Jesse Hagopian is a high school teacher and social justice activist in Seattle. He has been a leading force on behalf of Black Lives Matter Movement.
He wrote this opinion article for the Seattle Times to explain why Seattle educators want money redirected from policing to social services.
He writes:
Seattle’s Education Association representative assembly — the union body that represents Seattle’s teachers, nurses, librarians, instructional assistants, office professionals and educational support staff — has overwhelmingly passed seven resolutions in solidarity with the movement for Black lives. These included removing police from schools and the King County Labor Council, (which was achieved by a recent vote of the council), educating SEA members on alternatives to calling 911 on students, and my own resolution to defund the Seattle Police Department and reinvest the money in education, health care and programs to support families.
These bold resolutions, adopted June 8, were surely spurred by the police killings of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor and Ahmaud Arbery, and the ensuing uprising that’s swept the nation. But this vote wasn’t only about injustices elsewhere. Seattle’s educators have been fighting institutional racism and the school-to-prison-pipeline here for some time.
In Seattle, our “Black Lives Matter at School” movement erupted September 2016. A white supremacist threatened to bomb John Muir Elementary School when the educators there — in conjunction with parents, community and the group “Black Men United to Change the Narrative” — declared they would celebrate Black students with an assembly, and by wearing “Black Lives Matter” shirts to school.
Black Lives Matter at School then went national, thanks to educators in Philadelphia who organized a full week of action and broke down the 13 principles of the Black Lives Matter Global Network into teaching points for each day of the week. Last year, educators in more than 40 cities participated in BLM at School, reaching many thousands of students.
Each year, Seattle’s educators have voted to support the demands of the national Black Lives Matter at School week of action during the first week in February, including the fourth SEA demand, “Fund Counselors, Not Cops.” And when Seattle Public Schools parent Charleena Lyles was killed in her own home in front of her children by Seattle police department officers on June 18, 2017, the Seattle Education Association urged our members to wear their Black Lives Matter shirts to school and join a rally to stand with her family.
Building on that legacy, educators took a bold new step to call for a 50% cut from the $409 million already budgeted for the Seattle Police Department this year. Seattle educators now understand the words of Michelle Alexander, leading human-rights advocate and author of “The New Jim Crow,” who recently wrote:
After decades of reform, countless commissions and task forces, and millions of dollars poured into ‘smart on crime’ approaches, the police behave with about as much brutality today as they did in 1966 … More than 95% of arrests every year are for nonviolent offenses like loitering, fare evasion and theft.”
Yet the resolution passed by Seattle’s educators wasn’t simply about shrinking the size and malignancy of the police but about re-imagining justice, education, public safety and our society. The resolution also demands that,
“Seattle’s Mayor and City Council must protect and expand investments to make our communities safe, prioritizing community-led health and safety strategies. Full access to affordable housing, community-based anti-violence programs, trauma services and treatment, universal child care and free public transit are just a few of the non-police solutions to social problems.”
As the saying goes, “Hurt people hurt people. Whole people heal people.” Massive wealth inequality and structural racism are hurting people in our city and constitute the biggest threat to public safety. We now have an opportunity to make the kind of social investments in housing, education and health care to create whole and healthy communities and create new paradigms for addressing the root causes of violence.
Several Seattle-based organizations are already providing a restorative justice and community building approach to public safety, including Community Passageways, Safe Passage and Creative Justice. These programs provide such services as alternatives to youth incarceration, mentorship to youth who are involved with the legal system and staff trained in de-escalation techniques to help mediate conflicts, providing an alternative model for public safety. These and other programs are limited by their budgets, however, which pale in comparison to the funding lavished on the punitive system of policing.
Minneapolis has already vowed to dismantle its police force and start over with a new vision for investing in social workers, public-health workers and conflict mediators who are trained to care for people’s well-being.
Seattle’s educators have a lesson for city officials. We hope they are sitting up straight and taking notes: We can create safe and thriving communities by joining the growing number of cities who are re-appropriating funds from a punishment-based system and re-aiming them toward a new system that builds thriving communities.
Jesse Hagopian teaches Ethnic Studies and English Language Arts at Garfield High School, is an editor for Rethinking Schools, serves as the director for Black Education Matters and is the co-editor of the book “Teaching for Black Lives.” He is the recipient of the NAACP Youth Council’s 2019 Racial Justice Teacher of the Year award.

Defang the Police …
LikeLike
Much improved, Jon.
