This cartoon summarizes Jeb Bush’s education record. He is best known for championing high-stakes testing, A-F school grades, supporting Common Core, charters, vouchers, third-grade retention, and anything that. Strips away job protections from teachers. He boasts of the “Florida miracle,” but it refers mostly to 4th grade NAEP scores, which are likely boosted by third-grade retention and by the state’s class-size reduction policy, adopted by popular referendum but opposed by Bush. The miracle disappears by high school, as Florida’s high school graduation rate is below that of Alabama, which had no miracle.
David Sirota reported in International Business Times that Jeb Bush steered Florida’s pension funds toward campaign contributors. He also pressed for legislation to shield these contributions from public view.
Sirota wrote:
Jeb Bush received the request from one of his campaign contributors, a man who made his living managing money: Could the then-governor of Florida make an introduction to state pension overseers? The donor was angling to gain some of the state’s investment for his private fund.
It was 2003, still a few years before regulators would begin prosecuting public officials for directing pension investment deals to political allies. Bush obliged, putting the donor, Jon Kislak, in touch with the Florida pension agency’s executive director. Then he followed up personally, according to emails reviewed by the International Business Times, ensuring that Kislak’s proposal was considered by state decision makers.
Here was a moment that at once underscored Jeb Bush’s personal attention to political allies and his embrace of the financial industry, which has delivered large donations to his campaigns. Email records show it was one of a series of such conversations Bush facilitated between pension staff and private companies at a time when his administration was shifting billions of dollars of state pension money — the retirement savings for teachers, firefighters and cops — into the control of financial firms.
Florida officials say Kislak’s firm was not among the beneficiaries of that shift. But verifying that assertion is virtually impossible for an ordinary citizen by dint of another hallmark of Bush’s governorship: At the same time that he entrusted Wall Street with Florida retirement money, he also championed legislation that placed the state’s pension portfolio behind a wall of secrecy.
The anti-privatization organization “In the Public Interest” filed a public records request and obtained emails between Bush’s Foundation for Educational Excellence and public officials. Read them here.
When Jeb Bush was governor of Florida, his brother, Neal, handled all the testing materials – quite a lucrative business – as alluded to in my recent novel about a teacher who opposes THE TEST – The Geography Bee. Dr. Marie FOnzi
There are many, many ways to manipulate test scores and one favorite is holding kids back so they are older when they take the test.
I remember once a Los Angeles school was declared a “miracle” and the principal was given a lot of credit and even received a job in Sacramento for her “success.” Well, I looked into it and discovered that she retained almost all first graders!
OMG…
Yvonne Siu-Runyan: variations of this practice have been around for a while.
From the contribution by George Woods to MANY CHILDREN LEFT BEHIND: HOW THE NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND ACT IS DAMAGING OUR CHILDREN AND OUR SCHOOLS (2004, pp. 37-38), in a section called “School Pushouts, Dropouts, and Retentions”:
[start]
… There is little educational research as conclusive as that on school retention. The evidence is clear—when students are retained in the same grade for more than one year the likelihood that they will drop out rises dramatically. While students have always been retained, retention seems to be reaching epidemic proportions. Nationwide there is a growing bulge of students in the ninth grade, leading, not surprisingly, to a growing rate of student attrition between ninth and tenth grades.
What does testing have to do with this? First, states are now retaining, by law, elementary students if they do not pass a standardized test, usually one in reading. Flying in the face of all the clear evidence on how children learn to read at different ages, the test and measure pattern of one-size-test-fits-all puts children who come to reading later in peril of being retained. With older students, schools are actually holding students back in grade so that they avoid taking the mandated tests and the school’s overall passing rate looks better. Stories such as that of Perla A., one of what is thought to be as many as 60 percent of Houston ninth graders retained to avoid a tenth grade test, is not unusual:
Perla passed all her courses save one, Algebra, in ninth grade. But when she returned the following year she was told she would repeat the same grade and courses. Protesting, she was told by her counselor, “Dont worry about it. … I’m just doing my job.” She spent three years in ninth grade, finally passing Algebra in summer school and being promoted right to eleventh grade—past the tenth grade and the all-important test. Lacking the credits to graduate, she dropped out.
[end]
[Original formatting not retained; last paragraph is a quote with a footnote indicating source, in this case “CBS News, Sixty Minutes, 7 January 2004.”]
How much clearer can it be that the self-proclaimed “education reformers” are not just in favor of “measure-and-punish” but also in mandating “punish-by-measurement” or even “measure-to-punish.”
Caveat: not to be confused with the education they ensure for THEIR OWN CHILDREN.
😎
Recently Jeb Bush met with Rick Scott in what was termed an “education summit” by the media. I would loved to have been a fly on that wall. It was more likely a meeting of the vultures looking for ways to pick the bones of public education and send pension funds to cronies for outrageous fees.
His only focus is on making $B on the exploitation of children and creating the StandardizedToxicTesting Bubble. What does he care about kids and the quality of education? None of these CorpProfiteers have fine-tuned this process. When will this bubble burst? Will it Ever? Who will mop up our children’s futures?
American Greed is a well funded ‘Value’.
Of the 50 states how many do not do business with Pearson? I thought Pearson had a corner on the testing market? Texas comes to mind that doesn’t use Pearson now. How many years does the 250 Million contract cover? I thought Pearson was a global Company and did business with about every country in the WORLD. So if Pearson didn’t have the testing contract for Florida who are the other candidates? Also didn’t other companies quote to get the testing business business in Florida? Please feel free to answer all or a few?
Utah’s tests are done by AIR. To my knowledge, Utah does not use Pearson for testing, although the online charter, Connections Academy, is a Pearson product, and, of course, many of the textbooks are Pearson.
Jeb Bush certainly rates highly as a deformer, but those who really need to be rated are the publications and advocates for their twisted and selectively ignorant views and ties to certain billionaires and organizations.
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Texas Education.
I’m just dreading the coverage of the “Florida miracle” because I recall the coverage of the “Texas miracle” with George W Bush. No one even looked at it until after the election, and by then it was US policy and we’ve been following it ever since.
It’s so weird to me that this one family, a family who probably haven’t attended a public school in several generations, have had such a hugely profound effect on every single public school in the country. It doesn’t even matter who you elect- it’s all the Bush family policy anyway. It’s really kind of appalling that we’re on Year 15 of George and Jeb running US public schools. That’s a whole school career for one group of children.
You forgot to mention that Jeb Bush is another “mamas boy” from the dysfunctional codependent Bush family. The hallmark of a codependent family is that they have a shared identity and lack autonomy. So, it is no surprise that brother Neal was profiting by supplying the educational materials in Florida, which was the same with his education materials scandal in Texas.
The pecking order of the Bush family is that Barbara is dominant over Poppy, then the dominance goes down the chain to little Jeb. Do we really want someone running for President who answers to this bizarre dysfunctional chain of people?
You are right! The problem with the cartoon is that it doesn’t show Jeb’s attachment to his codependent family! Maybe the pig should have Barbara’s face on it with Poppy, Neal, George, and little Jeb all attached to the teats and getting their supply from Mama!