Fifteen years ago today, our nation was subject to a horrific terrorist attack. Four civilian airliners were hijacked, two smashed into the World Trade Center in New York City, one struck the Pentagon, and a fourth was forced down into a field as a result of the bravery of the passengers who sacrificed their lives to prevent further loss of lives.
If you were alive and cognizant, you will never forget that day. I remember the day President Kennedy was assassinated. I will never forget 9/11/2001.
I can never forget that day because I lived right across the harbor from the World Trade Center, in Brooklyn Heights. It was as gorgeous, cloudless day, as beautiful as it ever gets in the fall. I was sitting at my breakfast table when I heard a thunderous sound, which I wrongly assumed was either a sonic boom or a crash on the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, a highway that abuts New York Harbor. My partner called from work and told me to turn on the television; something terrible had happened at the World Trade Center. I did, and I saw one of the tall buildings on fire at the top. What happened? Did an airplane hit it by accident? I ran down to the waterfront, a two-block jaunt, and as I looked up, I saw the second airplane hit the second tower. I stood there with half a dozen people. We didn’t speak. We all took a deep breath. We knew it was no accident. I watched the plumes of thick black smoke and the flames, and I knew that people were being incinerated. I could see what was happening but at the same time, I didn’t know what was happening ran home to watch television to find out what was going on. After 15 minutes watching and listening, I ran back to the waterfront. Then the wind shifted, and the dense cloud of smoke turned towards east, where I was standing. I could no longer see anything. Small bits of debris and ash were falling everywhere. The cars were coated with ash. Later, in my backyard, I found a charred piece of paper that had been on someone’s desk, and except for some burn holes, it was intact. It had floated gently from his or her desk across the river to my yard. After my partner came home, we went to the nearest hospital to see if we could give blood. They turned us away. They said no blood was needed. We walked to the foot of the Brooklyn Bridge and watched hundreds of people trudging slowly across the bridge, from Manhattan to Brooklyn. They were dazed. Some were shoeless. All of them were coated in ashes. We went back to the house. We were glued to the television, filled with apprehension and sorrow. We watched the buildings collapse, one after the other, knowing that many people were still inside. We stayed inside, because outside, the air was thick with the dust from the burning towers. There was a peculiar smell in the air, an acrid smell of burning plastic. That smell remained for weeks. We watched television, we were glued to the screen. The city ground to a halt. No subway service, no bus service, nothing flying overhead except fighter jets. It became very quiet, except for the sound of sirens. The sound of sirens continued for days. Gasoline stations quickly ran out of gasoline, so not many people were driving. After some days, when we were able to walk across the bridge, we saw the photographs, posted everywhere, on every empty wall: have you seen this man? have you seen this woman? Missing. Help. For months afterwards, I could not stop thinking of the people who were trapped in the towers, especially at night. I traveled to a family wedding in November in Texas, and people were surprised that I was so obsessed with what had happened. To them, it was a news story, but it was over. For me, and for everyone else who had a personal connection with that day, it will never be over. I don’t have nightmares anymore, but the vivid memories will be with me always.
Let us never forget. I won’t.

I vividly recall where I was on that horrible day. I was a teacher in a small upstate NY school. I had a class of French 5 students, Seniors, and they didn’t have class due to an extracurricular activity, so I had a little “free” time. I walked into the library to read the newspaper, and the librarian had the tv on. She told me what was happening and we all watched the day unfold on tv. Students began to come into the library on their free periods to watch the news. Needless to say, there was not much French teaching for me or the students that day. Most of the day was spent answering students’ questions and allaying their fears and comforting their tears. Tells you a little something about the role of a teacher.
LikeLike
On my drive to school that morning, I could see the Twin Towers, emanating plumes of smoke in the distance. Everyone in the classroom, when I arrived, was glued to the TV.
My daughter, who was then a Barnard C. undergrad was unreachable, as NYC phone lines were clogged/down, and it was only my then husband, a Time-Asia editor in Hong Kong, who kept us in touch with each other, at that terrifying time.
Many students at Montclair High School, where I was undergoing doctoral training lost a parent/s. My doctoral cohort, each one an NJ public school teacher, reported that night in class, that in every one of their classes, there was a student who had lost a parent/s.
