E.J. Montini, opinion columnist for the Arizona Republic, explains how Governor Doug Ducey pulled a fast one on the teachers who thought they won a promise from him.
“An analysis by The Arizona Republic – based on the state auditor general’s numbers – indicates that 59 school districts wouldn’t get enough money under the law to give all of their teachers the promised raise.
“In other words, that 20 percent pay hike for all teachers was 100 percent bull.
“Sure, some teachers will get raises, but apparently not all of them and not at the level that was promised.
“In addition, the devastating education spending cuts made for years were not reversed. Support staff salaries were not guaranteed an increase. And there was no moratorium on tax cuts.
“If the RedForEd people want to accomplish their goals they’re going to have to do it on their own.
“With a ballot initiative.
“Perhaps it will be one that has been put forth by coalition of teachers, parents and education advocates led by the Center for Economic Progress.
“The plan, called the Invest in Education Act. would increase taxes for individuals earning more than $250,000 a year and couples earning more than $500,000.
“The wealthy prefer a sales tax
“A group of local CEOs, along with the Chamber of Commerce – people who earn that kind of money – would rather place the tax burden for education on our poorest brothers and sisters by boosting the sales tax.
“They’re prepared to spend a ton of money to fight the income tax proposal.
“(They’d rather do that, apparently, than put the money into public education.)”
They will need to collect 150,000 signatures by July 5 to get the proposition on the ballot. A number of groups and faith communities have offered their help. They say it is a moral issue.
“The protesting educators in the RedForEd movement tried to teach that lesson.
“The governor and Legislature failed the exam.
“They’re going to need a make-up test.”

Why are more taxes always the answer? Why isn’t reprioritizing the expenditure of existing revenues?
LikeLike
Because Republicans have spent the last 40 years insisting that lower taxes are the fix for everything, and have left the government (Federal, state, and local) starved for funds. It serves their purpose to lower collections then complain about how there is no money for whatever people are complaining about. At the Federal level Republicans are trying to save money by going after food stamp programs while at the same time lowering taxes on Apple so that it can spend 47 Billion$$ on a stock buyback. It’s insanity.
LikeLike
Actually, you are wrong. Receipts are higher than ever, but so is overall spending. I just don’t buy the argument that Republicans personify all that is evil in this world and that the Democrats have all the answers. We just went through hell with Arne Duncan/Obama in charge of federal education policies and in New York, where I live and teach, Cuomo and the Democratic Party controlled Assembly caved on APPR, testing and charter schools.
LikeLike
Actually, I’m not wrong about the reduction in education spending OR in overall tax receipts. Every one of the teacher strikes have happened in states that have both reduced education spending AND reduced state revenues over the past decades. Whether at the national level (last year’s tax bill that reduced taxes by more than a trillion dollars) or the state, tax collections have been reduced so that Republicans could turn around and say there is no money to do what people want done.
LikeLike
Fed Up Teacher
There are lessor of two evils and workers do not find out until it is too late . Would you rather be fighting Cuomo or Scott Walker. Let me know if you think Janus would happen in a Democratic court.
LikeLike
lesser
LikeLike
I’m guessing that is Arizona is anything like a lot of other states, there are plenty of perks built into the system for those who occupy the top economic rungs. It may be easier to take more directly out of their pockets than to unravel all the giveaways built into the budget. that is not to say that shouldn’t be done, but I’m guessing it would take much longer.
LikeLike
This is so sad after all the efforts the teachers made to effect change. The GOP legislature and the plutocrats have too much power. Hopefully, Arizonans can vote out the libertarian regressive cultists. There are many anti-union people in NJ who would love to duplicate the Arizona model, fortunately they are a minority.
LikeLike
Arizona wants to say clearly and loudly that teachers and public schools should not expect to be “favored” and that in the long run, parents who cannot afford eduction should just suck it up and do what they can. The Republicans and corporate interests seem to think this is just fine. The best solution is to get rid of the legislators responsible for this deceptive move.
LikeLike
The libertarians represent opposition to all common good. As DeVos repeats like a robot, I only see individuals. The one she sees best is her own reflection. The libertarians only believe in elevation of the self, and the poor, elderly and sick are viewed as not taking responsibility for themselves.
LikeLike
The Democrats are not all good, but given the conduct of GOP politicians lately, we are more than justified in voting against them in droves. The teachers’ have done a great job of seeking a fair pay and funding. It though, becomes apparent that we will have to take more interests in the actions of our representatives, and try to influence them as much as possible to pursue paths that are beneficial to all of us.
The education system is of the greatest importance to the nation and we need to make it crystal clear to politicians that they need to address the needs of the majority. We get a chance in November to address this at the polls so we must not forget.
LikeLike
Joe
West Virginia was a strong Democratic pro Union state a little over a decade ago.
LikeLike
There is hope. From Raw Story: A Republican state senator in West Virginia has lost re-election after opposing the state’s teacher strike and claiming the educators were holding children “hostage” in their protests for pay increases.
The Intercept reported Friday that state Sen. Robert Karnes was a longtime union opponent, and in March expressed pessimism about the political impact the largest teacher’s strike in the country would have. [snip]
Karnes was challenged in the state’s GOP primary by state Delegate Bill Hamilton, a rare Republican that sympathized with the teacher’s strike and opposes “right-to-work” laws. Unions responded financially, raising more than $10,000 for the state Senate race and making up a substantial portion of his total $53,850 raised for his campaign.
https://www.rawstory.com/2018/05/west-virginia-republican-mocked-striking-teachers-loses-re-election-thanks-teachers/
Let’s hope that Bill Hamilton isn’t lying and will deliver. Maybe in the general election the Democrat will be even better than Hamilton? I really don’t know that much about WV politics.
LikeLike
That’s great!
LikeLike
Joe
“In 2015, the president of the Racine school board tried to eliminate this provision. His effort narrowly failed, but the teachers were not so forgiving. The union recruited candidates for the nine school board seats and locked down eight of them in the next year’s election.”
LikeLike
What else can we expect from Koch clones … but manipulating lies?
LikeLike