In Florida, state officials ordered schools across the state to open fully without regard to safety or local officials. The Florida Education Association sued, and a judge blocked them reopening.
A Florida judge Monday granted a temporary injunction against the state’s order requiring school districts to reopen schools during the novel coronavirus pandemic, saying in a harshly worded decision that parts of it were unconstitutional. Circuit Court Judge Charles Dodson, in a 16-page decision, granted the request in a lawsuit filed by the Florida Education Association to block the order issued by state Education Commissioner Richard Corcoran compelling schools to reopen five days a week for families who wanted that option.
The state also required districts to offer virtual learning. School districts can now proceed to follow through on starting the 2020-2021 school year as they want, according to the teachers union.
The Florida Education Department said it could not immediately comment on the decision.
The White House, where President Trump has been pushing districts to reopen schools and threatened to withhold federal funds if they didn’t — though he doesn’t have the power to do that unilaterally — said it would not comment on state matters.
Dodson said in his decision that the state did not take many important health considerations into consideration when it issued the order. “It fails to mention consideration of community transmission rates, varying ages of students, or proper precautions,” he wrote. “What has been clearly established is there is no easy decision and opening schools will most likely increase covid-19 cases in Florida.”
The judge ruled that the plaintiffs had established that the order was being “applied arbitrarily across Florida.” He sided with the plaintiffs, granting a preliminary injunction against the order and striking down parts of it as unconstitutional.
The administration of Gov. Ron DeSantis (R), who is an ally of the president’s, has for months been pushing districts to reopen. On July 6, Corcoran issued an issue requiring that school districts reopen school buildings, though it gave a few districts in south Florida, which had extremely high coronavirus rates, permission to start the 2020-2021 school year remotely.
Other districts that wanted to start remotely were not given approval, including Hillsborough County, which was threatened by the DeSantis administration with the loss of nearly $200 million if it carried out its plan to open remotely.
The lawsuit said that Corcoran’s order was unconstitutional because it threatened the safety of schools by conditioning funding on reopening school buildings by the end of August, regardless of the dangers posed by the pandemic.
The lawsuit also said the order was “arbitrary” and “capricious” on its face and application. The state responded, saying the order was a reasonable exercise of emergency powers by the DeSantis administration that balanced the constitutional rights of students to a public education against the risk of harm during the pandemic.
It also said that states had submitted reopening plans that included the opening of school campuses, and that showed the districts wanted to proceed that way. Dodson didn’t accept that reasoning, saying that districts had no choice but to open buildings because of the order.
The White House … said it would not comment on state matters.”
Really, how many times has Trump attacked Democratic mayors and governors for not doing what he wanted? Below is just a quick sample of how Trump is attacking, pressuring, bullying states to do what he wants.
“Defeating a pandemic is hard enough, but Trump has introduced another layer of complexity: He has personalized the battlefield. He calls COVID-19 ‘the invisible enemy,’ but he also seems fixated on the visible variety—all Democratic leaders, who in his view have been insufficiently grateful for the federal government’s response. A stray complaint about equipment shortages invites a public feud with the man controlling the spigot. ‘If they don’t treat you right, I don’t call,’ the president said at a news conference last week.”
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/03/trump-democratic-governors-cuomo/609124/
“Trump Brings in the Infantry for His War on Blue America
“Even during the pandemic, he is using the tools of national authority to advance Republican priorities while weakening Democrats’ capacity to impede them.”
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/05/trump-escalating-his-war-blue-america/611653/
“Trump demands ‘law and order’ and tells Democrat leaders to ‘get tough’ on ‘anarchist’ rioters after fleeing to his bunker as protesters besieged White House”
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8374737/Trump-bashed-Democrat-run-cities-burned-rioters-demands-National-Guard-activated.html
“Yesterday, President Trump declared his intention to stage a resurrection for the U.S. economy – just in time for Easter Sunday. As he spoke, 17 governors across the country had placed their states on total lockdown, and another 11 had imposed such orders on the hardest-hit portions of their states, setting up a potential test of wills between them and the federal government.”
https://www.brookings.edu/blog/fixgov/2020/03/25/trump-or-governors-whos-the-boss/
Parents have the option of home schooling. 😐🤔
Yes, but the staff does not get that option.
I hope, the school staff can work remotely. 😐
I heard on a Florida radio station that the state is appealing the decision, which won’t be dealt with until mid September. That basically makes this ruling meaningless as schools will have to follow the state order until the final court deals with the case.
It is a temporary injunction. The case will be appealed.
In his decision the judge stated that districts were not prepared to keep students and staff safe. Most districts were not providing PPE and reducing class size to provide space for social distancing. The judge also said that districts should not lose funding if they do not open. DeSantis is appealing the decision.