Before I left NJ for CA, I visited the 9/11 memorial and now I teach about it to my students when we discuss Maya Lin’s work. Those two reverberating waterfalls descending into immense, gaping black holes give you a sense of a rushing, inescapable, fall to your death.
LikeLike
I was teaching middle school English that morning and as had become custom in my room, we were watching the news on CNN. As the horror unfolded live in front of my students, I had the take out their journals and write what they were thinking. The story was very real to the class as several had been to NYC the preceding summer and the uncle of one worked in the tower. (Thankfully he was not yet at work that day.)
LikeLike
When news of the attack came to the middle school where I teach, the administration was very pro-active. Many people in our suburban town work in lower Manhattan, and the goal was to avoid distressing any students whose parents were in “the city” at the time. We were instructed not to mention the attack, but if students asked, that “Something happened in the city, but we don’t know the details.” By 2 PM about a third of the children had been picked up by their parents, and the busses were lining up for dismissal when the principal came on the PA, and gave a short explanation of the “Incident.” He told the students that attendance for Sept 12 would be optional. The next day only 2 of 1400 students came to school. Both were my students.
I teach ESL, and both students had their first day of school in the US on Sept 10, 2001. We called home and had the parents pick them up. There were no classes in our middle school that day.
Later on, I heard how other schools on Long Island handled the situation. Some teachers allowed elementary students to watch the tragedy unfold live on TV! I was proud of the way our district responded to events, and 15 years later, I am proud to be a teacher in a school district that always strives to do what is best for its students.
LikeLike
I have many direct memories of 911. I was in an IST (student intervention) meeting at my school in the NY suburbs when the secretary came in an told us about the first plane. I could not believe it as it was a clear, cloudless day. When the second plane hit, we adjourned the meeting as parents started coming to pick up their children. By noon about forty percent of the students had gone home. A frantic father came into the gym where students were eating lunch. He was screaming, “They’re all dead. I saw them jumping.” The principal and several of us got him out of there and tried to calm him down. This man was a news helicopter pilot, and he was right by the towers “covering the story.” He and his younger son had to get psychological help because of the trauma the father had experienced that day.
After the dust had settled, we discovered had many other connections to the events of that day. In my district one teacher’s son perished along with the husband of another that was a fire fighter in tower two. The parents of two other students in the district also died that day. My son actually saw tower two fall from his school in Hackensack. The father of one of my son’s friends escaped from tower 1, but he was in the vicinity when it fell. He died from leukemia six years later. We found out that one of the men that rushed the hijackers on United Airlines flight 93, Jeremy Glick, was the older brother of one of my daughters’ classmates. It is a day that is forever etched in my mind.
Now retired in Florida , I attended a wedding in New Jersey this summer. My husband and I decided to visit the 911 Museum and Memorial. We were touched by the number of visitors from all over the world. While it was a bit uncomfortable, I felt I had to pay tribute to all those that lost their lives that day. I am also moved by a tribute the local ROTC in my Florida town (yes, they train them early to serve) from the high school. Each year they place over 2,996 flags in front of the school and roll call the victims. I was very touched that these young people, most were barely born when this happened, would do this. https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10209390060900864&set=pcb.1178608668862310&type=3&theater
LikeLike
Jon Stewart has been fighting to get adequate medical coverage for the first responders. Let’s remember them on this day and tell Congress to do the right thing.
LikeLike
I just heard last night on one of the 9/11 specials that 160 firemen have died from one company in NY because of illnesses resulting from that day.
LikeLike
I was a software engineer at the time, working in Gaithersburg, MD. It’s located about 25 miles north of the Pentagon in the Maryland suburbs of DC. The previous day, I had just gotten back from a red-eye flight from San Francisco.
Brian walked into my office that morning and said, a plane has flown into the World Trade Center. What? I was so confused. How does a plane fly into the WTC? We were working in an office of five engineers, myself included. We all went into Brian’s office because had a radio. I called my wife and told her to turn on the TV. Then the second plane hit the WTC. Then Flight 77 crashed into the Pentagon. We called our main office in Reading, MA and they told us to go home.
My wife and I sat glued for hours to the TV set in shock. We heard about Flight 93 crashing north of us in Shanksville. If that plane had not crashed, it would have flown right over my office on its way to the White House or Congress.
