The New York Times reports that billionaire Betsy DeVos refuses to sell her interest in Neurocore, a company that uses biofeedback to enhance brain functioning. She has a direct conflict of interest. Will that stop her nomination? I wouldn’t bet on it. It didn’t faze Republicans that she knows nothing about federal law regarding children with disabilities. Why should they care that she will use her position to enrich herself? When is enough enough?
The committee vote on DeVos will take place on January 31. Call your Senators’ offices. Speak to his or her aides. Urge them to vote NO on this unqualified, uninformed party debutante. She is not entitled to be Secretary of Education as payback for hundreds of millions of donations to the Republican Party.
“Betsy DeVos, the billionaire school choice advocate selected by President Donald J. Trump to serve as education secretary, is a strong supporter of using biofeedback technology to help children and teenagers enhance their performance in school.
“Ms. DeVos and her husband, Richard DeVos Jr., are major financial backers of Neurocore, a Michigan company that operates drug-free “brain performance centers” that claim to have worked with 10,000 children and adults to overcome problems with attention deficit disorder, autism, sleeplessness and stress.
“In an agreement with the Office of Government Ethics made public Friday, Ms. DeVos said that she had stepped down from the Neurocore board but that she would retain her financial interest in the company. She valued that stake at $5 million to $25 million in her financial disclosure statement.
“On Friday evening, Senator Lamar Alexander of Tennessee, the Republican chairman of the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, said he would delay the initial vote on Ms. DeVos’s nomination by a week, until Jan. 31, as Democrats argued that the process had been rushed through, without enough time to answer remaining questions about her financial disclosures.
“Ms. DeVos and her husband promote Neurocore heavily on the website for Windquest Group, a family office the couple use to manage some of their many investments. The website, for instance, includes a link to a Washington Post article about Kirk Cousins, a Washington Redskins quarterback who describes how he “retrained” his brain to better perform on the field by going to a Neurocore center.
“But the claims that Neurocore’s methods can help children improve their performance in school could present a conflict for Ms. DeVos if she is confirmed as education secretary — especially given that the company is moving to expand its national reach.
“Neurocore, founded about a decade ago, operates seven of the brain performance centers in Michigan and recently opened two in Florida. It has said it has plans to open as many as seven other centers across the country this year. Ms. DeVos’s financial disclosure shows that she and her husband have an indirect interest in the company through a family partnership.
“Richard W. Painter, a White House ethics adviser under President George W. Bush, said he was familiar with Neurocore and applauded the business and education concepts behind it — but he said the DeVoses would be better off selling their interests in the company.”
California teacher Jack Covey sent the following comment on this news story:
“I am very sensitive to the needs of students
with disabilities.”
— Betsy Devos, at her confirmation hearing,
in response to a question from Senator Murray.
I think we now may have a little clarity as to what
she meant by that remark … as in when such needs
benefit her investment portfolio.
QUICK BACKGROUND:
Neurocore — a totally unscientific, quack medical
“bio-feedback” company that claims to cure autism, ADHD, etc.
where it operates nine “brain performance centers,” where
the controversial “drug free” cures offered there are not recognized by
any entity or anyone in the mainstream medical establishment.
Despite its grandiose claims of success, Neurocore has never consented
to have these practices tested or investigated in peer-reviewed
studies.
… “snake oil” is how Jennifer “Edushyster” Berkshire
referred to it in a recent tweet:
https://twitter.com/EduShyster/status/822793877614710788
Indeed, the Michigan Dept. of Insurance has upheld
insurance company denials of coverage for any Neurocore
“cures” on the grounds that there is zero evidence supporting
the efficacy of any of their treatments. These repeated
denials and upholding of these denials contradict
Neurocore’s website, which claims that their treatments
are covered by insurance carriers.
Betsy and her husband are two of Neurocore’s main investors
via their umbrella company Windcrest, which also is the
main backer of that Boxed Water being peddled to
the struggling citizens of Flint, Michigan. (a photo
of Betsy at a school site, included a product placement
for this “Boxed Water.”)
Her stock ownership and membership on Neurocore board of directors
was discovered two days ago — alas, after her confirmation
hearings.”

Potential conflicts of interest are currently worn as badges of honor.
LikeLike
These folks are not interested in leading by principle or considered judgment, they plan to improvise and magically bestow divine powers that allow the chosen ones to win over all others, uber alles. So conflicts of interest do not register.
LikeLike
Who’s going to be the Secretary of Agriculture, again? The CEO of Herbalife?
LikeLike
I wonder if there is a connection between Neurocore and “gay conversion therapy.” We know that DeVos’ mother was involved with this belief as was Mike Pence. In addition to the obvious conflict of interest, DeVos may have a fundamentalist Christian motive for keeping this company. In any case how many more reasons do we need to drop this woman? We have to keep in mind that in United States of Trumpistan evidence and facts are meaningless!
LikeLike
Not that it matters, but I’ve been wondering whether Heavens to Betsy might actually believe this works. I’m certain her education went kinda light on science.
LikeLike
And light on history, too.
LikeLike
There is no evidence that any claims of success are true. Sounds like value added. Sounds like charter scams. It’s a crazy new batch of pseudoscience to go with the last. Bill Gates says he hopes Trump will get rid of regulation. Betsy DeVos says she hopes to one day learn the definition of the word regulation.
LikeLike
LeftCoast Teacher: much appreciate the remarks by you and others on this thread, but if I may indulge in a little nitpicking…
The title of this posting has perhaps led us to be a little unfair.
It’s true that Betsy DeVos refuses to divest from “Brain Enhancement” Corporation but she has, lo these many years and quite openly, divested herself completely from her brain.
Now that ought to be worth at least a little something, dontcha think?
😎
LikeLike
K.TA,
You made me laugh aloud. I just watched a replay of the Los Angeles district charter school division’s report to a school board committee. APEX Charter brags it will continue with its Competency Based Education model and hopes to finally meet its reclassification targets — this time, by 2021. Apparently, Betsy DeVos’ divestment from authentic brain usage is old hack. It’s already been done, and on a large scale. We’re all set up for this scenario.
So, here’s what we do, we put DeVos on a computer — no, we teach DeVos to use a computer… no, we teach DeVos what a computer is. Eventually, we put her on a device and use CBE to collect data for DeVos’ Big Database profile. Will she learn what the scientific method is? No. Will she learn anything? No, CBE doesn’t teach anything well. We will, however, treat a billionaire like they treat us for once. We will, however, show that to run a snake oil company, to run the DoE, to run the USoA, you don’t need intelligence anymore. This is the 21st century! All you need is grit.
LikeLike
DeVos doesn’t have grit. She never needed it. She has billions to hire people with grit.
LikeLike
Right, sorry. All you need is inheritance.
LikeLike
Fits with the anti-vaxxer, anti-science mindset.
LikeLike
And pro-Creationist.
LikeLike
I’ve been doing a little Mercedes-Schneider-ish on-line sleuthing regarding the latest revelations about Betsy Devos’ and her “brain cure” company Neurocore, which alleges that it can provide miracle cures for kids suffering from autism, ADHD, epilepsy, etc.
In a nutshell: Scientology-lite.
“Scientology” in that Neurocore’s treatments are a money-making scam, based on utterly bogus pseudo-science, the practices and technology being utterly ineffective in treating what it claims that it can treat, and with no scientific basis whatsoever.
As with Scientology, so-called “medical experts”/ non-experts also engage in high-pressure sales tactics to get customers to pay for more and more of Neurocore’s “treatments.”
Most of the time, the patients and their parents complain that they’ve been scammed.
“Lite” in that no one is getting a full-on Scientology-style brainwashing. Not yet anyway. At this point, Betsy and Co. just want your money.
