This wonderful article in the American Educator describes the work of the Dallas Institute of Humanities and Culture, which has been conducting summer seminars for teachers for 30 years.
It opens the story through the eyes of a teacher named Keith Black:
“Instead of being subjected to what he disparagingly calls “PowerPoint drudgery,” Black spent eight hours each day dis- cussing classic works of literature, 17 in all, that he had read the previous three months on his own: Prometheus Bound, Agamem- non, The Libation Bearers, The Eumenides, Antigone, Oedipus the King, Oedipus at Colonus, Peace, Lysistrata, King Lear, Othello, Hamlet, The Tempest, A Midsummer Night’s Dream, Blood Wedding, Crime and Punishment, and Beloved.”
The Dallas Institute does not mention the Common Core or testing or rubrics:
“For 30 years, the Dallas Institute has treated teachers as intellectuals. To that end, the nonprofit educational organization, founded by former faculty members at the University of Dallas, offers teachers from all grade levels and all disciplines—not just English—an experience that either reacquaints them with or introduces them to the literature of Western civilization. The classic works studied are taught at the level of a graduate-school course and do not at all resemble typical professional development. Educators who attend this program rise to the challenge of engaging in insightful discussions about these complicated texts. In fact, they hunger to do so.
“Teachers work with human material, and the best way traditionally to gain access to human things is through the humani- ties, which are the foundation of a liberal arts education,” says Claudia Allums, who directs the Summer Institute. But a liberal arts education encompasses more than literature or philosophy or history courses, she says. It’s a particular spirit with which one approaches any discipline. “If a teacher has a broad, strong liberal arts education, then he or she is going to have a broad, strong foundation in human sensibilities. That’s the foundation we believe is important for any teacher’s wisdom.”
“Today, that belief is not widely shared. With the overwhelming focus on testing and measuring, it’s rare to hear words such as “wisdom,” “humanities,” and “human sensibilities” in relation to public education. Occasionally, reports like The Heart of the Matter: The Humanities and Social Sciences for a Vibrant, Competitive, and Secure Nation,2 published last year by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, will decry the narrowing of the curriculum and call for a renewed emphasis on the liberal arts and their importance. But in the end, often little will be done to act on these ideas, however noble.”
I visited the the Dallas Institute a few years ago and was exhilarated by the spirit that permeates it: love of learning. Learning for the sake of learning, not for a bonus or a prize. This is a very small island of joy in a land where joy has been banned by federal and state authorities. Here there is intellectual freedom, which is endangered in our society by the powerful plutocrats who prize standardization and the ability to check the right box.
How ironic that the Institute flourishes in Texas, where the educational industrial complex was first launched. It is a small but important form of resistance to the status quo, a place where learning lives and thrives.

If there is an international standard (rule of thumb) for determining whether a curriculum is “excellent” it is this: Does the school offer a balanced program of studies in the arts, sciences, and humanities, K-12?
I find it amazing that in better days this nation set up the National Science Foundation as well as the National Endowment for the Arts and the National Endowment for the Humanities.
I also find it amazing that these agencies, representing major forms of human achievement are totally separate from the Department of Education and have no coordinated interest or voice in stopping the current charade of educational reform.
I suppose that is because the agencies are in competition for funds.
In my wishful thinking, I would love to see someone require these agencies to enlist teachers, scholars, and researchers in proposing four or five models K-12 education, not in detail, but for the purpose of re-envisioning what education is for and for refreshed thinking and conversations about the content, skills, and affinities that public schools should nurture.
Of course, historians and philosophers of education should be present to “educate” the participants so they are not re-inventing the wheel, or if so, are doing so for good reasons.
LikeLike
Such delightfully fresh thinking, Laura!
LikeLike
Laura, great points. I don’t understand why more teachers aren’t alarmed by the bizarre turn that curriculum design has taken since NCLB. Not only is the curriculum narrowed, but it has mutated. Instead of units on poetry or the Gold Rush, we have units on using context clues and other metacognitive strategies. What smart person ever got that way by undergoing such a strange mode of education where content is discarded and unproven literacy strategies become the main fare? This trend seems to be getting exacerbated by the dominant interpretation of Common Core. Just look at a lot of the new Common Core materials (e.g. on the LearnZillion website) that are coming out. THIS is education? Teachers –why aren’t you fighting for the liberal arts against these zombie curricula?
LikeLike
Is this not a paradox that Dallas should host this wonderful seminar for teachers in a district that is about to have a corporate takeover of their schools?
What wishful thinking that we could incorporate programs like this into schools. Too many of our schools now have been taken over by punitive styles of Common Core and Whole Brain that look more like “managing livestock” than authentic creative teaching.
LikeLike
Thank you SO MUCH for this post on the Dallas Summer Institute:
“An island of joy where joy has been banned…” In these Orwellian times I have come to the conclusion that THIS is what we must construct for our children who are living their lives under the thumb of The Test amid the fight for change. Every day we must try to offer some island of joy to our students—Debra Frasier, Author & Illustrator
LikeLike
Wow. This is truly refreshing.
When was the last time you heard of a district doing a “training” that actually dealt with the intellectual CONTENT of English studies, the last time you came away from such a “training” knowing something substantive that you didn’t know before?
I have long thought that we would be getting somewhere when districts stop offering “trainings” (Sit up. Roll over. Good boy.) on crap like Implementing Common Core Close Reading Strategies and Interpreting Your VAM Score and started doing trainings in material like
Key Ideas and Texts from the American Transcendentalists
Film Script Formatting for Middle- and High-School Students
Creating Secure Web Pages with Simple Style Sheets for Publication of Student Writing
New Models in English Grammar II: Theta Roles and Thematic Structure for Analyzing Sentences
Hermeneutics for High-School Classrooms, Five Approaches: New Criticism, Reader Response, Authorial Intention, Deconstruction, and the New Historicism
Discovering Current Collaborative Reading and Writing Communities III: Fan Fiction
Distinguishing among the Truth Conditions for Conclusions of Deductive, Inductive, and Abductive Arguments
Coherence: Relations among Statements in Extended Discourse
The Categories We Think In: Metaphorical Frames and the Ubiquity of “Dead” Metaphor
Rethinking Genre: Natural Prototypes versus Aristotelian Natural Types in the Analysis of Literature
The Archetype of the Hero’s Journey
Motifs of the Folk Tale: the Arne/Thompson System
Masterpieces of Post-Colonial Poetry and Prose
I’ve Got Rhythm: Acquisition versus Explicit Learning of Metrical Forms
Classic Twentieth-Century Dystopian Fiction and Film
The Science and Philosophy of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein
and so on.
LikeLike
I would love to take any or all of these classes!
LikeLike
Thanks for bringing this amazing place to our attention, Diane. I am going to find out more.
LikeLike
What a DELIGHTFUL post. Education is a road that one travels, not a destination ever reached. May I add that BookTV on Cspan 2 which broadcasts for 48 hours on Saturdays and Sundays is a delight. Non fiction authors who have researched their book for 3, 4, 5 years or longer write on all kinds of subjects, something for every palate. Conservative, Liberal, all there. Some authors are better intellectually than others of course. Because someone can write a book does not automatically mean they are “top of the class” intellectually but over all, for me it has been enlightening to a degree never imagined. Actually this is where I first “found” Dr. Ravitch and her book on “The Rise and Fall ….
I HIGHLY recommend watching.
LikeLike