Chalkbeat reports that many parents are calling on Mayor DeBlasio to endorse outdoor classes.
A Brooklyn lawmaker has joined the growing chorus of parents and activists calling on the city to close streets around school buildings for use as car-free space for recreation, lunch, small group instruction and other activities.
In just two days, City Council Member Brad Lander received proposals from 14 schools from his district — stretching from Boerum Hill and Park Slope to Sunset Park and Kensington — to use surrounding streets. He called on the Department of Transportation to establish an “Open Streets: Schools” program to help coordinate and oversee a citywide operation.
“Families, teachers, school staff and many others are deeply concerned about the safety of sending students back to indoor school in the fall, about whether their school facilities can be made safe (e.g. what about the schools where windows don’t open),” Lander wrote Thursday to the transportation department.
Lander’s letter is part of the effort to maintain social distance guidelines while providing in-person learning this year. Schools are figuring out how to safely hold socially distant classes for their hybrid of in-person and remote schedules, opting to repurpose cafeterias, auditoriums and even office space as classrooms. The push to look outdoors comes as much of the scientific evidence points to less transmission of the coronavirus outside, and as many families remain concerned about the ventilation inside classrooms despite promises from city officials that HVAC systems and ventilation upgrades are underway. Schools are also grappling with how to figure out how to follow social distancing rules with limited space, which means that most children will attend school next year between one and three days a week.
“This is especially dire for students in our most crowded schools, who may end up with up to 66 percent fewer school days simply by virtue of where they live,” Lander wrote.
The letter suggests that blocks could be closed to traffic during school hours to make room for students. Temporary tents could be set up for shade or rain protection, or in some cases, blocks could be fully closed to allow schools to set up semi-permanent tents and outdoor classroom spaces.

Amen to this. I interviewed at an independent school that was located in the middle of sugar cane fields. They had many science and history classes take place in open areas, it was inspiring. Kids got out in the fresh air, had to walk, and didn’t realize they were learning all along. It was then that I realized if I didn’t want to teach there, I needed to get out of teaching.
LikeLike
I want to know who these parents are who are pushing this. I suspect it is the few middle and upper middle class, mostly white, parents who send their kids to the few progressive public schools. The parents I have worked with would never agree to this. They don’t want their kids outside in anything below 50 degrees. This is another case of white privilege rearing its head without thinking. Believe me I would love to see the beautiful out door classes some children have in beautiful natural settings, but this is not that. It would have to be far better than some flimsy tents to be satisfactory to most parents.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am a teacher who has spent the last few years practicing lock down drills with my students. We literally huddle together as silently as possible so a shooter won’t know we’re there. How do we do that outside in a tent? Has Covid-19 solved the school shooting problem? Is our society so anxious to go back to “normal” that we are willing to sacrifice students and teachers?
LikeLike
Nobody has provided an answer to this question. I guess protecting students and staff against school shooters (and others who might want to disrupt classes in tents) isn’t really important anymore.
LikeLike
When Denver backed off social distancing in the 1918 pandemic, the results were deadly
https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2020/04/22/opinions/denver-1918-lesson-avlon/index.html
LikeLiked by 1 person
the second spike was shockingly high
LikeLike
Closing off the streets to allow more options to individual schools sounds good to me. One size fits all mandates are horrible, but having more flexibility sounds good. Even the old school buildings that had steam radiators for heating have probably converted to forced air with the installation of air conditioning. Forced air heating and cooling during the pandemic is less appealing, since it increases the hazard for downwinders [people downwind of an infected person].
LikeLike
👍👍
LikeLike
**This. Would. Not. Matter*** Just today, major league baseball is looking at cancelling the season–+ covid-19 cases amongst ballplayers (NYT daily coronavirus bulletin).
IL High School Athletics has cancelled sports this fall.
So–WHY is it that children will be safe in any schooling environment? (Not to mention adults.)
Sickness & death or distance (learning)? I’m going to post a KISS (Keep it Simple, Sweetie) link. Read & heed.
LikeLike
Here’s the link:
https://teacherpoetmusicianglenbrown.blogspot.com/2020/07/17-arguments-why-our-children-should.html
LikeLike
Great link. Originally posted on FB by a parent. This link re-quotes it in Glen Brown’s blog. Also cited in Daily Kos [7/17?] Needs to be read by all in its entirety. My favorite quotes:
“I posed the following question to 40 people today, representing professional and management roles in corporations, government agencies, and military commands: ‘Would your company or command have a 12-person, 45-minute meeting in a conference room?’ 100% of them said ‘No’ they would not. We do not even consider putting our office employees into the same situation we are contemplating putting our children into.”
“my view of the School Board: if the 12 of you aren’t getting into a room together because it represents a risk, don’t tell me it’s OK for our kids.”
Morice makes a major point usually ignored: ““Hardly any kids get COVID.” …is a cherry-picked argument… One can reasonably argue that, due to the school closures in March, children have had the least EXPOSURE to COVID.” This caveat was included in
the several studies on this topic, but routinely left out of articles citing them.
I also like: Morice notes that his arguments pertain as well to “part-time”/ staggered/ shifts etc, and he remains unconvinced. Teachers need to stick to their guns on this. Such schemes limit children’s total hours of exposure– but not adult staff’s!
LikeLike