The state of Michigan allows school districts to determine their policies on masking, which is a terrible idea since it politicizes decisions in each district. The decision about masking and vaccinations should be made by public health professionals, not laymen.
In Ottawa, Michigan, a crowd of hundreds of anti-maskers showed up to a meeting of the County Commission to protest the decision by the school board and the Health Department to require that children from preK-6th grade, who are not yet eligible for vaccinations, must wear masks. Carol Burris of the Network for Public Education shared a tweet with me, which had gone viral.
After I listened to this enraged and threatening rant, I read more about Ottawa County. Dr. Rob Davison testified in favor of the masking requirement, and when he left the board meeting, he was confronted by hundreds of anti-masking parents.
The chair of the Ottawa County Board of Commissioners released a statement critical of those who came to the meeting to “bully and intimidate” anyone who supported the mask mandate that had been recommenced by the local Health Department.
On August 9, the county Health Department reported that the COVID risk level had increased from “moderate” to “substantial.”
Only a few days later, on August 13, the Health Department announced that the COVID risk had gone from “substantial” to “high,” the highest risk level.
Public health officials urged citizens to take all necessary precautions, including wearing masks indoors. They said:
The spread of the delta variant is most likely fueling the increase of positive case rates in Ottawa County. The delta variant is causing concern because of its high rate of transmission and severity of illness.
The virus is infecting mostly unvaccinated people, though breakthrough cases in vaccinated people are emerging.
“The delta variant is spreading quickly, increasing the number of positive cases reported in Ottawa County,” said Derel Glashower, Senior Epidemiologist at Ottawa County Department of Public Health. “The delta variant has pushed us into the ‘high risk of transmission’ category so it is important to take extra precautions to protect ourselves and our community.”
In light of the worsening situation, on August 20, the Health Department mandated masks for all students in Pre-K to sixth grade in schools.The goal, health officials say, is to protect vulnerable people and those who can’t get vaccinated from the virus, slow the spread of the virus and keep kids in classrooms.
“This was a necessary decision as we are seeing rapid increases in COVID-19 cases due to the highly contagious Delta variant,” Kent County Administrative Health Officer Adam London said in a Friday statement. “It also appears as though this variant may be more likely to cause serious illness and hospitalization, so we need to take precautions to keep our children healthy and in school.”
Despite all these warnings by public health professionals, large numbers of people in Ottawa County oppose masking their children.
Several parents at the recent County Commission meeting were seen with posters that said, “My body, my choice.” One can’t help but wonder if they support abortion, given their stance. One doubts it.

OMG and holy cow. INSANITY reigns.
LikeLike
Remarkable to watch the thousands of full time, paid ed reformers do no defense at all of these public schools.
We see more lobbying from them supporting federal funding of for-profit charter management companies than we ever see for any public school.
They simply provide no benefit to public school students. They contribute nothing to our schools. In the case of the ed reform governors who have spent the summer conducting anti-public school political campaigns the ed reform “movement” does actual harm to public school students.
I suppose they’re afraid of alienating their political allies on the Right so are once again forbidden to speak, but weren’t we told this was “all about the students”?
Except public school students, I guess.
LikeLike
Detroit public schools are using federal funds to clean up the buildings their students attend and reinstate art classes.
The ed reform echo chamber feel this is a poor use of funds- instead it should have been spent on hiring ed reform consultants to impose “innovations”:
“So far, there’s little evidence of major change, said Marguerite Roza, director of the Edunomics Lab, a school finance think tank at Georgetown University. Part of the problem, she said, is that the aid was given to schools with few strings attached.
“That’s not a recipe for innovation,” Roza said. “We sprinkled the dollars as blank checks to every one of these districts. And many are going to do what they already know how to do.”
“Blank checks” is amusing. Georgetown’s tuition is 59,000 dollars a year and their economists believe mold removal and art teachers in public schools is an extravagant expense. This is the mindset.
