Maurice Cunningham is a political science professor at the University of Massachusetts who has become an expert on the subject of Dark Money. He has his own name for the billionaires devoted to charter schools. He calls them the “Financial Privatization Cabal.” That’s clever and accurate but I stick with “corporate reformers” because there are fewer syllables.*
Cunningham (no relation to the charter-loving Peter of the same last name) has done a deep dive into the Dark Money funders of the 2016 campaign to expand charter schools in Massachusetts via a referendum called Question 2. A New York City organization called Families for Excellent Schools (FES) arrived on the scene to bundle and dispense Dark Money and renamed itself Great Schools Massachusetts. (FES was funded by the Waltons and has now been replaced by a new group which calls itself Massachusetts Parents United, also Walton funded.)
What is Dark Money? It is money given to political campaigns by donors whose identities are hidden. The donors do not want their names to be revealed. So they give to a group like “Families for Excellent Schools.” After the charter lobby lost in Massachusetts in 2016, beaten by a sturdy coalition of teachers, parents, and volunteers, the state’s Office of Campaign and Political Finance conducted an inquiry and fined FES for failing to disclose the names of its donors. The fine was $426,00, along with a five-year ban on future political activity in Massachusetts. Shortly thereafter, FES folded due to a #MeToo scandal involving its executive director.
Before it closed its doors, FES was required to reveal its donors. One of them was billionaire Seth Klarman.
Maurice Cunningham has checked out Klarman and found that he is one of the top donors to the Republican Party in New England. He doesn’t like Trump, so he recently gave $222,000 to the Democratic Party. That was front-page news in the Boston Globe.
Cunningham wonders why Klarman’s gift of $222,000 to the Democrats made the front page, but his gift of $3 Million to the pro-charter campaign in 2016 didn’t merit even a mention.
But then relentless Maurice Cunningham discovered this:
“Klarman also is a part owner of the Fenway Sports Group, the Boston Red Sox parent company that is led by principal owner John Henry. Henry is also owner and publisher of The Boston Globe.”
Blood is thicker than water. Money is thicker than blood or water.
It is way past time that I name Maurice Cunningham to the honor roll of this Blog for his indefatigable sleuthing and pursuit of Dark Money. As always: Follow the money.
PS: To learn more about Stand for Children as a conduit for Dark Money and about Strategic Grant Partners read this post by Cunningham.
*He explains:
“A NOTE ON TERMINOLOGY: I’ve failed to come up with a catchy name for the dark money funders so for now I’ve settled on “Financial Privatization Cabal.” Financial since most of the dark money is coming from the financial services industry. Privatization, because I believe their intention is to privatize public services. Cabal because it denotes a secret plot.”
See also Mercedes Schneider’s forensic work on how and why Eva of Success Academies has off the charts annual compensation and unbelievable compensation for five hours of work.
Reblogged this on NANMYKEL.COM and commented:
Blood is thicker than water. Money is thicker than blood or water….
Charter schools are the best evidence of the class war
Excellent sleuthing! Thank you, Maurice.
Cunningham was also criticized for using the term “dark money” by Keri Rodrigues, who heads up Massachusetts Parents United, a fake parent group funded by the same billionaires behind banned-in-MA Families for Excellent Schools.
Always the provocateur, Rodrigues, trying to deflect away from Cunningham’s pulling back of the curtain, claimed the term has racial overtones, so Cunningham has opted for Financial Privatization Cabal. Maybe we can crowd source a catchier phrase?
Obscured money?
Dark Money is the title of an excellent book by Jane Mayer.
I will stick with that.
Rodrigues is grasping at straws
Yep, that’s her MO. She’s a toxic attack dog who claims to represent Latino parents. It’s easy to ignore the wild claims she makes on her blog, but she’s got suction and regularly gets published in mainstream media, like CommonWealth Magazine. In this article, she goes after Lisa Guisbond of Citizens for Public Schools, and she has also attacked Monty Neill and FairTest. All the while, she claims the crown of social justice warrior.
https://commonwealthmagazine.org/opinion/testing-isnt-punishment-matter-social-justice/
The big news of the week of course, was the ruling by the MA Supreme Judicial Court that the cap on charters is constitutional. Coverage in the putative newspaper of record, The Boston Globe, sought to portray the decision as public schools and teachers hating on charters.
“The court fight escalated the long-running battle over charter schools, which are controversial because they do not have to be unionized, operate independently of local school districts, and are given more flexibility to set their curriculums, budgets, and staffing levels.”
https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2018/04/24/state-high-court-rejects-challenge-charter-school-cap/j6eoQGIp6JY2p0CxcZzLmO/story.html
Importantly, as Professor Cunningham points out, John Henry, The Globe’s owner and publisher, is Klarman’s business partner. Klarman, the billionaire hedge funder, contributed $3 million to the Yes on Question 2 faction. He also holds some $92 million in Puerto Rico’s debt, which bodes ill for the islanders as they face the impending, sweeping charterization of their public schools.
https://www.alternet.org/hedge-funder-puerto-rico-charter-schools
By contrast, Clive McFarlane, writing in the Worcester Telegram, unafflicted by allegiances among business partners, had this perspective:
“Mr. Nicolette (executive director of the Massachusetts Charter Public School Association) and other supporters will continue to point to the charter schools that are doing well, while highlighting the traditional public schools that are struggling.
But they won’t tell you about the attrition rates of students attending charter schools, that the top 11 and 17 of the top 20 schools statewide with the highest attrition rates are charter schools.
They won’t tell you that the top seven schools with the highest dropout rates (ranging from 21 percent to 54 percent) in the state are charter schools.
They won’t tell you that the top nine schools in the state with the highest churn rate (the percent of students leaving and arriving during the school year) are charter schools.”
http://www.telegram.com/news/20180425/clive-mcfarlane-states-high-court-rejects-argument-for-lifting-cap-on-charter-schools
The interests of the elite make it clear that though decisive victories against the charter industry have been won, the proponents are not about to walk away.
So, though we’ve won three times in the struggle to keep our “best in the nation” public schools here in Massachusetts, don’t count the charteristas out. Seems there’s a lot of money riding on them.
Thanks for you excellent tracking of the mischief in Massachusetts.
Thank you, Laura! Mischief in Massachusetts sounds like a grea book title.
“But they won’t tell you about the attrition rates of students attending charter schools, that the top 11 and 17 of the top 20 schools statewide with the highest attrition rates are charter schools.”
That is such an important statistic! Thank you for posting it.
I wonder if the charters with the best performance also had some of the highest attrition rates. That’s an anomaly that seems unique to charters — the public schools with excellent test scores don’t have scores of students leaving. But oddly, the charters often do.
I wonder how many of the names that belong to the Financial Privatization Cabal are also members of the Kochtapus founded by Charles and David Koch, the same group that Betsy DeVos belongs to.
I appreciate the accuracy of the term financial privatization cabal. Sometimes I call them corporate reformers because they are reforming their yacht, jet, and mansion collections. They can be called Wall Street and/or Silicon Valley. Some of them are Big Oil and/or the Kochtopus. Usually, I just call them what Bernie Sanders does, billionaires. There are billionaires and those who take billionaires’ money in exchange for harming their neighbors.
To Laura & Christine above: & we in Chicago are writing a book titled, “Chicanery in Chicago.” (Not yet, but someone should!)
On a roll. This could be a winner, coast to coast. And it could be a song.
Love it! Just waiting now for SomeDAM to but it all into poetry.
marybeth
Boston: Billionaire Seth Klarman, Charter Love, and Dark Money | Diane Ravitch's blog