Archives for the month of: February, 2015

Rick Perlstein reports that Chicago is the national leader in privatization of public property and services. Mayor Rahm Emanuel has become the master of privatization, building on his predecessor’s legacy.

This is an eye-popping article. It begins like this:

“In June of 2013, Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel made a new appointment to the city’s seven-member school board to replace billionaire heiress Penny Pritzker, who’d decamped to run President Barack Obama’s Department of Commerce. The appointee, Deborah H. Quazzo, is a founder of an investment firm called GSV Advisors, a business whose goal—her cofounder has been paraphrased by Reuters as saying—is to drum up venture capital for “an education revolution in which public schools outsource to private vendors such critical tasks as teaching math, educating disabled students, even writing report cards.”

“GSV Advisors has a sister firm, GSV Capital, that holds ownership stakes in education technology companies like “Knewton,” which sells software that replaces the functions of flesh-and-blood teachers. Since joining the school board, Quazzo has invested her own money in companies that sell curricular materials to public schools in 11 states on a subscription basis.

“In other words, a key decision-maker for Chicago’s public schools makes money when school boards decide to sell off the functions of public schools.

“She’s not alone. For over a decade now, Chicago has been the epicenter of the fashionable trend of “privatization”—the transfer of the ownership or operation of resources that belong to all of us, like schools, roads and government services, to companies that use them to turn a profit. Chicago’s privatization mania began during Mayor Richard M. Daley’s administration, which ran from 1989 to 2011. Under his successor, Rahm Emanuel, the trend has continued apace. For Rahm’s investment banker buddies, the trend has been a boon. For citizens? Not so much.”

Knewton, as you may recall, is a leader in data mining, collecting information about children and using it to develop and market products.

Peter Greene has done an amazing investigative review of the Boston Consulting Group. What is BCG? Why do reformers in so many cities hire this management consulting firm? What is its connection to the Gates Foundation and Arne Duncan?

Greene writes:

“Word went out today that immediately after Arkansas decided to make Little Rock Schools non-public, the Walton family called a “focus group” meeting “in conjunction with the Boston Consulting Group. This is worse than finding the slender man in the back of your family portrait. For a public school system, this is finding the grim reaper at your front door. And he’s not selling cookies.”

Greene reveals BCG’s business strategies, which are totally inappropriate for education but beloved by reformers.

“Bottom line? Say a little prayer for the formerly public schools of Little Rock, because BCG is in town and they’re sharpening their axe.”

Karen Lewis Speech to City Club Today
BY CTU COMMUNICATIONS | 02/02/2015

CTU President Karen Lewis releases new blueprint for
Chicago and the ‘soul’ of public education

CHICAGO – Before a sold-out audience of City Club of Chicago, today Chicago Teachers Union President Karen Lewis unveiled a new plan to level the playing field for thousands of students and their families as the city inches closer to the municipal election. “A Just Chicago: Fighting for the City Our Students Deserve,” serves as a challenge to the status quo—Mayor Rahm Emanuel, Illinois Governor Bruce Rauner, and others—to do what is morally just and protect the interest of working families, while fostering policies that eradicate poverty, inequality and racial injustice in our city and state.

The full “Just Chicago,” report can be found on the union’s website at http://www.ctunet.com. The text of her City Club speech follows:

I cannot tell you how happy I am to be here with you today. It is always a pleasure to be among my good friends at the City Club of Chicago. I can also tell you it’s better to be seen than viewed.

And, for the last few weeks I’ve been sharing an old Jewish joke that I came across: It says…If you want to make God laugh, tell Him your plans.

I had a plan—or so I thought. I was planning on running for mayor; and in doing so I intended to lift the voices of the marginalized people in this city who remain ignored and overlooked by the current administration. That means I was planning on beating the incumbent to help restore justice, equity and democracy on the 5th Floor of City Hall. That also meant that if my mayoral motorcade was blowing through red lights, I was planning on digging deep into my purse to pay those fines.

Do I regret not being able to implement my plan? Regret is too strong a word. I have no regrets.

At least I made God laugh.

