A while back, Ohio Governor John Kasich proposed that teachers should be required for recertification to spend time in a business so they could understand the real world.
Sarah Guinn of The Athens “Messenger” reported that:
“Some legislators responded by proposing the Get REALS Act (Governor’s Externship for Training of Realistic Expectations of Academic Leadership in Schools) which would require Kasich to spend 40 hours of on-site observations inside a public school. The Messenger decided to do the externship for a day at Athens High School.”
Guinn took on the challenge that Kasich has so far ducked. She learned a lot. The teachers wish that Kasich would try it. He would stop loading up the schools with mandates and unnecessary tests. He might learn a lot too.
She writes:
“Natalie Bobo’s classroom is replete with a tennis shoe-filled box for anyone who may need them, a griddle she uses a few times during the year to make breakfast for students and a myriad of basic school supplies and materials — a number of which are paid for from her own pocket.
“So what else might Kasich see if he were to venture to Athens High School?
“For this psuedo-Kasich who hasn’t spent a full day at high school in almost a decade, the experience was eye-opening in a number of ways.
“Bobo, an intervention specialist, changes gears many times throughout the day. She spends three periods in her own classroom providing instruction to students who need a slower-paced class than what’s typical for their grade level, and three outside of her classroom co-teaching. Two other periods are dedicated to academic coaching and planning.
“For the periods outside her classroom, Bobo teams up with Molly Roach to co-teach two freshman English classes; one for students at a typical level, and another at college-prep. She also co-teaches social studies with Paul Kaiser.
“This is a typical day for Bobo from 7:30 a.m. to 3 p.m., but her true hours reach far beyond what’s contractually agreed upon, as is the case with many teachers.
“Teaching is physically and mentally exhausting,” Roach said. “I am on my feet all day, lecturing, monitoring group work, jumping from student to student to give individual help. I have to attend meetings. I have to plan and write tests. I have to grade the work of 132 students. I have one 43-minute planning period during which I am supposed to accomplish all my grading and planning, make copies, enter my grades, check and answer my emails, make parent phone calls, and Heaven forbid use the restroom or call home to check on my own children.”
“She eats and works at her desk during her 30-minute lunch break, she said, and takes home folders of ungraded papers each night.”
“When you are a teacher, you get no rest. There is always someone needing something from you,” she said. “You’re never finished with your work. It feels like a treadmill on high speed sometimes.”
Take this idea and run with it. Invite elected officials to be a teaching assistant for a day. Target state legislators. They have no idea what happens in schools.
You can’t “fix” them. They are not “broken.” They know exactly what they are doing. They don’t really care that reality runs counter to their narrative. If they did, don’t you think they would have done a little research themselves (or have a staffer do it). These things are not hard to find out. The reason they do not spend a day in a classroom is because it is bad optics, to be showing that one’s narrative is wrong.
It is easy to be cynical. I think John Kasich is beyond redemtion, but who knows?
This is newsworthy. I received this link morning from a former student and savvy BAT.
Senator Patty Murray, the top Democrat on the Senate committee that handles education, sent aletter and report to her Senate colleagues titled, “Real Choice vs. False Choice: The Repercussions of Privatization Programs for Students, Parents, and Public Schools.”
In the 19-page document, dated March 22, 2017, Murray lays out an argument against the kind of private-school choice programs that President Trump says his administration will champion and that Education Secretary Betsy DeVos has long supported.
This document has solid research. Someone has really done the homework. Take a look. Then help to circulate it.
Here’s the document:
Click to access Murray_Privatization%20Caucus%20Memo.pdf
Where was Murray
In Duncan years
Of testing fury
And VAMming spears?
Where was Pat
When Billy Gates
Went to bat
For charter fates?
Where has Senator
Murray been?