And with the power of U.S. Department of Education behind her, there’s no telling what Betsy could do: financial incentives to states — a la Race to the Top — encouraging their schools and state education departments to mandate or encourage the employment of Neurocore to treat kids with autism, ADHD, epilepsy, etc.?
If that happens, we’re talking hundreds of millions will be going to a company primarily owned by Betsy and her husband.
Given Betsy’s other connections, I would suspect that some fundamentalist Christians allies of hers are behind all of this nonsense… though I have no proof of this as yet, just my guess. There’s an anti-Science pseudo-science at work here that often goes hand-in-hand with Christian extremists (“intelligent design,” anyone?)
In some cases, the patients are assured that they have made “progress”, and the patients’ trust in Neurocore’s seeming authority sometimes might lead to a placebo effect of feeling you’ve made “progress” when you really haven’t.
Put yourself in a kid’s shoes: you get to watch full-length Disney animated features (SEE BELOW) during your “treatment, “and will watch more Disney full-length cartoons in further treatment sessions.
What kids wouldn’t claim “progress” or emerge happy from a “treatment” or happily go to further “treatment”?
In other cases, the parents of kid Neurocore patients, and adult Neurocore patients are absolutely livid, and report the whole Neurocore experience as a money-depleting scam.
(Complaints are in a link BELOW).
Neurocore’s YouTube videos are a joke.
In the following promotional piece, kids sit in cubicles and watch the Disney animation hit “FROZEN”, while wearing headphones, and having their breathing and heart rates monitored, using a highly toxic encephelogram cream applied to the skin just above the EKG nodes. (the toxicity accusation is from a complaint in another link later in this post).
This Frankenstein freak show takes place in Neurocore’s “Neuro-feedback Brain Performance Centers,” nicknamed “The Brain Room” where Neurocore’s resident expert “Dr.” Tim Royer explains how the video player pauses when it’s detected a patient’s loss of focus or interest — detected via the “bio-feedback” monitoring. Watch this video (it’s only 2:48), and just take in the absurdity:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UO1c2lnXJR4
“There’s nothing like this in the world,” enthuses “Dr. Tim”. Yeah, I bet!
Indeed, watch “Dr. Tim” explain how the little girl patient “Emily” gets rewarded for staying focused, or for returning to being focused — the film FROZEN continues playing, or returns to playing, respectively — “sort of like ‘sticker charts’ for the brain … adapting a brainwave related to sleep … allowing us to bring her into the zone where the brain is perfectly balanced … making sure that oxygen is going to the brain in an appropriate way. … ”
Huh?
” … where the brain is perfectly balanced … ” Hmm, as opposed to being “imperfectly balanced”, or it being “perfectly unbalanced.”
” .. making sure that oxygen is going to the brain in an appropriate way. … ” Hmmh… as opposed to “oxygen going to the brain in an inappropriate way.
Whatever you say, “Dr.” Tim.
I was wracking my brain as to what this pseudo-scientific farce reminded me of, and then it hit me. It’s sort of a white-faced version of AMOS’ ‘n ANDY — in the scenes where the Kingfish would attempt to verbally and otherwise demonstrate scientific expertise in a field where he has none:
In the following video, the Kingfish claims simultaneous expertise as a doctor and aviation instructor (?!) when giving Andy a physical examination as a preface to teaching him to be a pilot. NOTE the expert exam to see if Andy’s heart is “running alright”, or whether Andy has “20-20 vision,” then how the Kingfish tests Andy’s “equib-uh-larium”, by attempting to “certificate ya.”:
(at about 11:15 – )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IYClXtGZr8
(at about 11:15 – )
Yeah, yeah, I’m fully aware that AMOS’ ‘n ANDY was and is racist-as-all-Hell, but please bear with me, as I’m trying to make the point that what the Kingfish is doing to Andy is not very far removed from what Neurocore’s Dr. Tim is trying to put over on unsuspecting people. There’s but a hair’s difference between the two
I apologize to anyone offended by including this video.
It’s also reminiscent of Scientology’s “Purification Run-down”, where Scientology patients/religious adherents stay in a scalding sauna for hours on end while popping
an endless number of unidentified vitamins … all to “purify” the body of “thetans” — the spirits of dead aliens that inhabit all human beings. (Medical experts have also been skeptical of this, to say the least;-) )
Here’s Neurocore’s slick introductory video, where it claims its work is “based on decades of clinical research.”
Yeah? By whom? And why won’t you allow independent researchers to study your “cures”?
https://www.youtube.com/user/NeurocoreMedia
Customer complaints are vociferous, yet there’s no “money back guarantee” here. Neurocore’s patient contract is written so that the “contract ensures (Neurocore’s) protection whether they fulfill their obligation (actually cure autism, ADHD, epilepsy, etc.) or not”: (BELOW is that quote, included in the first complaint listed)
http://www.complaintsboard.com/complaints/neurocore-c324014.html
BELOW is the third complaint from the above link, written by “organic fan.” Note the similarities to Scientology (or EST or its current incarnation Landmark Forum), in that the staff are all about putting on the hard sell and signing you up to pay for more and more Neurocore “treatments.”
Also, as with charter schools and their untrained, uncredentialed teachers, those administering Neuro-core’s medical psychiatric treatment are young — mostly college-aged. As with the Kingfish in the earlier video, they have ZERO actual medical education or expertise (outside of Neurocore “expert training,” of course) As with Scientology, think of the cost savings / profits where you can pay your untrained “medical personnel” minimum wage. This is a total money mill scam:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
organic fan:
“The staff is young, uneducated and barely trained in brain-solving issues, but their training is mostly in selling you the program.
“It is a mass production enterprise that doesn’t pay attention in results, but mostly in signing you up for an over-$3000 program. They have a computerized system to make appointments that is not verified, so many mistakes are made and double appointments are booked.
“One assistant is supposed to view/adjust your progress during the session and do seven other people at the same time in the same room…very unreliable!
“Some of the staff are rude and (patient) hygiene is not their priority. They reuse the same earphones and other device, from one person to another, without any cleaning. The Ten20 cleanser and conductive cream they use, are highly toxic and applied on the ears and the cranium. Research has shown some of the ingredients like methyl and propyl parabens in their cream to be carcinogenic and one wouldthink the application on the skin with an electrode makes it even more absorbed by the body. Glycerin and Polyoxyethylene20 cetyl Ether also have a long list of side effects that nobody at NEUROCORE wants to hear about…liability is the issue here…
“They are pushing you to refer people before you ever know what the session is all about and frankly, are unaware of people’s needs. No therapy here, and the contract is worded carefully, so that if you don’t get any result, you can’t blame them.
“Do your research before spending your money there.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
… and here’s one more complaint from adult Neurocore patient “Jane Vander Sloot (further down the page at the same link ABOVE),
Here, as in the first YouTube video above, Jane talks about just watching movies while being monitored.
When she asks how and why the Neurocore treatment works — the precise scientific mechanisms, that is — she gets stone-walled:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
JANE VANDER SLOOT:
“So I started going to The Neurocore. All appointments have to be made online, which is confusing and frustrating and overall, employs a horrible software system that creates scheduling problems. I also have to agree with the fact that they seem to hire only men and women who are college age and don’t seem to really understand how everything works or why it isn’t working.
“After going for months and spending tons of money, I saw absolutely NO progress, even though their ‘reports’ showed my ‘progress.’ After thinking it may all be a scam, I found it to be absolutely TRUE as the whole process involves being hooked up to probes while watching a movie.
“Somehow, mysteriously, your brain gets ‘re-trained’ by simply watching the movie. Well, my sleep deprivation was so bad at the time that after a few weeks, I’d actually fall asleep while ‘watching’ the movie.
“Lo and behold, their stats and charts still showed I was making progress! How the heck does your brain re-train itself when you’re asleep and not following the protocol?
“HUGE SCAM.