If anything, this experience has made me even more compassionate toward those who have greater challenges before them. Having a greater capacity for compassion will make me into a stronger leader, not just in my union, but also in my community and in my nation. While there were no bright lights and no visions of my 61 years flashing before my eyes, my health scare has done much to increase my focus. I have a renewed outlook.

I can also tell you that when the doctors presented us with the diagnosis, I didn’t worry about what would happen to me. I was more concerned about my husband, John, and what would happen to the tens of thousands of people across this city who are crying for new political leadership; the people who were building a movement for a more just Chicago; the same people who were counting on me to take on the mayor.

I’ve gotta say this. Can I say this? It was a little odd watching the news and seeing reporters speaking of me in past tense. I kept pinching myself—thinking, “I’m still here right? Is there something someone wants to tell me—because if this is the afterlife, it looks awfully like my dining room.”

So for me, this was just another challenge. Another fight even if this time it is very personal. And, you know I’ve been underestimated before. So even though I couldn’t run for mayor I knew it was not the end of the world—it was an unfortunate moment in our movement. All we had to do now was switch lanes.

That is why I asked Commissioner Garcia to mount a campaign for mayor. I knew Chuy would be able to fight for what our City deserves. For more than three decades he’s been in the forefront of strengthening neighborhoods. He is the leader with a keen understanding of the financial crisis looming in Chicago and yet he possesses the moral courage to make the really tough choice of not throwing poor people and working families under a CTA bus.

We just switched lanes. This is sort of a relay race—and I simply passed the baton to the better runner ahead of me.

That is also why I’m backing several people for City Council including members of the Progressive Caucus. I am also supporting everyday people who have the courage to stand up for what they believe, like David Moore in the 17th Ward; and teachers, clinicians and members of the Chicago Teachers Union like Tara Stamps in 37, Sue Sadlowski Garza in 10 and Tim Meegan in 33. People are tired of status quo aldermanic cheerleaders who are beholden to the mayor and his crazy “hedge fund homies.”

They are tired of being represented by people who agree with privatizing public assets; those stealing our pensions while they protect their own; those City Council members who think it’s okay to vilify hard working teachers, paraprofessionals and clinicians. People are tired of City Council members who are complicit by their silence as the mayor’s hand-picked board closed 50 schools; complicit in their silence as the city engages in charter madness. People are tired of elected officials who think it okay to lie to the President of the United States about the length of our school day because they are desperate to win. I think it is a shame when the President goes on the radio to repeat a lie that Jonah Edelman already admitted (at the Aspen Institute) that this was something he made up and the mayor just took it and ran with it.

The longer school day myth is just as bad as the “STEM” myth being propagandized across the country. I’d like to know where are all of these vacancies that are going unfilled—when Microsoft lays off 18,000 workers, and high-tech companies continue to outsource to other countries. STEM is just another tactic of the ruling class to decrease wages in this protracted war on the middle-class.

You know, as I think of it: It is patently unfair that these people get to clamor for the heads of teachers —as they call for accountability by looking at high-stakes test scores—yet we can only hold these people accountable every four years. And who holds the venture capitalists responsible? Who has been held responsible for the foreclosure crisis that saw the greatest reduction of wealth among the middle class in our nation’s history? Who has been held accountable for the rampant pension thefts? For the destruction of American jobs? For the unjust murders of unarmed Black men?

Their education policies have been disastrous from New York to L.A. Their private-public partnership means PRIVATE: employees will be overworked and underpaid and living in constant fear of losing their jobs; and, PUBLIC: no jobs, attacks on pensions, benefits and health care. (I got a bill for $78,000. I have reasonable health care; what happens to the families who are one illness away from catastrophic disaster and financial ruin.) Something is wrong in our nation when the top 1 percent continue to siphon every resource available from the 99 percent trapped on the bottom rung. And sending kids to charter schools is not going to change that.