How dare Detroit public schools set policy for their public schools without consulting elite universities who serve the wealthiest 5%? How will they possibly “innovate” without accepting direction and mandates from the ed reform echo chamber?
https://apnews.com/article/pandemic-aid-public-school-funding-346d3d4b86f904184e357c34c9754800
LikeLike
From the same AP article, “In Detroit, that means fixing buildings with crumbling ceilings and mold infestations. Like other school systems, Detroit is caught between the Biden administration’s lofty aspirations [“dream big” – take leaps, not steps” – “bold innovations”] and bleak realities.”
Apparently Roza and the other ivory-tower-airheads at the stink-tank are unaware that for Detroit, fixing decrepit moldy buildings IS a leap not a step, and bringing back art classes a bold innovation. What Detroit schdistr “already knows how to” puts them to shame– all Edudeformers, er I mean Edunomics Lab knows how to recommend is disruption and privatization.
What do you want to bet this stinktank drafted Biden admin’s lofty goals for the– ahem—covid-era relief $$?
Take a gander at their “Funders and Partners” – all the usual suspects. (Arnold, Gates, Walton, Center on Reimagining Public Education, New America Foundation, et al ad naus).
LikeLike
Detroit is about 50% charters at this point, thanks to the energetic privatization lobbying from the ed reform echo chamber. Arne Duncan and Eli Broad went there personally to cheerlead the 2012 privatization push (never to be seen again- they took off after the roll out).
Didn’t these same people tell us charters would be doing the “innovating”? Now they also want to direct all decisions that are made in public schools?
Some of these places are 50% charters and private school vouchers. Can the ed reform echo chamber continue to blame public schools for the failure of their experiments when they’ve designed the systems they’re criticizing? How long is labor union bashing going to cut it when they’ve had such success abolishing labor unions?
LikeLike
This morning I saw an interview with Dr. Carlee Simon, the superintendent of the Alachua, FL Public Schools. She has received several threatening letters from the governor because she has mandated masks in her district. She also said that her district has received very few federal dollars to help mitigate the impact of Covid. She said that many students are in quarantine from Covid, and the governor refuses to allow her district to access an online platform so students can continue some level of instruction. People in Florida should be asking themselves: What kind of governor works against the interests of schools and the health and well-being of children in a pandemic? Where are the federal dollars that should be helping school districts?
LikeLike
Ed reformers will continue to evade accountabilty for their ideas until the last public school closes its doors.
They have spent more time bashing labor unions and promoting vouchers in the pandemic than any productive or positive effort to support public schools. By far.
As they succeed in privatizing more and more of the K-12 sector I am genuinely curious when the lockstep ed reform narrative goes from one of public school bashing to one of cheerleading their redesigned, privatized systems. At some point they have to own their handiwork. Unfortunately at that point it will be too late and the public systems will be eradicated.
LikeLike
A Grand Haven public schools choir director–Grand Haven is in Ottawa County–took a leave as he refuses to get vaccinated. FYI–Ottawa County, for many years, has been one of the most Republican counties in the country. Think Erik Prince and Betsy DeVos–both have great influence here.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Judging by his professional achievements and his refusal to be vaccinated, his education in the arts was far superior to his education in science and history (including civics). I wonder if he was educated in the public schools, because my observation is that we have always neglected those two subjects in K-12 education.
LikeLike
I encourage everyone to read within the ed reform echo chamber:
“A better way forward for education reform is to give families control over their child’s education funds from the outset, whether they want to leave their current school or not.
Under this choice model, students would have access to some or all of the education dollars that the state already allocates to them for public school. Families could choose to spend these funds on not only private school tuition, but any number of other educational services and offerings.”
A grudging recognition that most children attend the public schools the “movement” doesn’t support and the “innovation” is (surprise!) yet another voucher.
They just now realized public schools might have SOME value, after all despite best efforts by the “movement”, millions of children still attend the unfashionable “government schools”.
Return no value to students in public schools, but insist on directing everything that happens in public schools. No one in their right mind should accept this deal. It stinks. Public schools should reject it.
