Want to get rich quick? Hurry on down to Florida and open a charter school. You don’t need any experience in education, it doesn’t matter if you failed in the past, just come up with a good idea!
The Sun-Sentinel in Florida published a powerful indictment of the unsupervised charter industry.
In the past five years, 56 South Florida charter schools have closed, expelling thousands of students. Five charter schools in Broward and Palm Beach counties didn’t survive three months.
Jeb Bush boasts at every opportunity about his “reform” policies of privatization in Florida.
Read this article and see what you think about Jeb’s “miracle.”
Unchecked charter-school operators are exploiting South Florida’s public school system, collecting taxpayer dollars for schools that quickly shut down.
A recent spate of charter-school closings illustrates weaknesses in state law: virtually anyone can open or run a charter school and spend public education money with near impunity, a Sun Sentinel investigation found.
Florida requires local school districts to oversee charter schools but gives them limited power to intervene when cash is mismanaged or students are deprived of basic supplies — even classrooms.
Once schools close, the newspaper found, districts struggle to retrieve public money not spent on students.
Among the cases the newspaper reviewed:
• An Oakland Park man received $450,000 in tax dollars to open two new charter schools just months after his first collapsed. The schools shuttled students among more than four locations in Broward County, including a park, an event hall and two churches. The schools closed in seven weeks.
• A Boca Raton woman convicted of taking kickbacks when she ran a federal meal program was hired to manage a start-up charter school in Lauderdale Lakes.
• A Coral Springs man with a history of foreclosures, court-ordered payments, and bankruptcy received $100,000 to start a charter school in Margate. It closed in two months.
• A Hollywood company that founded three short-lived charters in Palm Beach and Collier counties will open a new school this fall. The two Palm Beach County schools did not return nearly $200,000 they owe the district.
South Florida is home to more than 260 charter schools, many of them high-performing. Some cater to students with interests in the performing arts, science and technology, or those with special needs.
Like traditional public schools, charter schools are funded with tax money. But these independent public schools can be opened and operated by individuals, companies or cities, and they are controlled by volunteer governing boards, not local elected school boards.
It gets worse every year, since the state’s weak law allows almost anyone to open a charter school, without regard to their qualifications.
State law requires local school districts to approve or deny new charters based solely on applications that outline their plans in areas including instruction, mission and budget. The statutes don’t address background checks on charter applicants. Because of the lack of guidelines, school officials in South Florida say, they do not conduct criminal screenings or examine candidates’ financial or educational pasts.
That means individuals with a history of failed schools, shaky personal finances or no experience running schools can open or operate charters.
“The law doesn’t limit who can open a charter school. If they can write a good application … it’s supposed to stand alone,” said Jim Pegg, director of the charter schools department for the Palm Beach County school district. “You’re approving an idea.”
Of course, letting anyone open a charter creates a certain level of instability and lots of closures. But that seems to be the way Florida’s leaders like it:
Fifteen charter schools in Broward have closed in the last two years. That number doubled the county’s total closures since charter schools first opened in Florida 18 years ago. Seven charter schools have closed in Palm Beach County in the last two years. That’s more than a quarter of the district’s historic total.
Eight of those failed schools lasted about a year or less. Five didn’t survive three months.
“These are our tax dollars,” said state Sen. Jeff Clemens, D-Lake Worth. “And to let them be used for a school that is only going to survive for one or two years is a huge waste of resources.”
Another 29 charter schools are expected to open in South Florida this fall…..
Charter schools, which receive public money in monthly installments based on student enrollment, can be overpaid if they overestimate their expected attendance or shut down abruptly.
State law requires that furniture, computers and unspent money be returned to the districts, but when officials attempt to collect, charter operators sometimes cannot be found.
“We do know there have been a few [charter schools] … where hundreds of thousands of dollars were never spent on kids, and we don’t know where that money went,” said Pegg, who oversees charters in Palm Beach County. “As soon as we close the door on those schools, those people scatter … We can’t find them.”