“And ALWAYS be weary when they won’t tell you HOW it actually works. A good doctor, therapist, etc. will always explain IN DETAIL how their process works and what to expect over time.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
More on “Dr.” Tim, in the next post.
(HINT of what’s ahead … I always put “Dr.” is in quotes.)
LikeLike
BIG NON-SHOCKER AHEAD:
“Dr.” Tim is not a real doctor.
Thanks to the work of “The Distracted Mom”, who details this on her blog, we now know that Neurcore’s Dr. Tim is not a medical doctor, though he employs treatments that are usually associated with, and can only legally be administered by an actual physician with and M.D. degree.
First, who is “The Distracted Mom”?
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“About Carolyn
“I’m Carolyn Mallon, RN, and I have ADHD. I’m also parenting at least one ADHD child, so it makes for quite an adventure! I don’t have all the answers, but I certainly share the challenges of many ADHD parents! I started this blog as an exercise to help us improve our game at home and at school.
“Join us!”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
How refreshing! An ADHD parent expert with actual medical training who admits that “she doesn’t have all the answers.” … unlike Betsy, the bigus “Dr,” Tim and Neurocore..
Here’s the post where Carolyn outs Neurocore’s “Dr”. Tim on his misrepresentation of himself:
http://www.thedistractedmom.com/recognizing-credible-sources/
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
THE DISTRACTED MOM (Carolyn Mallon, Registered Nurse)
“Does Neurocore’s Timothy Royer (who calls himself ‘Dr. Royer’ on Twitter) pass the credibility test?
“Well, his PsyD degree is in psychology, not medicine, and he has no published research to be found. His site does not provide links to research studies that would indicate how he might substantiate his claims about raising the IQ with his technique or to back up his claims of so many patients who no longer require medication after his treatment.
“Finally, he most definitely has a vested interest in selling his product: a very expensive treatment program which may not be covered by insurance, leading one to question the efficacy of the treatment.
“While Royer’s claims are interesting and appealing to anyone who depends on medication to function normally, without conducting any research studies or publishing his findings for peer review, his claims remain unsubstantiated and anecdotal at best.
” … ”
“As concerned parents or adults affected by ADHD and related disorders, we see a lot of headlines designed to grab our attention. Many of them sound like they are reporting new scientific findings, and some of them are… but others are peddling their wares and hoping to influence consumers or impress them with false authority. Every responsible consumer should know how to critically analyze an article or study, especially when the it concerns their health and money.
“Many of these press releases and articles do not link to any studies at all, but rather reference “research” in a nebulous way. Others may use buzz words and scare tactics or rely on implied authority. Others may appear like legitimate reporting but may actually be selling something. The ‘Fish Oil’ headline above, for example, looks like a press release, but scroll down in the “article,” and you’d see that it’s an ad for a supplement and that it doesn’t even link to any research at all!
“How to Spot a Dubious Source
“When evaluating the credibility of a source, first examine the author’s credentials and institution affiliations. Some are well-respected (major universities and government institutions), but others can appear well-respected but are agenda-driven (the Discovery Institute).
“When evaluating an author making any big claims, you should examine not just their degree, but also if they have any credentials from the field or any peer-reviewed published research.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Here’s one final tidbit:
“Dr.” Tim presents and promotes “Neurocore” at … wait for it … Amway conventions, where a captive audience of thousands of Amway fanatics have to listen to him promote “Neurocore.”
C’mon! You had to see THAT ONE coming. After all, both Neurocore and Amway are owned by … the proposed Secretary of Education Betsy Devos and her husband. If Betsy becomes Secretarry of Ed, you don’t think she’s going to take advantage of every opportunity to get rich, mix things together, and engage in conflict of interest whenever she has a chance to make a buck?
Billing himself as “Dr. Timothy Royer”, he puts on a hard sell about Neurocore’s theories and treatments at an Amway convention.
I can’t find any video yet, but I would presume that, in part, he was pushing Amway sales partners to employ Neurocore for themselves as well as pushing others outside Amway … again, all the while Betsy and Dick Devos own both Neurocore and Amway.
Here’s a tweet from an Amway salesperson devotee looking forward to the presentation:
https://twitter.com/JohnW_3/status/621307607689658372
And to get an idea of what these Amway Nuremberg-rally-style conventions are like (and what Amway’s all about), watch this Dateline NBC expose video BELOW. NOTE how Amway keeps changing its name — rebranding itself as “Quixtar” or “Alticor” or whatever to fool unsuspecting people who already know what a scam Amway is:
(Hey, at 2:04, isn’t that Betsy’s husband Dick Devos speaking to the masses — making the ridiculous promise that they all can “have a wonderful life” and “make millions” — with Betsy looking on admiringly?)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xL6QHHO4-6Q
(Hey, at 2:04, isn’t that Betsy’s husband Dick Devos speaking to the masses — making the ridiculous promise that they all can “have a wonderful life” and “make millions” — with Betsy looking on admiringly?)
LikeLike
I just thought of another comparison to Neuro-core’s farcical pseudo-science.
Back in the 1980’s, SCTV did a TV parody of a National Enquirer-based TV show (actually called the “The National Midnight Star” TV Show), and the late John Candy would portray a medical expert or “Top Researcher.”
Here he is explaining… Dr. Tim-Neurocore-style … how “dreams can kill you”:
(at 00:16 – )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VbvvftwZbOo
(at 00:16 – )
ANCHORMAN: “Your dreams can kill you, say Top Researchers.”,
TOP RESEARCHER: (graphic reads “Top Researcher”)
“It’s true. Say you were dreaming that you were at a party, and that you’re just wearing … your underwear … or you were running, and you were being chased, but it was real slow because your feet were like lead … and you’ll …
“You’ll probably die.”
LikeLike
Should we call this “justice” or an eye for an eye? The DeVos’s who have tricked millions of people with their pyramid scheme known an Amway are getting a taste of their own medicine. The difference is this investment may cause a small dent in DeVos’s portfolio, but they won’t have to sell their house or empty out the kids’ college fund the way some Amway dealers have had to. I just had sickening idea that pseudo-scientific “neuro-training” could be one of the ways the $20 billion in ESSA funds gets flushed down the corporate toilets.
LikeLike
“I just had sickening idea that pseudo-scientific ‘neuro-training’ could be one of the ways the $20 billion in ESSA funds gets flushed down the corporate toilets.”
BINGO!!!!
That’s why, on Friday, Betsy reluctantly, and under pressure, made the hollow gesture of stepping down from the Neurocore Board of Directors, but stubbornly insists on keeping the ownership of her Neurocore stock. What’s the point of being Secretary of Ed, and using her cabinet position to promote Neurocore, if she know longer owns stock in Neurocore, and won’t financially benefit from this promotion?
That sort of defeats the whole purpose of her millions of donations to Trump’s campaign — once she stopped opposing him and came on board.
LikeLike
Great research work, Jack! If only Elizabeth Warren had had this in her hands on the day she grilled De Vos about how she’s treat fraudulent for-profit education programs.
Neurocore –brought to you by Trump’s psycho corps.
LikeLike
These self-righteous capitalists claim they’re the heroic “producers” while the rest of us are useless “takers”. But this shows a product that is sheer garbage. Trump U. and Amway too. Trump’s casinos –what good do they produce? I am sick of these loathsome people who rise to the top not because they’re smarter, but because they shed their morality (if they ever had it).
LikeLike
Any representative that votes to confirm Betsy DeVos must be targeted to lose their next election. Maybe we can seek an alliance with the people who organized the protests that filled cities and towns around the world on Saturday, January 21.
LikeLike
When is enough, enough, enough, enough, echo, echo, into the void of nonreflection.
LikeLike
Free market frenetics refuse to divest from brain entrenchment corporation.
LikeLike
Jennifer “Edushyster” Berkshire found Neurocore’s “promises” page and tweets it here:
Yes, that’s right. Neurocore promises to raise a person’s IQ by 12 points!!!
