In this editorial, Harold Meyerson plumbs the depths of meanness in the Senate’s majority party. It would be better for the unemployed if more of them were quarantined and unable to vote:
ON TAP Today from the American Prospect
MARCH 26, 2020
Meyerson on TAP
The Senate’s OTHER Vote Last Night—Along Party Lines. As every news-following American knows, the Senate voted unanimously last night to pass a $2.2 trillion stimulus package for our rapidly shrinking economy. But hardly any news-following American knows about the vote that immediately preceded that—on the amendment that four Republican senators introduced to greatly reduce unemployment insurance payments.
The senators’ objection to the agreed-upon UI fix in the stimulus bill was itself widely reported. Because unemployment insurance levels in many states with right-wing governments are so low, Democrats insisted upon the federal government topping off UI payments with an additional $600 a week to the unemployed for a four-month period. Four conservative senators objected on the grounds that that might create incomes for the unemployed that exceeded their pay when on the job. Not surprisingly, two of those senators were South Carolinians Lindsey Graham and Tim Scott. South Carolina, it should be noted, is one of the six states that have never passed a minimum-wage law, and one of the two states (the other is North Carolina) that always place first or second in having the lowest rate of unionized workers—invariably, below 3 percent. In short, it’s no great achievement to make more money off the job than on the job in the senators’ home state, precisely because South Carolina’s historic denigration of workers creates so many poverty-wage jobs. Graham and Scott were like the kids who kill their parents and plead for mercy because they’re orphans.
But here’s the kicker: Surely, the objections of these two troglodytes and their two co-sponsors (Florida’s Rick Scott and Nebraska’s Ben Sasse) were just idiosyncratic social meanness, right?
Wrong. The vote on their amendment was 48-48; the only Republican to join the chamber’s 47 Democrats in voting no was Maine’s Susan Collins. (Fortunately, the Democrats, as part of the agreement on the stimulus bill, had insisted that the amendment require 60 votes to pass.)
If there’s a clearer expression of Republicans’ concern for their fellow Americans who lose their jobs in the pandemic crisis, I sure don’t know it. ~ HAROLD MEYERSON

Fortunately, one senator had something to say about it. Hint: it wasn’t Joe Biden.
LikeLike
Thank you, dienne77,
“Go Bernie!”
LikeLike
You can count on Bernie to speak the truth.
LikeLike
Bernie sure makes GREAT POINTS! Exactly.
Go Bernie.
LikeLike
UnAmerican Senators
It’s not just “mean”
Or “un-aware” of them
What we’ve seen
Is “un-American”
LikeLike
“How deep is your loathe, Senator?” (With apologies to the Bee Gees)
How deep is your loathe? how deep is your loathe?
How deep is your loathe?
You’re really mean, I’ve learned
‘Cause we’re living in a world of pols
Breaking us down when they all should let us be
They do wrong to you and me
LikeLike
“We the People of the United States, in order to form a more perfect Union, establish justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.”
Maybe privatized schools don’t teach that.
I am sending it to my red state Senators right now.
LikeLike
The GOP is this far right wing/libertarian anti-science death cult that always stands in the way of anything, (the merest iota), that would help ordinary Americans. They have always wanted to kill off Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. Trump is on the TV every day pretending to be presidential while Joe Biden is fumbling with his inept home podcasting efforts or whatever it’s called. I hope Biden gets his act together and tries to appear on more of the cable news shows (via phone or Skype) to pound home his message.
LikeLike
What message? “Nothing will fundamentally change”?
LikeLike
dienne77,
Yes, the silence is deafening.
LikeLike
Yvonne,
Returning to the way this country was under Obama IS a fundamental change.
There is a vast difference between America right now, and America nearly 4 years ago. It’s shocking how horrifying the right wing takeover of this country has changed it for the worse.
Bernie Sanders would be an excellent change from Trump. But it is clear that lots of primary voters believe that a return to the Obama years – except a bit more progressive – would also be an amazing change.
It is shocking that people still believe this country is no different today than it was when Obama was President. It is fundamentally different. It is frighteningly different.
Having Biden would be a HUGE change from Trump. Having Bernie would be an even more enormous change. But the real change already happened with the election and empowerment of Donald Trump and the right wing Republican Party and we are now about to massively suffer because of it.
I don’t understand those who seem to be saying we are in the exact same place as when Obama was President and there has been absolutely no change at all.
Does it take a full scale neo-fascist takeover before we recognize that Trump has changed this country significantly and it is nothing like it was under Obama?
LikeLike
a far rightwing/libertarian anti-science death cult
That sums the Repugnicans up as well as anything I’ve ever read does. Well said, Joe Jersey!
LikeLike
What is his message??