Past projenitor
Of private win
“When it comes to making our country more competitive, improving our schools and preparing our workforce we face real challenges. Those challenges require innovative solutions and that is why I am pleased to welcome to the Senate one of the most innovative thinkers of our time, Bill Gates” (senator Murray, 2007)
Quite correct Steve, quite correct!
Kasich is a hard right wing/libertarian ideologue, he is impervious to any alterations in his agenda. How about shoving a week’s worth of papers and assignments to be graded, commented upon and recorded in the grade book. That would be hundreds of papers, essays, quickie exams, quizzes and tests to be graded and recorded. Let’s be nice and give him all of Saturday and Sunday to evaluate/grade all those papers. And that’s just one small part of what teachers do aside from in the classroom. Then make sure he does lesson planning for the upcoming week and makes a substitute’s packet for a month.
And yet, Kasich and LeBron were named as some of the top leaders in the country.
“The Unteachables”
Kasich can’t be taught
Cuz learning’s not his thing
He only can be bought
A present tied with string
Public schools bring in local members of the business community and we talk to students.
They’ve been doing it for years. Kasich wouldn’t know because he ignores public schools except when he’s bashing them or coming up with stupid gimmicks to impose upon them.
Boy, I sure hope ed reformers don’t get this wish and we replace all the public schools with charter schools:
“When two charter school operators announced plans to leave Tennessee’s turnaround district this spring, many people were surprised that they could break their 10-year agreements.
“How could any charter management company come into a community and up and decide we’re not going to play anymore?” asked Quincey Morris, a lifelong resident of North Memphis, home to two schools that abruptly lost their charter operator.
But in Memphis and across the nation, there’s nothing to stop charter operators from leaving, even when they promise to be there for a long time.
Contracts signed by both Gestalt Community Schools and KIPP contain no penalties for exiting the Achievement School District before agreements run out, according to documents obtained by Chalkbeat.
And by design, that’s not unusual in the charter sector. For better or worse, operators are given that autonomy, according to Dirk Tillotson, a lawyer and founder of a charter incubation organization in California.”
Thank goodness for the unfashionable public sector schools that are there to pick up the kids these charters rejected.
http://www.chalkbeat.org/posts/tn/2017/03/27/heres-why-charter-operators-exiting-tennessees-turnaround-district-can-walk-away/
When I was teaching in the Lansing Public Schools in Michigan, the bond issue for schools was on the table for a public vote: YES or NO. We were asked to put on PROGRAMS for the parents in ALL schools. I did NOT do this. I thought, “The parents NEED TO KNOW first-hand what teachers DO.” So, rather than putting on a program, I decided to call all the parents with students in my class and INVITE them to drop in ANYTIME they had time. When they arrived, I put them to work. OH MY…some parents lasted only 5 – 10 mnutes and had to leave because they were already exhausted. Other parents/guardians lasted longer. They were on recess duty, helping kids do all sorts of things, and trying to understand what they needed and wanted. ALL the parents told me that they were going to vote YES for the bond issue and they has NO IDEA how HARD teachers worked and how exhausted they were.
I say: PUT the PARENTS TO WORK when they enter your classroom. Then they will know first-hand.
God for you! Way to make them understand”
Also, if you’re in a rural school district be aware that your district is now fashionable with ed reformers.
Be aware that a whole bunch of gimmicky fads are headed your way. They are newly concerned with the plight of the “working class” and they can’t replace rural public schools with charter or private schools.
My sense is it will be all about pushing rural schools to invest in cheap ed tech garbage but absurd new requirements for teachers are certainly a possibility also.
Look a gift horse in the mouth. Don’t buy without someone you trust reviewing these “innovations”.
Better yet, don’t buy anything any of these people are selling 🙂
“As the demand grows for a skilled labor force that can compete in the global marketplace, the question is: How will the Trump/DeVos team address the needs of the 50 million students who attend traditional public schools and will make up the bulk of this workforce? The nation’s future depends on the answer. ”
Ed reform can’t answer this question. The fact is this “movement” does absolutely nothing for public schools and that is becoming increasingly clear.