I guess this private-public crowd is happy now that one of their buddies was able to purchase a tenth house—the governor’s mansion in Springfield. Bruce Rauner ran on a platform about nothing. Yet, in the days of his taking the oath of office, the real Rauner is starting to emerge. He’s wasted no time attacking the wages of working-class people; attacking their labor unions; and threatening massive cuts to social service programs which help the most vulnerable people in our state. That is the real Bruce Rauner. He is not some easy-going-blue-jeans and $20-dollar-watch-wearing good guy who’s coming in to save the day.

He is Scott Walker on steroids. He is a person who has made it a mission to vilify the Chicago Teachers Union for no other reason than our opposition to the vicious attacks on our character, classrooms and students. We won’t apologize for standing up for what is right for our children. We will not ever be silent in the face of austerity.

This is a governor who has admitted that he is only interested in “the Strivers.” This means the Real Rauner thinks that only certain people are worthy of a high quality education. He does not believe that every child should have one—only those he deems “the Strivers.” This type of thinking will only further class divisions and increase conflicts.

The Real Rauner is also busy trying to make the term “collective bargaining” into dirty words.

If there is any silver lining, it is in the fact that no governor can rule by fiat. He’s going to have to learn to work with the General Assembly. He’s going to have to learn to listen to everyday citizens, that he spent nearly $30 million of his own money to represent. He’s going to have to learn to work with organized labor.

The Chicago Teachers Union is currently negotiating its new bargaining agreement. We’re in the early stages right now. We don’t know if the mayor’s handpicked Board of Education will make the same mistakes it made three years ago that sent 30,000 educators to the picket line. If they do, I assure you, we will be prepared. Ultimately, it is up to them. We met their threshold before—and we can meet it again.

There’s some guy in the Illinois General Assembly who got the bright idea to try to pass the same kind of threshold legislation, SB7 type of thing for districts throughout the rest of the state. Someone call him up and tell him not to do this. Tell him not to poke the bear. He shouldn’t do that to people who can read and do math.

Make no mistake about it—teachers and other school employees are demoralized because there are climates of fear in our schools. While we were able to win considerable gains in the last contract, other problems are crippling our district. Principals, covered by autonomy, are able to segregate their faculties. Lane Tech, where I taught chemistry, and my husband taught for 28 years, has not a single Black male teacher. Only one person on the staff is over the age of 40. Principals are enticed with a form of merit pay. This competition for coins leads them to create conditions in their buildings that are adverse to collaboration. Some principals are so far gone that they believe teachers should stand on their feet all day—no desk. No “random acts of teaching.”

They want “Stepford Teachers” and “Children of the Corn”—kids who are compliant and will not challenge authority or the system on eradicating inequality, poverty and injustice.

The district is focused on testing, testing, testing. We are boring children to death.

Testing does nothing but show you the educational attainment of the child’s mother. We don’t even get to see the test results. Why? What is the point of all of this testing? These tests are what they are using to ruin people’s lives–adults and children; and then they run around saying, “I’m for the kids.” We have been talking about a crisis in education since I was a baby. We continue to brand public education as a failure. Why are we telling these lies?

In the coming days we will present our contract demands and what type of investment the Board will make to ensure every child has a world-class education. If you want well-resourced schools, educators with tenure and job security it is going to cost money. We shouldn’t shy away from this. Great working conditions for educators are also great learning conditions for our students.

Our new contract will reflect our values as educators. The election is about the same values. We stand in solidarity with every parent in calling for more resources; with every LSC leader who champions the cause of true education; with every activist working to strengthen their communities, despite rampant disinvestment and political meddling. The movement we have started in Chicago will intensify and expand. That is why today we are releasing our blueprint —“A Just Chicago: Fighting for the City our Students Deserve.”

