Businesses and their allies in politics have done a successful job of whittling away the power of unions and nearly strangling them. Big-business is now trying to decimate public sector unions. But there are still millions of low-wage workers who suffer from long hours, low wages, and poor working conditions.
This article describes efforts by workers in New Mexico and elsewhere to gain some protection from abusive conditions by forming “committees.” Businesses don’t like this either but it is still not a labor union, with the power to bargain collectively and gain victories for workers.
SANTA FE, N.M. — Jorge Porras used to report to his carwash job here most mornings at 8:15 a.m., but he said that his boss often did not let him clock in until 11, when customers frequently began streaming in. Many days he was paid for just six hours, he said, even though he worked nine and a half hours.
One day, when the heavy chain that pulled cars forward got stuck, Mr. Porras tried to fix it, but it suddenly lurched forward and cut off the top of his right ring finger. The injury caused him to miss work for the next two weeks, he said, but he received no pay or workers’ compensation for the forced time off.
Mr. Porras and nine co-workers became so fed up that they took an unusual step. They formed a workers committee (not a labor union) and sent a certified letter to the owner of the carwash. In it, they complained about being “insulted and humiliated” in “front of our co-workers and customers” and protested being required to work off the clock and not being given goggles or gloves even though they worked with toxic chemicals.
An advocacy group for immigrant workers, Somos Un Pueblo Unido, advised Squeaky Clean’s workers to set up such a committee because the National Labor Relations Act — enacted under President Franklin Delano Roosevelt in 1935 — prohibits employers from retaliating against workers for engaging in “concerted” activity to improve their wages and conditions, even when they are not trying to unionize.
In an era when the traditional labor unions envisioned by Depression-era supporters of that law have weakened steadily, many advocates now see work site committees as an alternative way to strengthen workers’ clout and protections.
Simon Brackley, president of the Santa Fe Chamber of Commerce, said Somos had exaggerated the prevalence of wage violations and had been too quick to pounce on employers. But Somos is not backing down, and many worker groups are now copying its work site committee idea, which has been adopted at about 35 restaurants, hotels and other companies in Santa Fe….
Only days after the Squeaky Clean workers sent their letter in 2012, the owner fired Mr. Porras, Mr. Muñoz and four others. The fired workers and Somos complained to the National Labor Relations Board’s regional office in Phoenix. That office soon filed a civil complaint against Squeaky Clean, accusing it of unlawfully retaliating against the workers for engaging in what the courts call “protected, concerted” activities.
“We knew we’d have little protection if we acted alone,” Mr. Porras, an immigrant from Guatemala, said in Spanish. “But we knew that if we formed a committee, we’d be protected.”
Ultimately, the labor board ordered Squeaky Clean to reinstate the workers and pay $6,000 in back wages. The carwash agreed separately to pay $60,000 to settle claims for minimum wage and overtime violations.
The deterioration of working conditions in low-wage, non-unionized sectors like fast food and other services makes you wonder whether there might be a rebirth of unionism. When things get bad enough, collective action becomes necessary.

So we have to re-invent the wheel. But why not just form a union? Or join an existing one?
LikeLike
Yes, it would be better.
But it is really, really, really difficult to organize a union in this country right now. It takes a long time and in most cases, the employer will do everything to delay it or stop it.
Employers don’t have to be ruthless about anti-union activity, because it’s so easy for them. There are lots of lawyers to help them with it. The employer will be able to get away with breaking the law in most cases.
This has been going on for 35 years. It’s institutionalized.
This partly explains the timidity of teachers unions, even though they are among the strongest unions left.
LikeLike
Let us always remember the power of the union via Poland.
Solidarity movement anniversary commemorated in Gdansk (8/30)
http://www.france24.com/en/20100830-poland-commemorates-solidarity-movement-changed-world-communism-walesa-donald-tusk-gdansk
Thirty(five) years ago …, an electrician led a burgeoning labour movement that would forever change Poland and the world. Lech Walesa’s bold advocacy for labour rights (…) ultimately lead to Communism’s demise in Europe.
LikeLike
Which Ronald Reagan supported. Would he make it past the GOP primary today?
LikeLike
I found this page as result of search about Solidarity today.
The same search found a 2005 interview with David Ost, an author I’d never heard of. Apparently Gdansk Solidarity was crushed in a few years, partly due abandonment by the ‘intellectuals’ who had supported Solidarity in the 1980s.
“This has been going on for 35 years. It’s institutionalized.”
employee unions/collectives have been effectively nearly banned (by overload of redtape, just as contraceptives and abortion are being banned); the oligarchs’ unions not at all.
LikeLike
I don’t understand why anyone would vote to get rid of unions. They are the only thing that workers have which gives a voice in getting decent working conditions and decent pay.
Around 32,000 workers protested in Indianapolis several years ago when the GOP Congress voted to pass Right to Work (for low wages) which weakens unions Our Congressmen and Tea Party Governor Pence still say we now have one of the best conditions in the U.S. for businesses to come to Indiana. The average worker in NW Indiana saw his salary go down an average of $3,000 in one year.
Hoosiers still vote for these politicians. Why????
LikeLike
I believe that workers need unions to advocate and protect them ( safety in numbers). However, the unions are a problem because they have forgotten who they serve. Much like politicians, union leaders are in it for their own longevity and benefit, not for the benefit of the workers who make their position possible.
LikeLike
How long before teachers in charter schools find out about this?