It still amazes me that DC was utterly captured by a “movement’ that omits 90% of US students. These people are absolutely clueless. How does that happen? How do we get a dominant public policy group that OMITS 90% of people?
I really do think it’s because so many of them didn’t go to public schools and don’t send their children to public schools. I never thought that before but how in the HELL are you a Senator from a state like Iowa and OMIT public schools from your education agenda?
It has to be that public schools are something they are just not familiar with.
http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/opinion/oped/bs-ed-devos-agenda-20170326-story.html
I have said it before & wil now say it again. Traditional statesmen [old-school, circa pre-Reagan] represent their constituents. FDR, for example, was a member of the elite who didn’t attend publicschools, nor was he a union member, nor had he ever known poverty or hunger– yet he fashioned a way forward, in the midst of globaldepression, that put middle & poor peope to work creating public works to benefit everyone.
Since Reagan & his pusilanimous ‘trickle-down’ [not] answer to global trade, bought into by both parties, we have been returned via dumping anti-trust laws & Glass-Steagall & numerous other consumer-protective laws, culminating in the Citizens’-United decision, to the pathetic low of having to hope our elective reps share our life experience in order to properly represent us [= statesmanship is gone].
The only way oiput now is get the $ out of politivs: campaign reform.
Kasich is a complete moron people and please do not let this crud wiping goon fool ya. It was reported to me from people in his office that kasich is a guy who you will see sitting in a bathroom stall reading the paper and then leave the bathroom without washing his hands….yes believe it people from a trusted source. Then goons like Kasich have this fantasy that they will become President of the US. Yeah right Kasich pipe dream buddd,,go wash your hands you ignorant goon and then take a course on education.
Kasich was lucky. He got a showcase where he appeared normal, centrist & nice compared to many of his opponents. Now that’s his national image.
Would it really be that difficult for legislators to find or hire staffers who would actually examine the state of public schools? By now, it should be obvious that perhaps there is more to the story than their reform pals want them to know.
“Sinclair’s Law”
“It’s hard to take a stand”,
As U. Sinclair once taught,
“And hard to understand
When job depends on not”
It would be unconscionable and unethical to subject the students to his presence for any length of time.
Off topic but, related to Ohio- Sen. Brown, who requested the release of $71 mil. to privatize the state’s schools, says he’s willing to oppose Gorsuch. If Brown decides it won’t cost him anything, maybe he’ll live up to his statement.
It’s time to ask the Senators to tell us their opinions about Rubio’s legislation, which proposes an across-the-board replacement for current college accreditation. Did the foundation, of the 800 pound vulture, design the new system? The testing/accreditation scheme will feature a copyright, no doubt.
Opposition to government is a great oligarch talking point. But, the rich jerks shift faster than sand, when they see an opportunity to turn student and taxpayer money into corporate welfare.
Linda, don’t mean to beat a dead horse here, but I still can’t find any documentation that Brown “requested the release of $71 mil. to privatize the state’s schools.” To be clear, I don’t agree with his stance that some charter schools do good things, mostly because he hasn’t specifically cited which ones are good. I think he is delusional about charter. But I still can’t find evidence of what you have claimed over and over again.
All the stories I have found are closer to this: http://www.cleveland.com/metro/index.ssf/2015/10/ohios_entire_democratic_congre.html, that he demands more oversight over charters.
I would be more than happy to go with you into his office to explain why he is wrong about the entire concept of charters. But I’m not comfortable to confront him about why he “requested the release of $71 million” until I see documentation that confirms it.