I’m curious. Why 12 IQ points? Why not 11 or 13? or 20 or 30? Exactly how did they calculate that number?
The same way they make sure that “oxygen flows to the brain in an appropriate way”?
Or by “putting the brain in perfect balance”?
I’m starting to imagine what it was like when a “medicine tonic” or “snake oil” salesman would come through town back in the Wild West, and put on a demonstration on the back of his wagon.
“This here tonic is GUARANTEED to raise your IQ by 12 points!” he shouts, holdiing the bottle. “Do I have a volunteer from the crowd?!” At which point, a pre-planted shill in the audience raises his or her hand, comes up on stage, drinks some tonic, then starts talking in some faux-intelligent manner.
The internet-era version of those shills are the testimonials at the bottom of the Neurocore page (JUST BELOW).
https://www.neurocorecenters.com/the-patient-treatment-experience
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“Neurocore:
“First, we identify real causes.
Then we train the brain to fix them.
“When you come to one of our Brain Performance Centers, you’ll experience a proven program based on your individual brain data.
“It’s safe, easy, and painless—with no side effects and no medication.
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“Brain Diagnostics
“How well is your brain working?
“Using advanced qEEG technology, we find out. Sensors are attached to record your brain’s electrical activity. We analyze the data to identify the sources of your symptoms and develop a program focused on your challenge. We build your database through a variety of methods:
” — Electroencephalogram (EEG)
” — Heart Rate Variability (HRV)
” — Integrated Visual and Auditory Continuous Performance Test (IVA)
” — Behavioral Checklist
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“Brain Performance Training
“At a Neurocore Brain Performance Center, our 45-minute neurofeedback and biofeedback sessions take advantage of your brain’s ability to change – its neuroplasticity. With neurofeedback, you watch a movie that plays only when your brain speed is within the therapeutic range. When it goes out of range, the movie pauses, which tells you that something is out of balance. During the 30-session program, your brain learns how to stop spiking out of range, and brain function improves. With biofeedback, you learn to breathe deeper and slower to maximize your heart function, allowing proper blood and oxygen flow.
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“Lasting Results
“ADHD
Adult ADHD
Anxiety
Autism
Depression
Memory
Migraines
Sleep
Stress
Teen ADHD
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“As you progress through the 90-day program and you optimize your brain activity, your symptoms recede. For the long-term, neurofeedback creates positive, permanent physiological changes in the brain that will help keep you well.
” — Over 10,000 children and adults have used our services for long – term improvements.
” — 75% of people who complete our program are able to reduce or eliminate their use of medications.
” — On average, neurofeedback can increase IQ by 12 points.
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“Our Stories
“Changing my brain changed my life.
Charles C. – Bloomfield Hills Center, January 2017
“I suffered from anxiety for more than half of my life. Everyday I lived with the fear of anxiety driven panic attacks.
“I no longer fear the onset of a panic attack. What is better is I no longer think I will even have a panic attack.
“At first I was extremely skeptical of the treatment I was receiving and really only continued with it out of desperation. Other treatments such as medication only worked for so long and came with side effects associated with various medications. When I heard about Neurocore on the radio I thought for sure it would be a placebo effect or simply not work at all. I jokingly called it Neurocore voodoo… I called and am now so glad I did. I can honestly say I have a different outlook on my life. My fears have diminished or are gone completely. Most people have no idea what life is like with the fears I had and today I can say that I’m starting to feel “normal”… No more fear!
“The staff at the [Bloomfield Hills] location exceeded my expectation in every way. I can’t say enough good things about them all. Very talented, caring, supportive and everyone seems to have a real passion for what they do. I wouldn’t be where I’m at today without them. I thank them all!”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Jennifer B. – Livonia Center, January 2017
“[Reasons for coming to Neurocore] Uncontrolled ADD and anxiety that was not responding to treatment and seemed to be getting worse.
“My daughter is more confident, relaxed and able to sleep better. She is doing better in school and more focused. She is a little bit more sassy..lol… but it is nice to see her come out of her shell. She has made friends in school and is less shy and fearful.
“Highly recommend. This is treatment for ADD through technology. Nothing else was working, even medication, for my daughter. Tried multiple different meds and different groups and classifications and nothing worked and sometimes made the symptoms worse. This program works and you’re not putting more medication in their little bodies.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Larisa – Boca Raton Center, January 2017
“I was very angry and moody, always in trouble. I had a lot of anxiety and lost focus easily. I was very aggressive.
“I am calmer. I can go to class and stay focused. I don’t fight with my mom as much. Neurocore was very helpful. I was on the brink of madness and I didn’t know what to do. Neurocore really helped me calm down and get a hold of myself and my anxiety/focus.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Anonymous – Livonia Center, January 2017
“Because my mother suffered from Alzheimer’s, I was beginning to fear I would too. My ability to focus and process information seemed to be slowing down. Even simple sentences were taking me longer to process. Also, my energy level seemed to diminish later in the day.
My short-term memory and long-term memory have improved. When I stated to my daughter with whom I share a house that I felt that my memory was better than my sister who is five years younger than me, she quickly agreed with me. She has also told me that my thinking has become sharper than my other sister who is two years younger than me. I feel more energetic now up until my bedtime. I enjoy parties more now because I don’t feel so tired…I feel more confident about myself now. Thank you!
The entire staff always clearly explained what they were doing and always asked me if I had any questions. I never asked any questions. Everyone has been very professional in their tone and attitude towards me. Never had to wait for my appointment times.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Anonymous – Grandville Center, January 2017
“We brought our son to Neurocore to mainly help him to be able to focus without using medication. He is now able to complete homework assignments without reminders or minimal reminders!”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Anonymous – Livonia Center, January 2017
“[Reasons for coming to Neurocore] Stress and anxiety overall and needed a way to bring myself back down to a calm state of mind and find tools that I could use moving forward without the use of medications
I have so many tools to help me in times of stress and worry and resources to turn to as well. It has opened my eyes to so many day to day small routine changes that have made a difference and I will continue to work on.
Just a great experience with wonderful people to help me.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Anonymous – Grandville Center, January 2017
“I actually have energy during the day and my mind no longer feels like it’s eroding away or in a fog. This now makes it possible to properly function in life and have actual clarity. The first time I came actually was very enlightening as to why I was having certain problems.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
LikeLike
Michigan blogger Mitchell Robison has also chimed in on the Neurocore fiasco, claiming Devos “is not just unqualified; she’s dangerous”:
http://www.eclectablog.com/2017/01/betsy-devos-is-not-just-unqualified-shes-dangerous.html
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
MITCHELL ROBINSON:
“The news that Betsy DeVos will not divest her financial interest in Neurocore, a Michigan “biofeedback” company, should alarm anyone who cares about the health and safety of our children. Because this is not simply a financial issue; it’s part of a disturbing trend in Ms. DeVos’ involvement and activism in education, and her potential confirmation as Secretary of Education.
“As reported in the New York Times, DeVos “is a strong supporter of using biofeedback technology to help children and teenagers enhance their performance in school…Ms. DeVos and her husband promote Neurocore heavily on the website for Windquest Group, a family office the couple use to manage some of their many investments.”
“The only problem with this is that Neurocore’s “product” is not a pedagogical technique, or even a widely accepted medical intervention. In fact, Michigan’s Department of Insurance and Financial Services recently denied a claim for Neurocore’s services:
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
…a randomized, prospective, single blind single center controlled trial was done to access the efficacy of biofeedback in reducing the frequency and severity of migraine and tension type headaches. Sixty-four patients with migraines with or without aura and/or tension type headaches, age eighteen to fifty-five, who had suffered from headaches for more than one year, were entered into the study. Patients were randomly assigned to receive biofeedback in addition to the basic relaxation instruction or relaxation techniques alone. Biofeedback training consisted often, fifty minute sessions utilizing standard electromyogram (EMG) feedback from the frontalis and trapezius muscles and temperature from the third finger ofthe dominant hand. Visual and auditory feedback was provided. Thirty-three patients were assigned to receive biofeedback plus the relaxation techniques and thirty-one, the relaxation techniques alone. All patients were asked to respond to periodic questionnaires for thirty-six months.
