Larry Buhl of Capital and Main writes here about the transient nature of charter schools. In California, as in other states, they open with bold promises but many close with short notice to patents due to under enrollment or financial problems or both.
As Buhl writes, parents are left scrambling and students’s lives are disrupted when their charter school closes suddenly.
Buhl begins:
IN LATE AUGUST OF 2018, Donald and Christine Fergusson were looking forward to the start of their daughter’s second year (second grade) at the International Preparatory Academy. The school, part of the Partnerships to Uplift Communities (PUC Schools), is located in the northeast Los Angeles suburb of Eagle Rock. But three weeks before the start of school, iPrep’s new superintendent, a PUC national board member and the PUC CEO held an emergency meeting where they told parents they would need to bring in more students or the school would close. The Spanish-Mandarin dual immersion school originally aimed to enroll 275 in grades K-2 and 6-8, although the organization told parents it could get by with 200. Panicked parents began distributing fliers in the neighborhood and urging neighbors to register for iPrep immediately.
“They gave us until September 24th to bring in more students,” Donald Fergusson said. “That’s not the parents’ job.”
After scrambling for a few days, the Fergussons decided iPrep was a sinking ship and enrolled their daughter in a Los Angeles Unified School District school with Mandarin immersion, which had been their main reason for choosing iPrep. It turned out to be a good decision. Three days after iPrep opened for its second year of operation — with only 114 students — PUC’s board voted to shut it down.
“Our school was under-enrolled from the very start,” Christine Fergusson said. “They told us it would grow and add one grade per year. I think [the board was] going to close the school anyway. They just strung us along.”

More like skunk cabbages.
LikeLike
Charters are like short lived sand flies. They annoyingly get in your face; can make public things like roads hazardously slippery; clog up everything, gutters for example; and smell like decay because their lifespan can be as short as thirty minutes. A bunch of them together is called a swarm.
LikeLike
I thought a bunch of charters was called a “crime” of charters.
LikeLike
One charter is a crime, so a bunch would be a spree. Wait though, Betsy DeVos said charters are like food trucks. She’s right. Just because one parks itself on your block doesn’t mean it’s going to be there tomorrow.
LikeLike
Perfect … “skunk cabbages.”
LikeLike
I am happy that some public schools are successfully implementing dual language bilingual education despite all the insanity in public education these days. So many innovative options for students have disappeared under so-called reform. I heard Beto say at the NEA forum that his children attend a dual language public school in El Paso.
LikeLike
Ballade des Chartes du Temps Jadis
Oh where are the charters of yesteryear?
(Sing we now the memento mori,
The brief but lucrative con man’s glory.)
Gone their flim-flam way, I fear;
The pillaging done, they’re out of here.
But not before their CMAs,
(Their charter management associations
Those racketeering organizations)—
Carpe Diem!—seized the day
And carried the taxpayer dollars away.
They promised miraculous scores we’d see,
(That no excuses would rescue the poor
From low expectations, as never before.)
They praised accountability
While hiding munificent management fees.
Their buildings to their own schools they leased.
(And paid themselves quite handsomely
In salaries and management fees)
Their equity the while increased
As they the public wantonly fleeced.
And then like the bloom that quickly blows
Like the travelling medicine man of yore,
Who sold cure-alls and fled before
Their remedies could be exposed,
They announced that tomorrow they had to close.
Oh where are the charters are yesteryear?
Their owners have fled to other schools
In other states with others to fool.
Of scams they’re the best, so don’t you sneer
At the charters, the charters of yesteryear!
LikeLike
penultimate verse, men, not man, ofc
LikeLike
cx: last verse, the charters of yesteryear, ofc
LikeLike
Francois Villon would be pleased and flattered by your work.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That rogue!
LikeLike
OK, it’s a little rough. Where’s SomeDAM Poet when you need ‘im?
LikeLike
Well, remember, it’s the deformer version of charters, which is something like a toy from McDonald’s as opposed to a puppy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
🙂
LikeLike
At least day lilies brighten the world and give us some joy and beauty.
LikeLike
The SF Bay Area NPR station ran a radio forum on charter schools this morning. Link here.
LikeLike
Finally a few people are getting a clue about charters. Like private prisons, they do not serve for the public good.
LikeLike