I spoke to the California School Boards Association yesterday, at its annual meeting in San Diego. I love San Diego. It is on the ocean and always beautiful, with a temperate climate. I had dinner the night before I spoke, with Cindy Marten, the superintendent of the San Diego district. As in the past, we had dinner at Miguel’s in Old Town. The one thing I have never been able to find in NYC is good Mexican food. When I first moved to NYC in 1960, after marrying a Native New Yorker, a friend told me that Texans in the city were always looking for Mexican food and always disappointed. In San Diego, I am never disappointed.
I spoke to a very large and friendly audience at the Convention Center. A few thousand people. I didn’t see any empty seats. When the video is released, I will post it. I was preceded by Marshall Tuck, who is running for State Superintendent and sure to have the support of the charter industry. We spoke in the Green Room, and he assured me that he would lead the fight to ban for-profit charters. The charter industry in the state is unregulated and unaccountable.
In my speech, I went through the history of NCLB and Race to the Top, and the damage they have done to students, teachers, and public schools. I then dissected the negative impacts of standardized testing and its utter uselessness as currently implemented. I pointed out that the achievement gap can never be closed with standardized tests because they are designed on a bell curve, and the bell curve never closes.
I then ticked off the many charter scandals in the state, the inevitable result of a total absence of supervision. I listed scam after scam. I reiterated the conclusions and recommendations of the NAACP report on charters.
My theme was the relationship between public schools, citizenship, and democracy.
When I concluded, I received a standing ovation.
Later, I was sitting in the lobby, waiting to meet a friend from Los Angeles and chatting with people who had heard me speak. One woman stepped up and said, “I walked out on your speech. It was too political. There’s no room for politics her.” She turned on her heel and left. I happened to be sitting with another member of the same school board, and I asked him, “What did she find ‘too political?’”
He said, “She’s a Trump supporter. You mentioned Trump in your opening remarks.”
That was true. I started by mentioning that Trump wants to cut federal funds for education by 13%, and he wants to shift $20 Billion to charters and vouchers.” These are factual statements. But the board member objected and walked out.
I can accept that people disagree. What I find hard to understand is an unwillingness to face plain and incontrovertible facts.
Anyway, I’m writing this on the airplane home. The CSBA was incredibly gracious. I met hundreds of people who are passionate about public schools. I’m looking to them to carry on the fight for better schools in their communities and at the ballot box.

Keep traveling and speaking everywhere and anywhere you can, which is not an easy task but valuable to keep the door from slamming shut.
LikeLike
Ira, this was one of my last tours. By June, I’m hanging up my traveling shoes.
LikeLike
But still ever present, Diane!
LikeLike
Wonder if she realized that “There’s no room for politics here” is a political statement. And if she was an elected school board member, the irony likely went right over her head. Let’s hope you converted some folks out there!
LikeLike
LikeLike
Thank you for bringing facts to the discussion of public education. There are so many “tall tales” floating around privatizers. I am encouraged by the overwhelming response you received. Everyone must back up rhetoric with activism, and I hope the crowd is inspired to fight for public education.
LikeLike
Great report about reaching a large audience in San Diego. I miss LaJolla where one of my sons, now 44, was born. You are amazing. He later got an MBA at Stamford and works in blockchain in NYC now..Do you know blockchain? Next thing after sliced bread and zipper and toilet.
LikeLike
I don’t know blockchain. What is it?
LikeLike
What is it? Good luck. The link below is supposed to be a blockchain explainer. it is marketed as if a cure for issues of privacy, especially in financial transactions, because those transactions are recorded on a “distributed ledger” and confirmed by a process that is supposed to be more trustworthy and difficult to hack than conventional banking. There is money to be made, and that is how blockchain and bitcoin have been ushered into the news. The techies in education are enchanted.
At https://www.cbinsights.com/research/what-is-blockchain-technology/?utm_source=CB+Insights+Newsletter&utm_campaign=dd19705164-FriNL_12_1_2017&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_9dc0513989-dd19705164-88273249
LikeLike
Diane,
I’m disappointed that the woman who accosted you didn’t offer any alternative facts to counter your inconvenient mention of -13% and stiffing public education for $20,000,000,000 to fund FAILING charters and voucher programs.
What part of “All education is politics” does she not understand? All of it, I suppose.
LikeLike
Bill, it is something I have noticed about Trump’s most zealous supporters. They idolize him. As he said, he could shoot someone in the middle of a Fifth Avenue, and his fans wouldn’t care. It is a phenomenon.