In their conclusion, the authors state that biofeedback is an extremely costly and time consuming treatment modality that, in their study, provided no additional benefit when compared to simple relaxation techniques alone in the treatment of migraine and tension type headaches in adults.
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
“While Ms. DeVos believes that biofeedback is a valuable strategy for addressing ADHD, medical experts are not at all convinced that this disorder can be effectively diagnosed, or treated, through electroencephalography:”
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
A 2013 article in The Detroit News questioned the efficacy of diagnostic testing for A.D.H.D., citing an article in the American Academy of Pediatrics News that suggested more research was needed.
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
“The medical research here doesn’t seem to have made much of an impact on Neurocore’s advertising pitch:
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
“In its marketing materials, Neurocore makes a direct pitch to parents, featuring the personal stories of numerous children in YouTube videos and offering tips on Twitter about helping students focus at school.
On Friday, Neurocore posted a typical tweet —
“ ‘Do you suspect your child may have teen ADHD? Check out these common signs/ ” —
with a link to its website and a photo of a student at his desk.
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
“Or on the thinking of the corporation’s chief medical officer:
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
Still, Dr. Fotuhi expressed confidence in the field. “It’s in its infancy,” he said, “but I can envision in the coming years, we’ll have objective data”…He said Neurocore had recently begun analyzing its data and results would be published soon in a scientific journal.
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
“Here’s what is dangerous about this issue: medicine and education are not professions that can afford to employ a “Ready, Fire, Aim” approach. Before physicians, or teachers, apply a technique or intervention with patients, or students, it is incumbent upon them to rigorously and strenuously test, examine, and analyze those strategies in experimental settings, and to vet these ideas widely and transparently in an effort to determine any potential problems or unintended consequences.
“Dr. Fotuhi’s acknowledgement that while Neurocore has just recently begun to gather and examine data on their biofeedback techniques, but is already advertising their services directly to parents at a cost of $2000 per session, is terrifying. And the fact that Betsy DeVos stands to benefit financially from this reckless activity is absolutely disqualifying with respect to her confirmation as Secretary of Education.
“Even more disturbing, the evidence here suggests that DeVos’ involvement with this untested medical intervention masquerading as pedagogical “product” is merely part of a larger trend in Michigan’s charter school sector.”
LikeLike
Amway products in every school and Pay to Succeed paying out to Wall Street because ALL the special ed students will have been cured by 3rd grade.
Wondering if DT participated in any neuro sessions?
LikeLike
Not too long ago we had a President whose wife believed in astrology as a way to find the answers to all of life’s problems. Astrology for her; therefore, her husband was the answer to lead us all down the right path of life. This Neurocore BS sounds like another form of witchcraft, like PARCC and Common Core, that will be forced down the throats of the Students in our Public Schools using millions, billions of taxpayers dollars. Beware America, the wicket witch of the North, DeVos, is soon to be confirmed. Clicking your heels will not get us out of the mess she will create.
LikeLike
This is very scary, and what most parents “in the know” would label “new age.” In my school if a teacher taught yoga as a part of P.E., we had parent permission slips filled out first. How this “new age,” Scientology-like practice even fits in with her brand of Christianity I can’t even fathom, unless the end justifies the means to radically change kids.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Permission slips for yoga? Yoga is exercise.
LikeLike
when the “end” is the accrual of massive personal income, MOST abusive/failing actions mandated for school reform have been quickly justified
LikeLike
Lol, I assumed DeVos had already been confirmed. Not that I really think that is a lauhing matter. I was working on a new post on new blog so I had to go back and edit it. I have sort of a different take or perspective on the whole mess if there is any interest: https://edreformfarceandfolly.blogspot.com
LikeLike
“I always thought of public education as a civic blessing and opportunity, especially for the lessers of this world.”
Please give us an explanation of the “lessers” of this world. TIA, Duane
LikeLike
*** ATTENTION: Betsy Devos’ “Neurocore” is, at bottom, a religious/Bible-based concoction ***
Jennifer “Edushyster” Berkshire first guessed this might be the case in a tweet (and I followed soon after on this site, but didn’t have any definitive proof until now.)
Yes, folks, there’s a fundamentalist Christian underpinning to this Neurocore’s pseudo-scientific crapola.
The video below shows a lecture from Neurocore founder “Dr.” Timothy Royer, where he intersperses his supposedly scientific facts with quotes from … you guessed it … The Bible.
I kid you not, folks.
NOTE: “HOPE 139” is the earlier or former name of Neurocore, created by Dr. Tim Royer. The number “139” refers to a verse in the Bible, from THE BOOK OF PSALMS, BELO “Dr.” Tim cites this verse as the foundation of “HOPE 139, later renamed as “Neurocore”:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
PSALM 139: “I praise You (God), because I am fearfully and wonderfully made by You.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
This video is from back when Dr. Tim’s Neurocore was called “HOPE 139.”
In the excerpt below, “Dr.” Tim — who’s not a real medical doctor (SEE EARLIER POST) —- carries out his powerful and scintillating “Linda Demonstration.”
First, he lines up a bunch of women all sharing the same first name, “Linda.”
Why?
Well, to invoke “The Bible”, of course.
(The CAPITALS and parentheticals () are mine, JACK)
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
( 5:40 – )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULfZtu8wv3I
( 5:40 – )
“Dr.” TIMOTHY ROYER: (carrying around a silly model of the brain while he talks)
“But when we look at each ‘Linda’, even though they have the same name, they’re the same sex (gender), every one of their brains is unique, AND GOD KNIT THEM TOGETHER IN A VERY SPECIAL WAY. They may have the same name, but they will never be like each other.
“You may have the same diagnosis as a hundred people in this room, but that doesn’t make you the same as everybody with that diagnosis. YOU HAVE BEEN CREATED (by God) IN A VERY SPECIAL WAY.
“HOPE 139, who sponsored tonight’s event, IS ROOTED IN A PASSAGE IN THE BIBLE, FROM PSALM 139, that says:
” ‘I praise You (God), because I am fearfully and wonderfully made by You.’
“Every ‘Linda’ has been ‘fearfully and wonderfully made’ (by God). Their brains have been knit together (by God) in such a way before the foundations of the world, that they will never be like each other.
“And even though the world’s pushing on you to become … or go into a box, I want you to know that everybody in here is special, and created in special and created in a very unique way, and you have a unique purpose.
“And your brain. You need to go and learn to know your brain.
“Linda’s, go a head and sit down. Thank you for coming up. Awesome.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Seriously folks, watching this video is truly an embarrassing experience. Both he and all the Christian extremist audience members are completely oblivious to how “Dr.” Tim is making a complete ass of himself.
Shortly after the brilliant, “Linda” demonstration, “Dr.” Tim babbles away about brain “electricity” and how the food we eats affects “the electricity” coursing through a brain’s “power plant” made up of “a quadrillion neurons/”.
“Oooh, al-righty then!” as Ace Ventura might say.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hS1okqbnePQ
Again, COMPARE “Dr.” Tim’s lecture to the scene from AMOS ‘n ANDY where the Kingfish attempts to verbally and otherwise demonstrate scientific expertise in a field where he has none:
In the following video, the Kingfish claims simultaneous expertise as a doctor and aviation instructor (?!) when giving Andy a physical examination as a preface to teaching him to be a pilot. NOTE the expert exam to see if Andy’s heart is “running alright”, or whether Andy has “20-20 vision,” then how the Kingfish tests Andy’s “equib-uh-larium”, by attempting to “certificate ya.”:
(at about 11:15 – )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IYClXtGZr8
(at about 11:15 – )
Is there any substantive difference between “Dr.” Tim and The Kingfish?
