The biggest scam in higher education was perpetrated by Corinthian Colleges, a for-profit corporation that once enrolled more than 120,000 students at 120 campuses. Corinthian collapsed recently, leaving tens of thousands of students saddled with debt and worthless degrees.
The recruiters focused on minorities, the poor, and veterans, making false promises about future employment and costs. The bottom line was always the same: profits. Not education.
The linked article is the inside story of the decline and fall of Corinthian, its predatory practices, its lies to students, and the inaction of the DOE.
“In lawsuits, official complaints to state and federal regulators, sworn declarations submitted in Corinthian’s bankruptcy proceeding, and conversations with The Huffington Post, dozens of former Corinthian students and several former Corinthian employees said that Corinthian drowned students in debt and sent them off with meaningless diplomas that did not help — and sometimes even harmed — their job prospects. It illegally padded job placement statistics and gave students college credit for “externships” at fast-food restaurants. It charged students up to 10 times what a comparable community college degree would cost. More than 1 in 4 Corinthian graduates defaulted on their student loans, according to Education Department data. And for years, the Education Department not only failed to recognize the depths of the abuse, but effectively funded Corinthian’s business model, sending the company billions of dollars in financial aid to help cover students’ bills.”
Why did the U.S. Department of Education allow this fraud to continue for so long? One might well ask why the U.S. Department of Education has been silent about the growth of predatory for-profit K-12 schools, both virtual and brick-and-mortar. For the first time in history, the U.S. ED just doesn’t see privatization and profit-making as a problem.
“In 2008, Tasha Courtright visited the Everest College campus in Ontario, California, with a friend. She was not looking to pursue higher education. “The recruiter said, ‘How about you? Do you want to go to school?’” Courtright recalled.
“I said I can’t afford it, I can’t do loans,” she remembered, noting that she was working a minimum-wage job at a gas station when Corinthian first recruited her. “They said, ‘Let us do the numbers.’ They said I qualified for Cal Grants and Pell Grants, and I wouldn’t have to pay anything.”
“The recruiter called Courtright repeatedly for two days, pressuring her to make a decision. “They said classes were starting and ‘If you don’t do it now, you never will.’ So I went down again and signed up.” Courtright spent four years at Everest, earning a bachelor’s degree in applied business management. She said recruiters promised she wouldn’t pay a dime; she ended up with $41,000 in student debt.
“High-pressure sales tactics like that were deliberately targeted at vulnerable demographic groups, including single mothers and the unemployed, according to Lueck, the former Corinthian manager. Recruits were often the first in their families to attend college. Almost anyone could qualify.
“Laurie McDonnell, a librarian at the Everest-Ontario Metro campus, resigned after learning that her school had enrolled a man who read at a third-grade level.
“The goal was simple: profits. Smaller chains like Lincoln Tech or DeVry used to dominate the for-profit college industry. But toward the end of the last decade, larger, publicly traded companies took over. By 2009, three-quarters of all U.S. students enrolled in for-profit colleges were at schools owned by a corporate conglomerate or private equity firm. Goldman Sachs owns around 40 percent of Education Management Corporation, another operator of for-profit colleges.
“Many for-profit college companies own multiple university brands. Corinthian, which traded on Nasdaq, ran Everest, Wyotech and Heald Colleges. The consolidation of the industry changed how for-profit schools operated, argues Elizabeth Baylor, senior investigator on a landmark 2012 Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee study of for-profits. “Student success was not the primary focus of the entity. It was returning investor value,” Baylor, who now works at the Center for American Progress, told HuffPost.
“One-quarter of the average for-profit college budget goes to marketing and recruitment, Baylor said. The goal is to capture and retain students, and squeeze as much money out of them as possible. The 2012 Senate report found that Corinthian’s students defaulted on their loans at a rate that was “by far the highest of any publicly traded company” that investigators scrutinized.”

I was reading the other day about University of Phoenix hitting the skids and ITT about to go bankrupt so it seems that the fall of Corinthian is just the first domino in the chain.
Why does this remind me of the Savings and Loan crisis of the 1980s which brought down another set of greedy, Friedmanesque ‘free marketeers’ who took advantage of government largesse to pad their own pockets and screw the people?
We need to start paying more attention to our history and stop electing crooks that make these kinds of scandals so easy. I’m looking at you, charter school supporters in the USDOE and in nearly every damn state of the union now.
LikeLike
When will people ever learn that education is not a business?
LikeLike
There are two segments of our economy that have higher inflation rates than ALL others – health care and higher education. What do these two markets have in common? THIRD PARTY PAYER SYSTEMS! Student loans and the convoluted insurance system shield the customers from the cost. This gives perverse incentives to act in ways that people would NOT if they were not shielded from the consequences.
LikeLike
Third party payment can distort demand. Unscrupulous physicians perform billions of dollars worth of unnecessary and potentially harmful procedures.
In education, there is a prevailing but unrealistic belief that “everyone” should go to college. In reality only about 15% of the population can do real college work. When people who are not capable of performing at the college level are enrolled in a university either the curriculum is dumbed down or the students are set up to fail.
People who commit massive fraud should go to prison. This includes private and public scammers. Tomorrow the Chicago Teachers Union is holding an illegal strike “for the children.” They are encouraging others to join in this so-called “Day of Action.” While there are many excellent teachers and staff in public schools, CTU in collusion with CPS is perpetrating fraud and not serving the people. FDR said there is no right to strike against the people.
Education needs to meet the needs of all students and the public, and this means significantly expanding trade and vocational education.