LikeLike
much more to the point
LikeLike
“Re-appropriate” funds from Bill Gates and Jeff Bezos. Use the money to finance social programs. Reimburse black people for lifetimes of discrimination.
Bill and Melinda Gates, who claim participation in a church, refuse to show Christianity, preferring to promote authoritarianism and greed, instead.
LikeLike
In the past, Gates has disavowed any religious belief, and his first instinct is still to refer to people’s “creation myths.” At the same time, he sees religion as sometimes playing valuable roles in people’s lives and has an open mind about ultimate realities. So, it’s pretty clear that he is an agnostic who leans toward atheism, but he’s also quite concerned with PR, so he tempers his public comments about this stuff.
LikeLike
The right wing, as expected, is already out with ads that are accusing the “socialist Democrats” of anarchy through “defunding the police.” I totally agree that policing in this country needs an overhaul, but the “defund the police” term is a messaging nightmare for the Biden campaign, even though Biden’s campaign had nothing to do with the movement. Biden has already stated that he does not support defunding the police, but the radical right wing is already associating “defunding the police” with the Democrats.
LikeLike
Agreed. The call to defund police is inane. Were a teacher to viciously abuse a student, would we call to defund teachers?
Look what happened to Vallejo when they defunded the police:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/this-california-city-defunded-its-police-force-killings-by-officers-soared/2020/06/22/253eeddc-b198-11ea-856d-5054296735e5_story.html
LikeLike
Insane and inane.
LikeLike
Jesse Hagopian is an all-around good guy and someone I hope emerges as an educational policy leader. Godspeed sir!
LikeLike
Geoffrey Fieger • Why “Defunding Police” Makes Sense
LikeLike
Why is so little written about the apparently successful reorganization of the policing structure in Camden, NJ? Is “defunding” a convenient but incendiary term?
LikeLike
I’d prefer a positive sounding title like “Invest in Community Policing.” Defund the police gives the right wing too much ammunition in an election year.
LikeLike
Community policing is a joke. It’s what’s promised every time these protests erupt. All it ends up meaning is more funding for more cops on the street who end up using exactly the same methods as the non-community police. The police have had their chance to reform and we certainly don’t need to “invest” any more in them. The only thing that can be done at this point – for the sake of both the police and the community – is reassign tasks that police shouldn’t be doing in the first place and put the funding toward health and human service programs.
LikeLike
Maybe someone should take a look a Camden, NJ, where they claim Community Policing is successful.
LikeLike
Invest in a Safety Force. Include social workers in calls where help is needed.
LikeLike
“Defunding the police” is a gift to the Trump campaign.
LikeLike
Then I guess Jesse Hagopian must be a Trump supporter because he is specifically using the word “defund”: “…my own resolution to defund the Seattle Police Department and reinvest the money in education, health care and programs to support families.”
LikeLike
I don’t see any well thought out plan for what the police department responsibilities should be and what should be left to other agencies. I am making a giant leap here in guessing that the lion’s share of the police budget is in personnel, which means very roughly eliminating half of the personnel. I know that is an oversimplification probably on the same order of the one that calls for reallocating half of it’s to various groups that are providing “a restorative justice and community building approach to public safety,…” I think we all agree that a rethinking of policing is in order, and that investing in under served communities in a meaningful manner is long overdue. How we do it in a responsible manner is a far more difficult question.
LikeLike
Here in CA there is now an epidemic of illegal fireworks use. In TINDER DRY California. I don’t want my house to burn down. The M80’s going off at all hours terrorize people and especially dogs. I’m curious to hear Jesse Hagopian’s solution to this problem. I want more police, not fewer.
I want more police on the freeways here too –speeding and reckless driving are out of control. I rarely see highway patrol.
Bashing police is idiotic. Civilization requires policing.
LikeLike
Jesse Hagopian is a jewel of a teacher and a great progressive asset in transforming racist and inequitable schooling. The support of the Seattle Teachers Union for defunding the police is a landmark declaration.
LikeLike
My son-in-law is graduating from the Camden police force next week and I’m so impressed with everything we’ve learned about their community outreach policy. They walk the streets and get to know the neighbors personally. They are trained to de-escalate first before using deadly force. A few years ago all 50 men, including the chief, were fired and had to reapply through a 50 page application and take a psychological test.
The police were commended by Obama for their handling of the protesters in Camden. They wore no riot gear nor helmets and carried no sticks and they actually marched with the protesters. They believe in gaining the trust of the people and having relationships with all community members. Crime has decreased substantially since these new community policies have been in place.
LikeLike