Our faithful reader Charles asked me a few days ago why I had written nothing about Betsy DeVos’ appearance before Congress. I confess I have a very difficult time watching her testify because I always feel that she is being evasive or duplicitous. She doesn’t say what is on her mind or in her heart. She wants to convince people that she really cares about children, when we know that she really cares about one thing only: School choice. She has taken steps to harm children and college students but she never says flat out what she did and why she did it. Her interview with Leslie Stahl on “60 Minutes” was not atypical. She was primed and ready to dodge questions, not to explain anything candidly. She continues this pattern and I find it painful to watch.
Valerie Strauss wrote a column about DeVos’ testimony on her indispensable “Answer Sheet” blog, hosted by the Washington post.
There were five topics that DeVos could not or would not say or explain, writes Strauss.
1) DeVos could not explain the mission of the department’s Office for Civil Rights.
DeVos has rolled back or is in the process of delaying or gutting some Obama-era guidance and regulations that aimed to protect the rights of some minority groups, including LGBTQ students. The Trump administration’s budget proposals have called for funding cuts to the Office for Civil Rights in the Education Department, but Congress has overruled that. DeVos has changed the focus of the office, limiting the complaints it will address and reining in the systemic action favored by the Obama administration.
During Tuesday’s hearing, Rep. Marcia L. Fudge (D-Ohio) told DeVos that she was concerned about the weak performance of the Office for Civil Rights. Then she asked DeVos whether she knew the mission of that office.
DEVOS: The Office for Civil Rights is committed to protecting the civil rights as determined under the law of this land. And we do so proudly and with great focus each day.
FUDGE: That’s not the mission statement. Do you know what it is?
DEVOS: I have not . . . .
FUDGE: That’s okay.
DEVOS: I have not memorized the mission statement.
FUDGE: That’s okay. Please explain for me what you would believe to be vigorous enforcement of civil rights in the context of schools today.
DEVOS: It would be following the law and enforcing the law as stated . . . .
FUDGE: So how do you do it if you continue to try to dismantle and defund the office? I’m not understanding.
DEVOS: We haven’t done any such thing.
FUDGE: I think I’ve heard enough.
Later, Rep. Gregorio Kilili Camacho Sablan (D-Northern Mariana Islands) said, “The mission of the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights is to ensure equal access to education and to promote educational excellence through all the nation.”
2) DeVos did not provide a single detail about any plan she might have to promote inclusivity and access to an appropriate education for students with disabilities. And she wouldn’t commit to pushing Congress to fully fund the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, known as IDEA, which requires public schools to provide free and appropriate education to all students with disabilities.
3) DeVos refused to directly address questions from Rep. Mark Takano (D-Calif.) about potential conflicts of interest in a pilot student-aid program.
4) A legislator asked DeVos whether she would work with more urgency on her Federal Commission on School Safety to come up with recommendations to make school campuses safer after a rash of mass shootings.
5) Sablan asked her about access to higher education in U.S. territories, and she couldn’t quite answer his question.
I have left out the best parts, meaning the colloquy between DeVos and the members of Congress who asked questions. Her evasions, her ignorance, her indifference, her lack of information were on full display. You can understand why members of Congress find this hearings with DeVos to be frustrating, irritating, and outrageous. She doesn’t know or she isn’t telling what she does know.

“Betsy DeVos has the talent, commitment, and leadership capacity to revitalize our public schools and deliver the promise of opportunity.”
Betsy DeVos was and continues to be recognized by highly rewarded education CEOs like Eva Moskowitz as exactly the leadership this country needs. Eva Moskowitz recognized that DeVos represents the ideal type of person who should be in charge of educating children. DeVos and Moskowitz share the same values and concerns for children, as Moskowitz has truthfully stated many times.
And Joseph Belluck at the SUNY Charter Institute says those are exactly the values that should be taught to new educators. Joseph Belluck says that Eva Moskowitz demonstrates such perfect judgment in recognizing greatness in education that she must be given free reign to train her own teachers with no oversight.
Enough said about the fans of DeVos and how they are pervasive in the NY State charter world.
LikeLike
I watch some of them and you’re not missing anything.
It isn’t that she’s unqualified. Everyone knew that and she was hired for her ideological agenda anyway. The thing that sticks out is she’s been there a while and she has learned nothing. She really can’t find the time to brush up on the basic US laws that govern public schools?
The education secretary isn’t interested in learning anything. It doesn’t just make her look like a fool. It makes all of Congress look like fools. The hearings are a waste of time because she hasn’t bothered to prepare at all.
I would say “what kind of example does this set for students?” but there isn’t a public school student in this country who cares what they say at these things, and rightfully so, so it’s not like they’re looking there for role models anyway.
It’s as if they TRY to be completely irrelevant.
