Tongue planted firmly in cheek, John Merrow questioned Rick Hess’s anguished post about the failure of reform in D.C. under Michelle Rhee and her deputy Kaya Henderson. Hess admitted that “reformers” circled the wagons and refused to listen to naysayers, but he blamed the naysayers for being critical of the fraud and the coverup.
John Merrow spent many hours covering Michelle Rhee as the PBS education correspondent, and it was only at the end of her reign of error that the scales fell from his eyes. But fall they did, and he has since documented the depth of the flimflam that Rhee, Henderson, and their enablers perpetrated.
When Merrow read Hess’ apologia, he reached for the phone to question Rick, but Rick was on a national speaking tour.
The phone at the American Enterprise Institute was answered, Merrow said, by a woman with a French accent.
“I told the young woman that I had the press release in my hand and had hoped to talk with him before he left. I asked her whether he was going to apologize for being wrong about the so-called ‘school reforms’ in Washington, DC?
“Mais non. Monsieur Hess is going to be explaining why everyone of importance got it wrong about Washington. And zen he will explain how to get it right.”
“Hearing that upset me. I told her that a lot of us, including USA Today, Guy Brandenburg, Diane Ravitch, Mary Levy, the Washington City Paper, local politician Mark Simon, and me, got it right about DC. I told her that we have been saying for years that Michelle Rhee and Kaya Henderson were perpetrating a fraud.
“Zen, monsieur,” she said with a provocative giggle, “You must not be of importance, because Monsieur Rick explained it to me very clearly.”
“Tell me about the tour, I said. I see from the press release that The Four Seasons is the tour’s official hotel, NetJet the official airline, and Uber the official means of transportation. Will Rick be visiting schools?
“Oh, I don’t zink so,” she said. “Monsieur Rick, he does not like to be with noisy children. He prefers to talk to old people in auditoriums.”
“Will anyone else be appearing with Rick, I wanted to know? After all, lots of important people were wrong about DC: Arne Duncan, Checker Finn, Richard Whitmire, Campbell Brown, Katherine Bradley, Tom Toch, Andy Rotherham, Mike Petrilli, Whitney Tilson, Kati Haycock, the Washington Post, some major foundations, and others.”
Merrow is a notorious trickster. I suddenly remembered his resignation letter, when he announced that he was leaving PBS to join the board of Pearson. Or was that his April Fools’ letter?

“I asked her whether he was going to apologize for being wrong about the so-called ‘school reforms’ in Washington, DC?”
Hmm. Odd, I’m still waiting for a similar apology from Merrow himself.
LikeLike
This was a very weird column by Merrow.
LikeLike
“Listening to her, every part of my body sprang to attention, if you get my drift.”
Assuming I’m drifting in the right direction, I think that’s really inappropriate, especially in the MeToo age.
LikeLike
“I told her that a lot of us, including … and me, got it right about DC.”
Merrow owes me for a new computer monitor. I spit my tea out reading that. Does he mean before or after he allowed Michelle Rhee to fire a principal on air?
LikeLike
I’m as frustrated by his hypocrisy as you are, Dienne, but it’s still a good sign when these privateers and their shills turn on each other.
Merrow has no integrity, but he clearly has a sensitive political antennae, and uses it to advance his reputation as a journalist. That he now finds it to his benefit to attack the so-called reformers he once carried water for is probably a sign of the shifting political narrative about education.
LikeLike
This is why the progressives can’t win. Merrow — like Diane Ravitch — was misinformed and believed that reformers actually wanted to really help schools be better. Diane realized that wasn’t the case long before Merrow did. But Merrow realized it and changed his reporting to reflect the facts as they were made clear to him.
If that isn’t “integrity”, then your definition of integrity is that of a cynic.
I only wish Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren showed as much integrity as John Merrow. I am still waiting for either of then to change their mind and stop supporting the reform movement and calling it out for what it is.
And do you know what? When Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren start doing what John Merrow does and recognizing their ill-advised support for the reform movement was wrong, I won’t ask for an apology for them. I will be grateful to them and assume that they have finally seen the light. Maybe you can attack them as frauds until they apologize for their wrong-headedness. I won’t.
LikeLike
Merrow didn’t make the firing of a principal happen. He observed and recorded that vicious act. Rhee was proud of what she had done. That was one of the most disgusting acts I have ever witnessed. I’m glad he filmed it.
LikeLike
The recording and broadcasting was itself a vicious act. Getting fired is one of the worst moments in a person’s life. Would you want that broadcast on national television?
In any case, Merrow didn’t broadcast it with the subtext of “look how evil this woman is”. He broadcast it with his stamp of approval – Michell Rhee was cleaning house and that was a good thing. I remember that episode vividly. I was sick to my stomach.
