The Akron Beacon-Joirnal reports on a multi-state charter scandal.
“The founder of an Akron-area charter school company is accused of using thousands of dollars parents paid for student lunches and uniforms and millions more from Ohio and Florida taxpayers to fund home mortgages, plastic surgery, extensive world travel, credit card debt and more.
“Criminal charges filed last week in Florida against Marcus May also allege he improperly used private and public funds earmarked for students’ education to expand his charter school empire in Columbus, Akron, Cleveland and Dayton.
“Florida State Attorney William “Bill” Eddins brought the charges of racketeering and organized fraud against May, the founder of Newpoint Education Partners and Cambridge Education, a Fairlawn company that manages about 20 charter schools in Cincinnati, Dayton, Columbus, Akron, Youngstown, Canton and Cleveland.
“In a prepared statement provided to the Beacon Journal on Friday, Cambridge Executive Director John Stack said: “My co-owners and I asked for and today accepted Mr. May’s resignation as managing member of Cambridge. We are now in discussions to remove him completely from ownership in the company because we feel it’s in the best interest of our schools.
“Despite this distraction, my colleagues at Cambridge and I will continue to focus on our core mission and the students we serve as we have always done.”
“Cincinnati businessman Steven Kunkemoeller also was charged in the First Judiciary Circuit, a regional court in Florida. Kunkemoeller is a longtime business partner of May, according to a Beacon Journal/Ohio.com report from December and a multi-state investigation that included help from the Summit County Prosecutor’s Office.
“Kunkemoeller was arrested Wednesday in Florida. May’s attorney has reportedly talked with authorities there. Neither man could be reached for comment.
“The Florida prosecutor alleges that the men fabricated invoices, embellished enrollment, misappropriated public funds and created an elaborate network of limited liability companies in order to bilk the federal and state governments, as well as parents and students.
“In Akron, where Cambridge manages Towpath Trail High School, Middlebury Academy and Colonial Prep Academy, school board members are taking caution but not jumping to conclusions.
“We are keeping a close eye on it and discussing alternatives if they are needed,” said Ron McDaniel, president of Towpath Trail High School. “But we need to be responsible and not make snap decisions. Our schools are running well and run responsibly. We verify things better than the Florida schools did from what I understand.”
“The mark up
“School and business records obtained by the Beacon Journal and detailed by a forensic accountant working on the case show that May and Kunkemoeller marked up the price of services and supplies provided to the charter schools they managed in Ohio and Florida, sometimes more than doubling the cost of school uniforms, desks, computers, chairs and website design.
“Florida investigators questioned the vendors who sold the goods and could find “no apparent business reason” for the mark ups. May and Stack, Cambridge’s executive director, have said that the schools pay more upfront for more flexible financing terms.
“Fabricated invoices
“Items listed on invoices, from iPads to furniture, could not be found when Florida investigators swept schools for evidence of how public dollar were spent…
“Property and bank records reviewed by investigators showed May and his wife, Mary May, purchased a Florida home soon after “rebate” payments began. In 2014, two payments of $175,000 were applied to Kunkemoeller’s mortgage and the May’s home equity line of credit. Investigators traced the money to a laundry list of other non-public expenses, including $381,631 for credit cards, $207,415 for Marcus May and his family, $52,388 for a homeowner’s association fees (including swimming pool services), $4,735 taken as cash, personal loans to other people, a $10,000 jet ski from Barney’s Motorcycle Sales in St. Petersburg, $5,000 to the Fairlawn Country Club, $11,000 for plastic surgery and additional money for trips to Amsterdam, the British Virgin Islands, Brussels, Cancun, China, France, Hong Kong, Iceland, India, Japan, Los Cabos, the U.S. Virgin Islands and Italy.”
Florida officials are investigating; Ohio officials don’t seem to care.
The story goes on to detail massive fraud, double-billing, and other misappropriation of public money.
When will the mainstream media report this story? We know that Betsy DeVos won’t care. As long as parents are choosing these schools, why worry about the money?

“The Ohio Dept. of Ed. pulls $30,000,000 annually away from local districts and sends it directly to Marcus May’s 20 charter schools.” Doug Livingston is Ohio’s finest journalist. In the article, Livingston cites the numerous Ohio government agencies (run by Republicans) that chose to sit on their hands. We can credit the Canadian ownership of the Beacon Journal with reporting as a free press unlike American-owned Ohio newspapers. The taxpayers are now forced to pay litigation costs adding insult to injury,
The people responsible for the debacle of contractor schools should be identified- BILL and MELINDA GATES, WALTON HEIRS, DFER and the politicians, think tanks and press that serves them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The crackerjack education reporters at the Dayton Daily News and Columbus Dispatch (who quote contractor-defending Fordham at every opportunity) were scooped by… first, the Beacon Journal and then…well, just about everyone. Maybe they should look around for some sources.