LikeLike
It is a cult. A cult build on racism, resentment, and irrationality.
LikeLike
Thank you for coming out and speaking to CSBA. I’m glad they were a good audience and I hope they really soaked in what you were sharing. I’m going to follow-up and see if any of my board members were there. I look forward to your video and passing it on. I teach in the more conservative Central San Joaquin Valley and private charters are headed here next.
LikeLike
Sadly, it is IGNORANCE that will destroy us and the Oligarchs who run this nation know this.
I posted this today at OEN as a comment about the tax bill’s hidden destruction of the schools.
The real destruction in America. The GOP wins when the schools go down.
“The destruction of the distinction between truth and falsehood is the foundation of dictatorship.” Oddly enough that wonderful truth, appeared in an article about Myanmar, where Emma Larkin speaks to a historian, Tin Tin Lay, who says:”There is no history in Burma any more. You can look in the school books and the libraries. You will not find it. We are a country without a history — without a truthful history.”
soon, THERE WILL BE NO NISTORY HERE, DIANE, to inform our ignorant citizens–
if the oligarchs continue to control the Congress and creates the conditions for the destructions of the schools. The hidden attack on the schools will end everything. AsE.D Hirsch says , there is no democracy without shared knowledge. http://www.aft.org/sites/default/files/periodicals/hirsch.pdf
The GOP wants to destroy what we know about our CONSTITUTION, and its separation of ‘church and state’.
Provisions like this one were put into the tax bill behind closed doors; Sahil Kapur, the national political reporter for Bloomberg News, found one provision in the bill that is both shockingly narrow in its target and amazingly corrupt in its intent.
“The narrowness of the tax loophole shows the lengths to which the GOP will go to get their “wealth transfer to billionaires” passed. P. 289 has a provision by Sen. Toomey to create an exemption from the university endowment tax — the exemption appears to apply only to Hillsdale, a conservative college the DeVos family supports.””The bill would apply to any university that forgoes Title IV funding — the program that offers federal financial aid to students. The acceptance of Title IV funds requires the universities to follow a set of government regulations that include things like banning discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation and rules for how to respond to allegations of sexual assault.”
There are so many amendments in the tax bill that will hurt our Public education system, but the worst outcome is that with no money coming in to pay for the budget, thanks to the windfall for the corporations, the states will be on austerity budgets, and the first thing they cut, is for public education.
LikeLike
Susan,
You are right on many levels. States will cut public education. Congress—as long as it is controlled by Koch and DeVos puppets—will cut Medicare and Social Security to make up for revenue losses caused by this Tax Scam.
LikeLike
Do you have any substantive information or evidence, that states will cut funding for public education, as a result of this tax bill? How many states, and which states, will be cutting, and by how much?
LikeLike
Anyone who is still a Trump supporter will think anything that criticizes Trump is Fake News and should not be spoken or printed. She walked off before having a chance to discuss the issue. That’s because Trump supporters are not open to a debate of any kind. The only reason the still support Trump is that their limited ability to reason if they are capable of logical, fact based, free thought, is inside a skull that is a closed system.
LikeLike
The dump voters I know are daft. Honest.
LikeLike
YUP!
LikeLike
The Mexican food everywhere in San Diego county is better than the Mexican food in anywhere Mexico. Even the fast food at joints called Roberto’s is delicious.
Education and politics are inextricably intertwined. If “there’s no room for politics” in a school boards meeting, there’s certainly no room for education in Trump’s cabinet. Hmm, come to think of it, I definitely wouldn’t mind if there were no room for DeVos in politics. I definitely wouldn’t mind if the Clinton, Bush, Obama, and Trump administrations never had anything to do with public education. But they did, and they do, and they will.
I am gladdened to know my school board heard you speak. They needed it. Thank you for coming to California. Have an easy flight home, Diane.
LikeLike
“The Mexican food everywhere in San Diego county is better than the Mexican food in anywhere Mexico.”
For real, Inservice? If so, how things have changed since ’68 when I travelled thro TX & thence by bus down thro Mexico to study at a lang school in Cuernavaca. The ‘Mexican’ food at best TX restaurants paled in comparison to truck-stop fare on the way South, & couldn’t hold a candle to the likes of Las Mañanitas in Cuernavaca. BTW, my son & another acquaintance have recently trialled the food at Las Mañanitas [still thriving – I was treated to 19th BD dinner there almost 40 yrs ago] & pronounced it intl-5* quality.
