Since 1987, The Concord Review (TCR) has sought and published more than 1,300 history research papers by high school
students from 41 countries in 121 quarterly issues. TCR.org.
Over the course of these many years, Will Fitzhugh, the founder of TCR, has been turned down by every foundation while seeking funding for this worthy endeavor. In their drive for innovation, the nation’s philanthropies did not find merit in the idea of acknowledging the dedication of students who conduct primary historical research and who are recognized by having their work published.
In different years,, three sisters from Cincinnati, Ohio, won the journal’s highest honor: the Emerson Prize.
The girls attended Summit Country Day School.
Winners of the Emerson Prize: (left to right):
Caroline Elizabeth Walton, The Tudors, Volume 27, Number 1 {18,000 words)
Victoria Claire Walton, Operation Valkyrie, Volume 29, Number 1 (15,000 words)
Emily K. Walton, Mary Queen of Scots, Volume 24, Number 3 (13,200 words)

Fitzhugh wants high school students to read history, not textbooks, but actual history. He wants them to do research and write in-depth history essays. He publishes the best of them in TCR.
In addition, he offers these services:
TCR SERVICES
High School students planning to go to college should know that they will face reading lists of nonfiction books and be asked to write research papers. The vast majority of American public high school students are not asked to read a single complete nonfiction book or to write a term paper before graduation. But they suspect that the safe spaces of fiction readings and personal writing will not prepare them well enough for college. In many cases their teachers have neither the inclination nor the time to help them with History research papers, and while some students, such as many of those published in The Concord Review since 1987, have set up Independent Study programs which let them write such papers, others may want to make use of the services we offer to serious secondary students of History:
One: The National Writing Board [1998] provides a unique independent assessment service for the History research papers of high school students. Our reports by two Senior Readers now average five pages and may be sent to college admissions officers. Inquire at tcr.org/nwb.
Two: The TCR Summer Program [2014] offers a two-week course on the writing of serious History papers by secondary students, with three sessions in the United States, and one in Korea, in 2019. Contact: steven.lee@tcr.org (Manager of the TCR Summer Program). tcr.org/summer.
Three: The TCR Academic Coaching Service [2014] matches high school students working on a History research paper online with TCR Authors now at or recently graduated from Chicago, Columbia, Harvard, MIT, Princeton, Stanford and Yale. Personal advice and guidance from a successful older peer (many are Emerson Prize winners) can be inspiring and productive for secondary students struggling with serious term papers. Contact Jessica@tcr.org (Manager of the TCR Academic Coaches). tcr.org/coaches.
Four: The Concord Review [1987] can provide students with a fine variety of examples from the History research papers published by >1,300 high school students from 45 states and 40 other countries in 121 issues since 1987. This journal remains the only quarterly in the world for the academic History research papers of secondary students. These papers have served many students as useful models of research and writing to inspire and guide them in their own reading, research and writing. Find many examples at tcr.org/bookstore.
Congrats Carolyn, Emily, and Victoria! And congrats to TCR for creating an opportunity for real publication of work by high-school kids! Awesome!
LikeLike
Goood for these students.
I highly recommend reading: Chasing New Horizons: Inside the Epic First Mission to Pluto by Alan Stern and David Grinspoon … a FABULOUS read. Every sentence is a gem. This book is enlightening and has so much soul.
LikeLike
Hooray! Recognition for students interested in the humanities!
LikeLike
Great writing is possible without the Common Core and endless standardized tests.
LikeLike
Congratulations to these accomplished young scholars! But I must take issue with the derogatory reference to “the safe spaces of fiction and personal writing.” The Common Core has drastically diminished student reading of “imaginative literature” in favor of “informational text,” such as instruction manuals and vocational job descriptions. Schools need more fiction and personal writing, as well as “safe spaces” where students can learn to be readers.
LikeLike
I support the derogatory reference to safe spaces. Witness this piece of truth and beauty sacrificed at the altar of safe spaces:
LikeLiked by 1 person
More truth than beauty in my opinion, but that was also true for many murals created with funds from the Works Progress Administration, an employment program for artists. Nothing in this article addresses the merit of the work as Art, capital A.
The amazing thing to me is that the NYTimes covered this, and that the unanimous action of the school board was not loudly contested by anyone in the school community, or SF arts community. The comments on the article are worth reading for some sharp thinking about the difference between this decision and decisions about the fate of civil war monuments on public property. The mural has a whole lot of educational value that is being ignored.
LikeLike
Laura,
I presume most of these school board members graduated from college. I worry that our colleges are not doing a good job. If all you learned in college is Race and Gender, then of course these murals should be destroyed. “Four legs good; two legs bad” (I’m rereading Animal Farm).
More and more I am worried about the anti-intellectual, know-nothing, cult-like mentality of the education world. Themselves ignorant, these educators see no reason to cure their students of ignorance. In fact, best to keep them ignorant as actual facts might challenge their beloved, simple, clear and pious certainties. One thing these school board members should study (I’m almost sure they haven’t, with our anti-fact curricula these days. Buy boy have they learned critical thinking skills [not]) is China’s horrific Cultural Revolution.
Ideologues on both Left and Right should love the “critical thinking/problem solving” approach to education because, ironically, it retards critical thinking. Only facts –inconvenient facts –can disrupt false ideas. Only facts can pop the Trump/Fox bubble, and only facts can pop the Cult of the Holy Minority/PC bubble. Too bad few educators understand this.
LikeLike
Great comments here, ponderosa, as usual. Every time I read and experience stories like this (increasingly common) I feel more alienated.
LikeLike
A friend & colleague just e-mailed me some very disturbing (yet, unsurprising) news about the ignorance of a large # of the 100 students she’d addressed at a well-known, highly regarded public high school, w/respect to the government & its functions.
Proving that our 4-12th grade students everywhere MUST have a strong education in civics.
Retired teachers, hie thee to a school near you, & start educating; I’m sure active teachers (tethered to Common Core & endless test prep) will welcome you w/open arms
(even if the adminimals don’t–&–in this era of IQ45–it’s my belief that many will turn the other way).
*Okay, Senor Swacker, I anticipate your rebuttal!
LikeLike