When a Broward school district auditor and school detective went searching for Mitchell at the Ivy Academies in September 2013, he left through a back door, records show. District officials said they have yet to find him, or to collect the $240,000 in public money the schools received for students they never had.
The Broward State Attorney’s Office is also investigating Mitchell and his involvement with the Ivy Academies.
The Palm Beach County school district never got back the $113,000 it overpaid La Mensa Academy in Palm Beach Gardens, which closed after a year. La Mensa projected it would have far more students than the five who showed up on the first day of school in 2011.
My Choice Academy has not returned $56,000 to the Palm Beach County school district but is seeking to reopen in the fall. It closed in January 2013 after four months in Riviera Beach because of problems with its lease. The school’s founder, Altermease Kendrick, said the start-up challenges were overwhelming.
Charter fraud is rampant. Ah, the perils of privatization. Maybe one of the news anchors will see this story and ask Jeb a question or two after he boasts about what he has done to education in Florida.

“An Oakland Park man received $450,000 in tax dollars to open two new charter schools just months after his first collapsed. The schools shuttled students among more than four locations in Broward County, including a park, an event hall and two churches. The schools closed in seven weeks.”
The politicians in Florida have actually been lucky so far, as strange as that sounds. There are safety issues involved in putting kids into buildings. They should all thank their lucky stars nothing happened during those 7 weeks. They don’t have to provide a certificate of occupancy until 15 days after the school opens so I bet he was moving locations to avoid that requirement.
LikeLike
And I bet he has since moved locations (out of the US) to avoid something else.
Then again, this is Florida we are talking about, so maybe he has nothing to fear from the judicial system.
A certificate of “crockupancy” would prolly be more apt in this case
Certificate of crockupancy
Is what I need to get
Before my charter occupancy
Can make me millions net
I’ll use a man named Morris
To write my application
Cuz he has something for us
He’s Rheelly a sensation
*Ted Morris of Greater Works Charter fame
LikeLike
Thank you for getting this out, Ms. Ravitch! Florida exemplifies the good ol’ boy government model. It is rife with corruption due to the weakest ethics rules in the country! The Sun-Sentinel tells a side of the story one would never see in the Tampa Bay Times, which prefers to attack public schools. The entire state of Florida should be under federal investigation. The good ol’ boy government just doesn’t reflect the states diverse demographic composition.
The good ol’ boy model for profiting from charters is simple: starve and strangle public schools. Test the students with ever changing assessment instruments with which the teachers are not allowed to become familiar, accuse the public schools of being ineffective, and steal the public money in the name of reform. It’s predictable.
It’s the parents who can change it, but the far-right disinformation machine is powerful. It amazes me, just how many people unwittingly engage in their in there own destruction through the far-right disinformation apparatus.
Hopefully, the tide is indeed turning.
LikeLike
I always wonder why Ohio charter schools are nationally known for poor quality yet Florida’s insane charter scheme is never mentioned.
I wonder if it’s because Jeb Bush is so powerful in the ed reform “movement” that no one dares to criticize his true education legacy. .
It would probably be really damaging if national ed reform leaders had to admit that both Ohio and Florida were disasters, particularly because those two states are important politically to national politicians like Obama or Bush or Clinton. If it becomes know that there are huge problems in OH. FL, MI and PA they’re really in trouble. It’s better politically to pretend that Ohio is a lone “bad apple” than to start adding up the states.
LikeLike
Yes, Bush has millions in champaign money and support from his brother’s and father’s political connections. They don’t care if hundreds of charters go belly up, they’re making money, taxpayer money. One commenter is correct, all these failed charters will not be converted back to the public domain. They will revise them and start another. Why? It’s not about the kids, never has been, it’s about the MONEY.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on The Withering Apple and commented:
The Sun-Sentinel comes through where the Tampa Bay Times fails miserably: Telling the truth.
LikeLike
You are correct. This report does not conver the rest of Florida with 50 plus counties.
LikeLike
67 counties, plus eight special “districts,” and lab schools. I am not clear on your point, however. Please explain.
LikeLike
Great reporting. I always thought charters were great for kids and parents. After reading articles like this, I’m no longer a fan.
