Two Tulsa teachers risked their jobs by refusing to administer state tests to their first grade students, reports John Thompson.
Karen Hendren and Nikki Jones hereby join the blog’s honor roll as heroes if American children, defending the rights and childhood of their students.
He writes:
“These first grade teachers, Miss Karen Hendren and Mrs. Nikki Jones were featured in a front page Tulsa World and the United Opt Out web site. They wrote an open letter to parents documenting the damage being done by testing and the new value-added evaluation system being implemented by the Tulsa schools under the guidance of the Gates Foundation.
“Miss Hendren and Mrs. Jones explain how this obsession with testing “has robbed us of our ethics. They are robbing children of their educational liberties.” Our poorest kids are falling further behind because they are being robbed of reading instruction. By Hendren’s and Jones’ estimate, their students lose 288 hours or 72 days of school to testing!
“They inventory the logistics of administering five sets of first grade tests, as classes are prepared for high-stakes third grade reading tests. More importantly, they described the brutality of the process.
“Miss Hendren and Mrs. Jones recount the strengths of four students who are victims of the testing mania. One pulls his hair, two cry, one throws his chair, and the fourth, who could be categorized as gifted and talented, is dismayed that his scores are low, despite his mastery of so many subjects. Particularly interesting was the way that “adaptive” testing, which is supposed to be a more constructive, individualized assessment, inevitably results in students reaching their failure level, often prompting discouragement or, even, despair….”
Their superintendent Keith Ballard is no fan of high-stakes testing. But he has a problem: he accepted Gates money:
“Tulsa has an otherwise excellent superintendent, Keith Ballard, who has opposed state level testing abuses. He has invested in high-quality early education and full-service community schools. Ballard also deserves credit for investing in the socio-emotional. I doubt he would be perpetuating this bubble-in outrage if he had a choice. But Tulsa accepted the Gates Foundation’s grant money. So, Ballard is threatening the teachers’ jobs.”
Will Superintendent Ballard listen to his professional ethics or to the Gates Foundation?

This looks like a situation to follow. When hasn’t the Gates’ money won with regards to this? Standing ovation to the courageous teachers.
LikeLike
“Tulsa has an otherwise excellent superintendent, Keith Ballard….”
Yes, but other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how did you enjoy the play?
LikeLike
Superintendent’s immediate response (Gates should be happy): http://www.tulsaworld.com/news/education/story-of-local-teachers-concerns-about-student-surveys-over-testing/article_849d923d-d4db-5757-bdfa-ba5014220b85.html
LikeLike
Based on the crap Ballard spewed in this article, there is nothing “excellent” about him.
“As the public outcry over over-testing begins to build, there is one voice that is not being heard. That is the voice of the child.”
Oh, like you speak for the child? Pul-leaze. I think crying and pulling out hair speaks loudly enough, thanks.
“While I understand the frustration of these beginning teachers, it takes a person experienced at using data to know how to use it to guide instruction.”
What a condescending [redacted for Diane’s benefit].
LikeLike
A true administrator, Dienne, speaking out of both sides of his mouth not willing to stand up for doing what is right by/for the students, only what is right by/for him$elf.
I hear his nickname in Tulsa is “No Balls Ballard”.
LikeLike
Ballard cannot take Gates’ money and also be a good guy.
Throughout history, people have been tested. They reveal their character when they choose their side. Ballard has chosen the side that history will damn.
The entire country sees what’s going on with testing, Gates and Pearson. Ballard sees it, too. But Ballard’s character led him to choose that side anyway, likely for personal gain.
LikeLike
I stand behind these brave teachers. Hopefully, others in the classroom will be encouraged to follow their lead and put children first. Administrator, are you paying attention?
LikeLike
Karen and Nikki are true heroines in this struggle.
LikeLike
They are leading the way and showing the BATS that actions speak louder than words.
Don’t know if they are a part of BATS but they certainly have more BALLS than the average BAT.
LikeLike
That’s not fair, Duane. I am opposing testing in my own way. I would lose my job AND my teaching certification if I did what these courageous teachers are doing. HOWEVER, I quietly encourage opting out, opt out my own children, and refuse to give any test that I can possibly refuse. I know that a lot of other BATs, and non-BATs too, of course, are doing similar things.
LikeLike
ToW,
It may not be “fair” but I call it the way I perceive it.
Yours is a particularly egregious situation as you described many times before. I applaud you for doing what you can within the parameters of the “official party decrees”. Every bit helps. It may not seem like it but it does. I’m thinking that this edudeformer beast will have to die a death of a thousand, no make that a million cuts and it will take time. We have to do it!
I don’t know if I’ll be able to last past this year with the way my administration is dictating all this SGP, SLO, etc. . . “measuring growth” bullshit. But I fight it as I can and refuse to do meaningless nonsense that has nothing to do with the teaching and learning process. I’m thinking the over/under number of disciplinary notices I get this year is 7.
LikeLike
Thanks, Duane. I appreciate your comments. Sometimes it seems like I’m spinning my wheels, so it’s nice to know that someone notices, even if it’s thousands of miles away.
LikeLike
I can only hope that every single teacher in the great state of Oklahoma will stand behind these teachers. Ballard’s statement about new and experienced teachers is his way of trying to put a wedge between the teachers. The Union’s statement is not enough. Every teacher and parents across the state have to stand up to Bill Gates and his $$$$!!!!!
LikeLike
If I may correct your first sentence: “I can only hope that every single teacher in THIS COUNTRY will stand behind these teachers.”
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Diane Ravitch's blog and commented:
The Tulsa Two join the honor roll as heroes of education!
LikeLike
Another reminder of how the children are punished in the name of reform. Called failures – and they don’t know why. Setting the stage for no self-confidence, something that every teacher works on, will make “college and career ready” irrelevant since a student will assume they simply won’t be able to succeed in college or a career – beginning at a very early age.
LikeLike
My view: ONLY when there are sufficient teachers to stand tall together against these egregious actions will we win the fight. Yes indeed, it costs and sometimes costs dearly and one or two persons standing up alone all by themselves will pay that price. I know. It happened to me.
We ask our military to lay their lives on the line for our freedom. In the past union members paid with their lives. It “ain’t” easy but that is what it took and takes now. I do NOT condemn those who cannot pay the price, only point out what seems necessary. At one time unions organized and led the way for the gains made which have made progress for the average citizen. Leadership must come from somewhere. Dr. Ravitch has done her part.
TRUE, freedom isn’t free. There is a cost to be paid and again, that cost can be high.
LikeLike