Nevada’s new voucher program is the most radical in the nation. Of course, it is not called a “voucher” program, but “education savings accounts.” A rose by any other name. A stinkweed by any other name. You can call a stinkweed a rose, but it is still a stinkweed. The ESA will accomplish the same purpose as vouchers, by transferring public funds to private and religious schools.
Since the Republicans took control of the Legislature, school choice has been their top priority in education. This is their answer to the financial woes of Nevada’s underfunded public schools.
Says the article, “Nevada’s public schools are in the toilet. The Silver State consistently ranks near the bottom when it comes to education spending. Things got so dreary in the mid-2000’s that the state even amended its constitution with “Nevada Fund Education First,” a measure to ensure the education budget is determined before all other items. Even worse, Education Week ranked Nevada dead last in 2014 in a “Chance for Success” analysis that combined data on student achievement, state spending, and standards and accountability.”
But why fund the schools when you can pass a school choice measure instead? The bonus is that you can call yourself a reformer as you are drawing even more money away from the schools that the majority of the state’s children attend.
Funny, the Nevada state constitution bars the use of public money for religious schools. Two-thirds of the private schools in Nevada are religious schools.
The Nevada Constitution states that, “No public funds of any kind or character whatever, State, County or Municipal, shall be used for sectarian purpose.” Anything ambiguous about that?
Nevada law also states in NRS 387.045 that, “No portion of the public school funds shall in any way be segregated, divided or set apart for the use or benefit of any sectarian or secular society or association.” Anything ambiguous about that?
Remember when conservatives used to be “strict constructionists” of state and federal Constitutions?
But that was then. Now, conservatives, led by ALEC, have set their sights on privatizing public education.
Don’t expect vouchers to reduce the achievement gaps between rich and poor: “It doesn’t promote better schooling for low-income [kids],” said Martin Carnoy, a professor at Stanford University’s Graduate School of Education. “It’s going to benefit new private-school providers and current private-school providers…It’s welfare for the rich.”
What are ed reformers doing in Nevada for existing public schools? Were these people elected on charters/vouchers or did they run on “improving public schools”?
I think public school parents and teachers have a right to demand that the public employees we’re paying work on behalf of public schools, instead of working to eliminate public schools.
Thank you for your very informative posts.Also loved your book “The language police”.
They are starting an “Achievement District” and turning over the lowest 5% of schools to charter managers. They also have passed a read by three law retaining third graders that do not pass the common core reading test. They will continue to destroy the public schools.
Old Teacher,
Nevada will get the same results as Tennessee: The “achievement school district” managed to move two of six schools in its original cohort from the bottom 5% to the bottom 6%. The other four remained in the bottom 5%. Charter managers have no secret solutions.
Reblogged this on Crazy Normal – the Classroom Exposé and commented:
In Nevada, there is welfare for the rich.
Cross-posted at http://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/Nevada-s-Radical-Voucher-P-in-Best_Web_OpEds-Corporations_Democracy_Diane-Ravitch_Education-160104-79.html#comment578023
with this comment which has links embedded in it,
Read in The Nation, how these zillionaires plan to remake education.
Scott McLeod, a blogger in Iowa, explains how politicians are following a script that details how to kill public education. Watch what they do. The same game plan is being repeated in other states.http://dangerouslyirrelevant.org/2015/08/imagine-that-you-wanted-to-slowly-kill-public-education.html
read: North Carolina: Important Discussion of Wrecking Ball Crew Trying to Demolish Public Education
https://dianeravitch.net/2015/12/13/north-carolina-important-discussion-of-wrecking-ball-crew-trying-to-demolish-public-education/
Go to the Diane Ravitch blog, and read about the rip-off and corruption that has been engineered by the Education Industrial Complex.
Click to access eic-oct_11.pdf
Access all my series http://www.opednews.com/author/series/author40790.html
where I offer you a look at the dismantling of our democracy by the billionaires who have waged a 30 year war on public education, beginning with the removal of the professional teachers –their voices and their classroom practice…and TELL EVERYONE YOU KNOW TO LEARN THE TRUTH BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE.
I have posted for years about the destruction of our INSTITUTION OF PUBLIC EDUCATION while the national media is silent. See my series or go to theDiane Ravitch blog
https://dianeravitch.net/?s=legislaturewhere state legislatures are taking over the local schools, with nary an educator on board, and giving them to charters, with not a shred of oversight! Here is a link to my series on charter school corruption.
