Is Betsy DeVos the meanest woman in America?
She has just taken the steps needed to remove protections from students defrauded by predatory for-profit “colleges.”
Like others in the despicable Trump maladministration, DeVos thinks that consumers should fend for themselves. If they get defrauded, it’s their own fault for making a bad choice.
You can see where this is going. Government protects the marketplace, not the consumers. If you happened to get suckered by slick advertising, that’s your fault. Don’t expect the government to police the marketplace. Caveat emptor is your job.
DeVos previously rolled back regulations that allowed students who were defrauded to get a refund.
“Education Secretary Betsy DeVos formally moved Friday to scrap a regulation that would have forced for-profit colleges to prove that the students they enroll are able to attain decent-paying jobs, the most drastic in a series of policy shifts that will free the scandal-scarred, for-profit sector from safeguards put in effect during the Obama era.
“In a written announcement posted on its website, the Education Department laid out its plans to eliminate the so-called gainful employment rule, which sought to hold for-profit and career college programs accountable for graduating students with poor job prospects and overwhelming debt. The Obama-era rule would have revoked federal funding and access to financial aid for poor-performing schools.
“After a 30-day comment period, the rule is expected to be eliminated July 1, 2019. Instead Ms. DeVos would provide students with more data about all of the nation’s higher education institutions — not just career and for-profit college programs — including debt, expected earnings after graduation, completion rates, program cost, accreditation and other measures.
“Students deserve useful and relevant data when making important decisions about their education post-high school,” Ms. DeVos said in a statement. “That’s why instead of targeting schools simply by their tax status, this administration is working to ensure students have transparent, meaningful information about all colleges and all programs. Our new approach will aid students across all sectors of higher education and improve accountability.”
“But in rescinding the rule, the department is eradicating the most fearsome accountability measures — the loss of federal aid — for schools that promise to prepare students for specific careers but fail to prepare them for the job market, leaving taxpayers on the hook to pay back their taxpayer-backed loans.
“The DeVos approach is reversing nearly a decade of efforts to create a tough accountability system for the largely unregulated for-profit sector of higher education. In recent years, large for-profit chains, which offer training for everything from automotive mechanics to cosmetology to cybersecurity, have collapsed under mountains of complaints and lawsuits for employing misleading and deceptive practices.
“The implosions of ITT Technical Institute and Corinthian Colleges generated tens of thousands of complaints from student borrowers who said they were left with worthless degrees. The Obama administration encouraged the expansion of public community colleges as it forgave at least $450 million in taxpayer-funded student debt for for-profit graduates who could not find decent jobs with the degrees or certificates they had earned.
“The regulations passed in the wake of those scandals remade the industry. Since 2010, when the Obama administration began deliberating the rules, more than 2,000 for-profit and career programs — nearly half — have closed, and the industry’s student population has dropped by more than 1.6 million, said Steve Gunderson, the president of Career Education Colleges and Universities, the for-profit industry’s trade association.”
There is a simple principle that every student should think about: Avoid for-profit “Colleges”and “universities.”
Don’t be scammed by the next fake “Trump University.”
Another case of protecting markets…Bailouts of Wall Street in 2008 but nothing for Puerto Rico with a debt burden of $17,000 per capita…see
https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2017/09/wall-street-got-bailout-not-puerto-rico.html
Russians have far less personal debt than Americans.
“Stealing”- In 2004, Vanderbilt, a legacy admission college, got an award from the government for a national center on school choice. Photos of the 7 people associated with the center suggest all were White. Not surprising because currently, of the about 190 faculty in “Vandy’s” Peabody school, the photo array shows approximately 10 Black faculty with about half of them at the lower faculty ranks. Moving forward to the new grant from the government for a national center on school choice, of the 9 people reportedly associated, all appear to be White. One change, most of the schools represented are state schools. Intuition tells me the fix is in to produce results that will destroy public education. If so, members of the new panel are theoretically smart enough to know that privatization of public K-12 creates the playbook for privatization of public universities, which means they will be pulling up, after themselves, the ladder that they climbed. I hope my intuition is wrong.