Friends of ours left their offices in downtown DC and walked miles north to find transportation out of the city to their homes. My wife’s office was right near NASDAQ in a DC suburb.Police surrounded it and evacuated nearby office buildings because they thought it might be a target also.
When I later went back to work that week, there were constant fighter jets flying over the suburbs of DC. Nine days after, I had a flight scheduled to Casper, WY. It was right after flights were allowed again. When we had boarded the plane and sitting in our seats, the pilot and co-pilot slowly walked down the aisle greeting each passenger as they went. I’m sure it was not just for our comfort that they were doing that; they were checking us out too. All of us passengers were very respectful to the pilots. Those early flights afterwards could not have been easy for them.
When I arrived in Wyoming, someone picked me up at the airport to drive me to my hotel. As we passed home after home, they all had American flags outside. I saw firsthand the the unity that Diane spoke of above. We were not democrats and republicans and conservatives and liberals and greens then; we were indeed the United States of America. There has never been that much unity in America in my lifetime.
I will never forget that day.
LikeLike
Oh, and Diane has her educator heroes. I have my short list of heroes from various walks of life, and the Americans on Flight 93 are my heroes.
LikeLike
I agree 100%. I watched a special the other night on the Pentagon attack. I had no idea it was damaged so badly. One person on the show described how it was critical the cold water and gas lines maintain integrity to fight fires and avoid more damage. A small group of custodians, plumbers, and electricians went into the basement of the damaged sections without hesitation or saying a word. It was risking death to do their job. We may never hear all the stories.
LikeLike
It was a sad day indeed.
But without knowing the truth as to what caused three modern high rise buildings to collapse as they did has never been fully investigated. The federal NIST report only discusses what happened right up to the initiation of the collapses and not how the buildings could have collapsed in the fashion they did.
To understand what really happened to those three buildings that day see what over 2,600 architects and engineers, many of whom have designed and worked on such buildings, have signed onto as what probably happened in the collapse of those structures 15 years ago.
No, it’s not a conspiracy theory, it’s science and a “fidelity to truth” attitude that guides their research. See: http://www.ae911truth.org/
LikeLike
While good to have opposing views, this small group claims unknown perpetrators, a massive cover up, internal conspiracies, planted detonation devices. Possible, but maybe a profit motive is also at work here. PBS (Frontline?) had a great overview of the structural failures. The buildings simply were not designed to handle the impact of two large jets full of fuel. Who would have imagined that when they were built? It was truly a sad day.
LikeLike
Bin Laden was a structural engineer. I recall a tape he made where he expressed great pleasure that his plans were executed as he planned
LikeLike
Yes. I think it is good to support scientific method, but I read the link Duane posted and it is some bizarre conspiracy stuff. Bin Laden hoped the attacks would weaken American resolve and western alliances. He underestimated US.
LikeLike
Sorry, but one of the four essential rules of this blog is no conspiracy theories, eg, 9/11 was an inside job, 9/11 was planned by the CIA/Mossad or someone else. 9/11 never happened, it was an elaborate stage show by the Bush administration to get us into war, the Jews inside were warned in advance.
There are Truther sites for this discussion. This is not one of them.
LikeLike
It has nothing to do with a “conspiracy theory” whatsoever, Diane. It has to do with scientific analysis. I have not, nor do these architects and engineers, you know the professionals who know how these buildings are designed and built using their knowledge and expertise to attempt to analyze how THREE high rise buildings could have collapsed in the fashion they did. They have explicitly stated that their work is from an engineering and architectural viewpoint/knowledge and not from a “who done it” but a how it could have happened given the knowledge of how these buildings are designed. And it can’t have happened the way the FEMA and NIST reports suggest because those reports do not say anything whatsoever about the collapses per se. The reports both stop at the point that the buildings begine to collapse.
Just as you and I don’t accept what many of the edudeformers and their supporters, what you call a “corporate agenda” (of which many of my successful business friends deride as a “conspiracy theory”, and I understand their concerns about using the “corporate takeover of public education” meme) say and do, I cannot accept the government’s reports on the collapse of those buildings.
