At last, an article in the mainstream media that tries to understand why teachers are troubled! It’s not the New York Times or the Washington Post, but still…it’s in print.
Roger Williams of the Fort Meyers, Florida, Weekly titled “Troubled Teachers.” He dwells at length on the stresses that have changed the nature of teaching, not for the better.
Williams interviews many teachers, who tell him what is happening in their classrooms.
“At least one disturbing conclusion can be drawn from what they tell us: Teachers now face what is arguably the most difficult and demanding stampede of challenges in the contemporary history of public education. And that’s not good for students who face, in turn, a range of contemporary social challenges they might not have experienced en masse in previous generations.
“For teachers, there is less time than ever before to teach, they say. There is data crunching and lack of trust and constant state-mandated testing of stressed students. Teacher evaluations and one-year contracts are based on the success of students as measured in tests created by people who don’t teach. There is pay that will not cover the costs of education and family life.
“In the face of all this, what makes a great teacher, we asked them — and conversely, what makes it difficult to be a great teacher? Why are so many leaving a profession so essential to our futures?
“Teachers are ill-prepared for the demands of the current system. So it’s not just a matter of how to make better teachers. It’s also how teachers are made to work within their system now,” says Sandy Stenoff, co-founder of The Opt Out Florida Network, a grass-roots organization based in Orlando that advocates a variety of assessments instead of a single, state-mandated test.
“If you look at other professions, the ‘masters’ all have one thing in common,” she adds: “Excellent mentorship — an expert under whom they really trained, learned the best ‘techniques.’ Doctors, lawyers, even craftsmen.
“We don’t do that in education anymore. It would help to reduce attrition, too. But expert teachers are leaving. They can’t teach the way they know teaching works best.”
Never before have state and federal governments imposed their will so forcefully in every public school classroom. Their often I’ll-advised intrusions aim for standardization, making teachers and students alike unhappy.
Williams writes:
“If the system has massive weaknesses right now, it also has very good people, it seems — people who advocate passionately, even when they leave.
“Can all this be changed? Yes,” says Bruce Linser, a musical theater teacher and outgoing dean of dramatic arts at the Alexander W. Dreyfoos School of the Arts in West Palm Beach.
“I think we need fewer administrators and more teachers. We need fewer people telling us how to do our jobs, and more people who know how to do this, and want and love to do this, being allowed to do this. Without all the strings and standardization. I’m not arguing against oversight, I think that’s important. There are things that need to be taught and learned and I totally agree with that.”
“But all the extra duties of teachers — the extra programs and management requirements — inhibit the teaching they’re called to do.”
Low pay and lack of respect are part of the reason for teacher discontent. Florida ranks 39th in the nation in teacher pay, and many teachers must work a second job to make ends meet.
Very likely, one of the reasons that hedge fund managers and billionaires look down on teachers is because they are paid so little. Instead of recognizing that teachers sacrifice financial security for being in a career that makes a difference, the 1% simply don’t understand why people choose to teach and feel justified in trying to redesign education and teachers’ working conditions.
This says it all. Give teachers the tools, the resources and the respect they deserve as professionals; get back to inquiry and hands on learning; get rid of high stakes testing; allow age appropriate curricula to be taught again; allow those teachable moments without having to worry about what at monkey is on your shoulder; let the professionals do their jobs with the assistance of seasoned mentors and our children will get the education they should have. Our schools will be happy, thriving places again.
We need to trust, encourage and create a collaborative environment for teachers in order for them to have academic freedom. Micro-management is designed to put teachers on the defensive. Florida would rather play “gotcha” with teachers than support and defend. This is because policymakers Florida are not interested in improving public schools. They would rather make the maximum number of schools eligible for privatization. The low pay and demeaning working conditions explain why Florida has so many unfilled vacancies in its public schools.
retired teacher
Bingo , and it is nation wide.
Reblogged this on Crazy Normal – the Classroom Exposé and commented:
The rich and powerful — like Bill Gates, the Walmart Walton family, Eli Broad, the Koch brothers, etc. — don’t understand why everyone else, especially teachers, doesn’t want to be rich and famous just like them. Psychopaths think like that, so they are abusing teachers in an attempt to fix and profit off the education of our children while their children go to exclusive, private schools.
