Jan Resseger writes in The Progressive about the biggest charter scam in Ohio.
When a charter operator gets a lot of money from the state, and selfsame charter operator gives generously to legislators, how can said charter operator ever be held accountable?
In Ohio, the press got fed up with ECOT and started paying attention to charter frauds. Politicians cannot tolerate constant negative press. So, lo and behold, the state conducted an audit of ECOT.
Resseger writes:
“With Betsy DeVos, a long-committed charter school proponent, in charge of the U.S. Department of Education, the country should look to recent goings-on in Ohio as a warning sign of what can happen when public institutions are privatized and an example of why a moratorium on more of these schools is necessary.
“In 2000, Bill Lager founded the Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow and the two privately held, for-profit companies that operate the school—IQ Innovations, which provides ECOT’s curriculum, and Altair Learning Management, which manages the school’s operations. According to an old 2003, Ohio Department of Education policy, online charter schools were paid a per-pupil amount from the state for every student enrolled. Until 2015, there was not a requirement that virtual academies demonstrated actual daily participation. Once the Legislature began demanding proof that students were regularly logging on to their computers, Lager and his attorneys have blamed the state for suddenly and unfairly changing the rules. In the 2015-2016 school year, ECOT was paid $106 million in public tax dollars for the more than 15,000 students it said were enrolled, but the state was able to verify the active participation of only 6,300 students.
“The state has demanded that ECOT pay back $60 million the school was over-paid for the 2015-2016 school year, but Lager has used his connections to the state’s biggest lobbyists and key Republican friends in the legislature to pressure lawmakers, even creating attack ads on TV aimed at the Department of Education.
“Thanks to relentless exposure of the scandal by the state’s major newspapers, it appears, finally, that Ohio may claw back some of the tax dollars Lager has stolen. But the state and a lot of local school districts are still owed $60 million for the 2015-2016 school year. And the Columbus Dispatch reports that the Ohio Department of Education has not released results of a new attendance audit for the 2016-2017 school year.
“Lager has been in court all year to block the state from making ECOT repay the money. In mid-June, the Ohio State Board of Education voted almost unanimously to accept the ruling of a hearing officer from the Ohio Department of Education, who is reported by the Columbus Dispatch to have declared that no school’s intent is to “teach to what could be the equivalent of an empty classroom.”
Keep your eyes on ECOT and whether it will be held accountable. Like other states, Ohio desperately needs charter legislation that is not written by lawyers for the charter industry. Ohio courts have ruled that anything purchased by a charter operator with PUBLIC funds belongs to the charter, even if it goes out of business. The law was written that way, by charter lobbyists.

Diane writes: “Ohio courts have ruled that anything purchased by a charter operator with PUBLIC funds belongs to the charter, even if it goes out of business. The law was written that way, by charter lobbyists.”**
What better evidence do we need to see that the fox is in the chicken house, and has been?
LikeLike
I know a bright student who used ecot for his senior year. He blew through the lessons in just a few months, finishing early. Obviously it wasn’t challenging enough.
His brother on the other hand has ADHD,couldn’t focus & dropped out.
LikeLike
I have been opposed to both Charter and Voucher Schools. Public Education is what needs to be fully funded.
LikeLike
Thanks to Jan Resseger and now Diane for making Ohio’s problem visible. This unconsionable ripoff of taxpayers from the charter and online education industries is also a national problem.
LikeLike
The disconnect is amusing. This is front page news in Ohio. Last week it led local radio news because it really is the biggest school scandal ever and charter schools are STATE schools in Ohio- state government (supposedly) regulates them.
It doesn’t exist in ed reform. Not mentioned. You won’t find a word about ECOT on any of the ed reform sites promoting online learning.
LikeLike
Ohio newspapers have done a great job with ECOT but the state attorney general and the auditor should be ashamed of themselves.
They simply aren’t doing their job.
When Columbus Public Schools had a scandal the state auditor literally raided schools- they put on a big show for the cameras. There were perp walks and trials- the whole works.
Compare that with how long they have allowed this theft to occur and they STILL can’t enforce their own laws. Utter and complete capture. They’re helpless. It’s embarrassing.
Try what ECOT is doing as a regular person in Ohio. The state would seize your property and accounts as a matter of course. They would GET PAID.
But not with ECOT. They get YEARS to comply.
LikeLike
Here’s how state officials and lawmakers treat public schools when schools break the rules:
“Twenty Columbus City high schools were raided Thursday as part of the investigation into data rigging in the Columbus City School District.
On Friday, portions of the search warrants were unsealed, revealing the scope of those raids.
Investigators confiscated reports showing a complete history of students in the Columbus City School District.”
Weird how they are simply helpless to stop charter school malfeasance. Did they run low on warrant forms or forget how to conduct raids? Why are the two sectors treated so differently?
LikeLike
The Canadian owned Akron Beacon Journal (its reporter, Doug Livingston) should be primarily credited with news coverage about contractor schools.
LikeLike
Steal state money, then use that same money to fund court cases to block all efforts by the state to get the stolen money back. Only in the USA.
LikeLike
The amount of money the virtual contractor schools are spending on advertising is the legacy of Gates and Walton heirs. It’s money that taxpayers in communities allocated so that kids could have an education. Instead, the money is diverted to PR firms and broadcast media. And, Gates and Walton heirs just walk away as if they have no culpability in the fleecing.
LikeLike