I challenge you to go to the site itself and read what over 2,600 certified practicing professionals, architects and engineers with the working knowledge of the science and engineering involved in those buildings. Just like we prefer to listen to the practicing professional teachers when it comes to pedagogy rather than someone like David Coleman, Arne Duncan, John King and their ilk, I prefer to listen to those experts who actually understand the science behind modern high rise buildings.
LikeLike
“. . . this small group . . .”
Over 2,600 architects and engineers should be considered a “small group”? I think not!
LikeLike
Duane,
If you keep it up with the conspiracy garbage, you will be placed in moderation, which means I will review your comments before they are posted and delete any that assert that 9/11 was a conspiracy (by whom? The CIA? The Israelis? The Jews? Always convenient to blame the Jews.)
LikeLike
I question the validity of that number. It’s like the climate deniers claiming support of thousands of scientists when in reality many of their “scientists” are not trained in climatology, or even science. Give it up, Duane! These conspiracies are way off.
LikeLike
You believe what you wish to believe, that is okay. I believe in the experts in the field of concern. That is how it is!
LikeLike
Sorry Duane, when I got to the part about a controlled demolition, I just stopped reading at that 911truth site. So why would the terrorists bother with the jets if they already had the building supposedly laced with explosives all over the place? It had to be hundreds (tons?) of pounds of explosives in all 3 buildings and no one is going to notice that someone or a group is carefully placing explosives at key points in the 3 structures. These 3 structures had good security; how the hell is someone going to sneak in with hundreds of pounds of explosives and put them in the correct places? Please, this is major BS. The first attack (1993) on one of the WTC towers was a huge car bomb in the basement, it was not enough to bring down the building, not even close. They tightened up security after that attack. There have been examples of gasoline tanker trucks crashing into bridges and bringing the bridges down in the ensuing inferno, practically melting the steel girders. As Vale Math said, there was a good PBS documentary that showed how the jets could indeed bring down the towers including the TWC7 which was the victim of the collateral damage from the destruction of the 2 larger buildings.
LikeLike
Joe, I guess no one at the Pentagon had to go through security. Really! This is why I have an ironclad rule: no conspiracy theories on this blog.
Don’t get me started about the Sandy Hook truthers, who say that there was no massacre, no one died, it was all staged by Obama so he could push gun control. All the “parents” we saw on TV were actors.
LikeLike
Ugh. A downside of the internet. Before, conspiracies were fairly dilute, local phenomena.
LikeLike
There’s a broad spectrum between “the towers collapsed because of the fire induced by the airplanes” and conspiracy theories, like “W orchestrated the whole thing with his father’s Saudi buddies to have a reason to gain control over Iraq’s oil.”
Here’s a not too long, readable article on the subject from the journal Europhysics News
Click to access epn2016474p21.pdf
There is no conclusive proof that Bin Laden was behind the attack, is there? Are there any letter or emails showing that he gave the orders, was doing the planning?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Responsibility_for_the_September_11_attacks
LikeLiked by 1 person
Science says anybody can question findings. But people confuse questioning conclusions and offering speculation with overturning evidence supporting a hypothesis. The preamble to this article says it all:
“This feature is somewhat different from our usual purely scientific articles, in that it contains some speculation”
LikeLike
“But people confuse questioning conclusions and offering speculation with overturning evidence supporting a hypothesis. The preamble to this article says it all:”
Clearly, you only read the preamble of the article. The speculation is not about what could have caused the free fall of the buildings but what couldn’t have caused it: careless engineering that didn’t think about the possibility of a commercial airplane hitting the towers.
The architect community was stunned at the time at seeing the free fall collapse—including both my parents, each with over 40 years practice back then. Realizing that there are no proper answers doesn’t imply a belief in a conspiracy theory.
LikeLike
I was driving to my IT job still half asleep. The first reports sounded like a small plane accident. Then more reports rolled in at work. Everyone watched the TVs all day. Some gasped and cried when the towers fell. Others swore. Some ran home and pulled kids out of school. The weeks after were filled people with escape plans to other cities, stocking up on water supplies, taping windows shut for gas attacks. National guard trucks rolled through streets, fighter jets left trails over cornfields. Our kids need to understand.
LikeLike
I forgot about working out the best route my wife and I could take to get out of the DC area that day. Evacuation from DC caused a huge gridlock with the transportation systems down and people trying to escape the city. We had decided on heading to a friend’s very remote home in WV.
