We have all noticed what’s happening in the retail business: the big-box chains like Walmart drive the mom-and-pop stores out of business by cutting prices. At a certain point, you notice that all the little local shops are gone, vacant. The shops in the malls are doing well, but they are not locally owned. They are chain stores.
This approach is now invading the world of charter schools. Textbook case: Camden, Néw Jersey. There, two small charters are being closed by the state as it clears the way for the corporate charter chains: KIPP, Mastery, and Uncommon Schools.
New Jersey blogger Mother Crusader writes here about the latest developments. “Small, independent charters are being given the boot, somewhat unceremoniously and precipitously, to make way for what are essentially big box, prefab, chain Charter Management Organizations (CMOs).”
She adds: “There is a well connected, well funded effort underway, and it seems that not even a change in Commissioner can stop the train that Cerf and his cronies have set in motion.”
Sue Altman, writing for EduShyster, says:
“Be warned, starters of small charters! You may have enjoyed a red-carpet spotlight in the past, but don’t expect much loyalty from reformy fashionistas these days. It’s a school-eat-school world out there, and on the path to global competitiveness and *bigger rigor,* there is no room for last season’s trends. Such is the hard lesson learned recently by City Invincible Charter of Camden, New Jersey, which is being forcibly closed by the state in order to make way for the bigger, more disruptive charter chains.”
A board member of City Invincible Charter said:
“[O]ur public education system is being hijacked not only in Camden, but all over our country. This decision simply exemplifies the circumvention of due process in order to benefit those who are more concerned with expanding their brand or their name or their influence or their pockets.”
He is right.

Say it ain’t so, Joe …
LikeLike
Yes, Joe’s dissembling and/or willful ignorance have always been transparent to those who have not drunk the charter Kool-Aid, or have a basic understanding of business and economics.
It is basic business logic, and openly spoken of by the edu-privateers, that charter chains would eventually “scale-up,” and that the mom-and-pop charters would be euthanized once they’d served their purpose of providing a feel-good narrative to mask the destruction of the public schools.
As for the administrators and teachers of independent charters who are now getting whacked, well, now you know what it’s like to be on the receiving end of these people’s mendacity, infinite greed and will to power.
LikeLike
Michael Fiorillo: you stated what should be obvious in a few very well chosen words.
Bravo!
😏
And it should be taken to heart by the shills and trolls that visit this blog, always trying to give the rest of us “a lesson in safe logic” as Phil Ochs once said.
Please pardon the presumption, but for those affected by Rheeality Distortion Fields, I will give part of your most excellent presentation in standard English a bit of a fractured English translation—
Big fish eat small fish; bigger fish eat big fish; biggest fish eat bigger fish; biggest fish become “too biggest to fail” [hey, I’m talking Rheeformish here!]—but now there’s no more fish small enough to them to eat, so they eventually start dying because they cannot satisfy their insatiable hunger and so begins their effort to take the rest of us down with them. *For those not on Planet Reality: “Hunger” is a euphemism for “zombie-like cravings for $tudent $ucce$$.”*
If I got it wrong, my bad.
Although if I did and you try to hold me ‘accountable’ I will pull out my Paul Vallas teflon defense: “I go in, fix the system, I move on to something else.”
Link: http://www.nbcchicago.com/blogs/ward-room/Paul-Vallas–213999671.html
Thank you so much for your observations.
😎
LikeLike
Only one minor observation T.A., they become to big to notice failure and they get to redefine failure. They can then say that education isn’t about test scores, it is about choice. Of course they mean their choice of where to build and how much to charge, as well as whom to keep in their schools, notice their, not our schools. Shakespeare had it right, the fault is not in our stars…..
LikeLike
Old Teacher: not a minor observation.
Chiara Duggan felicitously calls that “choice not voice” — or as you put it, they have the “voice” to decide what kind of “choice” we have.
Thank you for your comment.
😎
LikeLike
We ain’t seen nothing yet. Wait until the federal building project gets underway. The Louisiana Democrat hopes to build 500 charter schools a year with dedicated federal funding that won’t be available to public schools – in her state, your state, whatever.
“A bill to expand charter school access is expected to receive a broad bipartisan vote in the House this week, a rare departure from polarizing fights over congressional investigations and healthcare.
