On June 4, 1989, thousands of Chinese people peacefully protested in Tiananmen Square in Beijing, demanding democratic reforms. The uprising was brutally suppressed. Since then, the Chinese government has effectively obliterated the events of 30 years ago. It has censored mention of the failed democracy and quickly punished those who dare to remember what happened. A few young people, born after 1989, learned about what happened and tried to commemorate it. “He tried to commemorate erased history. China detained him, then erased that too.”
As I read this account in the Los Angeles Times, I could not help but think of the current debate in our country about “critical race theory,” which at root is an effort to suppress honest discussion about racism and its toxic and persistent legacy. Red-state governors like Texas’ Gregg Abbott, want “patriotic education.” Tennessee passed the most extreme legislation, banning the teaching of racism, sexism, or bias.
BEIJING — He stood in Tiananmen Square, wearing sneakers, track pants and a black T-shirt printed with the date of a massacre.
It was June 4, 2019, the 30th anniversary of the killing of hundreds of pro-democracy protesters in Beijing. Dong Zehua, then 28, hadn’t even been born when tanks clattered over the square and the world watched. The events on that bloody day in 1989 weren’t taught in school or ever mentioned in Chinese media. But Dong knew what had happened.
Tech-savvy and good at English, Dong had mastered circumventing the Great Firewall. He had learned about the anti-government protests and deaths through foreign websites banned in China. As the anniversary approached, he booked a train ticket and traveled to Beijing, keeping the T-shirt hidden until he was on the square.
Dong was a jiulinghou, as those born after 1990 are called in China. They are a nationalistic generation raised on “patriotic education” and state propaganda in a prosperous, increasingly strong China. Many have little knowledge of the traumas their parents endured or the ongoing suppression of Chinese citizens around them.
But there are outliers among them. A handful of Chinese youth like Dong have tried to expose and preserve China’s true history and honor those erased from the official story. They do so despite censorship, imprisonment and growing pressure from peers who are encouraged to report on anyone who criticizes the state.
Counter-narratives have been crushed by a Communist Party determined to carefully choreograph its 100th anniversary in July. That means deleting official wrongs, promoting a whitewashed version of party history, punishing those who deviate — and in recent days, expunging the records of that punishment as well.
“What they’re doing is to control every Chinese person’s thinking and erase every person’s history,” Dong said. “They want to write history themselves.”
To Dong’s surprise, two other young people were in the square the morning he arrived: Yuan Shuai, 24, a recent college graduate from Inner Mongolia working at an advertising company in Beijing, and Gao Tianqi, 21, a Beijinger attending university abroad who’d come back for the summer. Gao carried a yellow umbrella — a symbol of Hong Kong’s youth-led democracy movement — with the number “30” written on it in black marker.
They hatched a plan to interview foreigners on the square and post a video of their comments online.
“It was a normal, simple sense of justice in our hearts, thinking: I want to do this, because someone should,” said Dong. “Someone should commemorate. This shouldn’t be forgotten.”
The three were arrested within hours. Yuan and Dong were convicted of “picking quarrels and provoking troubles” and sentenced, respectively, to six and seven months in jail. Gao was let go after 38 days of detention without trial.
Dong was quiet for several months after his release. But on June 4, 2020, he emailed The Times about his experience and provided a link to a judgment issued by the Beijing Dongcheng People’s Court. The Times verified the judgment, which was documented in a public archive of court rulings kept by the Supreme People’s Court online.
Last month, he contacted The Times again: The record of his arrest had vanished.
“In their eyes, it’s as if our detention never happened. It’s as if they never did it to us,” Dong said. “They deleted it … as if they can just delete all Chinese people’s memories…. With one stroke of the arm they can cover the sky.”
Orwell would be proud. Hard to tell the pigs from the men.
Nailed it, Roy. Except that Orwell would be vindicated and sad, not proud.
You are no Doubt correct. Autocratic is as autocratic does. There is far less difference between Stalin or PolPot and Hitler or Franco than the common wisdom suggests
and frighteningly little difference in their power over the masses
Ah the Repugnican Party, which stands for separating children from their parents, lowering taxes for the richest people, and promulgating mythology to brainwash children to turn them into white supremacists, cannon fodder, and slavish underlings who can be counted on to vote against their own interests.
Comparing Repugnicans to pigs is unfair to pigs.
BTW, a group of baboons is called a troop, a flange, or a congress. The last term is unfair to baboons.
Baboons were around long before Congress, so can’t be held responsible for the fact that the Fondling Father’s adopted the term for their sludgislative body.
The fondling fathers introduced an American tradition that came down to us through Grover “the Groper” Cleveland (his actual nickname) to Bill Clinton and Donny Dumbo.