LikeLike
Anyone that is looking for something to do on Labor Day should check out “Norma Rae” with Sally Field. Times may have changed, but the struggle continues today.
As for the above story, it is well known that immigrants are often exploited by employers. As an ESL teacher that has worked with some undocumented parents, I heard terrible complaints about working conditions as well as getting cheated out of wages. Some employers know that undocumented workers will not cause them problems so they exploit the situation.
LikeLike
Our teacher unions around here are weak – afraid to confront the superintendents. If every union went on strike until they got rid of the Common Core and its aligned tests we could go back to our Learning Standards and move forward.
LikeLike
I just moved to MA and I am in a district that is under receivership. I think that being a union member here is probably not really important:( I think tenure is where you get some protection.
LikeLike
Best of luck in your new position. Have a great year!
LikeLike
Welcome to MA, Texas! But I think you’re mistaken about not needing a union. I know things look a lot better here, but if you’re under state receivership in Holyoke, Lowell, or one of the Boston schools so designated, be wary. The MA DESE wears a pretty smile, but it’s got venom in its bite.
LikeLike
” I think that being a union member here is probably not really important:( I think tenure is where you get some protection.”
You are partially right. As an probationary teacher (non-tenured) you typically do not have much in the way of job protection since you are basically an at-will employee. You do not have due process rights and typically the union has no way to protect you. They have concentrated on building in protection for their tenured members. I have been around during negotiations when the veterans have decided that in “this round” of negotiations they have to do something for beginning teachers, like put more of the salary increases in the earlier years (that frequently have been ignored for more lucrative later year increases). That’s one reason why teachers don’t move around much once they get tenure. You lose that protection and start over if you go to a new district. At least that’s the way it works in my Midwest state.
LikeLike
I think it’s great that working people are acting on their own behalf instead of waiting for their elected representatives to respond. It’s been 30 years. The cavalry isn’t coming. They really, really need advocates and who better but themselves? Bravo.
LikeLike
I listened to public radio this morning. There is a shortage of welders. The news person interviewed a vocational instructor and a representative of a lobbying group for manufacturers.
On Labor Day, it doesn’t occur to public radio to 1. interview a representative of a labor union, even though labor unions offer skilled trades training OR 2. ask why US manufacturers don’t make an investment and train the welders they need.
They all decided the shortage of welders was a failing of the public education system.
Incredible. There is literally NOTHING that is not the fault of the US education system 🙂
US companies are completely helpless when they can’t find welders. It is UNIMAGINABLE that we could ask them to train people, or ask them if maybe there aren’t any skilled trades people because they all lobbied so hard against labor unions so destroyed that pipeline.
LikeLike
When I get up in the morning, if it is cloudy, I think it is the fact of the local school. Ha Ha Ha
LikeLike
Chiara. The writers of the common core and the college and career ready standards also want to offload the burden of training employees to K-12 education..
In fact, many low-wage entry level occupations require “on the job training.” A typical US worker has held 11 different jobs by the age of 44.
An “introduction to welding” course was a staple in many large high schools not too long ago.
Now, learning to “code” is being taught in more schools, urged on by the tech industry and the proliferation of online courses, after school programs and camps (including camps for hackers). The glut of coders is intended to lower wages.
As for NPR, it looks like the unions missed an opportunity to offer PBS the pitch and the personnel for a lively interview on a VIP day.
LikeLike
It is too depressing that the billionaires have also bought our public radio and television airwaves.
LikeLike
Shortage. Glut. Shortage. Glut.
It seems either condition lasts no longer than two years.
It reminds me of news stories, “Latest study indicates that coffee may not be so bad for your heart. Though too small to be definitive…”
Two months later, “New study suggests that coffee may raise blood pressure in middle aged men. Though too small to be definitive…”
LikeLike
You rarely hear comments about police, firefighters, or nurses unions. I wonder why.
LikeLike
the oligarchs are siccing nurses, too. But most of their fire is currently aimed at government employees.
LikeLike
Might be a good thing. Unions need to reinvent themselves and perhaps as professional organizations or a true party for labor. The only reason teachers’ unions exist as they do today is the widespread demonization and antagonistic attitude of America towards teachers. Throw in a dash of misogyny with a sprinkle of anti-intellectualism and you have the conservative/corporate catalysts creating the need for unionization in education. If America actually valued and respected its teachers like other advanced countries, teachers’ unions would look a whole lot different. Instead, teachers must constantly try to teach while dealing with interference and nonsense from statehouses and departments of education.
LikeLike
There are laws that protect workers. A worker must be paid for the hours worked. Any one who is being defrauded by an employer can and should contact their state wage/hour office. Too bad teachers do not get all of these safeguards. We do not get time and a half or the guarantee of a forty hour week. We literally spend all of our hours in front of the students which means that all of our prepping is done for free.
LikeLike
Here is what Bernie Sanders says about unions.
Sanders writes: “The middle class is at a tipping point, and it won’t last another generation if we don’t boldly change course now. The surest path to the middle class for American workers is with unions. The security and strength of a union job means that workers can have good pay, health care, and a voice at work.”
LikeLike
He needs to remember that…”The security and strength of a union job means that workers can have good pay, health care, and a voice at work.” …and that it applies to teachers as well. So far his stance along with most other progressive voices cannot understand the destructive power and control of today’s high stakes testing that takes away the teacher’s professionalism.
LikeLike