Despite the failure of No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top, despite the cruel pressures of this approach on very young children, the New York State Board of Regents is set to adopt a punitive plan (to meet the requirements of the new “Every Student Succeeds Act”). Common sense and concern for education values appears to have disappeared from Albany.
Cruelest of all: the state will retain the absurd Common Core standards for the littlest children, K-2 (with a new name, of course).
Districts with high numbers of opt outs will be punished.
Here is the summary in Newsday, by John Hildebrand, showing how little impact parent activism has had on the Board of Regents. Sorry to note, the state teachers’ union applauds these retrograde decisions. (Postscript: I hear the state teachers’ union is discussing their position, so the quote in this article may not be the last word.P
“ALBANY — Sweeping new objectives for school districts and students, with potential effects on controversial state tests and academic standards, are on the state Board of Regents agenda at its first meeting since classes resumed for the 2017-18 academic year.
“The 17-member educational policy board on Monday will tackle the issue of regulating districts as it works toward agreement on enforcement of the revamped federal law called the Every Student Succeeds Act, or ESSA. New York, like many other states, must submit its enforcement plan to the U.S. Department of Education by Sept. 18 for final approval.
“A 200-page draft plan, under review since May, would regulate schools on a range of objectives important to Long Island.
“Those include steps to discourage students from boycotting state tests — a movement that last spring swept up about 19 percent of more than 1 million students statewide in grades three through eight eligible to take the exams. That included about 90,000 students in Nassau and Suffolk counties, more than 50 percent of the region’s test-takers in those grades.
“Later on Monday, the Regents are scheduled to approve new academic standards, formerly known as Common Core and recently renamed as Next Generation Learning standards. The detailed guidelines — 1,048 standards in English and 450 in math — encompass classroom lessons from preschool through 12th grade statewide.
“The actions, while distinct from one another, are largely intended to settle controversies over student testing and school accountability that began rocking the state more than seven years ago. Though disagreements continue, policy experts said the Regents’ upcoming actions could set the state’s educational course for years to come.
“They’re kind of like cornerstone initiatives,” said Robert Lowry, deputy director of the New York State Council of School Superintendents and a veteran observer of Albany politics. “The standards define what students are supposed to learn, and ESSA defines how schools will be held accountable for teaching students.”
“Highlights of proposals the Regents are expected to consider include:
“School districts that don’t meet federal requirements for student participation in testing — and that includes all but a handful of districts on the Island — would have to draft plans for improvement. Systems that don’t improve would face potential intervention by a regional BOCES district or the state.
“The goal for high school graduation rates would eventually rise to 95 percent statewide, from a current level of slightly more than 80 percent. State education officials have not decided how diploma requirements might be revised to make that reachable.
“In rating school districts’ academic performance, greater recognition would be given to students who score well on college-level exams sponsored by the Advanced Placement program and by International Baccalaureate.
“For some districts, that could help balance out low performance by other students on the state’s own grade-level tests.
“Greater weight also would be given for student improvement, or “growth,” on state tests, as opposed to recognizing only the percentage of students who reach proficiency level. This reflects the intent of the Every Student Succeeds Act, signed into law in 2015 by President Barack Obama, which was to provide states with greater flexibility in regulating schools than was possible under the former federal law known as No Child Left Behind.
“Questions linger over whether the proposals will have an effect on stemming the test-refusal movement, especially on the Island.
“Jeanette Deutermann of North Bellmore, chief organizer of the Long Island Opt Out network, predicted that test boycotts in the region will continue unabated as long as the state sticks with academic standards that she and many other parents believe place too much stress on students.
“Deutermann pointed especially to standards in the earliest grades.
“Pre-kindergarten standards say all students should write their numerals to five,” she said. “Some kids are just learning how to hold a pencil.”
“At the state level, education leaders credit the Regents’ leadership and Education Commissioner MaryEllen Elia for listening to their concerns and quieting debate over tests and related issues. Statewide, the percentage of those opting out of the spring English and math exams was down 2 percentage points from 2016.
“New York State United Teachers, a statewide union umbrella group that once fiercely opposed federal and state efforts to tie test results to teacher performance evaluations, recently expressed support for much of the state’s plan to enforce ESSA.
“Overall, it’s reasonable and rational,” said Andy Pallotta, president of the 600,000-member NYSUT organization, during an interview on WCNY-FM, an upstate public radio station. “I think we’re on the way.”