LikeLike
YES.
LikeLike
Diane Here’s an interesting paragraph from the article:
“All told, the Florida Department of Education paid May’s schools $57 million from 2007 to 2016. The Ohio Department of Education pulls about $30 million annually from local school districts and sends it directly to May’s 20 charter schools.
LikeLike
Sorry Linda–I duplicated your note here before I read it. But it does bear repeating.
LikeLike
The problem is they will always make false equivocations . Always point to where a public
official, be it a school superintendent or a politician has been found to be corrupt.
To bring them down one has to defeat them on a broad scale of issues which means you
have to propose a completely different narrative across the board. The narrative of the FDR years was that the Government is the solution to assisting a failed enterprise system(always resisted) . The Reagan narrative of the last 40 years has been that government is the problem .
2008 should have been the opportunity to change that , that it was not was a profound failure of leadership.
So here is the question, have the underlying facts on the ground changed, such that what we witnessed in 08 -09 will not revisit us. Are family incomes up, is inequality lessening. is personal debt out pacing earnings… …
As the ROBOTS come!!!!, no they are not here yet. 600 carrier jobs did not just leave an efficient factory in Indiana to go to Mexico for their superior robots. When the more educated workforce gets clobbered in White and Blue Collar professions.
The system will have to be gamed again, to make up for the declining standard of living.It already is being gamed .
“More Americans fell behind on their car loan payments in the fourth quarter, bringing auto delinquencies to their highest since the height of the financial crisis, Federal Reserve Bank of New York data released on Thursday showed.” 2/17
So much for that Obama economy .
That has been the experience of the last forty years . An economy that is only capable of maintaining itself on bubbles. Reagan’s bubble was a fiscal conservative(LOL) who blew a hole the size of Jupiter in the National debt. followed by the Stock bubble and the housing bubble. The last time the American people forgot who they were ,they elected a black man..
So how bad is it now . Think of the exit polls both in the primaries and the general. Voters under 50 voted heavily progressive .The truth is they are living in the new economy . Those over 50 for a host of reasons are more secure in their incomes. Especially those over 65 who are more likely to have things like pensions than those approaching retirement . By the next election those unhappy 50 year old’s will be 54,
Will their standard of living be better or worse.
Move over Bernie you may be too moderate for the next time.
LikeLike
Well-said and so true!
We are going to have to rely on the wisdom of our younger generations, who have lived their entire lives under the greed, selfishness and cruelty of the Reagan and post-Reagan years. And yes, that include Obama, who said he supported Single Payer, refused to push for a Public Option, and now has a $64 million book advance.
His track record is also abysmal on public schools and prosecution of Wall Street banksters, as we all know.
LikeLike
I could have copied and pasted from an indivisible Facebook page my identical response to yours. Let us not forget that the greatest chance to reverse the fate of the Union movement was passed up at a moment of severity equal to the great depression. The only thing that made it different was we knew how to manage it . We knew how to “print dollar bills and drop them from helicopters “. Most of which landed on Banks and corporate lenders, like GE or GM. Not their workers . A trillion dollar mortgage crisis does not make a 17 trillion dollar financial crises..
LikeLike
It is time for taxpayers’ to hold their representatives accountable for all the charter waste and fraud. In a public school funds are largely spent to serve the needs of students. There are no hidden costs. Taxpayers have a right to know where their money is going, and public schools are independently audited so there is little waste or fraud. Sending tax dollars to the “market place” is a ticket to waste and fraud for no better results. Public education is an investment in a community. Charters are in business to mostly send local tax dollars outside the community to a parent corporation. It is time for taxpayers to resist and question the value of the money going out of the community and into corporations’ pockets. It is like taxation without representation when charters buy those that hold the purse strings. As with the healthcare bill, privation is a massive transfer of wealth from the middle class to the wealthy,
LikeLike
Kettering, Ohio’s Peggy Lehner is the Chair of the Ohio Senate Education Committee.
LikeLike
“Public education is an investment in a community.”
Thank you to retired teacher for another important talking point.