To beat a dead horse-The Dayton Daily News reported on the letter. (Diane may have posted Brown’s specific letter or, referenced it, because I commented that Walton’s Fordham-run schools could cheer Brown’s position but, I wouldn’t.) The $71 mil had been authorized by the U.S. Dept. of Ed., then put on hold, because of the well-publicized abuses of charter schools in the state. Brown asked King/U.S. Dept. of Ed. to release the hold. In that letter, Brown talked about his wish for controls. (Rhetorically, how’s that going, if not for Yost?) Brown is on the board of the OSU John Glenn school of public affairs, which had a 2015 leadership conference, in which charter schools were referred to as “public”, despite the Ohio Supreme Court ruling that charter assets belong to the operators. The leadership panel included only charter school supporters.
I contacted Brown’s government office and his campaign, asking if he gets campaign donations from charter-affiliated groups. They have been unwilling to answer my request for info.
There is no point in visiting Brown’s office on the subject of charter schools. IMO, his office is fully aware of the charter school implications.
To further beat a dead horse, Brown was unwilling to work for the election of the Democratic candidate who ran for Portman’s seat (reported by Ohio media).
Since I have responded numerous times to your question, I assume you reject the info. because it is not consistent with what you want to believe. Asking me again, will not change my answer.
The reason I keep asking is because you never answer my question. To paraphrase how you beat a dead horse, your responses are consistently to the effect of, “This has been written about and posted but I don’t have the specific reference.” I searched for articles in the Dayton Daily News and still have not found a reference to Brown asking to “release the hold.” Everything I found shows that Brown had the same befuddlement on the award as just about everyone else.
In one story, (http://www.mydaytondailynews.com/news/ohio-could-lose-huge-charter-school-grant/8Ge51rtlOazqwtWWv8lUrN/) I found this paragraph:
“The fraud that some Ohio charter schools and state officials have engaged in is unacceptable and it’s our students that have paid the price,” U.S. Sen. Sherrod Brown said Wednesday. “I’m grateful the U.S. Department of Education is taking steps to address this scandal and ensure that Ohio’s charter schools spend taxpayer dollars on students, not fraud and abuse.”
In another (http://www.mydaytondailynews.com/news/local-education/govwatch-was-ohio-charter-school-award-71m-mistake/SDof2afzKGl8ZoHoahAT1L/), I found these:
“Unfortunately, high-up people close to the administration in the Ohio Department of Education have fudged the numbers, or worse, falsified them,” Brown said. “If all that’s true and that effected the federal dollars, it’s particularly shameful.”
Brown said he is trying to pass a measure to increase oversight on the federal level. He sent a letter to the U.S. Department of Education demanding to know how Ohio scored so much federal dough despite a history of charter school problems.
I’m not saying you’re lying. Indeed, if you would not try to belittle my request, you might find that we’re on the same side of this issue. But I won’t trust your characterization until I see verification. And you have to present it. You rely on your recollection. Sometimes recollections can be wrong. It is obvious you hate Brown and perhaps that’s what makes you remember it in this way. And until I see proof, I’ll continue to dismiss your characterization. I’ll be happy to apologize if I’m shown to be wrong.
Ohio media recently quoted charter advocates as saying the downward trend in new charters opening, will experience an uptick when Ohio receives the $71 mil. If Brown opposed charter schools, his June 20, 2016, letter to the U.S. Dept. of Ed. (posted at Brown’s senate site) would have said three things (1) Don’t release the money. Ohioans don’t want charters, a point made in research from Columbia Teachers College about successful cities for charter schools. (2) Charter schools deny citizens democratic control of school boards and (3) the U.S. Dept. of Ed. perpetuates the deceit of the American people in referring to charter schools as “public”.
Instead, in his letter, he said,”…the CPS grant could greatly benefit students…When Ohio has satisfied conditions…ensure funds are spent for their intended purpose” i.e. charter schools.
Two more points Brown would have made. (1) He would have told the Department to let Gates/Walton fund promotion of charter schools-that use of taxpayer funds was unnecessary (2) He would have called a press conference years ago and told Ohioans that Gates and Walton heirs were spending $1 bil. each to privatize their most important common good.