The corporate education reformers were very good at scapegoating teachers when the economy tanked. The profiteers saw their chance and coordinated efforts through ALEC to attack public education and here we are. Union leadership sat by, passive and complicit, allowing their members to be steamrolled while they collected fat salaries and remained immune from the awful policies being enacted.
Liz
I am going to agree and disagree . Union leadership sits back because Union membership is not active. Whether you are on the establishment team or the or the insurgency . You activism encourages or discourages their actions. They are responding to a membership like most other Unions that is not active siting back and expecting results . I just retired from one of the more powerful trade unions in the country . A thoroughly autocratic benevolent monarchy with a more active membership than most, though not enough .One that is still delivering somewhat and is functional for its members even in hard times. . I have seen it from both ends of that equation as an insider and outsider looking in .
Union membership gets the leadership it deserves and Union leadership gets the membership it deserves. No one is going to fight this battle for you.
Yup–we have to get people to run for leadership positions and challenge them. I ran knowing I had little to no chance of winning, but more to let them know someone would be nipping at their heels. I raised some good points in my platform, and hopefully membership will hold them accountable.
Thank you, Diane.
One thing I don’t fully get is exactly why the hedge funders and billionaires are targeting education in such a consistent and single way. I mean, at a personal level. Are they pretending or thinking they are looking out for their employees kids? Aren’t there plenty of other better ways to make money? Or is this a good way for them to make money and appear to help society? Is this their fake token contribution when they can’t go green any further? Or is it all just very simplistic thinking: government is not efficient, let’s privatize everything, turn everything into a business, and then we can run everything?
When school didn’t seem to work well for me, it never occurred to me to blame my teachers. The things that really didn’t work were always clearly initiatives the school was being pressed to introduce. And larger issues always seemed to stem from larger societal myopias and limitations. Yes, a few were a bit nutty or neurotic, but even their intuition about educating was far above any given incoming blanket initiative, it seemed. And this was long before deform. Deform is absolutely horrific. In Arthur Goldstein’s words, it’s amazing that parents haven’t stormed the DOE carrying pitchforks and torches. Deform is a real Frankenstein’s monster, and not Mel Brook’s version, Andy Warhol’s.
I think a lot of it has to do with ideology. The deformers subscribe to this libertarian, free market, privatizing, Ayn Randian social Darwinism which they would love to impose on the rest of us.
Aka,
Mostly, it is simplistic thinking. The free market is efficient. Private always better than public. Regulation is bad. Teachers need incentives and threats or they won’t produce. Unions are bad. We are the good guys. We have pure intentions. You don’t need to know anything about a business to run it and make money.
“I think a lot of it has to do with ideology.”
Nah, doesn’t have anything to do with “ideology” (which implies a certain level of consistent thought) but everything to do with “idiology.”
Idiology (n.) a. The ideology of errors and falsehoods, lacking in fidelity to truth, b. The ideology of idiots.
At what point do these guys, the deformers, get disabused when they fail over and over again in education?
Don’t the deformers have a tipping point? Or are they weighted and rounded at the bottom like so many inflated clowns?
Do they have a learning curve, other than an EEG?
Or does ‘idiology’ prevent that?
All skills are fungible, in the eyes of the new financial elite.
Everything that should be publicly funded and run is being privatized by the vultures who are after tax dollars. Prisons, schools…My public school system employed some great custodians. They were thorough, they cared, they engaged with the children, etc My room was always well-maintained. I would request something and they came asap. Then the school system contracted out to a private company that, of course, paid less and so got less. But the fat cats don’t care if my classroom is well taken of for my children to have a clean and safe learning environment. So some great custodians lost their jobs and my room was disgusting. This isn’t going to end. We worship capitalism.
I cannot help but think of the days when Eisenhower warned us of the “Military Industrial Complex” in a speech toward the end of his tenure. It was a very complicated issue. Many engaged in building the weapons of the day we’re sure that they were holding a hostile Soviet enemy at bay.