LikeLike
I was on the subway going over the Manhattan Bridge not long after the first tower was hit. We could see an enormous hole in the side of the building and a small cloud of black smoke above it. When I got off the subway in midtown, fire engines were screaming downtown, and by the time I reached my office, the second tower was on fire.
My child was too young for school that day, but at the public elementary school he eventually attended, in Brooklyn Heights, the teachers and children could see the burning towers from the third floor classrooms. I believe the children were taken to the basement before the towers collapsed.
Now in high school, my son complains that every year, the teachers make them do a 9/11 remembrance lesson of some sort. It’s the same thing every time, he says, with all the wisdom and ennui of a teenager who’s focusing on college applications and AP courses.
Our job as parents, as teachers, as adults who lived through that horrible day is to help our children understand what happened that day. As with other transformative events–Kennedy’s assassination, Pearl Harbor, the Holocaust, among many others–we must help them see these events clearly and understand why it is necessary that we remember.
LikeLike
I was in shock and pain at the massive loss of life and of course it will always be a painful memory and reality. Those twin towers were like small cities unto themselves. If not for the bravery of all those (unionized) public workers as well as ordinary citizens, the death toll would have been higher. Immediately after the attacks, all the nauseating conspiracy “theories” popped up to pollute the airwaves. We were told it was a false flag operation, it was a Mossad operation, Jews were warned ahead of time, that bombs had been placed in the towers, that the Pentagon was not hit by a plane, that it was a massive truck bomb that destroyed part of the Pentagon, that there was no wreckage debris in the PA crash site or even the Pentagon site. All damn lies. And then there were the anthrax attacks, more grist for the tinfoil hat brigade.
LikeLike
I remember the anthrax attacks one week after 9/11. That just added to all the anxiety in the Washington, DC area. Fort Detrick is about two miles from my home. Then the next fall we had the sniper here.
LikeLike
Meant to say no PLANE wreckage debris. The conspiracy nuts claimed there was no plane wreckage debris at the Pentagon or in PA. Lies.
LikeLike
On 9/11 I’d just arrived at work, to teach, and I was on my way to my high school classroom. I heard students crying through one open doorway, and I stopped. The teacher saw me and told me what happened.
They were watching the news seeing the planes hit. Back then the Common Core Crap and high stakes tests didn’t rule the schools so we had more freedom to drop what we had planned to teach and focus on this event with our students. To help their students make sense of it.
I don’t listen to the radio when I’m driving so I missed the reports until I arrived at work.
How many teachers today would dare drop the CCC script of test prep to focus on a tragedy like this one? If they worked in a district that has been hijacked by the oligarchs, rum by Broad minions, fear would stop them.
LikeLike
I would hope that today, even with the Common Core Crap, that teachers would do the same as they did on that day–protect kids and do what they could to inform and ease fears. I was a stay at home mom on 9-11, so I don’t have personal experience with that, but I know that I would do everything to protect, ease fears, and inform. And I know a lot of others would, too.
LikeLike
I visited the 9/11 memorial museum in July. Despite the tribute paid to the tragedy and heroism of that day, I was mostly left with a terrible sadness that the unity that occurred in the wake of the attacks has dissipated to the point that Donald Trump – with his hateful vindictiveness – is a viable candidate for the office of the presidency. So much care and tenderness for one another squandered.
Is this the best we can be?
LikeLike
Robert Browning
I wonder do you feel to-day
As I have felt since, hand in hand,
We sat down on the grass, to stray
In spirit better through the land,
This morn of Rome and May?
For me, I touched a thought, I know,
Has tantalized me many times,
(Like turns of thread the spiders throw
Mocking across our path) for rhymes
To catch at and let go.
Help me to hold it! First it left
The yellowing fennel, run to seed
There, branching from the brickwork’s cleft,
Some old tomb’s ruin: yonder weed
Took up the floating wet,
Where one small orange cup amassed
Five beetles, blind and green they grope
Among the honey-meal; and last,
Everywhere on the grassy slope
I traced it. Hold it fast!
The champaign with its endless fleece
Of feathery grasses everywhere!
Silence and passion, joy and peace,
An everlasting wash of air —
Rome’s ghost since her decease.