LikeLike
Too many of our citizens are simply uninformed but many others have had their votes marginalized via voter suppression efforts, gerrymandering, media propaganda, Dark Money (Super PACs – thank you “Citizens United’) and other impediments such as closed polls or closing earlier, Republican state legislatures that have enacted laws vis a vis voter ID requirements and other requirements that discourage voting (keeping college students from voting where they may reside for four years) and so on. We have met the enemy — and it is Congress and ALEC and the Koch Brothers and the Walton Family Foundation and so many others. It is unsettling but grassroots organizers and supporters are needed — to run for state and local offices or to work for those who do choose to run. It won’t be easy but the efforts must occur if this corporate-run country is to survive as a so-called democratic republic.
LikeLike
most people do not read newspapers, and they watch local news.
Here is an interesting piece on that.
View at Medium.com
LikeLike
The biggest problem with the local news is that their readers (they do not feature journalists) are among the most vacuous people humanity is capable of producing. They are only capable of conducting the most shallow interviews and recycling gossip magazines’ topics. The only reason I watch the local news is for weather—and even that is a stretch, especially when the weather readers are incapable of distinguishing between weather and climate, which leads to their idiotic opining of how climate change is refuted by the most recent winter snowstorm or cold spell.
LikeLike
Meanwhile there is an element of the left that still insists the problem is those Democrats who are secretly conspiring to allow the entire right wing agenda to happen. They are irrational but very, very loud. So are the trolls that mimic them.
LikeLike
How true, Will Thomas. I was shocked recently to learn that my upstate-NY hometown– a collegetown, always a liberal pocket surrounded by conservative elements– is represented by right-wing R rep Tom Reed. Browsed thro google & saw what gerrymandering has done to my growing-up part of upstate-NY. Nearby Rochester, always Dem but once part of a larger, mixed district, has had a line drawn tightly around it [“Dem”]. My poor little collegetown, longtime part of a mixed central area, was scooched 3 yrs ago, a lone NE outpost, into a rock-ribbed-red S Tier area. Ithaca’s votes will go unrepresented.
LikeLike
Marshall Tuck is spouting the same stuff that gubernatorial front runner Gavin Newsom is—they’re against for-profit charters. what nonsense. Isn’t there only one for-profit charter in the whole state of California? It is the not-for-profits that are causing so much damage to public schools. They think the electorate is stupid.
LikeLike
Second that!
LikeLike
Unfortunately, that’s not that different than what Bernie and Warren are saying.
I truly don’t think they think the electorate are stupid. I think they themselves are truly ignorant. I don’t know how to get some sense into them. Maybe we need to get Tim Kaine on a big campaign.
The way to put an issue in the forefront is to have every politician on your side talk about it all the time so the media can’t ignore it. I realize they were busy fighting this tax disaster, but once that is done, they need to talk about education, too.
Because it’s a winning issue.
LikeLike
This is the real problem. There is a segment of the country that is not interested in any kind of discussion with facts. To them, “facts” are malleable.
The problem with the left and Democrats too is that they have idealized these people instead of recognizing them for what they are. They will not be convinced by any argument. It is possible that if they have a personal experience of a family member directly harmed by a right wing policy they will change their mind, but since that is beyond our control, there is NOTHING that can be done to kowtow to them.
The moderate Dems say we need to make sure we don’t say anything too radical that these deplorable people might not like. The progressives say the moderates are not speaking properly to them. Neither recognizes that it is impossible.
The far right caught on to this long ago, but in the other direction. They knew that there was a whole segment of educated people who saw that their policies twice harmed this country and would again. Since they knew that they would no longer believe their lies, they simply stopped trying. But they made sure their base understood that we were all their enemy.
We have got to stop PANDERING to Trump voters and start ignoring them. If you vote for Trump, you won’t listen to reason and if you are still supporting him after his year of deplorable behavior, you need to be ignored, period.
And same goes with the left. If you hear anyone on the left saying that Dems are complicit — trying to brush the entire party with negative attacks — they should be treated as pure pariahs. They are helping the rise of the most dangerous thing to happen to the US in a century. They are no different than Trump voters and not interested in rational discussion. They are interesting in smearing the left and looking for easy scapegoats. In that they are acting exactly like Trump voters.
Bottom line: The Republicans are DANGEROUS. Their behavior on this tax bill demonstrates it. They do not want to discuss or debate. They are AFRAID of democracy. That is not good at all and if they will do what they did to get this tax bill passed, they will do anything. I do not expect them to give up power lightly. And that is freakin scaring me.