LikeLike
Chiara,
Everyone did not know she was unqualified. Eva Moskowitz knew she was very well qualified and was a terrific choice. I know this because she wrote op eds and gave interviews over and over again to tell America that DeVos was wonderful and very well qualified.
It’s that kind of good judgement about how much children need education leaders like Betsy DeVos that makes billionaires adore Eva Moskowitz. Her judgement is impeccable and her ability to recognize greatness in an education leader like Betsy DeVos is the main reason that she will be given carte blanche to train her own teachers with no oversight needed.
LikeLike
Tomorrow,BetsyDeVos & school safety commission will explore PBIS or Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports.
Someone who actually attended a US public school could tell them public schools have been doing this for at least 25 years. My kids all had it. It’s in place right now.
They probably miss these things because they are so focused on bashing public schools they cannot imagine that anything good happens in one.
LikeLike
“Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports”
I believe the correct acronym is BPISS.
A new supe adminimal came into the district and tried to have us implement the hyper-Skinnerian BPISS. It didn’t even make it out of the faculty committee of which I was a part.
A new supe adminimal came into the district after that other one and then attempted to force BPISS, can we say Pavlov’s Dog, onto the high school. We fought it tooth and nail. The students were saying things like, “Oh that’s the stuff they did to us when we were in 1st grade.” They rejected the concept from the start also.
Reward and punish, reward and punish, with an emphasis on the reward part, yeah stupid little tokens and certificates for just doing what a student should be doing. Ludicrous and risible are the nicest adjectives that I can use to describe that excrement of bovine origin malpractice.
LikeLike
And just this morning, a mere 4 miles from my home, Betsy Devos paid a visit to Frank Hebrin-Harmen ES in Anne Arundel Co, MD. She was there to learn about PBIS (a very failed experiment IMHO) and it’s impact on the learning environment. Harmen ES used to be a regular public ES but I believe it has become a sort of Charter school (it’s listed as IB PYP). This school sits about 1 mile from Ft Meade and is located among the numerous military housing in the area. Recently, AA Co announced that it would be expanding in the Charter school sector. I wonder what information she garnered from her visit and what was the real purpose of this visit? Finn and Smarick along with our teacher bashing, Governor Hogan were probably there to welcome her with open arms…. and open wallets (since it’s an election year for the Gov.). This woman always has a motive and it’s never to make public schools a better place for students and teachers.
LikeLike
The question is how much longer? How much longer can Devos continue this evasive me vs the world mentality? I have said it before and will say it again, devos has a pair of balls that I never knew she had.
I mean this woman can take a punch and then some as she has taken some big blows to the head from the public, social media, students at schools and colleges, media interviews, blogs around the country and yet this neophyte in education stands up there and gives some bogus verbal explanation – time after time – similar to a student who has no idea what he is saying or writing but they put it down or say it.
So again my question is how much longer can devos continue this evasive facade of bull crap that she is flinging to all of us including congress!!!! Eerie is the fact that trump does not mention devos not one single bit of mention. I guess a billion dollars goes a long way in the new America.
LikeLike
DeVos is the mistress of word salad. She can answer a question at length and say nothing at all. It is a carefully honed skill.
My guess is that she will be there as long as she wants because Trump loves her (unlike him, she really is a billionaire), and the Evangelicals love her, and she has paid off most of the Republicans in the Senate. She will stay until she gets bored.
LikeLike
Like every other Trump appointee, she will remain as long as she is an asset to Trump.
When she ceases to become an asset, she will leave. That could happen tomorrow or never. She will remain as long as Trump believes what she is doing will help him get whatever he wants (power or growing his businesses, or whatever).
LikeLike
For the very brave, find three hours of her testimony here, or scan the transcript. See who sucks up to her.
https://www.c-span.org/video/?445809-1/education-secretary-devos-testifies-agency-priorities&start=406
I am not certain if this is behind an instant paywall. https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2018/05/30/devos-deflects-criticism-at-capitol-hill-hearing.html
LikeLike
Dang. The Democrats are always the blame for something…first Trump blames them for children being taken away from their parents and now DeVos’s deregulatory power isn’t being stopped. Rotten bunch those Dems. [Sarcasm]
With Legislation Stalled, DeVos Moves to Wield Deregulatory Power…NYT
WASHINGTON — The top Republican on the Senate Education Committee effectively killed on Thursday all hope for a highly anticipated overhaul this year of the law governing the nation’s 4,000 colleges and universities, paving the way for Education Secretary Betsy DeVos to wield her deregulatory power.
The committee chairman, Senator Lamar Alexander of Tennessee, said at a New York Times education conference in New York that the Senate would not produce promised higher education legislation this year, and blamed Democrats for the delay…
LikeLike