This is a post by Justin Williams, an educator and resident of Uniondale, Néw York. Uniondale is a highly segregated school district on Long Island in Néw York. 98% of the students in the district are Aftican-American or Latino. Neighboring districts are 95% or more white.
Justin Williams writes:
Rising Violence in Schools Serving Predominantly Black and Latino Students
Over the last ten years, I have worked as a certified English teacher in a high school in Long Island, New York, a suburb of New York City. I am in my seventeenth year working in public education. I have taught various courses in four different school districts on Long Island that range from grades six to twelve. Children and adolescents, whether they are school shooters or gangbangers, do not become violent without cause. None of them were born violent.
I tend to connect the rise in school violence in my suburban school district, 95% of which is African American and Hispanic, to the recent economic downturn and education policy insidiously devoted to teacher, principal and school evaluations tied to standardized testing of students. These students have been exposed to school curriculum, said testing, and “raised” standards (Common Core) conceived by politicians, economists and billionaires, not professional and long-time education practitioners who would know much, much better how to make our public schools the envy of the world (again). They have also been victimized by inflexible “zero tolerance” policies with mandatory minimum suspension periods, as well as increased in-school surveillance and security measures that prepare chocolate and caramel students much more for the realities of prison than they do a safe existence.
I have noticed great family uprooting provoked by the trickle-down effects of the predatory mortgage-lending thievery that targeted chocolate, caramel and other relatively poor folks, all over America. This crime against humanity precipitated global economic catastrophe. American school children were affected too. My students were affected.
Largely (but not only) because of this dreadful event in our history, violence escalated in my community (I live in the town where I work), inside and outside of our schools, largely made up of the same demographic hoodwinked by bankers and lawyers who knew exactly what they were doing yet, remain unpunished. So many of these kids do not or cannot live with their parents (realistically homeless) that new categorical terms like “displaced” or “unaccompanied youth” have been recently coined for them in schools. These kids are angry, don’t feel protected by any adults, yet we’re asking them (forcing them) to do coursework and take tests they cannot and do not wish to do. They need therapy. And skills with which they can function in the workforce.
There have been numerous fights and assaults over the last decade in the secondary settings of my district, steadily escalating in severity. Adult professionals have been grabbed, groped or assaulted. A troubled young man, a recent graduate of our high school, shot himself in the head in a backyard next to mine. I heard the shot clearly. A kid was stabbed in a cafeteria. About two-dozen young men have been killed in our community or neighboring community, school districts with no more than seven thousand kids. I could not find many of these incidents in the local news. I’m talking about a middle class town where the median income is $70,000. This is not a stereotypical ghetto.
Presently and throughout the past two years, a huge influx of Central American kids with harrowing stories to tell of their journeys to New York have and are adding to the socio-emotional quagmire of the schools (students, teachers and administrators are emotionally, morally and ethically drained, strong as we try to be) in my district. Gangs like MS-13 are replenishing their ranks with Hispanic boys adrift in an American ocean of ambivalence aimed squarely in their direction. Others wish to learn enough English so they can work. Too many received little education in their native countries. Few of them are that interested in coming to our schools for anything else, save food. The Common Core has zero relevance to them. Z.E.R.O.
If my students find irrelevant the Common Core, as well as for-profit corporations like Pearson who greatly benefit from its ill effects, then Pearson and the Common Core are irrelevant to me.
I don’t need “the state” telling me how and what to teach. By paying close attention to the dreams, goals and/or likes and dislikes of my students (they always tell you or show you when they know you care), I know precisely what I need to teach, how I need to teach it, and when I ought to do so. When you can get ten or fifteen re-writes on a research assignment from kids prone to extremely disturbing, violent episodes, not only do you have fodder for great work, but you also have young people who are not thinking about being angry (for the time being).
Every teacher cannot and will not become a master teacher. Every doctor cannot and will not become a brain surgeon. Every lawyer cannot and will not become a famous defense attorney. Every mechanic or welder cannot and will not gain his or her own business. Every politician cannot and will not become Commander in Chief.
There is no profession, organization or country that thrives because of its talented tenth. Though often driven by the talented few, average, hard-working people are the engine that makes progress happen. Most teachers are average, hard-working, women committed to educating the children of others. You do not need to be a Marie Curie to teach, any more than you need to be Babe Ruth to be a professional baseball player.
The big failure of the current school reform debate is that creating great teachers is talked about much more than the creation of great homes. But even the very best teachers are unable to perform consistent miracles with our most angry, violent students; no more than a doctor can treat an emotionally volatile patient or a lawyer adequately interview a hostile witness. In these scenarios, the doctor and lawyer are not typically viewed as the areas to be addressed.
Angry, violent, aggressive students, on average, do not come from stable, healthy homes. Schools full of violent kids and fearful adults are rare in societies that are generally non-violent. But blaming professional educators is easy. Re-energizing and empowering the American family unit is harder.
But not impossible.
Justin holds a B.S. in English education and a M.Ed. in education administration from The Pennsylvania State University, a certificate of advanced studies (C.A.S.) in educational leadership from Hofstra University and he is working on a doctorate degree (Ed.D.) in educational and policy leadership at Hofstra University.

Justin is absolutely correct, but the Leadership of our Nation doesn’t/won’t/can’t care.
From their point of view, the growing problems in our schools, to include the growing resistance to the Common Core ethos, seems to justify their continued crusade to reform.
Short of a National Teacher STRIKE, the Leadership of our Nation doesn’t see a problem with what they are doing or at least with what the corporations they have hired are doing.
LikeLike
Don’t wait for NEA/AFT/CTA et al to listen either.
