Conor Lynch writes in Salon that the rightwing media is having fun blaming liberals and liberal social policies for the unrest that followed the death of Freddie Gray.
He quotes commentators from Fox News who see the civil disorders and riots as the fault of the protestors.
What Lynch points out, however, is that Baltimore (like Detroit) was once a thriving industrial city. As globalization and technological change produced deindustrialization, jobs dried up, especially for those striving to rise from poverty to the working class. The war on drugs, he writes, led to mass incarceration of black men, even though whites use drugs as often as blacks. And then there is the historic residential segregation in Baltimore, enforced by federal, state, and local policies.
Back in the mid-20th century, Baltimore was a booming manufacturing hub, as were many other cities that today have become shadows of their former selves, such as Detroit. In 1916, Bethlehem Steel bought a steel plant in Baltimore, and by the Second World War, more than a quarter of a million people were employed in the city’s manufacturing industry. This was the so-called Golden Age of American capitalism, where manufacturing accounted for 50 percent of corporate profits and 30 percent of American employment. Today, by contrast, industry profits have dropped to about 20 percent, and employment has dropped to less than 10 percent. This is not a phenomenon unique to Baltimore — the process of deindustrialization has occurred throughout America, turning formerly thriving cities into impoverished ghost towns.
There are various reasons for why America’s manufacturing industry has fallen from grace, but the two major ones are globalization and technological innovation. Globalization, which really began to take off in the ’70s and ’80s, has made capital much more flexible, and today many companies choose to produce in developing countries where labor costs are significantly lower, owing in large part to scant protection for workers, who make a fraction of what it would take to live a decent middle-class lifestyle. Technology has been even worse for America’s middle class; it has been reported that the great advancements in computer and robotic technology over the past few decades have hollowed out the middle class and destroyed jobs faster than it created them.
Baltimore was hit hard by deindustrialization – in the latter half of the 20th century its industrial workforce was depleted by 75 percent. And as manufacturing jobs left, so did the middle class and white Baltimoreans. Since the death of manufacturing in the city, the economy became a service-based one, and the incomes have dropped significantly.
This is not the story you will hear on Fox News. But it is the context you need to know.
Mr Lynch is wrong.
It is the fault of teachers. And unions, of course.
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Texas Education.
A classic by Randy Newman, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yhdh8kSM7lY
This happens in every western country. Look at Great Britain. Either protect the workers or become a socialist country or put up with a high amount of social unrest. Learn from what happens in any country. It isn’t a race thing. It is an economic thing, like it or not. No way to educate out of it. There is a decline in jobs for the educated.
In any case, when I began teaching in South East L. A. in 1979, I wondered why we weren’t teaching all these students CAD and programming and computer aided cartooning. The students would have been receptive, even in M. S. and there was a need in industry at that time. I do not think politicians are interested in actually educating kids as they are in talking about educating kids. And the public has no concernt in general. Eligible American voters are just not interested, having taken their image of America for granted for so long.
You won’t hear it on ABC, NBC, CNN or MSNBC told that way either. You could have heard it told that way several times in the past week on XM 115, 124, and 125. Anyone that is awake could have written this article and it adds nothing except another Fox bashing opportunity for the oh- so-tolerant Salon. Lynch didn’t bother with the details, West Coast Teacher got it exactly correct, and the Randy Newman song is better than Lynch’s article. Having taught and lived in B’More since 1977 I can tell you that the industrial jobs left no doubt and there hasn’t been one administration that has ever cared enough about the West and NE parts of town to replace those jobs with anything close to comparable in compensation or hope for the future. And I know it is disappointing for Lynch but you can lay that directly on the doorstep of the politicians running the city. We’ve had black and white mayors and governors, doesn’t matter. America doesn’t manage cities, the cities manage themselves. I left B’More as a teacher because I wanted to have a family and the fact is my salary is determined by the taxes collected. A transfer to another county yielded a 12K salary increase for me and the thought that I would make enough money to support a family. Baltimore will never get out of it’s own way until that tax base increases. My suggestion is more relevant jobs, not more of the same decades old policies in his anti-Fox fever Lynch contradicted himself on this). And if West Coast Teacher would, he/she should become the Supe. I stopped commenting here and at HuffPo, Daily Kos because I have never interacted with more intolerant, smug, condescending, and rude people anywhere on earth so I’m leaving my stats so the long knives can come out: SAT 1100 before it was dumbed down, BS from OSwego State University which might as well be Canada, MS from Johns Hopkins, high school AVG 93, college QPA undegrad 2.75/grad3.9, registered Democrat but only for this year so I can vote against Billary, last year I took a quiz that said I was a libertarian but Stossel cured me of that. I miss Crunchy Mama and Labor Lawyer, hope they still write.
For a discussion of where the tax base has gone, about who has invested in the city, where, and with what consequences, here is some history and what at least one new Baltimore billionaire wants. I am not a resident of Baltimore, but this is from someone who is a resident.
http://archplanbaltimore.blogspot.com/2015/03/do-cities-need-sugar-daddies.html
I have heard some comparisons….not very much on the mark…..about Ferguson and Baltimore this week. I do not know for sure…..but it appears to me that compared to S
t. Louis……….Baltimore keeps a much tighter rein on Charter schools……..Missouri is lining up the big shots….without much fanfare……and Missouri is going to get rolled by the charter entrepreneurs in the next two years. Including the area in the county close to Ferguson.
The second wave is deprofessionalization. Many professional jobs are candidates for displacement by technology. It is a “good enough” philosophy of business, particularly service oriented jobs. Not individualized, high quality care, but service levels always just above the point where customers revolt.
Legal documents and decisions are generated by rules based engines. Medical diagnosis is handled by Watson like front ends in a mall kiosk with call center PAs multitasking. Or surgery is robotics based. Accounting is a vast interconnected electronic commerce network. And we know how teachers are replaced. On and on. To maintain a human centered society will take a purposeful effort.
In defense of the right and just for fairness it should be noted that the Dems are most responsible for opening up free trade and are intent on doing it again in few months. It is a bravado gesture by liberal presidents which has cost our country dearly. Stop the fast track trade bill or at least slow it down.
Lynch’s analysis is useful. But there are more direct connections to the educational issues on which this blog focuses. A Maryland judge had found that the state had unlawfully underfunded the city schools by $400 million to $800 million between 2000 and 2004. Then the Governor at the time and now “presidential candidate. Martin O’Malley, froze the inflationary increases provided to school systems under 2007 legislation. In Baltimore, that freeze, the Baltimore Sun estimated, came to a $50 million budget shortfall. So the issue isn’t only earlier deindustrialization, but current policies designed to starve schools of poverty, as in Baltimore.
Excellent piece of information . It reminds me of my first trip to Boston many years ago when I was only nineteen. I grew up in prosperous and modernized California. I was astounded by how static the economy was in East Coast cities. Perhaps there needs to me more intermingling of the people and business from all the states to promote progress. A wise president would try to create more dialog between the states. My spouse is from Toledo Ohio and learning about the trials and tribulations of this city and state is mind blowing for someone from the West. It seems we do not know enough about people in our own country.