Such life here, through such lengths of hours,
Such miracles performed in play,
Such primal naked forms of flowers,
Such letting nature have her way
While heaven looks from its towers.
How say you? Let us, O my dove,
Let us be unashamed of soul,
As earth lies bare to heaven above!
How is it under our control
To love or not to love?
I would that you were all to me,
You that are just so much, no more.
Nor yours nor mine, nor slave nor free!
Where does the fault lie? What the core
O’ the wound, since wound must be?
I would I could adopt your will,
See with your eyes, and set my heart
Beating by yours, and drink my fill
At your soul’s springs, — your part my part
In life, for good and ill.
No. I yearn upward, touch you close,
Then stand away. I kiss your cheek,
Catch your soul’s warmth, — I pluck the rose
And love it more than tongue can speak —
Then the good minute goes.
Already how am I so far
Out of that minute? Must I go
Still like the thistle-ball, no bar,
Onward, whenever light winds blow,
Fixed by no friendly star?
Just when I seemed about to learn!
Where is the thread now? Off again!
The old trick! Only I discern —
Infinite passion, and the pain
Of finite hearts that yearn.
LikeLike
Thank you, LCT
LikeLike
I was teaching in a middle school in Arlington VA at the time. The principal’s secretary came into my room and motioned me over. She whispered to me “Ron is all right.” Having no context, I did not understand. So she expanded “Your wife called to say your brother-in-law Ron is all right.” Ron at the time was an FBI agent stationed in downtown Manhattan. I asked why he wouldn’t be. She told me a plane had hit the World Trade Center. I obviously showed a reaction, asked what I should say, and she shrugged her shoulders.
My students asked what was going on. I said that a plane had hit the WTC, we did not know details, and that someone I knew who worked near there had called his family to say he was okay.
By the time our team was on break for planning, we had the TV on and saw the towers come down. And with the Pentagon, only a few miles away from us, got hit, we knew our lives were about to get very complicated. Parents began showing up to pick up their kids, and we had to go get them. People were visibly worried. When we learned the airline and destination of the plane that hit the Pentagon, one of our teachers and one of our studies hugged one another and cried, waiting in terror – the teacher’s father was a pilot for the airline flying deadhead to pick up a flight in LA and the student’s father was flying on the airline that morning to LA, and neither knew the flight number. It was more than an hour before they learned both were safe.
I was called by a reporter and asked what we were doing. No one had told me not to talk to press. What I told him was at that point we were trying to figure out where teachers who could not get home (with bridges being shut down) could spend the night, while others were trying to figure out new routes because roads near the Pentagon were shut down.
When the towers came down, cell phone service was lost in Lower Manhattan. It was not until almost 4 that Ron was able to get through to his wife to let her know he was okay. For hours she worried that he was buried in the rubble.
We live two blocks from the main hospital in Arlington. My wife, who was running late, had never been able to get into DC to work, and was therefore back home. She kept expecting lots of ambulances, but actually there were not that many.
As the scope became clear over the next few days, the impact started to fully sink in.
One person we knew worked in the section of the Pentagon that was hit, but he was having a cup of coffee with an acquaintance in another part of the building so he survived. Someone I knew slightly from my days in data processing did not.
One principal of an elementary school was outside with her students when the Pentagon was hit. She took them inside to comfort them, not knowing that her own husband had just been killed.
My small alma mater, Haverford, lost 4 in the Towers. I knew three, one well. One of our alums Howard Lutnick was the head of Cantor Fitzgerald, which lost over 600 employees, including both his brother and his closest friend Doug Gardner. Howard was not there because he was taking his son to his first day of Kindergarten.
I began scouring lists of the dead in New York. I grew up in the suburbs, lived in the City until I was 25, and knew lots of people who worked in companies with offices in the Towers. I found a couple of other names of people i had known slightly, but I did not have the losses that Howard Lutnick did, or that those in police and fire families did.
Reading Diane’s column reminded me of my days living in Brooklyn Heights. I remember watching a fire in a skyscraper downtown with helicopters landing on the roof to take people off. Some died in that fire because the buttons on elevators were heat sensitive and the doors opened at the floors with the fire with people trying to use them to get down. I also remember sitting in an eatery not far from the Promenaded late one night when the plate glass window vibrated almost shattering and the booth in which we were sitting shook. The friend with whom I was and I went out, and looked across the river – apparently a storage tank at a refinery or tank farm in Jersey had just blown up, and we were feeling the shock wave.