“Adopt” test and punish? Hell, the Regents invented it. I remember when a good friend of mine moved from Illinois to New York in fourth grade (around 1980) and she started telling me all about the Regents tests. Back then it was actually surreal. Now it’s just for real.
LikeLike
I grew up in NY and the Regents tests used to be pretty basic.
Even members of the Regents could probably have passed.
Now, there is no chance — and not just because the members of the Regents have become dumber over time (though they almost certainly have)
LikeLike
You could find monkeys at the zoo smarter than people like Tisch
LikeLike
And then this:
““At the state level, education leaders credit the Regents’ leadership and Education Commissioner MaryEllen Elia for listening to their concerns and quieting debate over tests and related issues. Statewide, the percentage of those opting out of the spring English and math exams was down 2 percentage points from 2016.
“New York State United Teachers, a statewide union umbrella group that once fiercely opposed federal and state efforts to tie test results to teacher performance evaluations, recently expressed support for much of the state’s plan to enforce ESSA.”
For those of you who still think union leadership is on your side.
LikeLike
Couldn’t agree with this statement any more.
LikeLike
It’s a toxic irony that, while public schools are being buried under a flood of “enforcement,” “compliance” and “regulation” mandates, it’s practically an Ayn Rand paradise for charter schools and privatizers, who are allowed to get away with just about anything.
LikeLike
And, in regard to Dienne’s comment, the UFT in New York City has for years now been little more than an appendage of the DOE, assisting in managing the workforce, not representing it. This sorry episode is yet more evidence of that.
This “collaboration” with management – that’s Randi Weingarten’s word, not mine, by the way – is going to have very painful consequences for our union mis-leadership, when the Supreme Court rules against agency fees in the upcoming Janus case, and all of a sudden teachers don’t have to pay over a thousand dollars a year to a union that ignores them.
I’m a Union Guy, and will keep paying my dues, since even a bad union like the UFT is better than no union at all, but with thousands of new teachers who have no idea what a union is or does, it’s going to be rocky times ahead…
LikeLike
Collaboration with management is undoubtedly what Wein(and dine)garten learned at Cornell ILR school.
LikeLike
Tisch is gone. Betty Rosa replaced her.
LikeLike
“Sorry to note, the state teachers’ union applauds these retrograde decisions.”
I wonder if this is just the leadership or a majority of the members.
In any case, parents, students, and members of the New York State United Teachers appear to be the losers. Andy Pallotta, president of the 600,000-member NYSUT organization cannot be trusted to support sound policies for students, teachers, or parents.
LikeLike
Laura, I think your question answers itself.
LikeLike
“They (common core and ESSA)’re kind of cornerstone initiatives” — Robert Lower, deputy director of NY State council of school superintendents
More like tombstone initiatives.
“Tombstone”
Here lies Ed. U. Cation
Died from Common Core
Teacher devaluation
Charters, tests and more
From A Damthology of Deform
http://damthology.blogspot.com/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, we’re going to be sorry now that Ed U. Cation is gone….
LikeLike
Alternative Names:
Common GOUGE State Standards
Common WHORE State Standards
Common Mind DUMBING State Standards
LikeLike
Good ones
Here’s some more
Common Coward Standards
Common Bore Standards
Common Floor Standards
Common Poor Standards
Common Store Standards
Common Yore Standards
Common Lore Standards
Common Door Standards
Common Corp(oration) Standards
There, that pretty well exhausts words that rhyme with Core
LikeLike
I guess that should be Common Cower
LikeLike
Love them, someDAM poet! We should compile a list of alternative names for those really STUPID standards. Guess those folks look at kids and us just as widgets on an assembly line, because that is all their PEA brains can handle.
LikeLike
So let’s start up with more alliterative names: Common Crap, Common Crud,… Add the other “S” in and you have Stupid Standards, Stale Standards,… Anyone?
LikeLike
OOps, I guess I was late to the game.
LikeLike
The above tombstone reference recalls what I used to call it: Common Corpse
LikeLike
“The Common Corpse”
The Common Corpse has rigor
Supported by the Gates’
Their money is the figure
That keeps the Corpse in dates
The Common Corpse is rotten
But Gates can hide the smell
Till people have forgotten
That Corpse is not quite well
LikeLike
Here’s another specifically for NY
Cuomon Core
LikeLike
Cuomon Corps works too
LikeLike
How about “Common Crap Shoot Standards”?
Or “Common & Crappy Scheiße Shenanigans”?