We used to teach “Brave New World” and “1984” in the 8th grade, and, hopefully still teach the books. Sadly they are increasingly relevant. Poland and Hungary elected populist autocratic leaders, democracies are under attack .. a. bright light, LePen’s populist party was rejected in recent French regional elections.
How do we win back the 74M Trump voters?
We don’t win those morons back. Anyone who could vote for the Orange Idiot after the utter boondoggle of his four years in office is irredeemable. I mean, come on, this is the guy who ordered his Secretary of Homeland Security to have border agents SHOOT asylum seekers, who thought that we could send astronauts to the sun and that stealth airplanes were actually invisible to the eye, the one who separated BABIES from their parents, who thought that injecting disinfectants was a dandy idea, who thought that China paid the tariffs he place on their goods, who caused the deaths of hundreds of thousands by downplaying the pandemic, not leading an adequate response, holding superspreader events, and so on.
No, we don’t win back those morons who voted for Agent Orange after ALL THAT. We teach their children to despise everything their parents stand for. We give those Trumpeteers exactly what they fear.
And yet, my friend the Trump voter just donated a kidney to a person who needed one. I suggest that what is needed is for good people to get truth instead of falsehood as their medium of communication. What a tall order in a media circus that seems to promote falsehood. All media seem to be shape shifters constantly bending themselves into the National Enquirer.
Roy, Hitler loved puppies and encouraged people to eat vegetarian and started national physical fitness organizations. Didn’t make him a great guy.
Sorry, I will have no truck with people who are OK with separating children from their parents because those children and parents are dark-skinned “foreigners.”
I grew up among Midwesterners and Southerners who thought of themselves as “good Christians” and got all weepy about Mom and America and would certainly do their share to clean after the church potluck but were, nonetheless, push come to shove, small-minded, homophobic, sexist, racist, war-monngering folk who were quite content to remain, willfully, idiots. #@&#@#@&^^$^#@@# those people.
The attitudes of those people had real-life consequences, and not only because they voted for the vile likes of Tricky Dickie and Ronnie Reagan and Donnie Dumpsterfire.
Hard to argue, since I know those same folks. Still, it strikes me they would act differently if false patriotism was crushed. Truth is powerful among humans.
Well, you’re right, Roy. So perhaps “irredeemable” was a bit strong. “Practically irredeemable” would have been more accurate.
Sadly they are increasingly relevant.
They certainly are.
The right wing stands for suppression and oppression. The only way they can win an election is to suppress people’s right to vote. They are trying to undermine our public institutions including public schools and colleges. The assault on academic freedom and free speech is reminiscent of what China is doing. What’s next? Reeducation camps?
“He sees you when you’re sleeping.” –from “Santa Claus Is Coming to Town,” John Frederick Coots and Haven Gillespie
“If you want a vision of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face–forever.” –George Orwell, 1984
“Every time I close my eyes, all I see is people dying.” –Sentence spoken spontaneously to San Franciscan Shawn Kinnear by the Amazon Echo personal assistant Alexa
Organize! Someone–maybe us–is going to have to go door to door, screen to screen, whatever, to win over some of the new voters. Meanwhile, let’s not be holier-than-thou. In most American schools, run by Dems and Repubs, kids are coerced into sayin the Pledge every morning–including ‘under god,” even though millions are agnostics, etc. Some kids are yanked and pulled to their feet to pledge. Nor do we tell the whole stories of history. We vilify Putin for defending Russian bases in Ukraine, but respectfully remember our blockade of Cuba and the Missile Crisis. Almost no one mentions our invasion of Russia in 1918, or violent interference in “Latin” America, from the Mexican War to our current attempt to strangle Venezuela.
Trump’s disruptive rule was not a digital change, but a gradation. This A.M. we learned that America airplanes–paid for by you and me–attacked Iran. WE overthrew the government of Iran in ’54, starting a whole chain of bad events in the Middle East. Internationally, it’s time to remember FDR’s Four Freedoms and the UN. Domestically, let’s stop trying to tell kids what to think, and teach them HOW to think. That requires debate, differing points of view, etc. I’m retired, so I can only write. Those of you being published, teaching, whatever, let’s bring back balance, and nuance. Peace!
“This A.M. we learned that America airplanes–paid for by you and me–attacked Iran.”
Did you mean “attacked Iraq”? I can’t find anything about the US attacking Iran.
The frightening thing about China, an authoritarian, repressive police state is its economic clout which increases with every year. It is already the manufacturing super power of the world and it is the second largest economy and is predicted to surpass the US sometime in the future. China is digesting Hong Kong, destroying any hint of democracy and has designs on Taiwan, like some giant boa constrictor eyeing an innocent tiny bunny rabbit. China has time on its side. Would we go to war to preserve the independence of Taiwan and risk a thermo-nuclear war? China is a nuclear super power and is becoming a space super power.
