and all totalitarian governments, are masters of Newspeak.
LikeLike
yes, you build a thriving democracy on strong public school systems: it is democracy we will be losing
LikeLike
I was just about to write something very similar to this. Yes, if public education is weak, democracy is weak. If public education dies, democracy dies. Not necessarily in that order, but the outcome will be the same.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The right wing in the United States is very good at both framing the national conversation by inventing language (death panels, government schools) and, importantly, FUNDING the dissemination of this language. Control the rabble by inventing slogans.
LikeLike
and altering meanings.
LikeLike
This is double plus bad.
LikeLike
I posted this at OEN https://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/The-Campaign-to-Destroy-Pu-in-General_News-Agenda_Conservatives_Diane-Ravitch_Educational-Crisis-211123-81.html#comment798890
My comment:
This is serious folks!
If the intention is to create an ignorant citizenry, and feed them falsehoods as violence is promoted as a deterrent, then like every autocracy in history, the children must be indoctrinated first… for they ARE the future.
Diane Ravitch has been writing about the privatization of our schools since she was the ass’t Secretary of Education. In her 2013 book, “Reign of Error,” she arrows in directly, and polemically, on the privatization movement, which she calls a “hoax” and a “danger” that has fed on the myth that schools are failing.”
LikeLike
Destroying public education is not the goal, privatizing the public sphere is. So, public education is just collateral damage as we used to say back in the Vietnam War era.
LikeLike
Agreed. Their goal has always been to strip the federal and state governments of the power to hold private businesses and corporations accountable, opening the door for a dystopian culture hell-bent on making profits off the backs of the many to benefit the few that already have great fortunes and power.
The goal has always been to eradicate working-class labor unions so the working class has no say in anything:
to publicly fund a FOR-PROFIT private military
a private sector, corporate police force
a private sector postal delivery service (and if it isn’t profitable, there will be no mail delivery to your community)
a private sector managed fire fighting force (if you don’t pay the fees, your house will burn to the ground with no attempt to save it and put out the fire)
no more public schools with democratically elected school boards answerable to local voters and parents
They already took over the health care system when President Reagan turned health care into a profit-based system instead of a non-profit one that it was at the time. As the result, the health care system in the US is now the most expensive health care in the world and tens of millions have no health care.
The same forces as in the KOCH network, the Walton family and other billionaires also want to get rid of Social Security, Medicare, SNAP, Section 8 housing, et al, and probably turn poverty and homelessness a crime. Remember what it was like in the UK when there were debtor prisons and those people almost never got out because if you are behind bars and can’t work to earn anything, you can never pay off the debt.
Maybe you didn’t know that bringing back debtor’s prisons is also on their list.
“North Carolina has become a central place of interest in highlighting the practice of modern-day debtors’ prisons. North Carolina features an array of fees triggered by contact with the criminal justice system, whether it be a one-time payment of a ticket, or fees for home ankle bracelet monitoring.”
https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-1-d&q=states+were+debtors+are+now+going+to+prison+for+theri+debts
Debtors’ Prisons, Then and Now: FAQ Congress outlawed them. The Supreme Court ruled them unconstitutional. Yet they live on.
https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdal/page/file/918356/download
LikeLike
I should have added, it is apparent the end goal is to get rid of the protections the U.S. Constitution offers us the people, mostly the working class.
The U.S. Consitution was written to protect us from our elected government, not corporations, and billionaires.
f corporations and billionaires get rid of the public sector and force the public to pay for private-sector services that were once publicly controlled, then the U.S. Constitution becomes useless and means nothing.
LikeLike
“…to publicly fund a FOR-PROFIT private military”
If this is indeed a goal, it turns back the historical clock to a time before the French Revolution. Napoleon showed that harnessing the power of national identification was a powerful military force, a lesson that all subsequent monarchs took to heart.
LikeLike
Our oligarchic overlords will not stop until The Commons are demolished.
This is an aside, but the privatization of traditional Medicare is underway. Under the regime of $45, a pilot program using a “e Global and Professional Direct Contracting Model” is shunting Medicare enrollees into privately managed networks. If one does not choose a network, it is chosen for you. Mr. Biden has done nothing to stop the program, and is, in fact, expanding the privatization of what remains of traditional Medicare.
Most of the companies who will be deciding what health care you receive are for-profit Wall Street buccaneers.
“No one should be surprised the Trump administration hatched a plan to put private insurance companies in charge of Medicare. What’s shocking is how President Joe Biden is moving forward with it.
“The 50-year-old, government-operated health program for the elderly will slowly and irrevocably end up managed by for-profit insurers under the Global and Professional Direct Contracting Model. The Center for Medicare Services says the program will increase “access to innovative, affordable care while maintaining all original Medicare benefits.”
“Wall Street expects it will generate billions in new dividends for health care companies. Critics warn seniors will find it harder to obtain care, and taxpayers will end up paying more than ever.”