This seems to be what we have today in education. Those who stand to make a lot of money believing an ideology will likely reject challenges to that ideology. Is this what we are going through with education?
Roy,
Today we have the Education Industrial Complex.
That ideology of free and efficient markets always extends to others. It never matters what issue we are talking about .
Dean Baker one of the clearest Public Economists loves pointing out that free traders have no problem with pastern protections a through distortion of markets.
Today he critiqued an article in the Washington Post
“It’s true that a FTT will downsize our financial markets by eliminating excessive trading, but for fans of economics this is good news. We wouldn’t want five million truckers moving goods back and forth across the country if one million could do the job. The same story applies to financial markets. If we can effectively allocate capital with half as many trades as we have today, why wouldn’t we want to see the gain in efficiency?”
The obvious answer who they are only favor efficient markets for others.
Patent ,
Eliminate are
5 errors in one post
thorough not through ,
The obvious answer who they favor efficient markets are only for others.
The politicians and the sycophant educrats who support them are stuck on the false premise of “accountability.” Some of those people believe they are doing the right thing, MANY know it is a false premise designed to discredit public education for their personal gain, and most educrats go along with the program because they lack courage and/or integrity.
Learning is a nurturing process. New teachers, who are trying to navigate a new profession, ought to be nurtured by mentors. No amount of “teacher education” can substitute for face to face time with students in the classroom, and constructive criticism is invaluable to becoming a better teacher.
The test and punish model attempts to identify “failing students” and then punish the students’ teachers. That system is perverse. It dehumanizes the students into a data point, and it encourages teachers to treat the students as obstacles to success. Some obstacles can be worked through, but many are simply bypassed for easier terrain.
If the aim of education is to edify, any assessment should be at the core diagnostic.
The rich and powerful — like Bill Gates, the Walmart Walton family, Eli Broad, the Koch brothers, etc. are “”the lost souls on earth””. They lost their ONE way to reach out their best destination.
According to the original founder of American Activist Retiree Professional, Mrs. Ethel Percy Andrus, her quotes are:
[start quote]
The human contribution is the essential ingredient. It is only in the giving of oneself to others that we truly live.
We learn the inner secret of happiness when we learn to direct our inner drives, our interest and our attention to something besides ourselves.
What I spent, is gone; what I kept, I lost; but what I gave away will be mine forever.
[end quote]
In short, human beings have three chances or choices:
1) Head up to TRULY live with contentment by detachment of all materialistic wants and needs
2) Remain to be human with a conflict within and to live with all emotional trivialities like love, hatred, hope and despair.
3) Gear down to live without being considerate for others’ welfare and to become animals or evils who enjoy consuming blood and corpse to live by.
Hopefully, some natural force can wake up those lost souls that have potentials to head up and to re-discover their own inner secret of happiness BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE. May God bless people on earth with a chance to head up day by day. Back2basic
It is all about arrogance. Do I know how to run a hedge fund? Can I make a pizza? Am I able to perform cardiac surgery? Would I be the person to design and construct a suspension bridge? No, no, no and no. I respect the skills of others. When it comes to my narrow area of expertise; teaching ESL, I am an idiot and in need of profound remediation.
The hedge fund and management consultant people think that if you can sell cars, you can sell paint. If you can market appliances, you can market soap. The product is irrelevant. That’s why they think so little of acquiring the skills for teaching.
This theory is VERY prevalent with reformers: If you can teach high schoolers to get ready for college, surely you can just as well be transferred into a first grade classroom….and vice versa.
CAVEAT: In case this sounds as if I believe that first grade teachers have less difficult jobs, I meant just the opposite. All student ages are particularly demanding, and require very particular skills and long years of experience.
Why? Here’s why:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2013/09/10/charter-school-gravy-train-runs-express-to-fat-city/#ff36f7f70e52
“In Florida, the for-profit school industry flooded legislative candidates with $1.8 million in donations last year. “Most of the money,” reports The Miami Herald, “went to Republicans, whose support of charter schools, vouchers, online education and private colleges has put public education dollars in private-sector pockets.”