In the area of employment, a just Chicago would:

eliminate employment discrimination, guarantee jobs that pay a living wage, and provide health insurance for families of Chicago’s students
offer racially and economically integrated schools with vibrant curricula for all students
In the area of justice, a just Chicago would:

end discrimination in arrests and sentencing and provide alternatives to imprisonment for non-violent offenders
treat first-time, non-violent drug offenders instead of jailing them
provide troubled students with additional counselors, social support services, and programs that implement restorative justice practices in the schools
make available mentoring programs, summer jobs, and school based mental health clinics to help address the impact of neighborhood violence
have a democratically elected, representative civilian police review board
In the area of housing, a just Chicago would:

address the affordable housing and crisis of Students in Temporary Living Situations
greatly increase the numbers of affordable and homeless housing units built across the city, including in wealthier and highly resourced neighborhoods
create affordable rental housing, regularly inspected for building code violations, with decreased numbers of evictions
In the area of health, a just Chicago would:

provide trauma centers, urgent care clinics, mental health clinics and other needed health care centers in all neighborhoods, particularly those currently lacking health services
rebuild the diminished lead poisoning prevention programs, increase the number of school-based health clinics and increase the staffing levels of nurses, social workers, and other school clinicians
In the area of education, a just Chicago would:

insist on equitable funding policies, including taxes on financial transactions and reduced dependence on property taxes
provide full day, developmentally appropriate pre-kindergarten to all who wanted it, but not use pre-K to enrich financial companies with public money
guarantee full funding for every school, and
have an democratically elected, representative school board.
This is what we want on February 24. This is what we want in our contract.

Thank you again. And, a special thanks to my husband John, who has been my rock through this ordeal, to CTU officers Jesse, Michael and Kristine for their friendship and leadership during this transition period; and Audrey, my executive assistant, CTU’s communications director Stephanie Gadlin and all of the exceptional staff at the Chicago Teachers Union for their hard work, dedication, leadership and support.

Thank you.

The party for “More Than a Score: The New Uprising Against High-Stakes Testing” will be held at the Powerhouse in Dumbo in Brooklyn.

 

 

37 Main Street

 

7 p.m.

 

Open the link for directions.

Philadelphia will hire at least 400 new teachers next fall to replace those who have retired or resigned. For years, the district has closed schools and laid off teachers.

The public schools have only 11 librarians,.

If you are in Canada or Oregon or Arizona, you can skip this post. If you are in or near Néw York City, please come to a book party tonight at 7 pm for Jesse Hagopian’s “More Than a Score,” a collection of essays about the new uprising against high-stakes testing. Jesse was a leader of the teachers’ boycott of MAP testing at Garfield High School in Seattle.

The book party will be held at a bookstore in Dumbo in Brooklyn called the Powerhouse at 37 Main Street at 7 pm.

Brave the sleet, snow, and ice to be inspired.

Mike Klonsky reports on a study of Rahm Emanuel’s unprecedented closing of 50 schools in one fell swoop.

Did the children end up in better schools or not?

Rahm’s school superintendent Barbara Byrd-Bennett says yes. She says:

“…the report “demonstrates that we kept our promises and upheld our commitments to our students and school communities… These results are based on the strategic, thoughtful, coordinated approach we took to managing the transition process.”

But:

“”I think the main takeaway for us, or for me at least, is nearly all the displaced students attended schools that were higher performing than the closed ones. But those schools were not substantially better than the ones that closed,” said Marisa de la Torre, one of the study’s authors.

“The things that keep coming back again and again are these issues of safety and transportation and not enough good options near where the families live.”

Mike asks:

“Are we looking at the same study?”

A group of alternative certification programs, the most significant of them being Teach for America, declared their support for the Obama administration’s plan to grade colleges of education by the test scores of the students taught by their graduates. Alternative certification teachers typically do not go to colleges of education, which is why their certification is “alternative.” Their decision to weigh in on this issue, which does not affect them, is no doubt intended to shutter the teacher prep programs where students study education for one or more years. It also is an expression of their support for value-added-measurement (VAM), which does not affect alternatively certified teachers who enter the classroom for only one or two years because they are not in teaching long enough to produce data by which to be evaluated.

 

The Department of Education’s proposal would make test scores the overriding purpose of education. Courses in child development, cognitive theory, the history and politics of education, psychometrics, and other studies that are usually part of teacher preparation, would be irrelevant as compared to test prep. Test prep is the specialty of the “graduate” schools (like Relay) that prepare charter school teachers, where many TFA teachers teach. The proposal would also discourage teachers from taking assignments in hard-to-staff schools or teaching students with disabilities, where it is harder to raise test scores, as compared to suburban districts and non-disabled students.