LikeLike
Good ones.
Here’s another
Common Clap Standards (for which you need antibiotics)
LikeLiked by 1 person
And Common Spore, since they seem to have spread like fungus.
LikeLiked by 1 person
For which you also need antibiotics.
Seems to be a recorent theme
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just checked and those alternative names for CCSS say it all.
Thanks for those alternative names. They are spot on!
LikeLike
“Systems that don’t improve would face potential intervention by a regional BOCES district or the state.”
This needs to be further defined. What does the intervention entail? Is this a BOCES or state takeover? We already know that state takeovers are huge failures. BOCES offers special services, how can a district pay for additional service without more funds? If the district or school must establish a “school improvement plan,” will this status entitle them to additional funds? We can mandate more hoops for schools to jump through, but if we are unwilling to fairly fund schools, we reach an impasse. Do they expect K-2 students to take a bubble test on a computer? This is developmentally inappropriate, and it will yield false information on these young students. I am surprised that NYSUT and The Regents, some of whom are veteran public school educators, would go along with such an unsound policy which is designed to punish school districts with high levels of poverty.
LikeLike
So if test participation is low what will this intervention consist of? ICE-like raids on the homes of students who refuse to take the test so they are rounded up and forced to test? Defunding schools because parents exercise rights that ESSA says parents have? It just makes no sense.
LikeLike
America is GRATING:
DUMP is a FASCIST liar:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mbA5FdiRdFk
LikeLike
“. . . education leaders credit the Regents’ leadership and Education Commissioner MaryEllen Elia for listening to their concerns and quieting debate over tests and related issues.”
“Education leaders”? Do they mean adminimals*? I believe that is the only conclusion that can be drawn. “Quieting debate”. In other words “shut the f@#k up if you don’t agree with me!”
Quieting debate!?!
YEP! That’s what matters most. And it has worked on that supposed union “lider”. Screw him.
What the hell is going on?
*This was written for an Australian audience but holds true here:
Adminimal: A spineless creature formerly known as an administrator and/or principal. Adminimals are known by/for their brown-nosing behavior in kissing the arses of those above them in the testucation hierarchy. These sycophantic toadies (not to be confused with cane toads, adminimals are far worse to the environment) are infamous for demanding that those below them in the testucation hierarchy kiss the adminimal’s arse on a daily basis, having the teachers simultaneously telling said adminimals that their arse and its byproducts don’t stink. Adminimals are experts at Eichmanizing their staff through using techniques of fear and compliance inducing mind control. Beware, any interaction with an adminimal will sully one’s soul forever unless one has been properly intellectually vaccinated.
LikeLike
Thank you Duane for reminding us that local buy-in is a huge problem. Local administrators who try to prove their educational prowess by requiring this form or that lesson plan which includes that data are as much the problem as anyone else.
I have a friend in the teaching corps who,once said that six weeks out of the classroom will make anyone forget what it was actually like. To me this should mandate that any administrator on any level should spend time with his or her ideas in the classroom as a teacher so that the consequences of the action are felt directly. I know this sounds insane, but the state commissioner itself should be teaching a class while they do the state commissioner job.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The terminal cancer of standards-based test and punish continues to spread destroying all healthy tissue in its path. Yesterday, you wrote about Bill Gates and his foundation keeping this test and punish cancer alive. We know who to blame.
LikeLike
So how does this work . The NYSUT leadership is elected by delegates the larger the Individual Locals the more votes for the state leadership . Leaving the UFT in NYC with a very large influence . But retirees are allowed to vote in the UFT , that is not the case in most Unions . The interests of retirees are not necessarily the interests of Working Teachers or Students . Why should they care about unfair teacher evaluations they are not being evaluated .
“Just keep my pension checks rolling and to hell with everybody else “. That is the same dynamic we see in other elections . Where the I got mine and to hell with you crew . Votes against the interests of younger citizens . What they do not get is that their heads are on the chopping block. This divide will be exploited to attack their earned benefits from pensions – Medicare . “Oh the burden being placed on the next generation ” heard it again just this morning.
Ask yourselves ; Why is there a symmetry of forces aligned on education and most other areas of discussion in the economy. Whose interests do these forces represent. . .
LikeLike
This is an excellent point.
How do you address this? Retired teachers are selfish. That’s what many on the far right would say. I would probably say that act like normal people who are far more concerned with their own self-interest than what happens to kids in public schools.