_______________________________________________________________________
“State Sen. Dwight Bullard, D-Cutler Bay, asked senators “to be frank” and questioned whether the House’s reluctance to ban charter schools’ “private enrichment” was because of “individuals who indirectly or directly gain personal wealth based on charter school construction.”
Several lawmakers have close ties to charter schools, such as Fresen. He is a land consultant for Civica, an architecture firm with a specialty in building charter schools. Many of those schools were built for Academica — which has been described as the largest charter school management company in Florida and which counts Fresen’s brother-in-law and sister as executives.
Fresen has said no conflict exits.”
Read more here: http://www.bradenton.com/news/local/education/article65572452.html#storylink=cpy
_______________________________________________________________________
http://www.bradenton.com/news/local/crime/article93969817.html
“Bergeron, who was charged with scheme to defraud over $20,000, is being held at the Manatee County jail on a $50,000 bond.
“The district was made aware of the financial issue at the charter school. Immediately, the district notified the Manatee County Sheriff’s office to request an investigation,” general counsel Mitchell Teitelbaum said in a statement. “ In addition, the district requested a full and complete financial audit of the charter school.”
Manatee School of the Arts and Sciences is a public charter school located at 3700 32nd St. W., Bradenton. The school district is considered a sponsor and money for the charter school designated by the state is doled out to the charter by the school district but the charter school board handles its own finances.”
_______________________________________________________________________
This has absolutely NOTHING to do with educating children, employing professional teachers, doing the ‘right’ thing for minorities and the poor, and EVERYTHING to do with greed and wealth creation for the legislators, their families and cronies, and enterprising grifters who board the Charter/Voucher/Choice gravy train.
Thank you Chris! To my mind, the one and only reason ‘hedge funders and billionaires are targeting education in such a consistent and single way’ [Akademos above] is that they are able to tap directly into the flow of public money to support iffy ventures & products, & walk away with profits before folks get wise to the pickpockets & organize against them.
Charter-funders make out fine skimming off even shaky ventures, & as long as the cap is high enough, they can keep opening new ones & folding older ones as needed. Folks like Gates & Pearson have only to convince legislators that standardization is efficient (even tho it’s efficient, in education, solely for the sales of computer-based products) and Wa-lah, a captive nationwide market.
I think we waste our time wondering what other esoterica might inform their drive. Blurbs about free market, anti-union etc are merely sales puffing– note how such blab is replaced by civil-rights mantras for more liberal markets. Grass-roots organization is the only way to beat them. Opt-out is the perfect boycott vehicle. Also needed: lots more hard economic data for mainstream taxpayers on how many dollars are squandered/ fattening the 1% purse to get middling to poor educational results and a net loss to middle-class jobs.
I am a teacher. I have spent 21 years in teaching. During my career, I have sent numerous students to state, national and international Science fair. My classes have always scored well on state mandated tests. I may be out of teaching within the next month. I am required to pass a test. The test is about what I know about all areas of education. I am having problems passing a writing test. I was notified yesterday, I missed passing this test by four points. I have not taken a writing class in 38 years. It is getting very frustrating. My level of knowledge of writing has very little to no bearing about how well I can teach.
Edward, I am so sorry about that. It’s not fair. After 26 years of teaching, I had to take 3 tests.I was worried I wouldn’t pass them, but luckily I did. It’s insane! Good luck!
Good grief, pushed out of teaching because of 4 points! What about 21 years of successful teaching, that should far outweigh some test? I don’t think there is any such type of test in NJ but I’ve been retired for some time. I’m sure the NJEA would have fought such a requirement. After all, you are constantly being observed and evaluated by the principal and then there are all these tests that the kids have to take which are used as a lever against the teacher.
There is a war against teachers, especially teachers with many years of experience (the more expensive teachers).
I think it is all about the roi. That is all. A way to make money off an ever flowing cash cow of taxpayer dollars.