Let’s think about hiring and taking direction from people who actually support our schools and students. That’s allowed. Public schools shouldn’t be run according to the dictates of people who are ideologically opposed to the existence of public schools.
https://www.the74million.org/article/barnard-school-choice-should-be-more-than-an-escape-hatch-from-failing-public-schools-heres-a-way-to-make-it-available-to-all-families/
LikeLike
That guy reminds me of the parents we run into at youth hockey games when we travel outside the NYC metro area.
LikeLike
OMG yes, über-sportsparents. Cut from same cloth.
LikeLike
Far more people support masks than oppose them. Those people have to start showing up at board meetings.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The margin is a lot smaller among parents, though. Last poll I saw showed about 60% of parents believe masks should be required for (unvaccinated) students. But about 60% also oppose school vaccine requirements.
LikeLike
big money has put itself behind the anti-masking noise: the organization, including printed signs and t-shirts, even billboards, is easy enough to follow
LikeLike
Sum total of ed reform echo chamber accomplishments in Ohio for 2020 and 2021:
https://fordhaminstitute.org/ohio/commentary/overview-ohios-recently-enacted-family-friendly-voucher-changes
Huge increase in voucher funding, and more promotion and marketing of charters. I didn’t think the ed reform lobby cheerlead charters any MORE in this state, they’re already a lock step cheer squad, but apparently new heights of promoting and marketing charters under the giuse of “analysis” can and will be reached.
Nothing positive or productive for students who attend public schools in this state. Yet another year where the ed reform “movement” delivers absolutely nothing for students who attend the unfashionable public schools.
Have public schools or public school students benefitted at all from the billions we have sunk into this “movement”? Couldn’t we break free from the echo chamber after 20 years? Is there some requirement that public schools must continue to hire these folks and accept orders from them? Public schools ALONE among schools must employ and pay a professional critics choir?
LikeLike
I confess I don’t understand the extreme mask opposition. I don’t really see how these parents draw a distinction between masks rules and all the other school rules.
If they want complete chaos where everyone makes their own rules for their own child, okay, but I think that’s nuts and we’ll all regret it almost immediately.
They all complied with each provision of the school handbook and district code but just on this one rule they go berserk? Is it to prove a point? That masks do or don’t work? Because no one needed evidence to justify dress codes and no one objects to those. What’s the “evidence” for requiring uniforms or sending them home to change when their shorts are too short? What’s the evidence for showing up on time? Why not just turn that over to parental discretion too? After all, parents know best.
Can “parents know best” really be the rule? Because if it is there aren’t going to be any rules.
LikeLike
Ed reformers realize they’ll be the dog who caught the car with this “parents know best!” stance, right?
How is anyone expected to run a school if each student has veto power over any rule?
The sloganeering that works when they’re marketing vouchers will run into trouble when it encounters the reality of “a school”. Perhaps we’ll all just take out edu-voucher and find 9 other people who share our unique family vision for school, but is that going to work in such a large and diverse country and what’s the plan for ensuring some rock bottom level of quality?
LikeLike
Anti-maskers – they want to restrict a woman’s right to have an abortion, but then refuse to wear a mask or get vaccinated so they can kill both mothers and their unborn babies?
If Republicans are going to push their personal freedom agenda (and lack of responsibility for others), they need to stop being so hypocritical.
LikeLike
“These masks are a violation of the Nuremberg codes.” Ah, yes, one so seldom has an opportunity to see real genius at work.
LikeLiked by 1 person
These antimaskers are a violation of the Hindenburg Code against using hydrogen in dirigibles.
LikeLiked by 1 person
ROFL 😀
LikeLike
There are only about 5 watts burning in that 100 watt bulb.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Negawatts
LikeLike
“Ottawa County, for many years, has been one of the most Republican counties in the country.”
Did you notice in the video that when Dr. Davison left, neither the woman escorting him out, nor the officer at the door were wearing masks? I wonder–were any of the County Commissioners wearing masks?
LikeLike
“There’s a lot of bad things comin” — Deranged antimasker
Bad? Like people dying from covid?
