Apparently there are places in the U.S. that never heard of the First Amendment and its guarantee of freedom of speech. Vermillion Parish in Louisiana is one of them. A teacher was arrested for speaking out against the renewal of the superintendent’s contract. Probably, if she were a parent, no one would have touched her. But she was a teacher and she was treated like dirt.
I hope the NEA, the AFT, the ACLU, or some other group hires a lawyer for her.
“The Vermilion Parish School Board is comprised of eight members. For the better part of two years, four members were in favor of renewing Puyau’s contract and four were against. On November 20th of last year, one of the board members against the contract renewal, Luddy Herpin, passed away. The board president, Anthony Fontana, took advantage of the situation and brought an interim member who would support the contract before the board for approval to fill the seat until an election can be held. The appointment passed with a 4/3 vote.
“On January 8, 2018, the board held a special meeting to vote on the contract renewal and provide Puyau with a $38,000 raise. The teachers of Vermilion Parish filled the room in opposition. The teachers of this parish have not received a raise in ten years. Puyau was hired as superintendent in 2012; however, the district has maintained a rating of B, or above, since the inception of the school grading system.
“One of the teachers present, Deyshia Hargrave, was given permission to speak to the board on the issue. After she finished speaking, she sat down. Chatter and protests could be heard among the board members and the attendees. At some point, President Fontana addresses Hargrave, who is seated to his right, directly. She stands to respond. Fontana is distracted by the increased chatter to his left and comments to the effect that things are getting out of hand. At that exact moment, the City Marshall officer on duty enters the room. Seeing Hargrave standing and speaking, he approaches her and asks her to leave. In disbelief that she is being asked to leave while responding to a question directed at her, Hargrave initially resists. After realizing what is going on, she walks out of the room, and into the hallway, with the officer where he pushes her to the floor and handcuffs her.
“Meanwhile, this publicly elected board sits quietly and allows this to happen not only to a taxpaying citizen engaged in a public meeting, but a teacher employed in their district who is calmly explaining why the raise is opposed.”

I’m glad you posted this. I hope she sues them and gets a huge judgment.
LikeLike
Here’s the video. It gives the full context. When she starts screaming in hallway, the camera is in the meeting room, capturing the audience’s in-the-moment reactions, then guy shooting it hurriedly rushes to the hallway to capture the continuing drama:
Go to about 6:55 for the last part of her speech, just before the cop comes in the shot:
LikeLike
No charges against teacher
http://www.katc.com/story/37220702/teacher-who-was-removed-from-vermilion-school-board-meeting-in-handcuffs-booked-into-jail
LikeLike
Charges were not pressed by the school board, but charges were pressed by the city marshall who was the arresting officer.
LikeLike
No charges????? She was removed to silence her. She should bring the charges! I hope the ACLU is on this.
LikeLike
Ms Hargrave is a parent. Louisiana Association for Educators is involved. She is not the first female that got thrown out
LikeLike
I’m going to guess that Deyshia is black or other minority. I’m sure that’s part of the equation.
LikeLike
Your guessing is not pertinent to this situation. Watch the video so your contribution in forum is at least aligned with what did occur. If you can’t follow this link then just google Vermilion Parish School Board Louisiana. Local television was there and recorded over 15 min. Various media have cut the video to smaller portions and included in their posts. Nobody has to randomly guess and then claim to be sure of an equation without actual factors for the equation. Do some math homework.
LikeLike
It so happens that the teacher is white, the arresting Marshall is black. I watched the video.
LikeLike
Ah, so Police State behavior is color blind, in this case at least. That’s consoling.
LikeLike
‘Slate columnist Jamelle Bouie summed up the research well when he wrote, “Just because an officer is black … doesn’t mean he’s less likely to use violence against black citizens.”’ …
“Black law enforcement officers have long faced this additional challenge. It boils down to a police culture that demands loyalty to blue over black. When Chicago police officer Renault Robinson formed the Afro-American Patrolmen’s League in 1968, he met unrelenting hostility from his mostly white supervisors and colleagues, culminating in anonymous phone calls threatening his wife and children. Robinson pressed onward, but others decided the price of resistance was too high. Glover acknowledged that the code of silence remains an obstacle for black officers today.”
https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/policing/2017/06/09/police-blacks-policing-the-usa-force-king/102608512/
LikeLike
The arrested teacher is white.
LikeLike
Lol. Racist bigots. She’s white.