China has put down deep roots via investment in businesses in the developing world. And it now has the largest GDP by PPP in the world.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)
And then there is the increasing militarization of China, including the building of artificial islands for military bases in the South China Sea. And there are the roots it is putting down via the Belt and Road Initiative–simultaneously providing itself with networks for free travel of Chinese goods and equipment and personnel and making its neighbors beholden to it via infrastructure loans.
Going to war with China or Russia–or any nuclear power–reminds me of one of our generals in Vietnam who said, “It became necessary to destroy this village in order to save it.” Are we willing to blow up the world and kill most of us to stop China or Russia? Better, let’s work within the UN, collaterally, with all nations to make the best world we can. It is possible that China will surpass us in every way. Rome surpassed Greece. History happens. But we had a terrible century in the 1800’s in Asia, forcing Japan to trade, taking part in the Caucasian looting and dismembering of China. Meanwhile, global warming is an even bigger threat–the collapsed building in Florida is another canary we shouldn’t ignore.
Our politicians fiddle and fiddle while California and Australia burn and our buildings and bridges collapse.
Daniel Ellsberg just released another trove of old documents dealing with possible nuclear war with China and/or Russia and specifically, with how close we came and how insane some of the people making decisions were (and undoubtedly still are) — every bit as insane as some of the folks in Dr. Strangelove.
The fact that we have avoided nuclear war so far is due to pure luck as much as (if not more than) anything else. And the threat today is greater than ever, despite what many people believe. The Bulletin of Atomic Scientists Doomsday Clock is set closer to midnight than it has ever been: just 100 seconds before Midnight (annihilation). That is based on all threats but nuclear war remains the imminent one.
Read 2034. It describes the misguided leadership mindset that could lead to a nuclear exchange between what the author refers to as a “peer war”. In the audio version the author, a retired 4 star admiral, goes into great detail about the need for education as a tool for national security.
Read 2034. It describes the misguided leadership mindset that could lead to a nuclear exchange between what the author refers to as a “peer war”. In the audio version the author, a retired 4 star admiral, goes into great detail about the need for education as a tool for national security.
Read 2034. It describes the misguided leadership mindset that could lead to a nuclear exchange between what the author refers to as a “peer war”. In the audio version the author, a retired 4 star admiral, goes into great detail about the need for education as a tool for national security.
This is where I might get attacked for pointing out the fact that China did not brutally suppress the students in Tiananmen square.
That protest did not start out as a democracy movement. Workers and not students started the movement, but the workers were protesting government corruption and they were not demanding democracy/freedom.
People did die on both sides but that fighting took place a couple of miles from the square when protesters (from the workers, not the students) attacked a column of busses transporting unarmed troops to the square to deal with the students.
And yes, China’s government does censor any talk/print that threatens the stability of the country and its government, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).
When someone is speaking out publicly, the government usually politely warns them over tea. I know someone that had that happen to them. They got the message and stopped blogging negative OpEds about China.
If that doesn’t work, the protestor will vanish for a while and end up being sent to a re-education camp. If that fails to shut up the protestor, they go to prison or leave the country seeking asylum, usually in Europe or the U.S.
All but one of the student leaders of the Tiananmen Square protest that started with workers protesting government corruption magically had visas to the US and fled as soon as that incident ended. At that time, it was almost impossible for a Chinese citizen to get a visa to the U.S.
Then once in the states, money fell out of the sky, probably from the CIA, and supported those Chinese immigrants that led the alleged student democracy protest to attend top rate US colleges all expenses paid, and even to start businesses.
How do I know all this?
Because I do my fact-checking and homework. I was also married to Anchee Min for about 16 years and we are still friends. She is the author of Red Azalea and other books about China that are all blacklisted in China. She grew up in China during Mao’s Cultural Revolution. She was a child living in Shanghai with her family during the great famine.
Anchee knew one of the leaders of that student movement that somehow hijacked the movement started by the workers protesting government corruption and turned it into a democracy movement.
Anchee was invited to join that leadership but declined.
Next, if you are still with me and not screaming profanity and accusing me of being a Communist, I’m going to point out a critical difference between the U.S. and China.
China’s constitution is not the one the U.S. is governed by, and China’s constitution clearly states the kind of protests for democracy that took place in 1989, were illegal then and are still illegal today. How do I know that? Well, there is a clause about freedom of expression in China’s constitution, but scroll down to read the exceptions and one of those exceptions is publicly protesting against the government.