The bill would free up more federal money for states and localities, and advocates say it would help reduce a national waiting list that has grown to more than 1 million children seeking to enroll in public charter schools.”
The plan is to give the money to national CMO’s, who will run these “local schools”
Congress can’t do anything for public schools other than rush to the microphones to denounce them as “failing” or put in another unfunded mandate but if it’s charter schools they find all kinds of money.
They’ll “investigate” education reform when pigs fly. Never happen. There is bipartisan agreement in DC that public schools should be replaced as quickly as possible with privately-owned, privately-run schools.
Read more: http://thehill.com/blogs/floor-action/house/205521-bipartisan-support-expected-for-charter-school-bill#ixzz348xt2UAI
Follow us: @thehill on Twitter | TheHill on Facebook
LikeLike
It’s getting worse each and every day. But this might also explain why people like Weingarten are turning her back on the public school teachers. Her power and salary are based on how many teachers pay dues, and with the shift going to charters and the possible takeover of all public schools, she is making sure charter teachers organize and join her union.
This explains why she has formed alliances with Reformers and Reform politicians each and every day. This is why so many of her contracts are now based on test scores, VAM and merit pay while including so many contractual givebacks. Not sure, but do TFAs join the union once they are hired for their 2-year substitute service????? And does Wendy Kopp also pay their union bill along with their student loan and housing costs? (not to mention the deals she has with large investment firms to hire these people when their contract is up)?
What Randi hasn’t realized is she is the final target of the Reform Movement. They are just allowing her to play in their schoolyard until they don’t want to play with her any more. This is why Karen Lewis won’t play with them. Karen is building an army while Randi is preparing each and every public school teacher to become pawns.
Reformers to Randi—Checkmate!!
LikeLike
I don’t focus on any labor role because I’m not a teacher or a union member.
I’m a parent who thinks it’s ridiculous and insane that teachers unions are (now) the only entity advocating for public schools. I get that this is always portrayed as “unions versus reformers” but to me that’s just a measure of how public schools have been completely abandoned and are left out of the debate.
I expect lawmakers to consider the needs of public schools. I think it’s their job.
LikeLike
school gal
TFAs here pay union dues like everybody else. Great analysis of Weingarten motives!
LikeLike
The Walmartization of Charters!! And with the help of Congress and the president, and so many governors (so many Democratic governors) this is going to be so easy!!! They are pulling the Parent Trigger Law on their own breed. Gotta love the irony here.
This is quickly becoming the new Mortgage, Prime Rate, scandal. Once every school in America becomes a charter and nothing changes, Wall Street walks away richer, and Main Street is left holding the bag. Even after many of these chains go belly up do to mismanagement, the CEOs can simply close up shop overnight leaving thousands of students without a school and walk away with millions of dollars of taxpayer dollars in their pocket. And like Wall Street, no one gets prosecuted. In fact, our government will even bail these charters out!!!
LikeLike
Interesting context for the disbanding of the Wisconsin Charter Schools Association, which is slated to happen at the end of this month.
http://www.jsonline.com/news/education/group-promoting-wisconsin-charter-schools-to-disband-b99285799z1-262123721.html
I bet the big chains are tired of “having” to try & work together with Wisconsin’s substantial home-grown, chartered-through-the-school-boards charter presence.
LikeLike
I think it’s fascinating how incoherent it is.
It’s about “experimentation!” but the whole focus is on replicability and “scaling up” and national operators.
None of this hangs together. The reality is so different than the hype that at some point there has to be an epic crash.
LikeLike
Meanwhile, Ohio lawmakers continue their laser-like focus on charter schools and private schools and really any other type of schools except the disfavored public schools they have completely abandoned, abandoned except for when they’re rushing to the microphones to denounce public schools, that is:
http://stateimpact.npr.org/ohio/2014/06/06/ohios-public-schools-will-soon-award-credits-for-private-religion-classes/#more-26694
LikeLike
Oh hello chickens you are coming home………
LikeLike
@Randi told me to “stop carping” tonight on Twitter. Nice that someone making 300K thinks it’s okay to get condescending with those of us at the bottom of the food chain.
LikeLike