Trump has already set the stage for the attack with his uninformed comments deriding community colleges. He would like to turn them into vocational schools. What Trump fails to realize is that most community colleges already serve this function for a much lower cost than comparable vocational schools. In addition about half of those that eventually get a four year degree start out a a community college including my daughter. As Diane mentions, the goal is to create a market, not protect consumers.https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2018/02/02/trump-calls-converting-community-colleges-vocational-schools
The colonialists’ primary goal is control of educational opportunity. They understand that the meritocracy in education threatens their heirs’ privilege. The increase in the ratio of Brown and Black populations increases their fears. Racial minorities can be controlled with a ceiling on social and economic advancement. When the minority becomes the majority, that ceiling has to be established, by assuring fewer and worse educational opportunities or through use of discriminatory legislation and enforcement, which the U.S. already has. The richest 0.1% are shoring up and increasing their control. It’s the only thing that explains the lies, deceits and distortions in the education research funded by the rich or, in the allocation of tax funds, by the rich like DeVos. So, it’s about far more than the market for many among the wealthy.
College students are notorious for loving to picket, but failing to vote. Perhaps if the Democratic Party hammers away relentlessly on them on campus with the fact of how they have been betrayed by DeVos and by the Republican Party, and the impact this is going have on their entire future life — a life of indebtedness unless political power shifts — college students might actually vote. The point needs to be hammered home into the heads of recent indebted graduates, too.
Maybe if the Democrats give them something to vote for instead of “hammering” them “relentlessly” to vote against, they’d get somewhere. College students know perfectly well who Betsy DeVos is and what she (doesn’t) have to offer. That’s why they’re not voting for Trump. But they also know who Duncan and King were and what they (didn’t) have to offer. That’s why they don’t vote Democratic.
The idea that the average college student, or any average person, not in education, knew/know the names Arne Duncan and John King is wrong.
Far more know Betsy DeVos because she takes bad governance to a stratospheric level. Duncan and King served greedy masters but, they’re not stupid like Republicans. They would have known that describing Black colleges as the first “choice” schools wouldn’t fly.
And, Erik Prince and DeVos ARE the greedy masters.
As much as I still and always will despise Obama for choosing Arne instead of Linda, among other things, I have to admit that giving defrauded students refunds and denying financial aid to for-profit colleges were very good things. That said, Go Bernie. Sigh.
If the Republicans weren’t so terrified of college students voting Democrat they would not be working so hard to disenfranchise them.
Ironically, what Duncan and King did was to public K-12 schools. In terms of college, no less than Andrew Cuomo is dangling free college.
Why is anyone Democrats on their COLLEGE policies when those are not the issue?
^^Why is anyone CRITICIZING Democrats on their college issues…
The “youth vote” has been energized to make huge impacts on political leadership in the past; surely we are headed into years when it will happen again.
“Stealing”- For a 2nd time, millions of dollars have been awarded to a private university to focus on (promote) school choice . The latest award to Tulane, as described by Syracuse University News (7-17-2018) is “to study how different approaches to school choice , such as voucher programs and charter schools can better serve disadvantaged students.”
And, as before, the entire list of researchers appear to be White. The private sector that runs the charter school system should do their own damn market research into how to produce a better product.
Where’s the money for the public schools? Each and every public university member of Tulane’s panel is complicit in the destruction of the public education system, K-12 and higher ed.
Why should she be any different than any other of the Trump appointees?
When I read yet another one of the many reprehensible things that Betsy DeVos is doing, I always like to send a special shout out to Eva Moskowitz for working so hard for DeVos’s confirmation.
“I believe Betsy DeVos has the talent, commitment, and leadership capacity to revitalize our public schools and deliver the promise of opportunity that excellent education provides, and I support her nomination as U.S. Secretary of Education”. The words of Eva Moskowitz.
I remember reading so many of Moskowitz’ op eds, interviews and speeches when DeVos was nominated, and I recall how strongly Moskowitz demanded that Senators confirm DeVos. Thank you, Eva Moskowitz, for demonstrating the judgement that guides you in all your actions.
It is this kind of judgement about the kind of education leaders students need that has led Joseph Bullock at the SUNY Charter Institute to demand that Eva Moskowitz be allowed to train her own teachers with no oversight.
It’s impossible to see DeVos without giving a special shout out to one of her most prominent cheerleaders, Eva Moskowitz.