Kristina Rizga, the veteran education journalist at Mother Jones, explains why Trump and DeVos love Florida. Although the state has a constitutional ban on the use of public money for private and religious schools, although the state’s voters rejected Jeb Bush’s effort to change the state constitution in 2012, Florida has figured out numerous DeVious ways to circumvent the state constitution and the will of the voters.
Jeb Bush is the permanent state minister of education in Florida, and he loves school choice. He does not like public schools. The state has hundreds of charter schools, many of which are managed by for-profit entrepreneurs. The head of the education appropriations committee in the state senate is a member of a family that owns the state’s largest for-profit charter chain. But better yet, for the purposes of DeVos, who is a religious zealot, Florida has a tax-credit plan that funnels hundreds of millions of dollars to unregulated and unaccountable religious schools.
Rizga writes:
Tax credit scholarships provide a crafty mechanism to get around these obstacles. Tax credits are given to individuals and corporations that donate money to scholarship-granting institutions; if parents end up using those scholarships to send their kids to religious schools—and 79 percent of students in private schools are taught by institutions affiliated with churches—the government technically is not transferring taxpayer money directly to religious organizations.
While DeVos is best known as an advocate of vouchers, most veteran Beltway insiders told me that a federal voucher program is very unlikely. “Democrats don’t like vouchers. Republicans don’t like federal programs, and would rather leave major school reform decisions up to states and local communities,” Rick Hess, a veteran education policy expert with the conservative American Enterprise Institute said. “Realistically, nobody thinks they’ve got the votes to do a federal school choice law, especially in the Senate.”
This political reality is perhaps why Trump and DeVos are singling out Florida’s tax credit programs as a way to expand private schooling options. While Trump and DeVos have not specified what shape this policy might take at the federal level, most of these changes will come from the state legislators. Republicans have full control of the executive and legislative branches in 25 states, and control the governor’s house or the state legislature in 44 states. At least 14 states have already proposed bills in this legislative session that would expand some form of vouchers or tax credit scholarships, according to a Center for American Progress analysis. (And 17 states already provide some form of tax credit scholarships, according to EdChoice.)
This perfect storm for pushing through various voucher schemes comes at a time when the results on the outcomes of these programs “are the worst in the history of the field,” according to New America researcher Kevin Carey, who analyzed the results in a recent New York Times article. Until about two years ago, most studies on vouchers produced mixed results, with some showing slight increases in test scores or graduation rates for students using them. But the most recent research has not been good, according to Carey: A 2016 study, funded by the pro-voucher Walton Family Foundation and conducted by the conservative Thomas B. Fordham Institute, found that students who used vouchers in a large Ohio program “have fared worse academically compared to their closely matched peers attending public schools.”
Businesses make gifts to Step Up for Students. They get a tax credit. Step Up for Students gets a hefty cut of the take. It currently has about $500 million to use to fund vouchers for private and religious schools that the state does not regulate or supervise. The voucher-receiving schools report attendance, but are not subject to the state standards, curriculum, or tests, and they do not report on academic performance.
Why did they choose Florida for their national model of school reforms?
Maybe they heard Florida say “Our reforms are based on FCATs” but thought Florida said “facts”.
Or maybe they actually read Florida’s claim and thought FCATs was just a typo.
UGH
To answer the question posed:
The Jebster!
So many refuse to see that absolute connection; Jeb’s “chiefs for change” strategy continues to be the big game to watch.
The FL Supreme Ct several years ago told legislators their voucher funding of private schools was unconstitutional, along with a few other ‘bad rulings,’.e.g., the Court found the legislature’s re-districting favored the Republican Party and tossed it out. And now the Republican legislators are going to punish the Court for meddling in its business, “violating separation of powers.”
We have a really, really nasty Republican speaker of the Fla House – . Richard Corcoran, who gets to appoint a slew of his buddies to a committee to develop revisions to the Fla Constitution in 2018. Corcoran has vowed to include term limits for all judges, including the Supreme Ct;, “to revise the Fair Districts amendments (put in the constitution through the citizen referendum), repeal the court rulings that invalidated private school vouchers and reinstate the ability of the Legislature to make redistricting decisions in secret without being forced to reveal their intentions under oath in court.”
Each of those rulings, “violated the separation of powers, and the will of the people was thwarted,” Corcoran said in an interview.
Corcoran was made in the same mold as Trump. Not sure if he is just dumb, as in not understanding how separation of powers works, or just a plain pathological liar.
.
Jeb Bush came to Missouri in support of expanding charters statewide. Some rural Republicans are opposed.
Jeb bush is weak and has no energy….my question to good ole jeb is why does he dislike public education?? After all, good ole Jeb has made a career working for the public in public service and yet this low energy man dislikes public education. Come on Jeb, I cannot help but think that if your daddy wasn’t the pres then good ole Jeb probably would have been an insurance salesman. Can you picture Jeb Bush knocking on your door saying state farm here!! Oh but wait, Jeb’s dad is somebody so Jeb has an opinion of public education and he does not like it. OK Jeb but what qualifications do you have that entitles your opinion and gives any weight to why Jeb does not like public education but rather likes school choice. Remember Jeb, walk down the isle and look at all the bad “choices” you have to choose from when in the supermarket proving that choice is not always good when you have bad choices to choose from.
Don’t forget that Jeb opened Florida’s first charter school in Liberty City in Miami. He had lots of photo ops. Got lots of publicity. When the school closed, he disappeared.