LikeLike
Sweet Jesus! “Dr. ” Tim’s lecture is crazier than a soup sandwich!
To visually demonstrate the ineffectiveness of psychiatric drugs, he puts on white sports headband that he tells the audience will represent “the brain” — being careful to mention that the headband was donated by a professional basketball player sitting in the front row.
Why that fact is relevant or important to mention, I have no freakin’ idea.
To set up the demonstration, the headband has earlier had velcro material glued on it or sewn into it. He then takes some pharmaceutical pill bottles that also have velcro glued on.
(Go to 18:49 )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULfZtu8wv3I
(Go to 18:49 )
When you go to a psychiatrist, “Dr. “Tim claims, the psychiatrist then prescribes medication, and that looks something like this. He then sticks the the pill bottles — one after another — onto the headband, all the while running down the so-called expertise of the man “who went to medical school” or “graduate school” who’s doing the prescribing.
Eventually after all the pill bottles are stuck on, “Dr.” Tim looks like he’s wearing Batman’s utility belt on his head.
For that full visual just go here:
(Go to 23:07 )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULfZtu8wv3I
(Go to 23:07 )
Don’t you see how silly that using psychiatric meds is? says “Dr.” Tim via this visual.
All the while, “Dr.” Tim is a guy whom most of the audience falselly presumes is a medical doctor, when he’s actually not one, and he’s trashing someone who actually DID go to medical school.
The mind boggles.
LikeLike
There’s more lunacy in Dr. Tim’s lecture. It just gets worse and worse.
After quoting percentages and statistics about the number of children who suffer from learning disabilities, “Dr.” Tim then goes for another riveting visual.
( 33:27 – )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULfZtu8wv3I
( 33:27 – )
When you’re a child with learning disabilities, “Dr.” Tim tells us, it’s as if you’re in a prison. A spotlight then illuminates a prop “jail cell” with bars, and within it is an adult performing the role of a child (wearing kids clothes), a child whose “imprisoned” by disability.
“It’s as if you’re in a prison,” sadly reports “Dr.” Tim.
The actor, portraying a mentally disabled child, attempts to read a book, then repeatedly throws up his hands and head in frustration, with some of the worst over-acting and gesticulating outside of a 1920’s silent movie.
For this full visual go here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULfZtu8wv3I
( 33:45 – )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULfZtu8wv3I
( 33:45 – )
To further illustrate the child’s low achievement, the word “KAT” is spelled on a poster board — presumably, that’s the level of the disabled child’s writing skills.
God save us all!!! This can’t be real!!!
THIS GUY is Betsy Devos’ expert on how to treat children with learning disablities???!!! The guy putting on this freak show?
LikeLike
When you subscribe to a worldview where faith trumps science, you open yourself up to all manner of charlatanry. Witness the success of Neurocore…and Trump.
Dr. Tim’s presentation is very much like the professional development sessions we teachers endure.
LikeLike
If any professional development at our school had the presenter strapping pill bottles to a headband, so he ended up looking like he was wearing Batman’s utility belt on his head, the presenter would have been laughed out of the room.
Remember David Coleman’s lecture when he said that journal writing or personal writing should be banned because these kids need to learn that, “when you grow up, no one gives a sh#% what you think”?
Well, that prompted a post from me last August and is applicable to “Dr.” Tim of Neurocore’s presentation:
posted on AUGUST 2016
Viewing one of Coleman’s lectures on YouTube is, for a veteran teacher, a simultaneously horrifying and surreal experience.
It’s like watching someone who never went to medical school, coming in and giving a lecture to an audience full of trained surgeons, where — with total certainty of his expertise — he dictates and demonstrates to them how they should conduct an appendectomy, blathering away in nonsense jargon that Coleman himself invented: (what the f— is “close reading”, anyway?):
——————————–
DAVID COLEMAN (demonstrating his newly-invented techniques for on a live but anesthetized appendectomy patient, with Coleman’s efforts being projected on a giant screen the audience can see):
— (affecting an Edward-G.-Robinson-ish cadence)
“Well, first, you cut open the patient-guy’s guts HERE, see? Then you gotta retract the frag-i-stat tissue HERE, while ya got the nurse-babe next sucking out a bunch o’ blood with this cool mini-vacuum thing-y, see. Then when that yucky blood’s all cleared away, that’s when take this little knife —
— (looks up at the audience of surgeons)
“You guys call that a scalpel, right?
— (glances back down in the patient’s guts)
” … yeah.. .what-ever … and now ya gotta cut away ‘n remove this funny-lookin’ whatcha-muh-whooz-it over here — that’s that appendix-thing, right? — and then after that, it’s a good idea to stop and rest for a sec while you take a good swig of some Diet Mountain Dew…”
— (quaffs deeply from a Diet Mountain Dew can, then resumes)
“Ahhh… that hit the spot .. and then your proceed to .. ”
—————————
The actual surgeons in the auditorium would react like the audience for “Springtime for Hitler.” Go here to get the idea:
( 2:20 – 2:26 )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHmYIo7bcUw
( 2:20 – 2:26 )
I’m only slightly exaggerating here with that above surgeon comparison parody. It’s positively insane that this pompous, know-nothing douchebag was ever afforded even the slightest credibility when it comes to the pedagogy and curriculum that teachers should use with children.
God save us all!!!
Seriously, my fifth graders spend the first half-hour of every day writing one of Coleman’s hated “personal narrative” assignments (while consuming LAUSD’s “Breakfast in the Classroom”.) Before class, I write the prompt on the board, so it’s waiting for them when they walk in. Then they all have a crack at it in their “Daily Journal”.
Yesterday’s prompt was written thusly:
—————-
Friday, August 26, 2016 —
TODAY’S PROMPT:
“If you could talk one-on-one to President Obama, what would you say?
“What do you think the problems are that he needs to address? In In Los Angeles? In your neighborhood? In the country as a whole?”
———————-
These kids are dirt poor residents of East L.A., and their writings are often quite brilliant. A couple of the girls are almost Republican when it comes to law-and-order get-tough-on-crime stuff, while a couple others wanted Barack to arrest Trump for “hate speech”… gotta love those kids! T
I later projected the best work on the whiteboard for the entire class to read, using a document reader-projector combo.
Oh yeah, and, I want to say, perhaps in part just to spite David Coleman …
… I actually do “give a sh#% what they think.”😉
In addition to helping them develop a point of view and learn about a topic (in this case “civics”), it’s also a good way for the kids to simultaneously learn grammar, punctuation, spelling, basic writing strategies, etc. I correct every mistake in real time, with the entire class watching, and this leads to improvement in all these areas.
LikeLike
Nailed it, Ponderosa!
LikeLike
“Dr. Tim’s presentation is very much like the professional development sessions we teachers endure.”
What?? You ungrateful ingrate. You aren’t satisfied with being professionally developed??
LikeLike
MORE ON THE Neurocore video:
At various times, “Dr.” Tim Royer condemns traditional mental health treatment because … wait for it … it doesn’t have “an exit strategy,” or a point at which the treating physician terminates use of a certain medication. “Dr.” Tim then condemns any prescribed course of medication from the mainstream medical establishment that has no such termination.
He makes an asinine analogy of an ambulance with pharmaceutical treatment.
Eventually, that analogy leads up to this comment:
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
( 23:13 – 23:20 )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULfZtu8wv3I
( 23:13 – 23:20 )
“Dr.” TIMOTHY ROYER:
“HOPE 139 (Neurocore’s former name) and the (HOPE 139’s) Reclaim (Your Brain) series is not about a short-term pharmalogical fix. The best medicine for the brain is the brain itself. The best medicine for the brain is the brain itself.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
“The best medicine for the brain is the brain itself” —which he repeats twice in succession — is code for Neurcore’s unscientific quackery.