LikeLike
Nope. she is white. https://youtu.be/8sg8lY-leE8
LikeLike
In this case, color is not or should not be an issue. This boils down to a violation of the First Amendment. This is what separates the USA from China, Mexico, and Russia. At least it’s supposed to.
This teacher followed the rules and was violated and oppressed. She should sue, and the ACLU should jump in. The officer should be stripped of his badge AND pension!
LikeLike
dienne — well, you got the [implied] oppressed part right — which in this case could be teachers, or women – parhaps even parents, taxpayers.
LikeLike
“I’m going to guess that Deyshia is black or other minority. I’m sure that’s part of the equation.”
She was white. The officer was black.
Tell us more about your equation, Miss Math Professor.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education and commented:
Wow…The end result will be interesting
LikeLike
I will be sharing this on social media and hope others do the same.
LikeLike
I have looked at several of the local tv and news posts. In one there is a woman named Laurie LeBlanc who appears to have a name tag so is possibly a board member or maybe designated PTA rep. Not sure of her position. But there is a very brief clip in which she is admonishing someone (board?) for the treatment of women and remarking about the poor treatment of women in the meetings and that she’s never seen men treated as she witness with Ms. Hargrave. I was glad to see a community member make that remark right there in that forum where all had just witnessed. In my not at all humble opinion this is exibit 1 of how the patriarchy keeps teachers/females in lockstep. Ms. Hargraves presented complaint about the teachers not getting raises for years and then the supt. renew gives him a big raise. She may have included some items as questions but majority of her talk was commentary as was appropriate. I don’t see Alex Trebec on the board clarifying what’s a question and what is commentary. I don’t think it was the question format. It was the topic that brings into the open that this man’s pay is being advanced as his contract is renewed but teachers (mainly women) are not getting raises in their contracts. I think they made wise decision to not press charges on her. I do hope she will press charges on them. She complied with leaving. If she was going to be pushed to floor and cuffed she may as well have stayed in the room to be “put in her place”. Glad the camera followed her. I think it was an Abbeville tv station but not certain. Hopefully they will have assist from affiliates to further cover this story. It should go viral. The patriarchy is out of control in Kaplan LA. I hope to see Laurie LeBlanc again because she called it out immediately.
LikeLike
I may have copied the wrong name. One of the tv reports I saw placed the name Laurie LeBlanc on the screen as a woman admonished the board for its treatment of women. I just looked at a NYT entry on this matter and they show a Laura LeBeouf as a board member was displeased with the situation. I found a facebook page for a Laura LeBeouf but nothing for a Laurie LeBlanc so I may have posted incorrect info in comment above. Ms. LeBeouf’s profile on facebook indicates that she is a stakeholder in the community. NYT write up gave me hope that someone on this board has the best interest of the community in mind. I was disappointed to see in the NYT article that Ms Hargrave did get taken to the Abbeville police station and was booked.
LikeLike
I am unsure of the person’s name, but I saw the clip, and the person in the clip is a school board member.
LikeLike
Laura Lebeouf and Sara Duplechain, both sb members, did admonish the behavior of the sb president, Anthony Fontana.
LikeLike
Two of the school board members are permanently disabled. They could not have stood to stop it.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Politicians Are Poody Heads and commented:
The “good old boys” network once again takes care of one of their own, while silencing the teacher with a legitimate statement to make.
LikeLike
Really bad news. I agree that she should have a lot of pro bono legal support in a lawsuit against the offenders on the board and the police officer who followed someone’s orders to take her out and arrest her….for exercising her free speech rights in a public meeting. Thank goodness this was captured on video.
LikeLike
In James Lee Burke’s latest novel, “Robicheaux”, the author describes Louisiana through his main character.
“The law in Lousiana was never intended to be enforced. Its purpose was to provide a vague guideline that made people feel respectable. … Louisiana is not a state; it’s an outdoor mental asylum in which millions of people stay bombed most of their lives. That’s not an exaggeration. Cirrhosis is a family heirloom.” — page 200 in the hardcover
I think the author knows what he was saying.
“James Lee Burke was born in Houston, Texas, in 1936 and grew up on the Texas-Louisiana Gulf Coast. He attended Southwestern Louisiana Institute and later received a B.A. Degree in English, and an M.A. from the University of Missouri in 1958, and 1960 respectively. Over the years he worked as a Landman for Sinclair Oil Company, Pipeliner, Land Surveyor, Newspaper Reporter, College English Professor, Social Worker on Skid Row in Los Angeles, Clerk for the Louisiana Employment Service, and Instructor in the U.S. Job Corps.” …
“Today, He and his Wife live in Missoula, Montana, and New Iberia, Louisiana.”
http://www.jamesleeburke.com/about-the-author/
LikeLike
A.J. Liebling described Louisiana as “the westernmost of the Arab states” and “delightfully Middle Eastern.” This is probably the most accurate description of the state I’ve ever read. Vermillion Parish is in the center southern part of the state on the Gulf Coast, solidly in Cajun country, one of the three states within the state, the other two being New Orleans and north Louisiana, which is not different than most of the rest of the Deep South.