LikeLike
Something else the reform crowd rarely talk about when blaming students and teachers for everything that is wrong Homeless children in America
Executive Summary From “America’s Youngest Outcasts: A Report Card on Child Homelessness
America’s Youngest Outcasts reports on child homelessness in the United States based
on the most recent federal data that comprehensively counts homeless children, using more than 30 variables from over a dozen established data sets.
A staggering 2.5 million children are now homeless each year in America. This historic high represents one in every 30 children in the United States. Child homelessness increased in 31 states and the District of Columbia from 2012 to 2013. Children are homeless in every city, county, and state—every part of our country.
Based on a calculation using the most recent U.S. Department of Education’s count
of homeless children in U.S. public schools and on 2013 U.S. Census data:
• 2,483,539 children experienced homelessness in the U.S. in 2013.
• This represents one in every 30 children in the U.S.
From 2012 to 2013, the number of children experiencing homelessness annually
in the U.S.:
• Increased by 8% nationally.
• Increased in 31 states and the District of Columbia.
• Increased by 10% or more in 13 states and the District of Columbia.
LikeLike
The stats cannot be disputed. The studied disregard for this issue by our political leaders on both sides of the aisle is immoral. The spillover effects become known to teachers by virtue of compulsory attendance laws and the fact that school approximates a safe harbor for some of these students. The “strictly academic” focus and outcomes-only policies of the last several decades–combined with the thefts that tanked the economy and literally displaced many of the most hope-full families from their homes– is the great tragedy of the early 21st century. This writer has the gift to tell the story well. I hope these experiences and the larger themes are at the center of his doctoral studies.
LikeLike
Fabulous statement; so,so true: There is no profession, organization or country that thrives because of its talented tenth. Though often driven by the talented few, average, hard-working people are the engine that makes progress happen. Most teachers are average, hard-working, women committed to educating the children of others.
LikeLike
This post highlights the disconnect between our leaders on the hill and the realities in the lives of poor, troubled students. More testing and accountability are not solutions to the problems these students face. Unless our society wakes up, the school to prison pipeline will continue to swallow young, minority men.
LikeLike
Off-topic, but related – another story that shows how medicine is being killed just like education, and for the same reasons: http://blogs.pjstar.com/haiti/2014/11/18/incomplete-medical-education/?_ga=1.91860124.728460713.1396143083
LikeLike
Dienne… yes this article about medicine resonates! If money is always the bottom line then we will always put its acquisition above the needs of people. This is tragic.
LikeLike
Common Core testing is doing irreparable damage to the psyche and confidence of NY’s neediest students. By the time the current 8th grade cohort gets to HS, the vast majority of urban poor/children of color, will have experienced abject FAILURE in both MATH and ELA for SIX consecutive school YEARS. Under NCLB and now Race to the Top, NY’s neediest will have experienced a lifetime’s worth of academic beat-downs courtesy of Pearson and Co. What would ever lead them to believe that success is just around the corner as they face CC math and ELA testing in HS? This scenario is being played out as we speak. Any student that perseveres in the face of a hopelessness that was ingrained over six years of test-and-punish policies will be a rare exception to the rule. And advocates for the neediest think that this is a 21st century civil rights grab. Oh what a laugh the reformers must be having over that idea.
LikeLike
I found out today that one of my former students, now a freshman, has just dropped out. We fought to get him services, gave him extra help, supplies, emotional support–you all know the lengths we go for these kids, But no matter what we did for him, passing was elusive-until last year. We took a new entrant, righted his ship as best we could and made him believe in himself. Until the state tests-there was nothing we could do. It is heartbreaking to watch a 14 year old young man cry because of a test. He took that feeling of hopelessness with him to the high school, tried for a quarter, failed and dropped out. American Dream indeed.
LikeLike
Our children are throw aways. Their children are George W. Bushes and John F. Kennedy, Jrs. Nothing makes their children more deserving, but then again, they run, and ruin, the world.
LikeLike
The elementary school in Virginia where I teach special ed is in priority status. This means we are supposed to get a bunch of grants for technology from the federal government and things will be crazy if we don’t cram all this info into the kids’ heads. My guess is that the kids won’t gain ground just from some eventual new technology. It takes time to make changes. I personally hope our scores will drop just to teach the state a lesson!
LikeLike
Great piece. Love his take on teacher quality.
LikeLike
I would like to give our nations’ politicians as well as our education secretary and president one year of lessons in Mandarin Chinese in a topic with which they are unfamiliar – perhaps auto mechanics. At year’s end, let them take high stakes common core tests in all sorts of other subjects they should know about … but in Mandarin Chinese. We shall give them time and 1/2 for their language “handicap”… Wow, they are going to have to read lots of convoluted word problems in what is labeled as “common core math” and they are going to have to write lengthy response essays for the English component and ALL IN MANDARIN! Hmmmmmm let us see how they do! Are they still going to blame teachers? I am addressing the English language learner student populations that live in poverty and are a huge population at our nation’s title one schools. Now let us move on with many of the other problems with this style of “learning” by test… well… this would take A VERY LONG TIME…
So how does making learning extremely “English language dependent” and abstract as in common core aid and assist someone just learning the English language? Maybe our nations’ supposed “experts” aka like Arne Duncan should ask for advice from real experts like Stephen Krashen!
LikeLike
“How common core hurts the neediest students” in the end is about the money trail. All roads these days lead to who is profiting… So if our nation looks at the BIG PICTURE… we need to quickly and radically alter campaign finance reform so that politicians are not able to be bought and sold through the highest bidders. We need to look AT THE BIG PICTURE first. How our nation’s leaders are elected is definitely THE BIG ISSUE. If it serves those financing elections to make profits off our national education policy, then we will continue to have more of the same nonsense being dumped on public schools. Once again, Robert Reich tells it intelligently like it is… read on… think “big picture” first …
http://robertreich.org/post/102926070780
LikeLike