 

The groups represent (at most) 80,000 teachers out of more than 3 million teachers. Their proposal does not affect their own members. It supports junk science.

 

According to the Education Department plan, programs that train teachers would collect data on items such as the teaching performance of their graduates in the job market and track the exam scores of the graduates’ students—an approach challenged by teachers’ unions and many in the teacher-preparation business.

 

“This is neither a valid nor reliable way of assessing teacher quality,” Kevin Kumashiro, dean of the University of San Francisco’s School of Education, said in an interview, referring to the regulations. In a National Education Policy Center review last month, he argued that the proposed regulations would, among other things, too narrowly define the role of a teacher.

Is it time to put the brakes on the number of standardized tests that students must take? In this article, Pennsylvania legislators say that the graduation rate will decline if state testing requirements are left in place.

“By 2017, in order to graduate high school in Pennsylvania, students must pass three state standardized tests: algebra, literature and biology.

Based on most recent student scores — especially in biology — if trends continue, Pennsylvania will soon see far fewer of its students walking down the aisle in cap and gown.

“In order to preempt that reality, state Rep. Mike Tobash (R-Dauphin County) has introduced a bill that would repeal the state-mandated graduation requirement, leaving the decision to local school districts.

“The children of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, they need to learn, they need to be assessed, but when we’ve gone so far that we end up handcuffing our educational system with really an overwhelming amount of standardized assessment,” said Tobash. “We need to stop and put the brakes on here, take a look at it.”

“The bill would also halt the creation and implementation of the seven other subject-specific Keystone exams called for by existing state law.

Tobash, who testified on the matter at a hearing at Philadelphia City Hall in November, is skeptical that the tests are actually judging students on material that’s applicable to modern workforce.”

To friends in Washington State: Join the struggle against high-stakes testing at a rally in Olympia on February 16. Now is the time to speak and be heard in alliance with other teachers and parents. Enough is enough!

In Denver last July, the National Education Association Representative Assembly supported a campaign that would end the test, blame, and punish system that has become prevalent in public education over the past ten years. The resolution to end “toxic testing” is a powerful statement and a step we must to take to protect our students. Along with this business item, another passed that would share with educators, the rights parents have when it comes to standardized testing and their children.

At the Washington Education Association Representative Assembly in Spokane, support for parents who refuse testing for their children, also passed. A strong connection between parents and educators needs to be fostered and nurtured if the removal of toxic testing is to be realized.

To that end, a group of parents, teachers, education support professionals, and concerned citizens have banded together and are ready to step it up in order to raise awareness about testing, parental rights, and how to get support when opting out. A rally is planned for February 16, noon-3PM, in Sylvester Park in Olympia. The event includes speakers and entertainment. All who attend are encouraged to set up meetings to lobby their legislators, in an effort to end testing madness.

We need you to join us in this battle! Getting educators, parents, and students to the rally is very important. Raising awareness of parental rights is powerful. So many teachers are scared to say anything about this option due to repercussions from their districts. Concerned citizens from all areas of public education must work together so that the message can ring loud and clear: Stop toxic testing!

What we ask from you:

1. Share with your organization

a. The rally is on Presidents’ Day so what better way to make a statement than to get people to show up!

2. Get involved—Contact Becca Ritchie at r.ritchie@comcast.net if you would like to help with planning, logistics, or any other part of the rally.

3. Reach out to parents, community members, and educators who would be willing to learn about testing and/or join in this action.

4. Arrangements for donations to cover organizing costs to can be arranged through Michael Peña at waoptout@gmail.com

5. Have a sign making party to share ideas for signs to use the day of the rally.

6. Contact Shannon Ergun at LincolnTEA@hotmail.com when your organization endorses the rally.

Let’s stand together, and with a collective voice, let it be known that we will not subject our students to the toxic testing environment that has overshadowed the many joys of teaching and learning.

In Solidarity,
All 720 Washington BATs