But neither of those had anything close to the impact even of just 9-11 watching on TV. From our home in Arlington we could not see the smoke from the Pentagon, but we certainly were aware of the impact upon our community.
In my last few years of teaching, my students had no memories of that horrible day. Certainly those old enough to recognize what was going on will forever remember what happened, where they were when they found out, just as those of us who are in our 60s or older (I am 70) remember clearly when we learned about the assassination of JFK. For those of my parents generation it clearly was learning of Pearl Harbor, first and foremost, but possibly also VJ Day and the end of the war, and before that the death of FDR.
I cannot help but point out that as horrible as 9-11 was, on a proportional basis our loss that day, as great as it was, pales compared to the losses other countries have suffered from terrorism – certainly Israel, most of all. What it has done is to force us to recognize that there is no place that is necessarily immune from the horrors of terrorism.
As I think back, I also remember when the plane crashed in Pennsylvania that I knew exactly where it had crashed, because I had been to Somerset County in 1983 on behalf of Sen. Fritz Hollings, who was then running for the Democratic nomination for President. I quickly realized I knew where that field was, relative to places I had visited.
I sometimes look back at things I wrote in the days immediately after 9-11, and that I have written in memory since, often but not exclusively on the anniversary.
I will not forget.
LikeLike
Re: Brooklyn Heights — I was on the Manhattan-side of the water when the planes hit and the towers fell, but I was living on Clark Street at the time.
LikeLike
As someone who was far away that day, thank you Diane for sharing your experiences as a witness to the events of that day.
LikeLike
For Boston’s public schools it was the fourth day of classes, so most of us were just getting to know our new students and catching up with returning ones. No one had cellphones yet, and my school lacked much in the way of infrastructure for the internet. I had three classes in a row that morning, then lunch duty, so the towers had already fallen before I or my colleagues teaching nearby knew anything was amiss.
At lunch, we scrambled to prepare for the afternoon to answer questions and to reassure kids, many of whom we barely knew. My fourth floor classroom had a direct view of the Prudential Center tower and I remember a ninth grader who commented to the class that we would all be able to see if a plane flew into it.
We did not dismiss classes early because it was considered dangerous to deviate from normal routines, but some parents came to school to pick up their children early. No faculty left early to retrieve their own children – we stayed to keep our students protected. My own kids, 10 and 14 at the time, were in different schools several miles from mine and I knew, without question, their teachers would do for them what I was doing for mine. As we left the school building, it was eerily quiet; there was little street traffic and the airport from which two planes had been hijacked was closed. Then we heard and saw fighter jets above our heads in the school’s parking lot. Someone commented, we’re at war.
I remember there was a question as to whether schools would be open the next day and the decision was made that it would be best to provide students with the routine of “a normal school day”. I don’t recall any guidance for us as to how to proceed, no grief counselors, no psychological support – we were on our own to provide that normalcy.
When I hear people demean teachers, I recall the heroism of the teachers in lower Manhattan who evacuated their schools, shielded their students as best they could from the terror literally raining down around them and cared for them as they would have their own children.
LikeLike
It was planning period that morning. I had a student who came in to take a make-up. She was a dear girl who always smiled, even when she was sad. She said to me that the plane had flown into the trade towers and I thought she was preparing me for a joke. Naturally, she reiterated the truth and made me understand what was afoot.
When my next class came in, I asked them if they wanted to watch the matter on TV. We watched for awhile, then I asked if they would like to focus on the Geometry for awhile. All of them did. We did a few problems and the turned it back on just about the time the first tower fell.
I do not really know how we knew that the towers had collapsed. I do not remember the narrators of the news saying anything to that effect. It recalled to me the time my nephew and I were watching as the challenger blew up that January in 86. For some reason, his five year old mind understood that the thing had exploded. My kids all understood the tower had gone down whe it went.
Like everyone, once the towers fell, we watched and ached and knew that something would be very different. I remember looking at the boys in my class and wondering how many of them would have to fight and where. We heard that an old friend, now a general, had been out of the pentagon when his office was demolished. When the kids asked questions, I told them this might be an event they would always recall very vividly.