Then later on, “Dr.” Tim ridicules traditional medicine.
Just go to a psychiatrist office, he tells the audience, and “have a good laugh” by asking that licensed physician what “Dr.” Tim believes is the ultimate “Gotcha!” question.l
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
( 26:56 – 28:00 )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULfZtu8wv3I
( 26:56 – 28:00 )
“Dr.” TIMOTHY ROYER:
“For those of you with ADHD, if you want to have a good laugh, go into your physician’s office and ask him … or her — and I have a lot of good friends that are physicians — but ask them:
” ‘What is the exit strategy … for my medicine?’ ”
— (DRAMATIC PAUSE as if he’s made some powerful “Gotcha!” moment)
“You know I had those medicines on my head.”
— (puts back on the idiotic headband with the pill bottles velcroed on it)
“When … WHEN … do I get to get rid of one of these things? What’s the exit strategy?” What IS the EXIT STRATEGY for stimulant meds? THERE IS NONE! OKAY?! You’re just GOIN’ forever with it, and you gotta wonder with all this STUFF in here.”
— (reaches up the headband with the pill bottles velcroed on it)
“And I go to talk to somebody, and I say, ‘Hi, I’m Tim.’ ”
— (DRAMATIC PAUSE)
“Well, AM I Tim? Or WHO am I? Am I REALLY everybody I was made to be, or am I Tim-plus-all -these-other-things?”
— (reaches up the headband with the pill bottles velcroed on it)
“Who AM I under the surface there? For the ADHD child and adult, they always wonder:
” What would I be like without medicine?’ ”
— (takes off back on the idiotic headband with the pill bottles velcroed on it)
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Re-read the last few sentences there. Psychiatric medicine, “Dr.” Tim implies, is going against God’s design of you as a person: “Well, AM I Tim? Or WHO am I? Am I REALLY everybody I was made to be (by God), or am I Tim-plus-all -these-other-things?”
Again, it’s the same anti-science, pseudo-science that is at the core of the extremist Christian mindset of Betsy Devos and her allies.
Earlier, “Dr.” Tim said, “The best medicine is the brain itself “— which, again, is code for “You need to use Neurocore’s treatments,” —which to date, are total quackery, and have no scientific basis whatsoever, and have never been studied or proven to have any efficacy whatosever.
Incredibly Dr. Tim then immediately pivots to the area where Neurocore is at its weakest.
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
( 28:00 – 28:11 )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULfZtu8wv3I
( 28:00 – 28:11 )
“Dr.” TIMOTHY ROYER:
“(At HOPE 139 / now Neurocore) we use quantifiable data. That’s what we’re about here (at Neurocore). Objective science of the brain, and understanding what is at the core of the diagnosis.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
This is the most ludicrous statement of all, made back in 2012.
THE TRUTH:
NEUROCORE HAS ZERO, NONE, ZILCH, NADA “quantifiable data” OR “objective science” backing up any of its treatments. Neurocore’s has ZERO “understanding (of) what is at the core of the diagnosis.”
As for trashing the concept of idea of accessing mainstream medical establishment, and taking prescribed medicine on an on-going basis, or even a permanent basis, here’s some thoughts.
With some medications, yeah, a patient sometimes has to take it for an indefinite period of time, or perhaps for the rest of the patient’s life… unless a medical breakthrough of some kind comes up with an alternate treatment. To just condemn or dismiss out of hand any and all such treatments as harmful or wrong is nonsense. Whether it’s insulin, or high-blood-pressure medicine or countless others, yes, there is “no exit strategy” to some conditions, unless the exit strategy is to stop taking it and eventually die.
The reason that Dr. Tim — a uniquely untrained quack who doesn’t have the medical training or licensing to diagnose a case of the “sniffles”, or to prescribe children’s aspirin — the reason he’s going after traditional medicine is the same reason that Scientology goes after it:
Mainstream medicine is Neurocore’s competitor.
Betsy Devos and other Neurocore honchos want to discredit traditional psychiatric therapy and treatment so that people with ADHD — or so that parents of children with autism, ADHD, autism, etc., who are in need of such legitimate treatment, will instead first choose to go to Neurocore, or for those who are getting legitimate treatment, they will abandon that in favor of Neurocore.
That’s dangerous, very dangerous.
That’s also why the fine print of Neurocore’s contract carefully polnts out that Neurcore guarantees NO POSITIVE RESULTS, and indemnifies Neurocore against any lawsuits that patients might file — you’re doing this at your own risk, so if something goes wrong, you can’t sue us.
The latest is that Dr. Fotuhi, a Neurocore representative, claims that they’ve been recently ollecting positive data, and promises that, in a few years, they’ll have data that verfies that Neurocore works.
Two problems with that:
1) you need a non-involved outside entity to make that determination — a peer-reviewed study, for example, conducted by a group with no financial gain. You can’t trust people who have a financial interest in the outcome of a study to control a study. Duh!
2) Assuming you accept that Neurocore can study itself, shouldn’t the folks and Neurocore FIRST do the studies that prove Neurocore’s efficacy before embarking on experimental treatment of patients?
A few posts earlier, Mitchell Robinson calls this the “Ready, Fire, Aim” approach to experimental medical technology medical technology.
Dr. Fotuhi, WHY DON’T YOU CEASE ANY AND ALL NEUROCORE TREATMENTS IF AND UNTIL YOU HAVE PROOF THAT IT WORKS?
Why? Because you can’t make money if you do that.
LikeLike
As per usual, Jennifer “Edushyster” Berkshire knocks it out of the park with her latest takedown and of Neurocore and Betsy Devos — hot off the presses :
http://edushyster.com/betsy-devos-alternative-facts/
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
January 23, 2017
by EduShyster
Betsy DeVos’ Alternative Facts
From Common Core to Neurocore, the right candidate for Trumpian times…
Image result for neurocore brain trainingAfter Betsy DeVos’ rocky confirmation hearing performance, she quickly became fodder for memes and late-night comic commentary. But what ya’ll are missing is that DeVos herself is in on the joke. As she prepares to take her spot in the highest IQ cabinet ever assembled, she’s the only cabinet member who has a real stake in raising your IQ—by 12 points. DeVos knows that in this, the age of alternative facts, no one gives a hoot about the difference between proficiency and growth. The testimonial is where it’s at. So Neurocore, the biofeedback company that she won’t be giving up on, has no research behind it. Who cares??? Neurocore changed Charles C’s brain and changed his life, and it helped football player Kirk Cousins take his game to the next level. If the plural of anecdote is data, then the plural of testimonial is franchises. To the brain rooms, reader, we’ve got qEEG data to collect and a national expansion to plan.
Before we get to how great Neurocore is, let’s take a quick look at how easy it is to retrain your brain. This won’t take long because it’s that easy.
At a Neurocore Brain Performance Center, our 45-minute neurofeedback and biofeedback sessions take advantage of your brain’s ability to change – its neuroplasticity. With neurofeedback, you watch a movie that plays only when your brain speed is within the therapeutic range. When it goes out of range, the movie pauses, which tells you that something is out of balance. During the 30-session program, your brain learns how to stop spiking out of range, and brain function improves. With biofeedback, you learn to breathe deeper and slower to maximize your heart function, allowing proper blood and oxygen flow.
I told you it was easy, and best of all it works! More than 10,000 adults and kids have been Neurocored for long-term improvements, including getting smarter and no longer having to take meds. But don’t take Neurocore’s word for how great Neurocore is, or the word of the, um, doctor behind the brain retraining train. Let’s hear from someone who experienced for himself how life can be transformed thanks to Neurocore’s non-invasive, brain-strengthening neurofeedback program. Like Betsy DeVos’ brother-in-law Dan DeVos, who is now working with more energy and focus as he explains in this Neurocore testimonial. Note: Amway employees and their families are now eligible for a Neurocore Diagnostic Brain Assessment for $100 off the regular price, which I believe is referred to as multi-level marketing.
