Just when I think the charter scandals in Ohio can’t possibly get worse, they do. The State Auditor, a Republican named Dave Yost, reported that a charter owner had inflated enrollment and overcharged the state by $1,3 million.
“General Chappie James Leadership Academy in Dayton reported enrollment of 459 students, however an investigation by state Auditor Dave Yost found nearly half of those students had never attended or long since left the school.
“To illustrate the extent of the deception, Yost said one parent told investigators “her kid could not have been in school because the child was incarcerated for two years. Another family had moved to Georgia.”
The state may never recover the money because the school closed a year ago. “Results of the investigation have been passed along to the Montgomery County Prosecutor’s office for review and possible criminal charges.”
When will Ohio taxpayers wake up?
Valerie Strauss sums up the embarrassing situationS of the Ohio charter industry: It has become a national joke.
Strauss quotes a story in the Plain Dealer in Ohio saying:
Ohio, the charter school world is making fun of you.
Ohio’s $1 billion charter school system was the butt of jokes at a conference for reporters on school choice in Denver late last week, as well as the target of sharp criticism of charter school failures across the state.
The shots came from expected critics like teachers unions, but also from pro-charter voices, as the state considers ways to improve how it handles charters …
Even charter supporters were laughing at Ohio’s troubled charter sector, which is low-performing and riddled with ethically challenged charter operators who care more about profits than education.
Strauss quotes:
An example of a joke from the conference: “Be very glad that you have Nevada, so you are not the worst,” charter researcher Margaret “Macke” Raymond said of Ohio. Raymond, from the Hoover Institute at Stanford University, conducts research on charter schools and issued a report late last year that said Ohio charter school students learn 36 days less math and 14 days less reading than traditional public school students — conclusions she drew from crunching data obtained from student standardized test scores.
Lest we forget: Nevada recently passed an all-state voucher program so that almost any student can attend a charter school, a religious school, a virtual school, or be home schooled. This is the state that Macke Raymond holds up as the worst in the nation for the poor quality of its choice schools. And Nevada wants more, to cement its reputation as the worst of the worst!

Legislators and charter operators have no shame in OH so I doubt they care about being the butt of a joke. As long as the charters get the public money and the Republicans get contributions from charter owners, they don’t give 2 hoots. By the way, David Brennan is looking to sell several of his charters to a national company, so something may be about to change, I’m crossing my fingers. Mr. Brennan doesn’t do anything that doesn’t provide easy (public) money.
LikeLike
http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/union-backed-group-calls-for-pause-in-federal-money-for-charter-schools/2015/06/12/b1cbff0a-1081-11e5-adec-e82f8395c032_story.html
LikeLike
Bill Gates worked with Capital Impact Partners to guarantee funds for charter school start-ups because he values information derived from data?
He opposes an increase in minimum wage, pensions, and higher taxation, on oligarchs, aimed at preventing concentration of wealth, because his decisions are based on data not, plutocratic ideology?
His company, Microsoft works with Pearson to develop curriculum for his copyrighted “charitable” Common Core project. His foundation, working with Pearson, backs for-profit Bridge International Academies, in countries that have populations that can barely scape up enough money to feed themselves. Data informs his decisions?
And, while he remains among the 5 richest men in the world, he’s claimed for years that he’s working to give away the bulk of his fortune.
Which oligarch appears to ignore data, more than Gates does?.
LikeLike
You’re supposed to be grateful to Bill Gates and not ask any questions.
Anything less that complete, groveling deference is a “conspiracy theory”.
He’s good and he’s always right because he’s rich. Any questions? I didn’t think so. Now take your “free gift” and thank him.
LikeLike
“Where’s Waldo?” (the charter student)
Waldo’s not in the charter
I’m certain cuz I looked
In classroom and much farther
The book was simply cooked
Waldo’s been in prison
So hasn’t been to class
He’s learning long division
With bars to help his task
LikeLike
When the corporate controlled media “educates” the public and corporate propaganda supplants quality journalism this is what results. Again, profound chutzpah, they castigate public schools, teachers and fail miserably to truly educate the public. Shouting lies and half truths long enough and people believe the lies and half truths. Hitler and other fascist mentalities know this well and our media emulates this and calls it democracy. Doublespeak if ever there it existed.
LikeLike
Ohio is offering “free summer promotions” for the newest ed reform GED product. I guess it’s in response to the plummeting numbers of people who can even attempt the GED.
Are the students the product or the test? I can never keep that part straight. Arne Duncan might say “both/and!” in that ridiculous business-speak he parrots.
“Students can keep their momentum going and stay engaged over the summer with these GED summer promotions. The graduation-themed promotion runs June 15 to Aug. 1, with savings for first-time test takers. The reactivation campaign runs June 15 to Aug. 1, offering various test and study material promotions for test takers who have been idle for 90+ days.”
http://education.ohio.gov/Media/Ed-Connection/June-8-2015/Take-advantage-of-GED-summer-promotions
LikeLike
I just checked out the website of Mike DeWine, Ohio Attorney General to see if there is any way to report these scams. Not, it seems, without out filing a “customer” complaint using the menus to that are available none of which mention education or charters, so you have to be clever–academy, school, training, children–etc and then hope for informative returns.
The only return I could muster without doing a formal request for records (5 cents per page) was for a computer training outfit with about 11 complaints of three types. An investigative team would be required to search the database, and it would help to have the legal name of the outfit or street address.
The “Consumer Complaint” website does not have categories that make it easy to report fraud. If does not have education as a major category, and unless you file a request for records you do not get much information about the extent of any action, if any was taken.
I found several vocational training programs with the action taken nothing more than referral to another agency.
Bottom line, there is no evident concern about charter fraud in this office, even if the fraud is making news nationally, for multiple years, and the frauds are moving to real estate deals, huge rip-offs of taxpayers money and outflows of those dollars from legitimate public schools. To be sure the charter laws need to be changed, but these scams are so numerous and so blatant that the operators ought to be be charged and hauled into court.
Also, I just sent this exact posting to the office of Mike DeWine. If I get a peply I will post it.
LikeLike
While you’re at it maybe we could ask Ohio lawmakers why they are proposing turning Ohio public schools into Ohio charter schools, taking advice from the Fordham people.
Are charter schools such a roaring success in this state that we now take direction from the people who set up the charter system? Why don’t they fix their own “sector” first?
http://stateimpact.npr.org/ohio/2015/06/11/teachers-without-credentials-or-seniority/#more-29632
LikeLike
And now this: http://knowyourcharter.com/share-your-story/britt-worthington/
LikeLike
I wonder if a newspaper could increase circulation in Ohio, by admitting that they were wrong to quote Fordham and Students First, without getting a quote from the other side?
What if they admitted it would have been good journalism to identify, in print, the corporate and plutocratic funders of education deform organizations? What if they wrote, “There is irrefutable proof that charters are corrupting state capitols and fleecing taxpayers”, adding, “We want to honor sacrifices made for democracy and expose the threat that Reed Hastings’ condemnation of democratically elected school boards presents, therefore, our newspaper, having witnessed more than 10 years of charter school failure and fraud, support commonly owned and community run schools. We advocate for the elimination of charter schools in Ohio.”
LikeLike