They are doing nothing good when they destroy neighborhoods, put teachers out of work, destroy unions, dumb down the kids, all the while sending their own kind to private schools. They rhetoric is that charters are a way for the underdog to get a leg up, but in no way does a no-excuses charter school that treats its students with disgust, distain and abuse compare to the academies to which their children/grandchildren are educated.
Just look at the offices Eva Moskowitz rented for herself with tax dollars and billionaire donations – posh as can be – meanwhile taking space away from public schools in buildings she shares, HALF of which she paints, rebuilds, air conditions, and quarantines off so “those kids” can’t mingle with her “scholars.”
One of the public schools in Newark was closed by Cami Anderson and sold in a sweet deal to a charter school – after which it was tended to, painted, repaired, and air conditioned. No way would Cami allow it to be renovated while it was for the public school kids. Therein lies the unfairness.
Anyhow, the rhetoric is masterful. Its like when you open a document in Microsoft’s Word program, and you’ve got an earlier version, and the prompt to open that earlier version is to answer “NO” – its just backwards. Even Gates’s products are good at the doublespeak.
“Low pay and lack of respect are part of the reason for teacher discontent.” Diane Ravitch.
Unfortunately this is also the premise for the McKinsey & Co. pay-for-performance plan dating to 2010, marketed by the Obama Administration as RESPECT —stands for Recognizing Educational Success, Professional Excellence, and Collaborative Teaching— with another version marketed as an Opportunity Culture for teaching, with the latest incarnation of this pay-for-performance scheme pushed by TeachStrong.org complete with a pitch refined by Peter Hart (public relations expert) to focus on “modernizing” and “elevating the teaching profession.”
TeachStrong.org is all about “modernizing the profession” while increasing “respect for teaching” and addressing compensation issues.
The worst part is that teacher unions are on board, also TFA, all of the promoters of the CommonCore, all of the foundation networks set up to undermine respect for teachers, including the Education Post and Educators4Excellence. I could be wrong, but the Gates Foundation has been a conspicuous contributor to most of those enlisted to support TeachStrong. The odd bedfellows contributing to this initiative have received, by my analysis, $333,751,744 in operating and other support from the Gates Foundation, and many are darlings of the Walton Foundation. As of August, 2016, only two of nine “principles” for the TeachStrong corporate-style managerial scheme have been published. Are these organizations buying a pig in a poke or did they see all nine principles before these were available for public comment?
See my prior post on the convoluted thinking on teacher preparation in ESSA and an extended comment on TeachStrong. In my opinion, teacher unions and other nominally professional organization endorsing TeachStrong need to be asked if they have read the fine print in all nine principles of TeachStrong.
https://dianeravitch.net/2016/07/08/laura-chapman-essa-and-the-degradation-of-teacher-preparation/
World News: Eli Broad, Bill Gates, the Walton family and Koch brothers finally see the light!
McZen opens 2018, the first fast enlightenment franchise, atop a mountain in Tibet, but soon to come to the Unites States: Seattle, Oakland, Chicago, Miami, Newark and eventually New York City.
Become a disciple now! Train to be a master in 6 days! A living god in 3 weeks!
Enroll in the following journeys at McZen’s Palace of Transcendental Thought:
Meditate Like A Champion
See Nothing, While Watching Your Own Back
Hear Nothing/Tree Sounds
Say Nothing/Mouth Bubbles
Do Nothing/EZ Pass
Think Nothing/Ideolog-ology
Be Nothing/Internalization
Advanced Nothingness
Extend Nothingness to Greater Nothingness
Rubrics for Nothingness
Measuring Nothingness by VAM
Not Measuring Nothingness
Publicly Displaying Not Measuring Nothingness
Rating Systems for Cities that Do or Do Not Publicly Display Not Measuring Nothingness or Greater Nothingness or Any Other Magnitudes of Nothingness
Already here: DisengageNY.org
UnawaresChiTown.com
MindlessMiami.edu
All journeys are free!
Monitoring enlightenment states and ensuring accountability in training and the deeds of the certifiably enlightened will cost billions upon billions, until there is nothing.