Now for the bad news: brain retraining doesn’t come cheap. Collecting qEEG data to identify neurological weakness, developing a personalized brain performance plan and restoring the brain to optimal functionality, all the while being monitored in a brain room will set you back $2200—which may or may not be covered by insurance. That’s bad news if you’ve got a stodgy insurer who insists on dated data metrics, like peer-reviewed studies (yawn). But wait—good news: Neurocore is now partnering with Prosper Healthcare Lending to assist clients with program financing. Also, be sure to ask a Neurocore team member about the Neurocore Scholarship Program.
Seeing green
As I read more about Neurocore, I felt the part of my brain that houses my recollections about Michigan education scandals light up. Had I not just encountered an expensive and, um, experimental miracle cure that claimed to make students smarter? Indeed, I had. I speak, of course, of Integrated Visual Learning, the brain-child of one Steve Ingersoll, the optometrist turnedMitten state edupreneur who was recently sentenced to 41 months in federal prison for tax evasion. While Neurocore is laser focused on the brain’s neuroplasticity, Integrated Visual Learning or IVL trained its sights on the gateway to the brain: the ocular orbs. Students at Ingersoll’s charter schools were hooked up to a machine to see if their eyes zigged and zagged across a page of text from the usual left to right. If not, expensive therapy was in order. Like Neurocore, IVL posted impressive results as self-reported on its website. At Ingersoll’s charter schools, Ritalin prescriptions were dropping and test scores were rising as throngs of students made the transition to visual learning.
Say what?
Imagine my surprise, then, when on my travels through Michigan last month, I found myself in the offices of a charter school lobbying org, listening to a lobbyist explain that Ingersoll’s schools were actually shining stars in Michigan’s charter landscape. My own eyes zigged and zagged in response. But the guy just got sent to jail! I responded. But as was patiently explained to me, I’d been looking at the matter upside down. Ingersoll’s sentencing was proof that the system works—checks and balances—while the fact that kids at the charter schools continued to excel even as the founder of the Excel Institute was being led away in handcuffs, well, that was what we should be talking about…
Two ends of the same cash cow
As Michigan State prof Mitchell Robinson explains here, the overlaps between the sordid saga of Steve Ingersoll and his experimental vision treatments, and the brain retraining of the DeVos-backed Neurocore, are obvious—even to the untrained eye. Both train right in on the apparently lucrative market of parents, so desperate to help their kids avoid the ADHD-drug trap that they’ll fork over thousands of dollars for treatment, even if insurance won’t pay for it. Ingersoll only got caught, by the way, because his criminality crossed over federal lines; in a robust education marketplace like Michigan’s, pushing questionable products onto desperate parents is just fine. Michigan officials were helpless to do anything, despite a mountain of complaints from parents and whistleblowing teachers at his schools, and the tireless work of local bloggers who worked to expose this glistening, quivering underbelly of edu-fraud to the light. Most tellingly, even as Ingersoll was under a restraining order, prohibiting him extracting yet more cash from his charter school cash cow, he and his business partners were peddling a refreshed version of their innovative curriculum.
Breathe deeply and sign here
Reader: if you felt your brain spike out of range whilst you were reading this, I recommend that you learn to breathe deeper and slower to maximize your heart function, allowing proper blood and oxygen flow. And focus on the fact that in addition to serving as our Secretary of Education, Betsy DeVos will also be propelling the expansion of Neurocore into a national brand. No longer will customers have to reside in the excellent states of Michigan and Florida in order to enjoy the benefits of brain retraining. Neurocore is currently evaluating other markets for expansion and will expand in those markets that make the most sense, and also cents. It won’t be long before you too will be working with more energy and focus, just like Betsy DeVos’ brother-in-law, who, as visual learners can immediately discern, has a plane. In the meantime, the wine box will have to do…
LikeLike
Education Week quotes multiple medical authorities who say Neurocore’s claims of curing autism, ADHD, etc. are bogus.
Neurocore responds with no independent data, but … testimonials, and “internal” data.:
http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/DigitalEducation/2017/01/devos_company_questionable_claims_autism_adhd.html
LikeLike
There is nothing new or revolutionary about using biofeedback for autism remediation. It has been tried for the past 40 years and most results are anecdotal rather then empiric. Dr. Amen of huckster fame, has long been a proponent and has written extensively on this form of treatment. I have worked with professors and sociologists who are believers, and others who consider it a farce.
It seems weird that this is where DeVos draws her line in the sand…makes me wonder if she and her family use this to try to increase their own IQs? Bizarre considering how many of her 102 holdings are far more dangerous (weapons, mercenaries) and egregious (lenders and collecting student debt).
From google….About 374,000 results (0.81 seconds)
Brainwave Neurofeedback for Autism: Can It Help? | Psychology Today
https://www.psychologytoday.com/…/brainwave-neurofeedback-autism-can-it-help
Jun 12, 2013 – Teaching children with autism to control their own brainwaves through neurofeedback may help to improve their symptoms.
Autism and Biofeedback Therapy
http://www.answers-about-autism.info › Autism Therapies
Autism and biofeedback. What is Biofeedback? Can it help my autistic child? What is Neurofeedback? Where does Hemoencephalography fit in to this?
Neurofeedback and Autism, Aspergers, and ASD | Brain Training …
http://www.aboutneurofeedback.com › Conditions
Neurofeedback, or brain training, can help people with Autism, Aspergers, … Neurofeedback uses biofeedback technology to establish healthier brain patterns.
Neurofeedback Training Elicits Behavioral … – Autism Speaks
https://www.autismspeaks.org/…/neurofeedback-training-elicits-behavioral-improvem…
Feb 27, 2008 – Mu suppression can be measured simply using electrodes placed on … to control his own brain frequencies with the help of visual feedback.
EEG and Autism | EEG Education and Research – EEG Spectrum
http://www.eegspectrum.com/applications/autism/eegandautism/
EEG and Autism. EEG biofeedback therapy for youngsters with autism is a new frontier. ACN is collecting related anecdotal reports; studies have not yet been done. … While all autistic children undergoing EEG biofeedback training may not have similar results, it appears to be an area worthy of exploration.
Is EEG-biofeedback an effective treatment in autism spectrum … – NCBI
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22903518
by ME Kouijzer – 2013 – Cited by 25 – Related articles
Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback. 2013 Mar;38(1):17-28. doi: 10.1007/s10484-012-9204-3. Is EEG-biofeedback an effective treatment in autism spectrum …
Neurofeedback Helps Those With Autistic Disorders, Study Finds …
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/02/080226185848.htm
Feb 28, 2008 – Research on autistic spectrum disorder (ASD) shows that neurofeedback (EEG biofeedback) can remediate anomalies in brain activation, …
Neurofeedback Brain Training and Autism, Aspergers, and ASD …
http://www.centerforbrain.com/conditions/autism-aspergers/
Neurofeedback can help people affected by Autism, Aspergers, or other Autism Spectrum Disorders or ASD. Brain training can be an alternative to medication …
EEG Info – Austism Research – Neurofeedback, EEG Biofeedback …
http://www.eeginfo.com/research/autism_main.jsp
Autism. Articles. Neurofeedback for the Autism Spectrum [pdf] by Siegfried … can be an effective schoolbased intervention for children in the autistic spectrum.
Autism Spectrum – The NeuroDevelopment Center
https://neurodevelopmentcenter.com/neurofeedback…/neurofeedback-for-aspergers/
Dec 31, 2016 – She was diagnosed with Asperger’s disorder, a form of autism spectrum … treatment for Aspergers that could complement her other therapies.
LikeLike