LikeLike
Really shocking and disgusting. Deyshia Hargrave is an incredibly brave and gutsy woman to take on the school board and superintendent. That display of police brutality will certainly send a message to the other teachers. How dare the teacher challenge a hefty pay raise for the superintendent while teachers get no raises for years and teach in overcrowded classrooms. Are there any teacher unions left in Louisiana? Do the teachers even have tenure?
LikeLike
I hope she sues as her comments were not the least bit inappropriate. She was arrested for making a legitimate comment. The video is a perfect example of the mistreatment many women face in patrimonial societies, and the type of treatment teachers are facing in many communities.
LikeLike
Thank you for sharing, Diane. a link to the original blog is below.
LikeLike
Thank you for sharing, Diane.
LikeLike
Shocking. I actually phoned Vermillion, took awhile to get through. For me to take such a step is a high bar but this is just so far beyond the pale, it’s hard to comprehend. That teacher was polite, articulate, controlled, accurate – I could not have behaved a fraction as well as she. In response she was met with disdain, criminality, aggression, violence — all in the presence of her students no less.
This is so far beyond a “bad look”, it’s just hard to really grok. I used to love reading science fiction in HS when the world was sort of shiny and full of possibility good and bad. Now, you can just view the outrage in real time on youtube. It’s not shiny, it’s shocking.
We did this to ourselves, it’s our democracy. Why is this stuff being allowed to persist?
LikeLike
kjlffe
LikeLike
Sorry… Here’s another teacher whom they took away in handcuffs in LA> and he is still fighting a decade later.
http://www.perdaily.com/2010/02/yesterday-i-was-removed-from-class-in-handcuffs.html
because he blew the whistle on corruption and the social promotion debacle in LAUSD.
Fabricated charges emptied the LA schools. 10,000 teachers charged on year alone …ALL fired!
http://www.perdaily.com/2013/10/why-does-utla-continue-to-support-lausds-violation-of-california-teacher-dismissal-process.html
So, begin your trip through the 15,880 with LAUSD, and then take a look at what happened to the FIRST largest of almost sixteen thousand school districts…nYC… get a cup of coffee and watch “The Inconvenient Truth About Waiting For Superman.
https://vimeo.com/419947609
LikeLike
Leaders of Ms. Hargrave’s professional association, the Louisiana Association of Educators, were informed of the situation shortly after the incident occurred. The legal team has been working with her on next steps since Monday (1/8) evening.
As an organization that advocates for the dedicated school employees of Louisiana, we firmly denounce the mistreatment of Ms. Hargrave, a loving parent and dedicated teacher serving the students of Vermilion Parish. It is every citizen’s right to speak up for their beliefs. Any action that infringes upon this right is unlawful and unacceptable.
We will continue to support the right of every single school employee to take an interest in, and ultimately stand up for, the best interests of their schools and their students.
LikeLike
Recognizing that it is every citizen’s right to speak at a public meeting, the professional association should be taking legal action that includes a public apology to this employee and the community.
LikeLike
This is not a black/white thing. It’s about the board ignoring & notwanting to be questioned by parents or teachers! This is happening all over Louisiana!!
LikeLike
Thank you, NBC Nightly News, for broadcasting this story on your national evening news. I hope this case gets the attention it deserves.
LikeLike
Big lawsuit. Should come out of the pockets of the board members responsible and the arresting officers
LikeLike
I called congressman Higgins n ask him to look into this
I couldn’t believe this was happening
U could expect this in a third world country
Maybe North Korea or china but la
Unbelievable
LikeLike
It’s not unbelievable in a Trumpist America. The handwriting has been on the wall for decades warning the American people that the Republican Party, no matter what it writes and says, is moving the country toward a bleak future where the only people that count are the super wealthy and corporations that are now legally considered individuals.
The first shot came when President Nixon was in the White House. Then President Reagan fired an entire volley as he lowered taxes and went crazy with spending sending the national debt climbing like a rocket on the way to the moon. The first Bush continued on that course and the 2nd Bush started two wars, one of them based on lies, and added even more to the national debt.