LikeLike
Momoffive: if I may, I would like to add that one of the victims of the self-styled “education reform” movement are—
What many call the “mom-and-pop charters” that are not part of the charter chains and backed by big money and that genuinely strive to serve those students most in need.
So I hope you do not mind my agreeing with you in general while still lamenting that the charters that try to do the right thing are also getting the short end of the stick.
That’s just the way I see it…
Thank you for your comments.
😎
LikeLike
Bombshell is right! It reminds me of the housing scams that led to another near Great Depression back in 2008. No income, no pulse…..sure, you can get a mortgage, as long as you can fill in the application. Crooks took off with the cash and then the taxpayers picked up the tab. The common denominator is little to no government supervision with plenty of moral hazard lining the pockets of business.
To quote from the article: “The law doesn’t limit who can open a charter school. If they can write a good application … it’s supposed to stand alone,” said Jim Pegg, director of the charter schools department for the Palm Beach County school district. “You’re approving an idea.”
This is REAL journalism. If newspapers are not covering this type of story then they are asleep at the wheel. We ought to forward this post to every media outlet we can think of.
LikeLike
They openly brag about the numbers of schools opened in Ohio. They “flooded the market” in Toledo. That’s the actual language that was used.
The difference between “charter” and “public” there is remarkable in my state. We’re building a new public school. The state of Ohio has something called “the school facilities department” and they rank the safety and efficiency and value of public school buildings. If you’re building a school you have to clear it with them at every step in the process. Charters must be completely exempt from this, because they open and close seemingly overnight. That’s unimaginable in a public school context. It would be against the law.
LikeLike
From the FLDOE website.
“Facilities Requirements as Stated in Statute
Section 1002.33(19), F.S., is entitled “FACILITIES.” Sub-section (a) reads as follows:
“A startup charter school shall utilize facilities which comply with the Florida Building Code pursuant to Chapter 553 except for the State Requirements for Educational Facilities.”
True public schools have to comply with stricter standards than charter schools. True public schools can be used for hurricane/emergency shelters. Charter schools can be in industrial areas where the speed limits are 45 mph.
LikeLike
When local school boards denied questionable charter schools, the charters simply appealed to the state and got approval.
http://www.sun-sentinel.com/local/palm-beach/fl-palm-charter-school-appeal-20150413-story.html
What would be an interesting investigative story would be a follow upon how all the schools that were initially denied by the local districts and won an appeal from the Charter Schools Appeal Commission in Tallahassee are faring.
So much for the Republicans being for local control and small government.
LikeLike
Lets not think, even briefly, that the increasing number of charter failures will lead to a collective moment of clarity and result in a re-public-ing of these schools. That will not happen. Once privatized, public space and resources rarely, if ever, return to the public. That isn’t just a cheap platitude. It’s backed up historically.
When one examines past adventures in privatizing (not difficult here in the US as that is basically the bedrock experience of our society), whether it be the privatizing of oil, mineral rights, military functions, whatever, one quickly sees a broad pattern emerge. There is a period of frenzy when all kinds of players jump into the new market created. A huge proportion of these are fly-by-night amateurs. Over time, amateur hour comes to a close and the larger, more competent players emerge and start dominating the space. This is from where monopolies begin to rear their heads, but it is nonetheless a sign of amateurs departing the stage.
We are still in prime-time amateur hour with school privatization. The flagrant, egregious, and very loud failures of many of these amateurs will not lead to a reassessment and eventual return to the public of their schools. Larger, more competent (by this I in no way mean to say good at what schools should be good at….I simply mean to say that the larger charter forces that will emerge will be competent in creating a narrative of and data of “success.”) entities will eventually prevail. Those schools and districts that are now charters will likely remain so in spite of their recent failures.
Here in NY, the latest talk about “receivership” schools is the first step in a broader play to begin privatizing on a larger scale throughout the state. We must realize that if we lose that fight we will have lost those schools for good.
Privatizers of public space have the luxury of fairly limitless failure.
LikeLike
NYSTEACHER: much food for thought.