Yeah, I bet he’s right about that prediction.
LikeLike
Oh, I know there are people that will read what I was thinking and not approve.
Don’t forget that I am a former Marine and combat vet as you read what I was thinking, the same thoughts I have every time I read about another anti-vaccine, mask mob screaming and threatening someone that supports wearing masks and getting the vaccine.
My thoughts: “I want the Civil War Traitor Trump and his supporters apparantly want to start ASAP, so people that can reason may legally use weapons to fight back and get rid of these lunatics.”
We outnumber them by huge margins. I only hope everyone that doesn’t support the Traitor and his mob of traitors will be willing to fight if that time comes.
LikeLike
” ‘…bad things comin” — Deranged antimasker’ Bad? Like people dying from covid?”
NO, SomeDAM– many of these people want a “Second Civil War”. Jan 6th was only the beginning, NOT an isolated incident of frustration. Gun sales continue to climb, militia activity too. And of course just look at the anti-social media, and the mob actions all over the country, of which this one in Michigan is only one.
LikeLike
And according to news reports, many in our military are vaccine resisters. I wonder how many will leave the military early, or not join as planned, or–in the event of another insurrection–refuse orders to use force to stop American traitors whom they agree with??
LikeLike
I know what he was threatening, but what will actually happen is far worse, that tens or even hundreds of thousands more people will die of covid.
LikeLike
If people keep opposing vaccines and masks, more Americans will die from covid than died in the Civil War.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Did you realize that more than. 200 times as many people have died with or from Covid than died in 9/11? 9/11 actually was fairly insignificant—it was barely even one 9/11!
LikeLike
and the strangest aspect of our US mess is that we are a very huge country which, due to our own narrow self-involvement, HAVE ENOUGH FREE VACCINES to stop the insanity….
LikeLike
The number of covid deaths is currently only about 100k fewer than the number of civil war deaths right now..
The number of Covid deaths per day in the US is currently over 1000.
LikeLike
Did you realize that I no longer respond to science deniers?
LikeLike
Sorry, these “did you know Covid has killed more people than [insert terrible historical event]” comparisons are too asinine to resist.
By the way, the internet says 4.5 million people have died from Covid, so watch your step with the idiotic historical comparisons on that one.
LikeLike
Except to point out that fact.
Ha ha ha.
LikeLike
SDP, did you know that not only did more than 600,000 people die in the U.S. civil war, but over a million additional people suffered from “long Civil War”?
LikeLike
I read on Twitter that it’s possible more people will end up with Covid “brain fog” and a poor sense of smell for several months than lost limbs in the Civil War.
LikeLike
Terrific analysis of this phenomenon here:
And it would play out in a political context primed not only by deeply entrenched partisanship but by a decades-long culture war cynically engineered by the right and executed by its media loyalists. Whipping viewers up into a frenzy over stuff like latchkey kids, gay marriage, and a Black president has facilitated the Republican Party’s lurch rightward, because there’s no way it could get millions of people to vote for massive corporate tax cuts without a heaping helping of disingenuous identity cultivation.
https://newrepublic.com/article/163466/ivermectin-culture-war-covid-vaccine?utm_medium=Social&utm_campaign=EB_TNR&utm_source=Twitter#Echobox=1630303316-1
LikeLike
Like so much else, this is co-ordinated.
and this guy:
LikeLike
Good grief, Steve Lynch is a brown shirt with his shouting for violence and the physical removal of a school board. I guess this idiot is not aware that school boards are elected and they are removed by voting them out of office not by brute force administered by right wing thugs and potential criminals like Steve Lynch. All this thunder and lightning, bloviation and bombast over face masks and vaccinations!? I wish all this energy would go towards something useful, like fighting for universal health care. But that would make too much sense for these belligerent morons.
LikeLike
Off topic
“China wants to ban written exams for young people…” 8-30-2021, Vice
LikeLike
These people are using their children as political pawns. They are putting their political views before their children’s welfare. Shameful and abusive.
LikeLike