The loudest warning came when the conservative-leaning Supreme Court voted to support Citizens United Ruling ending the legislation from 2001 to control campaign spending.
“The justices’ ruling said political spending is protected under the First Amendment, meaning corporations and unions could spend unlimited amounts of money (but unions don’t have the deep pockets of billionaires and corporations) on political activities, as long as it was done independently of a party or candidate.”
The 2nd loudest shout was when the GOP refused to allow a vote on Obama’s choice for an empty seat on the U.S. Supreme Court and let almost an entire year go by as the GOP gambled (but maybe it wasn’t’ a gamble … maybe they knew their guy would win the White House in 2016 because the election was rigged in the GOP’s favor) that their candidate would win the White House and nominate an extremist that was a theocratic nightmare to sit on the Supreme Court.
That nightmare’s name is Neil Gorsuch who has a long history of ruling against workers, women, and regulation (like for the environment).
https://ru-clip.com/video/g4vEEVJccJQ/neil-gorsuch-trump-scotus-pick-has-history-of-ruling-against-workers-women-regulation.html
LikeLike
There is an underlying factor that is more troubling: the increased use of police personnel to monitor schools… and now democratic assemblies. https://wp.me/p25b7q-22v
LikeLike
I have noted that at our meetings presented by state in assorted schools in last several years to deliver information about highway construction there have been officers on hand. State police. They linger around the lobby as folks arrive. We sign into a roster then proceed into auditorium or gym. Once the group is assembled some of the officers come in and observe. ALL of them are in the room when public response takes place. I have encountered other citizens at these events who annoy me, seem to think I am there to hear their personal opinion and even stand in front of me blocking my view of speakers. One guy wanted to tell me the entire history of all the streets in the county, many of which I traveled daily in childhood and I explained I was present to hear future plans not past road history. So, I would not mind at all if officers would walk the aisles asking those interfering with my ability to pay attention to be seated and listen. But it seems they are there to intervene with the potential of a member of audience interferring with presentors. After half dozen of the highway meetings I feel certain that some folks go to those meeting just to agitate and get attention. I have yet to witness anything more than annoying but some speakers do get into finger pointing, angry gestures, spittle out the mouth and stomping. So……maybe the police presence is proactive? I read this post and it does concern me. The canine officers in my district have frightened me a few times when I park in visitor spot beside patrol car and don’t realize they are napping inside and suddenly face to face with snarling German Shepard angry that I have invaded his space. Of course one is always on camera on school grounds and officers monitoring.In the situation with this teacher and board I am glad the activity was being filmed. Not so happy with the police intervention and board leadership.
LikeLike
Teachers and all educators need to do a national walk out of all schools in all states. We need to rise above and send a hard message to the public in general about educators and the issues against us. We need tough, ruthless people to start kicking some butt as this is unfortunate becoming necessary. We need to drag around one of these politicians like Khadafy was dragged around by a pick up truck. This is what needs to happen to make up for all the dragging of our people boy i would love to see a poitician dragged out by their neck.
LikeLike
I saw this on the ABC News w/David Muir 2 nights in a row–they showed clips on Tuesday w/comments & did a follow-up Wednesday, rebroadcasting clips (w/a longer one of her speaking there), then the cuffing & arrest, then a new one, where the school board president said…get this!…”It was the teacher’s fault.”* (that she was cuffed & arrested!) Oh–& there was also one where she was interviewed & stood her ground.
Muir then explained that the teacher’s union was defending her & holding a rally. The news program cast the teacher in a very positive light, & the school board (specifically the president) negatively. Kudos for REAL news, reporting the TRUTH.
*Yep, once again that explanation for everything, “It was the teacher’s fault.” !!!
LikeLike
The part of this that is most appalling is not that she was removed, or handcuffed. It is that no board member took notice or spoke up while it was happening. Ms. LeBoef decried the action after the fact, but what did she do to prevent it or call attention to the disgrace in progress?
LikeLike
It starts small, http://www.fno.org/apr02/leaderreview.html. Usually they don’t arrest us, defamatory references, blacklisting, exploiting students to get even with teachers they “don’t like”
My home district tried to find a way to accuse me of criminal things for years, it’s been awful. I’ve been dodging bullets for nearly 20 years, not always successfully, but I can still write, even if it’s been hard to keep a job in teaching.
LikeLike
2 of those school board members are physically disabled. I doubt if they could have done anything to help Mrs. Hargrave although each one of them have condemned the action.
LikeLike