Again, I am being picky, but until the situation on the ground changes I would amend your last sentence to read: “Privatizers of public space have the luxury of limitless failure.”
And, I might add, the luxury of constantly screaming that public schools are failing students who will never get back all that precious time of missed educational opportunity—and they are completely absent decrying such about Florida and other places where charters are doing what they claim is inexcusable.
Double think. Double talk. Double standards.
Thank you for your comments.
😎
LikeLike
Wow.
LikeLike
It is important to remember that our predecessors paid taxes and bought municipal bonds to build and develop public schools and it is their legacy that we need to honor and respect by keeping public education free, local, and under school board – representative control. Anything less is undemocratic.
LikeLike
This should be illegal, the private use of public monies with no oversight. That means previous felons and child abusers can be hired without background checks. How can this be illegal in public schools but allowed in charters. Every state should have laws on the books to make charters illegal especially if they operate out of the view of the public.
LikeLike
The “good” charter operators extract money from the public school system; the “bad ones straight-out loot it.
Ah, yes, welcome to “the civil rights movement of our time.”
LikeLike
This is appalling! How utterly irresponsible—and worse—to have a system that allows application ‘plans” to be the only criterion for getting large amounts of tax dollars. It is normal to do basic background checks on prospective rental tenants. This can take as little as three phone calls to check references, or it can include a credit check. None of these requires much time, cost, or effort. Why would you do less than that when children and their education are involved? With no investigation of one’s educational, professional, or criminal history, this process creates a situation where profit, instead of education and children, is the primary (and perhaps only) goal. What a sure fire way to attract a less than moral (criminal) element! Exploiting anyone is bad, and to do so to children is reprehensible. To have a system that facilitates exploiting children and their need for good educations in safe, stable environments so that they can grow and develop is OUTRAGEOUS!
Thank you for exposing this disgraceful situation. I hope it will become nationally known, and lead to badly needed reform asap. Our children deserve our respect, trust, protection, and guidance. There should be laws that protect children from this kind of abuse.
LikeLike
I’ve not listened to much that Jeb Bush says.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Lloyd Lofthouse and commented:
Jeb Bush boasts at every opportunity about his “reform” policies of privatization in Florida.
Read this article and see what you think about Jeb’s “miracle.”
LikeLike
The tight fisted “good ol’ boys” found expanding Medicaid to the poor too expensive, but they can find taxpayer dollars to roll the dice in the casino of privatization. That makes perfect sense in an upside down world.
LikeLike
Same story, different state. What concerns me is what we DON’T know. Charter schools want less regulation and scrutiny. Of course! So, the government obliges them and look what happens. Which makes me wonder, what are some of the so-called “good ones” doing? In Camden, NJ there is a charter school that enjoys a good reputation. They were one of the first to open and are supported by a local university. I watched as they siphoned off my best students from a nearby public school where I was teaching. Not long after, the local newspaper reported that the founder and director was using public funds to have her suburban lawn in a wealthy suburb taken care of by one of the employees at the school. When he complained, she fired him.
What DON”T we know about? With less transparency, there will be more hands in the cookie jar. It infuriates me.
LikeLike
This article was written before two more charter schools closed in April 2015 – — Red Shoe Charter School for Girls and Obama Academy for Boys; they couldn’t account for $876K.
http://www.sun-sentinel.com/local/broward/fl-urban-academy-charter-schools-final-closure-20150407-story.html
This is the guy that ran them. He says they will become private schools. (My guess he is hoping for vouchers.)
http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/news/local/ex-south-bay-manager-says-he-pled-guilty-rather-th/nhNdR/
LikeLike
Ohio is nearing the anniversary of the oral arguments in a landmark charter school case before the Supreme Court. Plunderbund reports 10 charter schools sued their operator, White Hat Management, to learn how state funds for their schools were being spent. The bigger issue is the use of public property to create private assets. It is taking the court an unprecedented amount of time to render a verdict. No surprise.
Continuance of a trend, judicial systems, without blindfolds and, with pockets, open
LikeLike