Thank you for a good joke, aka.
I would like to take this opportunity to elaborate about McZen.
If diamond can be naturally formed less than couple thousands of years, then reformers can manipulatively market for McZen to give people a taste of enlightenment or even to certify to be a Master from McZen.
People, who have money and are bored with materialistic lifestyle, will be gullible enough to pay for a trip to the moon (death of crashed landing), hell (injection of cocaine) or heaven (indulging all con artists who praise the gullible as their God = heaven, ah ha, that is the way the gullible like to hear). Back2basic.
This spring our county was going through a political wrangling over whether to build a new school. As a joke, the local paper wrote an April Fools article about a proposal,to build the new jail and our high school together to save money on food services. It took me the whole article to realize the joke. But it was not really funny. It only reminded me that there were people in power positions on our own county board who might do that sort of thing or worse.
McZen might actually take off. We need to mandate it and sell it to local government that is looking to cut corners. We need not forget in the face of all the distant threats to public Ed that there are local threats as well, people in whose best interest it is to fail at the job of educating kids. When all these distant and unfounded mandates come down from heaven to local school boards and county governments, the last thing anyone wants to do is to raise taxes to comply with any new idea.
Bill Gates: Oh, it’s lit!
Eli Broad: Head UP! Everybody Say!
Koch Bros: Tune in, Turn off, in record time!
Walton Family: Transcend-plify!
Mike Bloomberg: Oh, yes, it is lit. Estah iluminadoh.
Joel Klein: Head up — where?
Rupert Murdoch: Rosebud.
Aka: >snort!< thanks for first belly laugh of the day! Wonderful 😉
Public Education in Florida treats teachers like reform school students and kids like it is a “free for all”- so upside down-angry disgruntled employees on all management levels really affect the caustic climate making it feel stifling and torturous
It seems Indiana follows Florida’s lead so often, so I’m sure this all too familiar to many. Here we had Pence who in his one term has created disaster in IN public schools. Granted he had a head start from previous administration. Now we have lower pay scales disregarding education level, we don’t have consistency with standardized testing because he won’t let Ritz do what we elected her to do, in fact, I believe he even took a break from campaigning to come to Indy to meet with ALEC, we have large school districts in low SES and high crime areas being ran by officers because they aren’t licensed or educated in their positions, and then the schools are being parceled out and shared with charters from companies which have not had success with other schools.
I and other school psychologists are usually paid on a teacher scale…they are not paid enough for sure but I bring up my role because so many specialized personnel are held up to similar and often unrelated expectations. We are rated, typically by others who don’t understand our role, with a rubric resembling the skills we have but we are so busy we can only focus on the most prioritized tasks. We are also rated on results of students’ state standardized testing. Many in my field are spread thin in many states, not just IN. Last year my son wanted to compare my hours to others working a full-time, full-year 40 hour a week job. I worked over 200 more hours than they would. To put it into another perspective…a PhD School Psychologist can make around $37,500 working with students having highest needs, work many more hours than contracted for so often won’t have time for a second job to help pay bills, not be rated as highly effective with so many cards stacked against, and then be told to buck up and be happy to get summers off.
I love my career and there is nothing to compare it to for me to switch, but I am at a loss of why we and the amazing teachers I work(ed) with who sacrifice so much for their students, are being demonized. It’s mind boggling. Luckily in some districts, like where I’m at now, they try to ease the state burdens how they can and respect their educators and other specialized staff. I admit I have been uneasy thinking it possible Pence would be putting his hands in the federal education reform cookie jar.
Reblogged this on karenw95 and commented:
What we know
1. Parents need to revolt.
2. Make getting an admin licenses, especially superintendent licenses, more difficult. They must learn and apply business methods to managing staff and data for instruction.
3. Textbook companies need to be forced out of the pockets of the US Dept of Ed and SEAs. They write a new forward just to sell more textbooks!
4. Instead of the US Dept of Ed hiring only PhDs who “can talk intelligently to Congress,” hire TEACHERS for those positions who know what works in classrooms!!!