LikeLike
John Oliver exposed this well: http://youtu.be/P8pjd1QEA0c
LikeLike
Diane,
I have been following your posts. Thank you so much for the work you’re doing to help keep people like myself informed. I work in a school system in GA that has become a charter system. I have not liked what I’ve seen happening. On the other hand, my son went to a charter school in Gwinnett County (I work i Fulton County) called Gwinnett School of Math, Science and Technology. It was a better fit for him than our regular high school. He has high functioning autism and ADHD. I feel like a hypocrite having utilized this charger school, but now experiencing negative consequences of a charter system where I work. I’m genuinely concerned about special education and 2e students in our regular schools. It’s not a good environment for their learning, and many parents are flocking to online programs which may or may not suit their child’s learning style.
On another note, regarding specifically to the blog below on Higher Education, that same son is scheduled to attend Beloit College in Wisconsin. How do we find out if the financial aid program there is run by a corrupt financial assistance program? He will have a great deal of loans by the time he is done, but he would also have loans in GA schools even if on the HOPE scholarship if he were to live on campus.
Thank you for any guidance or direction you can provide, and again, thank you for all of the information you send out each day!
Rachel Cole
LikeLike
Rachel, I don’t know the answer to your question about financial aid at Beloit. It is a good college, not-for-profit, so I would assume the best. It is the for-profits that are thoroughly corrupt by greed.
LikeLike
Don’t worry about Beloit. They are totally legitimate. One of my sons and his now wife both attended Beloit.
LikeLike
Are any of the political leaders who promoted this going ti be held accountable?
They were not aware that the for-profits were brutally ripping off low income people and veterans?
I mean, this is ridiculous. We’re now all going to pretend this wasn’t heavily promoted for 10 years? Can we get a corruption investigation or is that no longer done?
LikeLike
Just remember this posting the next time the heavyweights of the “new civil rights movement of our time” and their salespeople aim their for-profit pitch at the folks like those that were sucker punched by Corinthian.
The rheephorm mantra of “unfettered greed will answer every educational need” is true only in the sense that it answers the needs of the few at the expense of the many.
And again, those in this smash-and-grab band of predators have various political labels and pretenses.
Pay no attention to external appearances. If you want to know what’s really up, best to heed that old adage: follow the money.
😎
LikeLike
What can be added to what has been said a thousand times on this blog.
However, one item needs emphasis:
We, the tax payers pay for at least some of these nefarious workings.
The GI bill, paid for by taxpayers, foot the bill for those GIs who have sought to further their education in these kinds of “colleges”. It is also true of charters.
It is so reprehensible, preying on – as mentioned – the poor etc. Not only does it rob them financially but emotionally too, that they put effort and time in a fraud that leaves them emotionally as well as financially devastated.
LikeLike
Likewise, the areas targeted for charter school expansion are mostly poor, minority urban areas. The way in which they do it is to put the “failing” school into receivership, and hijack parents’ democratic input in the process. The whole procedure resembles an invading army, not government. The governor or mayor never puts anything to a vote. In fact, when parents and students protest because they want a neighborhood public school, they are ignored because the leader is obliged to deliver these schools to his cronies for profit. This is more like a dictatorship than a democracy.
LikeLike
Three words, which make me shudder: It’s ONLY business.
LikeLike
This is the same basic pattern that was followed by Wall Street banks with the subprime lending that led to the financial meltdown in 07/08: targeting the poor to take out mortgages that banks knew could not (and would not*) be paid pay back (*which was of no concern to the banks because the mortgages were simply packaged up and sold off to some state pension plan or other unsuspecting sap long before they exploded)
Notwithstanding Alan Greenspan’s idiotic assumption to the contrary (an “error” which he finally acknowledged in his famous “I have found a flaw” statement), fraud is the inevitable result of insufficient regulation and oversight.
LikeLike
and just to be clear, the primary fraud was committed by banks themselves (not by those taking out the mortgages)
LikeLike
This fraud was committed with the knowledge and the support of the Trustees of Corinthian.
And this one bio gives you an idea of why USDE looked aside at the corruption in addition to just loving on-line and market-based education, including scams.
One of Corinthian trustees was Sharon Robinson. Look at her bio.
Sharon P. Robinson, Ed.D, age 69, was appointed to the Board of Directors in January 2011 and is a member of the Compensation Committee of the Company’s Board of Directors.
Dr. Robinson currently serves as President and Chief Executive Officer of the American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education, a position she has held since 2005. (still had that post in 2014).
Previously, she held a number of senior management positions at Educational Testing Service beginning in 1997, most recently as Executive Vice President and President of its Educational Policy Leadership Institute.
From 1993 to 1997, Dr. Robinson was Assistant Secretary of Education with the U.S. Department of Education’s Office of Education Research and Improvement, and before that, she was Director of the National Center for Innovation for the National Education Association.
Dr. Robinson earned a doctorate degree in educational administration and supervision, a master of arts degree in education curriculum and instruction and a bachelor’s degree in English and education from the University of Kentucky.
She has served, or currently serves, on the Board of Trustees of the Woodrow Wilson National Fellowship Program, Southern Education Foundation, National Education Association Foundation for the Improvement of Education, and the Management and Training Corp., for which she serves as compensation committee chair, and she serves as a director for Jobs for America’s Graduates.
Bios for all of the other” trustees” of this sham operation can be found at : http://insiders.morningstar.com/trading/executive-profile.action?PersonId=PS00007GYI&flag=Director&insider=Sharon_Robinson&t=PINX:COCOQ®ion=usa&culture=en-US&cur=
LikeLike
Trustees were paid big sums to lend their names and by proxy the organizations they represent. Similar,I think,to the big bucks Gates and other s spread to leaders of the teachers unions.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Texas Education.
LikeLike