This is the kind of argument that makes parents like me become anti-union. One reason the education reform movement got power is that parents got disgusted with seeing them promote so many things that was not in the best interest of kids at all.
I have had arguments with people I respect who live in California and embrace charter schools there because they saw years of union rule that seemed to benefit only the union teachers. Maybe that really meant the retired union teachers at the expense of the non-retired ones. But these are parents who believe in progressive ideals but were seeing things go wrong.
I despise it when the far right takes some teacher who gets caught committing some atrocious crime and anti-union people say “look the union protected him”.
But I find it much harder to argue when people say “look the union only cares about protecting pensions and they will sell out anything to keep pensions high.”
One reason it is so easy to attack public schools is that the union leaders have agreed not to challenge the myth of how much is spent on public schools. There is a huge amount that is spend each year to service the pension debt of retirees. It should be kept outside the budget discussions because it has nothing to do with what is spent on the cost of current teachers (including pension contributions).
Instead, those numbers seem to be hidden as if the retirees fear it will be taken away if we really saw how much of the per pupil allocation each public school supposedly gets is spent to give retirees a check each month. But making good public policy is impossible when people want to cover up some costs.
LikeLike
You address it by having the UFT align their voting procedures with almost every other union in the country . Only active members vote.
The criticism of Unions is well deserved . The Union movement has been all too willing to eek out minor gains for their own members at the expense of other union workers and workers in general. The union movement becomes a broad based social movement or it perishes as individual unions . By the way if that sounds harsh, it came right from Trumka who in 2012 proposed making the AFL CIO an umbrella group with voting rights given to other organizations from the Sierra club to NAACP…. ……
My objection is as an insider ,not from the right. . It is not a winning strategy to pretend that everything is just ducky.
As for pensions both Public and Private they are differed salary and should have been paid for up front. With reasonable returns assumed on investment rather than pie in the sky projections and inadequate
funding . The problem is not that teacher pensions are so far out of line . But that others do not have these bennifits . So if teachers and unions in general want to preserve these benefits the best way to do it is to fight for improvements for all workers . Part of that fight, is to fight for the best for their students. The days of private deals, for advantage have to come to an end. Whether that is with oligarchs or politicians.
LikeLike
Union Rule?!?!?!?!?
This is BS influenced by the Alt-Right conspiracy theory machine based on alternative facts (lies and misinformation).
You have been played if you think teachers’ unions rule. This kind of thinking is exactly what the Koch brothers, ALEC, and the Walton family want people to think.
It’s crap. It’s pure crap. And I don’t care if my language offends anyone because I’m boiling angry.
The schools are not ruled by teachers’ unions. They are ruled by education codes that are passed by state legislatures and sometimes those ed codes are interpreted and refined by court cases when they are challenged. Most of the challenges are from parents.
For instance, correct me if I’m wrong, but you alleged, “There is a huge amount that is spent each year to service the pension debt of retirees.”
I taught in California. My retirement is paid through CalSTRS, a retirement fund that is more than 100-years old that teachers and school districts pay into. CalSTRS survived the Great Depression and never missed a payment to retired teachers.
Today, CalSTRS has about $200-billion. But in 2007-08, that retirement fund lost about $50 billion from the results of the global financial crises. Even after that loss, CalSTRS reported there was enough funds left to pay retired teachers their full retirement benefits for thirty years.
When I retired after working as a public school teacher for thirty years, I took a 40-percent pay cut with no medical, and for those thirty years, I paid my share into the CalSTRS fund.
Where did that huge pension debt you mentioned come from?
Let’s take a look at the 2017-18 California State Budget to see what that HUGE AMOUNT is.
K-12 Education’s share of the state budget is $53,455,000,000 compared to the total state budget of $125,096,000,000
Click to access SummaryCharts.pdf
How much of California’s budget went to CalSTRS?
Currently working public school teachers in California pay between 9.025 to 10.25-percent that is deducted from their monthly gross income.
The District’s contribution is 14.43-percent.
The state’s contribution is 6.828 percent.
Several years ago. the legislature passed legislation to help make up for the money lost to CalSTRS due to the 2007-08 global financial crises and Governor Brown signed that legislation.