Bottom line: The Democrats are not dangerous. They are FLAWED. Just like the socialists were flawed. Just like the progressive were flawed. There has never been a political party that has not been flawed and if anyone tells you differently, we need to abandon them as they are beyond help. It is possible to be FLAWED and do good things. Just as LBJ. Just ask FDR.
Bottom line: There are forces on the left that need to be abandoned and not be given the same pandering to as those deplorable Trump voters are. They are peddling the same kinds of untruths.
I am not talking about Bernie Sanders or the majority of progressives who have terrific ideas and do not to this. BUT – there is a vast difference between how Bernie Sanders talks and how some of his hopeless supporters talk. Bernie does not smear. He does not attack Democrats. He does not help the right do their dirty work.
But some of his so-called supporters do. We already know that many were Russian trolls. There is a reason that Russia used that persona. And instead of pandering to those people who have no interest in facts, we need to ignore them.
I’m sorry for this rant, but we need to recognize that the danger is to democracy itself. And if you are still making the democrats your enemy or blaming the democrats because some racist Trump voters LIKE his scapegoating, then you are part of the problem, not the solution.
LBJ. He was a democrat. He did some flawed things. He also did some good things. And this country became more progressive because of him. And the flawed things he did were not because he wanted to destroy our country to enrich himself and his cronies. The flawed things that LBJ did were because he was human and made mistakes thinking he was doing something good.
That is not what the Republicans are doing. People who make mistakes will recognize and change their minds. That is what Diane Ravitch did. That is what Hillary Clinton did. That is what Bernie Sanders did. That is what pretty much every single politician in history that has done good has done. Not one of them knew all the answers. Some of their mistakes didn’t have much impact because they weren’t particularly powerful at the time. But making mistakes is part of being human.
Stop making a false equivalency. Making a mistake is different than intentionally trying to subvert democracy to get your way.
LikeLike
Yes. All of it. “Progressive” democrats are as bad for public education as Republicans right now. They want to pander for votes and they don’t want to lose the “school reform” vote. So they won’t ever come out and say charters are all bad for public education. They’ll stick by their “for profit charters are evil and we will just ignore what the rest are doing” story. Because they can no longer deny that charters have harmed our country. Maybe the best we can hope for is that as far as politicans’ Lies go, they are lying to the charter people to get vote but will listen to us in the end. Except that the money will not stop coming from the “reformers.”
LikeLike
Some progressive Democrats are bad for public education — certainly much worse than moderate Dems like Tim Kaine — but DESPITE that they are good for this country and if one of the pro-reform progressives is running against a candidate that will vote for the Republican agenda, they need to be supported. Not smeared because on the subject of public education they are still ignorant and need to be educated.
LikeLike
Yeah, no.
Look at this quote from
https://t.co/P8AP1B3CWt
which Diane referenced earlier today.
“Christie worked directly with former Newark Mayor Cory Booker to force charterization on Newark’s children–and Anderson (a campaign worker for Booker), Cerf, and Hespe were the governor’s chief enforcers of the policy.”
Cory Booker is everywhere, posing as a progressive, making frownie faces at the Trumpian antics of his fellow Senators. No one should EVER belief a word from Booker.
Caption:
Former Mayor Cory Booker, Cerf, and Anderson–architects of the privatization of many Newark schools.
LikeLike
UG!
LikeLike
I get that rancor, I really do. What this country needs is more people like my husband. He doesn’t talk much about politics, but he doesn’t miss anything either. This tax bill is so beyond the pale it sparked him to deliver a hilarious ad lib Monopoly-man monolog — in his broad Queens-ItaloAmerican accent– ‘Here, I’ll take that too, no wait, just gimme all of it, OK? Oh, ya got cancer? I got a charity. I’ll call ya — putcher name on the list.”
If I could just get him to it on camera for youtube.
LikeLike
Years before Trump, my wife was on a tour of a New England town. The tour guide mentioned that there was a house that had been a historical project carried out by First Lady Hillary Clinton. A partisan on the tour complained loudly that they should mention the historical project of Laura Bush. The tour guide patiently explained that Laura Bush was doing her project in another town.
Conservatives, as my mother used to say, do not want anyone else to “have air in a jug.”
LikeLike
I heard San Diego offers teachers some paid family leave for having a baby, the only city I heard of that doesn’t make women use their sick days.