LikeLike
I clearly remembering hearing about Michelle Rhee for the first time while I was cooking supper for my tribe after a long school day. In my distraction, I nearly burned the meal as Merrow’s melodious voice crooned his approval for Mayor Fenty’s out-of-the-box choice of a TFA’er to run DC’s schools. Good thing my kids were old enough to hear mumma swear.
LikeLike
LOL. My kids were not old enough for that, but fortunately they were young enough to be in bed. I think I was uttering some of the same words as you.
LikeLike
Seriously, though, this is what I admire about you, Diane. You used to be on the other side, and have frankly and repeatedly admitted you were wrong. I wish some of your integrity would rub off on folks like Merrow.
LikeLike
A life lesson. When you are wrong, say so. When you make a mistake, apologize.
Now that the NAEP scores reveal the blanket called Reform, let’s see how many admit they were wrong. My guess: none.
LikeLike
I wish Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders would admit they were wrong and start fighting for the right things like John Merrow does.
I don’t care whether they apologize. I just want to start supporting PUBLIC education instead of lending their progressive credibility to those politicians who are happy to privatize it. Giving shout outs to “good” charters without recognizing what “good” means. (Hint: it means you have abandoned the most vulnerable kids.)
Seriously, if Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren started fighting FOR public education, I would not spit out my coffee or say that they are phonies because they used to be reformers. I don’t care if they apologize.
I just want them to fight for the right things the way John Merrow does. I will happily settle for that over any apology from Warren and Sanders. Unfortunately, I’m still waiting for them to start fighting for the right things, period. But if they do, I won’t attack them for not apologizing enough to satisfy my need to punish them for their helping the reformers do their dirty work for so many years.
LikeLike
I don’t know about anyone else but as a confirmed introvert, I could catalogue innumerable times during my “adult” life when my beliefs or actions are an embarrassment to me now. I have no intention of sharing most of them. Merrow is in a profession where it all hangs out. How long does he have to pay for his previous support for reformsters before he is judged as pure enough to be allowed to utter progressive ideas?
LikeLike
Thank you – I agree.
John Merrow is terrible and dishonest because he hasn’t sufficiently apologized. And at least Betsy DeVos is “honest” about her agenda.
There is something off about some of the people who post here. If you talk about all the terrible things Betsy DeVos does, those people immediately post “at least she is honest” (!!??). If you post about John Merrow they say “but he hasn’t sufficiently apologized and the fact that he has spent the last 2 or 3 years reporting on the hypocrisies of the reformers is not enough.”
It’s almost as if they are trying to undermine public education. Attack and undermine the friends of public education as being fake and corrupt. And insist that the enemies are “honest” even though they are not honest at all.
That’s what brought us Trump. And a Republican House and Senate.
People who insist that Betsy DeVos is honest about her agenda. She is not.
LikeLike
Merrow lent his voice in favor of the reformistas on arguably the most trusted platform in the media, public television, where he had a recurrent segment on The News Hour, as the education reporter. He was in a position to do a lot of damage.
Warren has joined fight against charters. We educated and turned her during the Question 2 battle to eliminate the charter cap in MA in November of 2016. She held her town hall last week at the Boston Teachers Union headquarters, where she praised the public schools which accept all students. Perhaps her TFA paid staffer has moved on?
LikeLike
I am attending a fundraiser for Warren in a week or so and will learn more. She’s running and she needs teachers.
LikeLike
Warren supported the charter cap — but she did it late. And as far as I saw, she made no public statement during that campaign in which she said there were enough charters, period and that her support to keep the cap wasn’t just temporary. I just saw her repeating the talking points about “good charters” but now isn’t the time to expand. She reinforced the notion that charters were doing something special.
Cuomo also met with teachers unions and then turned around and made sure charters got disproportionate resources.
Diane, I would be so grateful if you ask Sen. Warren whether she supports the NAACP moratorium on charters. I suspect she does not.
And when she explains why she does not, I expect she will offer a lot of pablum about the “good” charters that need to flourish.
And then I hope you will ask Elizabeth Warren why a charter can’t flourish if they are PART of the public education system instead of separate and run by private non-profits with separate oversight and separate rules and lack of transparency?
I find it amazing that people attack John Merrow while giving Elizabeth Warren a pass.
And if Sen. Warren surprises me by saying she agrees with the NAACP moratorium and won’t pretend there are “good” charters that can only exist if private groups are allowed to run them with no transparency or local oversight, then I will NOT be demanding that she offer an apology for all her support for them for so many years.
I will just be glad she has finally changed her mind.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Nonpartisan Education Group.
LikeLike