Submitted on Monday, Jan 4, 2016 at 12:42:55 PM
Citizens of Nevada should unite to fight this misuse of public funds, especially when they have a law on the books that is clearly being violated. Perhaps they should contact the League of Women Voters or even the SPLC. We have to fight back when the state violates its own laws and tread on democracy.
In addition to the organizations mentioned, definitely add ACLU.
Yeah > Good idea…that is going to work against this
http://www.opednews.com/articles/At-Stake-in-2016-Ending-t-by-Robert-Reich-Corporations_Politics_Progressives_Wealth-Inequality-160103-235.html
Nevada is comprised of mostly immigrants and retirees, they do not, for the most part, support public schools. They think privatizing education entirely would be wonderful. Nevada is a libertarian playground politically and a stingy selfish lot socially. Barrick Gold, a Canadian company, goes on and on about spending a million dollars in charity to support education. Most of us just wish they would pay taxes, then we would not need their charity. There are several court cases pending based on a number of different legal points, the state is spending millions on outside attorneys to defend the state because the state A.G. is not a competent enough litigator to represent the state (his words not mine.)
The only things these people understand is voting results. Vote your conscious during the next election.
The new governor of Kentucky also manages to completely ignore existing public schools when discussing public education:
“Bevin is a supporter of charter schools, most recently pledging in his inaugural address to push charter school legislation as a way to give parents and students alternatives to failing schools. Earlier this month, Bevin also appointed longtime charter school advocate Hal Heiner as the secretary of his Education and Workforce Development Cabinet.”
Maybe kids in existing public schools can hire an advocate. The people they’re paying in government don’t seem real interested in the unfashionable “public sector” schools.
http://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/education/2015/12/29/bevin-attend-west-lou-charter-school-event/78014978/
A month ago in early December 2015, Nevada’s top politicians and business leadersrecently convened a conference — “The Education Summit at The University of Nevada Las Vegas” — to address the teacher shortage “crisis” in the traditional public schools. “Crisis” was their word. Governor Sandoval gave the opening speech.
Predictably, such ideas as attracting and retaining teachers through such blatantly obvious methods such raising teacher salaries, decreasing class size, or improving teacher’s working conditions were ever considered; indeed, they never even came up.
Why?
Because those solution would cost money.
The title of an article covering this nonsensical, so-called “Education Summit” — one THAT INCLUDED NO TEACHERS WHATSOEVER — is …
“Nevada’s Efforts to Solve Teacher Shortage Could Be Model for the Country, Officials Say”
Now read the article and try to find what these “efforts” will be… the ones which the politicians and business leader attendees decided to recommend, or the ideas that were even discussed:
http://lasvegassun.com/news/2015/dec/07/nevadas-efforts-to-solve-teacher-shortage-could-be/
Read it again… nowhere within does the writer list any examples of such “Efforts to Solve Teacher Shortage (that) Could Be Model for the Country.”
The article states stuff like …
—————–
“Folks are watching what happens in Nevada. They’re watching to see what we do and how we do it and how it works.”
—————–
Okay, great! So what ARE you doing, or what ARE you going to do?
No answers to that question, but more stuff like …
—————–
“There’s no short-term fix for the teacher pipeline,” said Skorkowsky. “Even if we have an amazing enrollment class at the college of education … that is four years away from actually making a real dent.”
“We have to realize that everything we do in the state of Nevada has to be toward that goal,” he added.
—————–
… and …
—————–
“Our education programs are not attracting the most talented folks out of high school and they’re not the most competitive programs at universities,” he said. “What are we going to do to make this the place where people want to be? There has to be some sort of long-term solution.”
———————
Okay, so what IS that “solution”, guys?
Nothing … just more stuff like …
——————–
“We are in some ways the future of the country,” said Metcalf. “It’s not just racial and ethnic diversity … Many of the other community and state issues we are dealing with will be faced by many other states and communities.”
——————-
Finally the article ends with:
————
“But recent strides to address the problems are making an impact, according to Whalen.
(Really, so what are they???)
“ ‘You are a model for what other states can do to really move the needle,’ she said. ‘We look to states like Nevada who are leading the way in their state investment.’
“And though the summit featured a pair of expert panel discussions on a number of education issues, the uncertainty about Nevada’s educational future was hard to avoid.
“ ‘There’s no playbook for where we’re going,’ said Punam Mathur, director of the Elaine P. Wynn and Family Foundation.”
————–
This almost reads like a piece from THE ONION.
450,000 students will be eligible to participate starting this month.
‘VULTURES in the toilet’ sound just as disgusting as predatory Casinos in Las Vegas. Yuck.