When in Rome do as the Romans do. The Roman Empire didn’t live by the same laws that governed the Han Dynasty in China and China did not live by the same laws that governed the Roman Empire.
The next link will take anyone that wants to educate themselves about China to the English translation of China’s Constitution. Use a highlighter for all the clauses that reveal that China is an authoritarian state but China is also a country that will probably never see anyone like Traitor Trump become its leader.
http://www.npc.gov.cn/zgrdw/englishnpc/Constitution/node_2825.htm
A fascinating perspective, Lloyd, and thank you for sharing it. BTW,. folks, if you haven’t read Lloyd’s novels, do. They are great.
You do realize, however, Lloyd that what you are saying is that yes, China has an extremely authoritarian, totalitarian government, but the people of the country are mostly fine with that. Correct?
Is it not true, Lloyd, that the Chinese government fired upon and murdered hundreds, if not thousands, of students?
Well it’s not just GOP governors. While we are talking about fake patriotic history can we stop teaching American Students that Tienanmen square was primarily a student revolt for Democracy. We neglect to mention that is was also a worker and farmer revolt against the (capitalist )market reforms that were being instituted . The inherent corruption that accompanied those capitalist reforms. China now takes the number 2 spot for the number of billionaires and the number of billionaires per million people . I will presume they were once corrupt party officials . The presence of that inequality and corruption, the economic insecurity brought on by market reforms ,were the catalyst behind Tienanmen sq.
So perhaps those protesters wanted democracy, a voice for the people. But that’s not what brought them to the streets. We equate capitalism with democracy. Those protesters came to the streets to maintain state owned industry ,wage and price controls, the dreaded socialism.
I was in Tianemen Square on the anniversary of the uprising in 2016. The presence of armored vehicles with automatic weapons made it very clear concerning the governments position on the protest.
Any break-up advice for Lonesome Bill Barr and Donnie Dumbo?
Or for Donnie Dumbo and Dense Pence?
That Donnie. What a playah!
New Made-for-Lifetime Movie: After Donnie Dumbo leaves him, Dense Pence, devastated, brokenhearted, travels to India and learns to trust and to love again.
Great comments. Informative and even fun. Mostly accurate, I think. (Though I did mean we bombed Iraq to get at Iran’s assets, dignity, whatever). But we do need to organize. That may mean getting outside our comfort zones and communicating–however we can–with the millions of folks who voted for T, against their own interests. Can it be done? I think so, but we won’t know unless we try. And we can’t just donate more money to those groups that don’t reach the T fans now.
Closer to home- various media reported today that Willis Johnson of Tennessee, is Kristi Noem’s checkbook to finance the Mexican border plans of her state’s National Guard (S.D.). Some warn that the arrangement creates a mercenary force.
In 2019, Johnson hosted a Mike Pence fundraiser for Trump along with other Tennesseans like Mike Hodges. About the same year, Mike Hodges and Werner Stegmaier, a German scholar, expert in Nietzche, founded the Hodges Foundation for Philosophical Orientation. The website explains the Foundation’s focus.
Adding some unrelated info. about the “philosopher of the 3rd Reich”. One research paper about Nietzche is titled, “The Godfather of Fascism?” Nietzche’s sister was married to Bernhard Forster, a German nationalist and anti-Semite. Historians conclude that it was after Nietzche’s death (he died before Hitler’s rise) that his sister and her husband manipulated Nietzche’s writings to accommodate their view.
A couple of translations of Nietzche’s work- “masses are manipulated for chauvinistic goals that crush the autonomy of the individual” and, the context for the concept of “Ubermensch… endowed with exceptional mental qualities.”
Before the National Guard donation, public records show Johnson’s largest charitable recipients were Christian ministries and health foundations.
Johnson thinks the border plans of the Commander in Chief, America’s elected President, Joe Biden, are wrong so he uses his money (avoided taxation) to undermine the majority will.
These are very dangerous times for democracy, for the 99%, for religious minorities and for people of color.
Baboons were around long before Congress, so can’t be held responsible for the fact that the Fondling Father’s adopted the term for their sludgislative body.
Response to Bob above
If our youth don’t love our country, why in the world would they strive to defend it against China and other threats? All countries need patriotic education to survive. We can do this without ignoring our faults, but we cannot ignore our virtues, which many on the Left do.
We do have Kanye West and Kim Kardashian.
Is that enough acknowledgment of our virtues?
Although they have split up, so maybe they are not virtues any more.
But we still have Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck, than goodness.
And we also have Hollywood, Disneyland and Disney World.
..and Clint Eastwood.
And American Idol and The Voice.
Man, we have a lot of virtues.
No, what the “left” wants is for us to honestly learn from our faults as a means to enhance our virtues. Being self critical is crucial for progress of any kind.