LikeLike
Jake,
I don’t know about that. I met the superintendent about 7 years ago. She was a principal. I was very impressed by her obvious engagement with and concern for students and teachers. She didn’t apply to be supe. The board had had its fill of corporate management and wanted someone who rose through the ranks. Because of students lured by charter marketing, the district has suffered deep cuts to make up for lost revenue. The supe has protected class sizes and teachers.
LikeLike
If that is true—and I hope it is—this is wonderful, humane, realistic, and truly progressive.
LikeLike
Regretfully, Marshall Tuck is rather like a snake-oil salesman: very personable and ‘charming’ and utterly not to be believed; inspite of his ‘educational leadership’. clueless about schools and education, which makes him dangerous to public education in California.
LikeLike
I just wrote in a completely separate post that Marshall Tuck is dangerous lol. It’s true.
LikeLike
Trump’s followers, explained:
LikeLike
I don’t find him a bit charismatic. I can’t stand watching the Orange IDIOT blather incomprehensibly and ramble with nonsensical sentences. How in the world does one find him ‘charismatic’? He spews hatred and ignorance. I respect leaders who have compassion, speak truth and want to enrich our lives.
LikeLike
I know, I know. It cracks me up to see a hall full of cheering conservative Southerners many of whom normally have a knee-jerk dislike of NYC accent/ mannerisms. I think it’s the ‘regular-guy’ appeal.
LikeLike
Thanks for coming to California to speak. I have some friends who attended CSBA in San Diego and appreciated your speech. I look forward to watching it on video when you announce it.
LikeLike
I wonder if any of the trustees from Livermore, CA were there. They could give an entire symposium on how “non-profit” charters can make a profit—at least for the high-level management. Marshall Tuck is dangerous.
LikeLike
Yes, the Livermore School Board was represented. I met two members, and they said they were still cleaning up the fiscal mess left by the charters.
LikeLike
” public schools, citizenship, and democracy.”
Yep.
We ought to be demanding a return to public schools that teach for democratic citizenship.
There’s a long history to that noble purpose, and it’s needed now perhaps more than ever. Not SATs and ACTs. Not Advanced Placement. Not STEM and “maker” academies. Not technology for the sake of technology. Not more of “the Bible.”
To know how are we’ve strayed, one needs only a glance at the morning papers.
LikeLike
:”THE DESTRUCTION OF THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN TRUTH & FALSEHOOD IS THE FOUNDATION OF any DICTATORSHIP”
Forgive me for turning the conversation away from ‘the schools’ and back to the LIES that are flying because of the LOSS of what our schools once gave the people– the history that makes it easy to see what is afoot in America…. the dissemination of utter nonsense by the LEADERS of the GOP, who are so happy that our citizens are ignorant. They can pose questions that are BOGUS, LIKE THIS ONE:
“The question of what the American government can afford is functionally meaningless. If any nation has ever been able to afford quality housing, education, health care, parks, museums — anything — the United States can.And we don’t need to tax anyone, rich or poor, in order to afford these fine things. The wealth — the fruits of our labor — already exists. Taxes are a way of managing the bookkeeping system, of setting national priorities for the distribution of wealth created by good ideas and hard work.
Our country’s wealth is created by everybody. It’s not created by rich people. Rich people are what happen when the bookkeeping units we use to keep track of that wealth — the dollars — get stuck on particular individuals. Sometimes these people fall into the world possessing such accounting anomalies in the form of inheritances. Sometimes they siphon them from other people through the daily operations of commerce. Sometimes Washington decides to hand them more.
The current corrupt crop of Congressmen are about to finalize the bankrupting of our nation.
“President Donald Trump, House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-WI) and congressional Republicans” HAVE GIVEN US “a multitrillion-dollar tax cut for a particular slice of very wealthy citizens. There is much more than math at stake: These are matters of justice, social prestige and political power. There is no economic law that governs how the $19 trillion we produce each year must be distributed.
The GOP Tax Plan Tells Us Everything About Who Matters In American Democracy http://billmoyers.com/story/gop-tax-plan-tells-us-everything-matters-american-democracy/
LikeLike
FYI: Good Mexican restaurants in Chicago.
LikeLike
I live in NW Indiana, considered a suburb of Chicago. We also have good Mexican restaurants. There are also two good Indian restaurants within easy driving distance. Chinese…not so good. Have to go to China town in downtown Chicago.
LikeLike
Thank you so much Diane for your public education advocacy. Unfortunately, my many years of activism, engagement, and participation in support of public education have taught me that so many school board members and public education administrators are not aware of the significance public education plays in our democracy.
LikeLike