Billions that could have been used to fund health care will be pouring into the pockets of Wall Street, and Mr. Biden’s administration is actually opening the flood gates further.
SOURCE: Biden moves forward with Trump Medicare privatization plan
https://pnhp.org/news/biden-moves-forward-with-trump-medicare-privatization-plan/
LikeLike
I agree with both you, education, CRT, etc is a tactic, not a goal. But I am starting to convince myself that it’s more sinister. In the past, privatizers of any public good have worked to manipulate the mechanisms of government, not destroy it. What the past decade is demonstrating with ever-accelerating speed is that they they’ve come to realize that they don’t need to waste their time with appearances in a fascist, corporate state that uses the Constitution as diversionary window dressing. That is why they are contributing so much to anti-governing forces. A soon-to-be armed and organized band of ignoramuses and their fellow travelers tempted by “the hollowed collegiality of shared skin” will clear the way for them. They like the odds and the promise of a payoff is too much to resist.
I really hope I’m wrong and this is a passing moment of delusional pessimism. I just can’t convince myself I’m wrong.
LikeLike
Same here, Greg. I used to think, hey, we just have to wait for the troglodytes to die off. I no longer think this. I think that they will lock in control fairly soon and that, to an enormous extent, they already have. It’s a frightening time, and I am worried sick about what kind of country my grandchildren will live in.
LikeLike
GregB and Bob,
I feel the same way. It’s not a good feeling to have.
I think Peter Thiel and his cronies are some of the most dangerous men in America. They don’t care about anything. It’s almost nihilistic. If America descends in chaos, I doubt they would care. I think Facebook became a democracy-destroying force because of Thiel. I think the connection between Thiel’s company Palantir helping Cambridge Analytica use Facebook data (Thiel is on the board) during the 2016 election has been (intentionally?) under reported and I suspect most people are terrified of him and the data Palantir seems to have on everyone. Trump is an oaf whose only ideology is serving himself (which means getting the trappings of wealth). But Thiel has more money than he can spend in 1000 lifetimes and seems happy to tear down democracy because he’d enjoy watching what happened. Not good.
LikeLike
John Moreland’s Gospel has a lyric that is likely the most succinct expression of how we feel: I wanna believe even though I know life don’t play fair
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Crazy Normal – the Classroom Exposé and commented:
Do you really want publicly funded (from the local taxes/fees we, the working class, pays) private sector charter schools that do not answer to anyone by their CEO and stockholders?
Do you really want to get rid of democratically elected school boards that are responsible to watch over public school districts, and our children, and who have to answer to local voters and parents?
Donald Trump is a private sector CEO. Do you want someone like him deciding how OUR children are treated in schools and what they are taught?
LikeLike
The oligarchs will not stop until they have complete control over our fates, from cradle to grave.
LikeLike
The catch-phrase “school choice” was concocted by racists following the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1954 Brown v. Board of Education ruling that required racial integration in public schools. After that, racist organizations used racist politicians to conduct a decades-long attack that underfunded public schools and crippled their ability to provide the full measure of education and to “prove” that public schools were “failing”. Public school “failure” is an issue manufactured by racists organizations and politicians.
The racial resegregation of America’s school systems by the private charter school industry is so blatant and illegal that both the NAACP and ACLU have called for a stop to the formation of any more charter schools. The Civil Rights Project at UCLA summed it up, stating that charter schools are “a civil rights failure.”
The impartial, non-political watchdog Office of Inspector General of the U.S. Department of Education has issued a report warning that so much taxpayer money is being skimmed away from America’s genuine public schools and pocketed by private corporate charter school operators that the IG investigation declared that: “Charter schools and their management organizations pose a potential risk to federal funds even as they threaten to fall short of meeting goals” because of financial fraud and their hidden ways for skimming of tax money into private pockets.
There is NO SUCH THING as a “public charter school”. Charter school operators spend a lot of taxpayer money telling taxpayers that charter schools are “public” schools — but they are not. As the Supreme Courts of Washington State and New York State have ruled, charter schools are actually private schools because they fail to pass the minimum test for being genuine public schools: They aren’t run by school boards who are elected by, and therefore under the control of and accountable to voting taxpayers. All — ALL — charter schools are corporations run by private parties. Taxpayers have no say in how their tax dollars are spent in charter schools.
The Stanford University Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) — which is funded by pro-charter organizations — has been conducting years-long research into the educational quality of charter schools. And yet even this charter-school-funded research center’s findings are that charter schools don’t do any better academically than genuine public schools. Moreover, CREDO reported that in the case of popular online charter schools, students actually lose ground in both reading and math — but online charter schools are the fastest-growing type of charter school because they make it easiest to skim away public tax dollars.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/petergreene/2019/03/29/report-the-department-of-education-has-spent-1-billion-on-charter-school-waste-and-fraud/#ab1fbdb27b64
LikeLike
Well said, quickwrit!
LikeLike