My mother always told me that she had been to a performance of Handel’s Messiah the day word hit the street that Pearl Harbor had been attacked. She recalled the boys running around the streets selling newspapers. She recalled herself considering the irony of stepping out of a celebration of peace on earth to learn that the conflict they had been dreading was now to be visited upon them.
Thanks, Dianne. The folks here have given us a trove of oral history. Maybe I could use it when we get to the last part of World History this year. Or gather some of our own. How quickly history wanes in the minds of those who live it.
LikeLike
Roy, Story Corps collected stories from 9/11. They are beautiful, poignant, heartbreaking. These animated versions would be great for students.
This is one I treasure: https://youtu.be/7k8HHfJe828
Here’s a link with more:
http://www.thirteen.org/metrofocus/2011/09/storycorps-presents-animated-shorts-on-911/
LikeLike
I visited NYC in the Spring, following 9/11. I saw the memorials tacked to the chain link fences and watched the bulldozers working in the pit. Uptown, daffodils were in bloom, thanks to a donor from the Netherlands and thousands of city volunteers who seemed to draw strength from planting the bulbs. I understand that daffodil planting has become a ritual, in addition to being a living memorial to those who died and those still dying from the toxic environment.
I also recall seeing a drawing created by a child who witnessed the planes flying into the towers. His drawings depicted people plunging to their death from the flaming widows. He had no words to describe what he saw or how he felt. His parents were wise enough to see the sense in that form of expression. Otherwise the child had been speechless.
LikeLike
I was working as a counselor in a Catholic HS on 9/11. As soon as we found out that the first plane hit, we turned on the TVs and saw the second plane hit live, as well as the subsequent collapse of both towers. We didn’t do any school work that day, nor for days afterwards. Instead, we spent the day comforting students and colleagues alike, and allowing everyone to break our “no phone calls during school time” policy liberally. At the end of the day, we went to Mass, the only part of the day which gave any comfort. I thank you for your description, Diane, as your first person account is so vivid. I will never understand why.
LikeLike
Thank you Dr. Ravitch for your insightful memory. Through this thread, I have learned that all sorrows have inflicted the same pain on the sufferers and the witness of the sorrow.
I watched movie “Sully” and the scene of people, who are rescued in Hudson river, brought me back the memory of my shipwreck. I was the sufferer for 7 hours in the darkest night on October 31st in China sea. I empathize with the fear of separation between being dead and alive.
I hope that the trait of being humanitarian will be with all human beings on Earth, so that one day people will soon experience their inner peace and their unity in humanity. May.
Here is my favorite song from Pink Floyd.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UbMOkdG8AY
On the Turning Away
…
No more turning away
From the weak and the weary
No more turning away
From the coldness inside
Just a world that we all must share
It’s not enough just to stand and stare
Is it only a dream that there’ll be
No more turning away?
LikeLike
Thank you, May.
LikeLike
Still hard to remember on those days. Husband and I had both worked in the SouthTower in the ’80’s before moving to Nj. The co still had an office there, we lost colleagues. A close friend & neighbor had it much worse having spent much of career working for Port Auth but thankfully consulting from home at that point. There was a lot of fear, just making sure we & ours were OK that morning, & waiting it out, feeling that more could happen. Having spent so many years working there & in nearby buildings, the televised scenes were all too real. For many years after I did not go to Manhattan, & looked away from the skyline when traveling to LI. Nine families in our town lost immediate family members. The mother of my son’s friend escaped her tower office walked north for hours. She was traumatized by the carnage she saw & her family moved far away. It changed my life mainly in bringing understanding of what war in your own land feels like.
LikeLike
I recall the immediate aftermath…and for months later, driving anywhere in
the Bay Area, American flags seemingly attached from windows…there was
a respect for the firemen and police, a feeling that we were all in this together…similar to the aftermath of JFK murder in terms of shared grief as I told my classes but too soon, within the yr.
conspiracy theories aimed to destroy our common ground as fellow
Americans began to destroy our shared sadness and replaced it with
the terrible divisions we see today…giving a new generation an excuse not
to mourn. This should be a time to honor the true heroes, the first responders
who gave so much…this should not be a single day of memory but of something
deeper to pass onto the next generations.
LikeLike