LikeLike
That we really need to protect the earnings of the heads of the U.S. healthcare RICOs?
That we have a crisis in availability of heliports at private hunting lodges for U.S. bankers?
That things really were better when Southern Segregationists could work together with their Northern counterparts to craft legislation?
LikeLike
What’s the frequency Kenneth?
LikeLike
SDP,
It requires a long memory to get that reference.
That’s what a mugger said to Dan Rather when he was on his way to a friends house in NYC. My ex-brother-in-law was Rather’s CBS producer, and Dan was going to his apartment when he was mugged.
LikeLike
He wasn’t really a “mugger” — not in the usual sense of trying to get money.
He thought CBS was controlling his mind with their TV signals and wanted to know the frequency so he could counteract it, presumably with some sort of electronic jamming device.
He figured Dan Rather would probably be privy to the frequency.
Or so the theory goes.
LikeLike
And my reference was a joke, by the way, lest someone take it seriously.
LikeLike
I don’t call them Rethuglicans for nothing. At the same time I don’t call them Dimocraps for nothing either.
LikeLike
Repugnicans and DIMocrackers
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Religious children are meaner than their secular counterparts” (The Guardian reported on the research finding.)
Pew Research ranks states by % of adults who are highly religious. Southern states top the list in both religion and Trump voting.
80% of evangelicals voted for Trump. Sixty percent of white Catholics voted for Trump.
Bellwether (Gates funded) advised reformers to reach out to churches to achieve their goals.
On 3-24-2020, the US Conference of Catholic Bishops and the evangelicals’ Family Research Council wrote a nasty letter about Planned Parenthood (link at CBS site)
that uses the humanitarian crisis of COVID- 19 to politic for a denial of women’s rights.
LikeLike
And, of course, Mitch McCraven McConnell, at the beginning of all this, announced that he wasn’t going to do anything, until Trump decided he needed to send out checks in order to save his reelection campaign, at which point Toady Moscow Mitch got on board. Then, what did he do? He crafted a bill that would have richly rewarded upper-middle-class folks just for being them and would have completely shut out poor people. It was only after Democrats cajoled and threatened to hold the whole thing up that Mitch gave in and decided to throw some crumbs to the poor.
Evil. The man is simply evil.
LikeLike
The Republicans ARE the party of big change — that is why Trump was elected to “blow up” the system. But what Trump’s panting fanboys and the white non-college grads (but affluent non-college grads) who voted for Trump in huge numbers did not realize is that they were going to suffer because for Trump, blowing up the system meant blowing up and politicizing the CDC and the everything that the federal government does to help people who aren’t billionaires and corporate CEOs and assault weapon lovers.
I keep thinking about how different this would be if the “evil and corrupt” HRC was President instead of Trump. There would still be problems, but you would have a federal government who is actually interested in helping people and not one led by a sociopath who can only see what benefits him.
Biden isn’t perfect, but a return to the old days would be a vast improvement over what we have now.
Even if I don’t love Joe Biden, he would be HUGE change from what we have now — a President who makes every disaster 100,000X times worse.
So those who say “Nothing would fundamentally change with Biden” are living in some privileged white world where they believe that our current country is exactly the same as it was when Barack Obama left office. It is not. We have HAD that “fundamental change” that some people were demanding, only it was the wrong change.
A return to normalcy — even with all its problems – would be a GOOD thing. Bernie Sanders knows that and the speech someone posted was NOT an attack on Joe Biden or the “corrupt and evil Democrats” — it was rightly an attack on the people who brought about the fundamental change that has turned our country into one that is terrible compared to when Obama left office. Except if you are living in a privileged bubble of “I hate the Democrats”.
Basically we are all about to experience what Puerto Rico experienced under Donald Trump at a time when a NORMAL President who wasn’t Trump would have done something to help them.
Anyone who is still saying that “Nothing will fundamentally change under Biden” is living in a protected bubble of privilege and believes that this country has not changed at all under Trump. On the contrary, we have HAD the change. That’s why Biden looks like he will be the nominee — because Americans did not like the “fundamental change” offered by Trump and wanted the flawed but fundamentally democratic Obama years.
Things have already changed under Trump. This country is fundamentally changed for the worse.
Biden is a return to something much better than we have now, and even if that’s not all we want, it would be the saving of our country. Biden is a HUGE CHANGE! Because what we have now is not democracy but the precursor of fascism.
LikeLike
The discussion about “nothing will fundamentally change” vs “HUGE CHANGE” already sounds stale. We’re in the midst of a huge change right now, and need any old Dem pres/ admin in place to patch us through it, then pick up the pieces. Toward that end (let alone restoring “normalcy” in the Obama-era sense), we can count on even an antique “3rd-Way” Dem to do the minimum required to reinvigorate govt’s ability to function at home and abroad : reverse Trump executive orders, appoint a competent cabinet and re-populate the exec depts, re-establish ties w/allies.