LikeLike
So far nothing at all connected to this story has been in the Cincinnati Enquirer, also serving Northern Kentucky. But I did find this:
“U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio. THE CINCINNATI ENQUIRER Metro D-3 Friday, September 26, 1986.
Embezzler gets public service
A Mount Lookout man was ordered Thursday to do 250 hours of community service and spend 90 days in a halfway house after pleading guilty to embezzling $76,311 from Central Trust Bank.
U.S. District Judge S. Arthur Spiegel could have jailed Steven J. Kunkemoeller, 25, for five years and fined him $250,000. FBI agent Henry Gittleman told the judge that Kunkemoeller took the money from the bank’s international trade profits by wiring it to a personal account at First National Bank.
Kunkemoeller, who said he had hoped for a career in finance and banking, was assistant cashier when he took the money in mid-1985. Gittleman said the theft was discovered when someone noticed the wire transfers.”
Well, Kunkemoeller has had a fabulous career in “financing and banking,” in ways that U.S. District Judge S. Arthur Spiegel could not have imagined.
Steven J. Kunkemoeller is the owner of SCHOOL WAREHOUSE INC
Tampa, FL · Cincinnati, OH Registration:Jan 28, 2011
Addresses: 3111 W Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd, Tampa, FL 33607
1018 Delta Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45208 State ID:P11000009799
Business type: Domestic for Profit Corporation
Members (2):Steven Kunkemoeller (President, Secretary)
Kunkemoeller Steven (President, Secretary, inactive)
Agent: Northwest Registered Agent, Llc
I looked up AGENT: Northwest Registered Agent, Llc This company offers fee-for service online help so that anyone can set up a business in any state. This agent offers templates and the boilerplate legal text required to set incorporate a business in every state. Their fees are reasonable compared to a full service legal firm. Steven J. Kunkemoeller also seems to have been an owner of Red Ignition. I could find nothing about that company.
I will forward this to the Enquirer and see if they do any additional work on this local and national news story.
LikeLike
You describe what the charter industry attracts-across the board-from the billion dollar vulture philanthropists, to the prevaricating policy promoters, to cyber contractor grifters, to the larcenous operators of contract schools and, to the contractor’s mercenary staff, promoted into school administration positions and into the teaching profession without doing the work required to get there.
LikeLike
Of course Betsy Devos won’t care about the scam, her family is in on it. Look what the walton family owns and follow the money. It’s not about education choice, it’s about filling their pockets with more money and the feds are letting her do it. As they say, they are just as guilty for not acting on this mess #45 has created.
LikeLike
YES!
LikeLike
Talk about welfare fraud! Why quibble about a few thousand when you can abscond with millions.
Must be nice.
My advice – purchase some soap on a rope.
LikeLike
cross posted at https://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/SHOCKER-Massive-Charter-S-in-Best_Web_OpEds-Charter-School-Failure_Charter-Schools_Diane-Ravitch_Education-170625-343.html#comment664233
with links to other posts on charter schools
The Network for Public Education: Our View on Charter Schools https://wp.me/p3bR9v-2st
Michael Fiorillo: The Not-So-Secret Agenda of the Charter Industry: There are issues of control woven throughout the charter issue, separate from the looting they are prone to. https://dianeravitch.net/2017/04/23/michael-fiorillo-the-not-so-secret-agenda-of-the-charter-industry/
and other links, which are embedded in my comments below.
Despite reports around the nation of thE scams and waste, THE MEDIA does not tell the story of how charter schools are failing.
There are almost sixteen thousand SCHOOL SYSTEMS, and our citizens are clueless as to the robbery of taxpayer money from our public schools, so they will fail.
here are a few stories:
Consider this report in the “Post & Courier” in South Carolina :”Online charter schools have grown exponentially across South Carolina and the nation — and questions about their effectiveness are growing, too.
California: Audit Says Charter School Founder Misappropriated Millions of Dollars!
Kevin McCarthy, State Assemblyman from Sacramento, published a terrific article in the Sacramento Bee with Joshua Pechthalt, president of the California Federation of Teachers, explaining what a rip-off for-profit charters are.
Pennsylvania: How the State’s Charter Law Cripples Public Schoolsthis articleexplains how the formula cripples public schools.
Jersey Jazzman, aka Mark Weber, experienced teacher and doctoral student at Rutgers, follows the claims of charter promoters in New Jersey, especially Newark. His latest post is simply “Facts About Newark Charter Schools.”
LikeLike