School districts are paid by the state according to the number of students enrolled. The more students, the bigger their slice of the state’s K-12 pie is.
https://www.calstrs.com/
How much did the members, the employers, and other receivables pay in 2016 to CalSTRS
$2,693,178,000
Click to access pafr_2016.pdf
The total k-12 education budget was $53,455,000,000 (and only 5-percent went to CalSTRS)
The total state budget was $125,096,000,00 (less than one-half of one-percent of the total state budget was paid into CalSTRS by the state)
That only additional burden to the state (or taxpayers) was almost 587-million dollars out of a 125-billion dollar budget or 0.4696 of the total budget.
And that 0.4696% is a HUGE amount? Really!
I’m sure the corporate reformers of public education manipulate anything they report to make it sound huge but when put in perspective, it is tiny.
They want to destroy the teachers’ unions by turning people against them. To do that, they must mislead and to do that they must lie.
LikeLike
But the Wall Street Journal reports: NY Education Officials Vote to Replace Common Core Leslie Brody, Wall Street Journal
They’re remobilizing.
LikeLike
It would have been more accurate to say “New York education officials vote to rebrand Common Core”
LikeLike
Who wrote this article? Was it you Diane? Some feel you are supporting this? I don’t Can you tell me please?
LikeLike
It was in the 4th paragraph:
“Here is the summary in Newsday, by Hohn Hildebrand, showing how little impact parent activism has had on the Board of Regents. Sorry to note, the state teachers’ union applauds these retrograde decisions.”
LikeLike
It was written by John Hildebrand in Newsday. I said so in the post on the blog.
LikeLike
I certainly don’t support test-based accountability. Why would you think that I did?
LikeLike
“Rebranding”
The Common Core is gone
With mirror in it’s place
It’s still the same old song
And still the same old face
LikeLike
I took a quick stab at a second stanza, SDP.
The Common Core is here
It never really left
It’s still the same old song
It’s all about the tests.
LikeLike
Right on, someDam poet!
LikeLike
#NxtGenOptOut #NotFalling4It #RegiftedCommonCore rebranded with a nane that associates it with Next Gen science standards to sow confusion among parents that is what the Regents just gave us in NYS. They aim to disrupt parebt powrr, teacher activism and student refusal. What other state has 5 exit exams for high school, an inordinate time lost on testing and prep from 3-8th grade and now they have come for the babies. This should not stand. We must #Standup4thelittles , defend childhood and stop this insanity. We cannot test our way to equity.
LikeLike
You should expect this from the Cuomo administration. He is a Wall Street democrat that panders to those that stand to make a lot of money by investing in education in various ways. Obama belonged to the same club of Wall Street democrats. That’s why we are where we are. It started under Bush with the help of Ted Kennedy. At the time Kennedy was terminally ill with cancer. He wanted a legacy, so he made a deal with the Devil, Bush to pass No Child Left Behind.I suspect if he could see what it became he would be rolling over in is grave.
LikeLike
Absolutely agree on all points. Btw, in W’s autobiography — written well before its dismantling — he champions NCLB as his signature legislative accomplishment. But this has been a bipartisan betrayal of public education promulgated by cynical politicians, unaccountable plutocrats, and countless (unwitting?) cash-desperate organizational accomplices.
LikeLike
This is a sad political game being played with the education of real children.
Starting with ESSA, a law Trump or DeVos don’t understand the first thing about – a law that was negotiated completely in the back room, which kept annual testing mandate in place despite bipartisan opposition.
Trump ran against Common Core, but then installed Betsy DeVos who supported it, and so Trump went silent, breaking his campaign promise and offering no leadership. No one knows where Trump is on standardized testing.
In NY, the unions have gone along with the testing through years and years of changes, tweaks and revisions and this is simply more of the same. The metrics that are being negotiated to include (or not) have nothing to do with measuring learning, science, psychometrics, fairness or accuracy. The process is completely political, driven by money and corruption, both federal and state.
Commissioner Elia’s signature is pretending to be listening, but continuing awful policies, blocking out evidence and the voices of proven practitioners. The opt-out parents are intractable because they see it’s corrupt politics affecting their kids and want better. This year, 92% of NY’s over 700 districts were over the 5% opt-out threshold that is supposed to trigger action.
Aside from NY shortening the testing from 6 to 4 days, there is nothing positive going on as NY flounders toward it’s ESSA implementation with campaign cash, the revolving door and the captured corporate media continuing to prevent educators from influencing policy. It’s also noteworthy that NYSUT, led by president Andy Pallotta was promoting opt-out just a few months ago, so he’s either done a total 180 or he knows the latest policy moves are just a facade for more useless tinkering.
LikeLike