LikeLike
bethree,
I agree! But it is important to call out those who seem to be under the strange impression that the country we live in today is exactly the same as it was under Obama – it is not. Everyone who didn’t vote for the Democrat in 2016 helped bring about a very big change and that has to be noted. Our current situation is a significant change from 2016 and that needs to be acknowledged. We got “change” big time and we are living through it.
In other words, the current “status quo” is Trumpism. Biden does not represent Trumpism. He represents a change from Trumpism that is necessary and good. Bernie Sanders understands that.
LikeLike
NYC-
Your omission of the religious vote for Trump means it was inconsequential to the outcome?
LikeLike
Utter contempt.
Our overlords have somehow managed to figure out ways to specifically hurt women, even now, during a massive public health crisis. Some states are using the virus as an excuse to ban abortion. Melissa Jeltsen reports. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/texas-abortion-coronavirus_n_5e791f9fc5b63c3b6495919a?ncid=newsltushpmgvoices_Information
LikeLike
Same in Ohio, Susan
LikeLike
The evangelicals’ Family Research Council and a secretariat of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops wrote a letter to the Secretary of Health and Human Services on March 24, 2020 (link posted at CBS site) asking for an abortion ban.
The women in the pews who give legitimacy to the churches bare responsibility for a return to the danger of coat hangar birth control. Many of them use birth control while the Bishops fund a clinic with $2.5 mil. that recommends ovulation charts to the exclusion of pharmaceutical birth control. America is a white, male-privileged theocracy made possible by the silence and voting of women.
LikeLike
“Theology after breakfast sticks to the eye,” wrote Wallace Stevens. Equivalently, he could have written “Ideology.”
For example, IQ45, not my President, to the extent that anything much occurs between his ears, has a knee-jerk libertarian, free market ideology. So, he has refused, so far, to use the Defense Production Act to order companies to produce necessary medical supplies. So, as the virus spreads exponentially, that production creeps along.
And as a result, hundreds of thousands of people will die.
Elections have consequences. I am ashamed that my country has put this utter moron in charge. And I am furious at the idiots who voted for him. Those who voted for this subhuman share in the consequences of this.
LikeLike
“We have it totally under control. . . . It’s going to be just fine.” –IQ45, Jan 22
“I would love to have the country opened up and just raring to go by Easter.” –Magical Fantasyland Barbie in Chief, March 24
LikeLike
“We’re going to be opening very soon. . . . We’re opening up this incredible country. . . . I would love to have the country opened up and just raring to go by Easter. . . . churches full of people.” –Magical Fantasyland Barbie in Chief, March 24
LikeLike
Diseaster
Jesus rose
While others fell
Ascent for those
Will turn to Hell
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow, all these verbatim Trump-nuggets are ripe & ready for pooper-scoopering into yet another youtube sequel to “Donald Trump: Your Drunk Neighbor” (Friend Dog Studios). His oratorial style has not changed in the slightest since the original episode was [hilariously] lip-synched four years ago.
There was a to-ROFL Trump covid-19 speech spoof aired this morning on WFAN. One of the sportscasters, an impressionist himself, found it being passed around among fellow spoofers. Can’t find it yet online. The high point: Trump compares himself to God in the context of his plans to save his people from the virus and bring the dead economy back to life on Easter Sunday. How many did God save? Really, just one. And by the way it was his own son; frankly, a little bias there.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s a very funny bit, and the imitation is spot on:
LikeLike
There’s a word for the conduct of these four legislators, now what is it…?
Oh yes: disgraceful.
LikeLike
The four are devout Christians.
LikeLike
And now we have #5. Thomas Massie R-Ky who is insisting on a quorum for the voting process even though most have come to an agreement about this issue. Now we have politicians flocking back to DC so that “the people” will have some kind of stimulus package in the near future…..maybe. Why, oh why do people continue to vote these people into office? Mr. Massie having a huge temper tantrum because he doesn’t get what HE wants and holding up aid to the American people is a crime against humanity and should be punishable by law. I say it’s time for the pitchforks and torches for these blobs of flesh….I can’t bear to refer to them as human.
LikeLike
Religion and Kentucky tribalism/politics.
1-20-2019 headline, “Thomas Massie defends Covington Catholic high school students who were involved in a confrontation with a Native American…”. (The students were in D.C. for a right-to-life rally.)
The attorney selected by a Cov Cath student for his defamation lawsuit against a N.Y. newspaper in the incident, is a Trump supporting attorney, who is now Massie’s 2020 primary challenger.
LikeLike