A teacher left this comment on the blog:
I am a teacher and PARENTS have everything to do with joining the dialogue on education (http://parentsacrossamerica.org/ ). And the teachers I see day in and day out want to know what parents think, what they see and hear from their children outside the school environment… we desperately want parents to understand what “reforms” are requiring of teachers nowadays… and that we teachers have not been part of the process at all! Any teachers (as well as “corporate ed reformers” like John King demonstrated in Poughkeepsie) who do not want your observations should be suspect! As far as setting policy, current “ed reformers” have worked hard to “sell their product” to parents via a very tight and highly organized PR machine that works relentlessly through the media and they have worked equally hard at keeping public school teachers away from policy setting dialogue. Someone commented that everyone always brings up the “medicine analogy”… i.e. just because we go to a doctor does not mean we should be setting medical policy etc… Well, everyone has a role to play in setting medical policy – some roles are direct and some less so. A patient can certainly let the medical community know things that do not work so well from a patient perspective and this will help set policy as to how patients should be dealt with so they feel comfortable. But do we want the patient to determine how the MRI machine is operated? Or how much anesthesia should be given to a patient? Sure hope not! Bill Gates, David Coleman, Eli Broad and a host of others have way over-stepped their bounds by creating and implementing education policy!
As a teacher, I dream of parents, students, teachers and fed up administrators joining hands and putting a stop to the “educational” abuse of our nation’s youth through “corporate ed reform” policies. If your child used to love school but no longer is excited about it, if your child is throwing up the night before a high stakes test or getting sick and not wanting to go to school during high stakes testing season… or is afraid to express an opinion on something for fear of “being wrong” or spending way too much time on a take home “vacation packet” designed to help them do better on high stakes tests thus having a stressful “vacation week” at Christmas etc…, join teachers in fighting the nonsense of corporate “ed reform” and find ways to get fellow parents to join in. I sure wish the middle and upper class parents whose students are failing under common core would realize and join hands with low income parents whose students have been suffering a lot longer due to the high stakes tests pre “common core” that their students struggle to pass.
So LT in addition to the cite referenced above http://parentsacrossamerica.org … also take a look at this cite:http://unitedoptout.com/
I think it can be hard for parents to “find a way in”, so I’ll recount my experience.
I volunteered to help with a school bond campaign (it’s going well but it will be close on November 5th). I have some experience with political campaigns and I felt they needed help.
I’ve been working with teachers, administrators and parents who support our public schools for the last three months on it, and it’s really been wonderful. We’ve had great discussions about what we value about our schools in the course of the campaign, and we have literally knocked on every door in the district.
It gave us a chance to explain to people here that we need more local funding because we get very little support from what I consider a federal and state government that has abandoned existing public schools.
It’s also given us a chance to push back against some of the media/reform chorus on “failing schools” – this is not, actually a “failing district”- but of course there’s been a concerted effort to portray all public schools as failing by media and politicians.
We’ve also started to talk about ed reform, and listening I’m able to discern which public school parents are aware that state and federal policy has shifted dramatically away from existing public schools and towards charters and vouchers.
Win or lose in November, it’s been a really worthwhile experience and a “way in”.
The big assumption is that parents are going to agree with you.
The other assumption is that teachers will agree with you. It is really hard for a parent to advocate for her children against teachers and administrators that are toeing the line on testing and core curriculum. It is the child that pays for this resistance.
Thanks Diane for re-posting my comment and links. Sadly, just this week I was in the teacher’s lounge and a wonderful and well loved third grade teacher came in to use the copy machine there. She was teary-eyed after just administering what our county is now calling the MOST test. In her class, one student started crying during the exam and others had looks of total bewilderment on their faces. She told me that the questions were completely developmentally inappropriate and showed me a problem that was more on the level of 6th grade. One student approached her after the tests were collected to repeat wording that he didn’t understand and she could not imagine how an English language learner could ever have gotten beyond the language component of the math problem. When is enough going to be enough. That a teacher would be crying because of what the students were forced to go through because she was required to administer this test… this is very telling. Things are seriously wrong in the land of public education.
artseagal: I worked with teachers just like the one you described.
The edubullies paint the average teacher as [among many other things] selfish, self-centered, lacking empathy for the feelings of their students—
And all they are doing is projection, i.e., they think that others have the same negative traits they have.
I never get tired of reading about teachers on Planet Reality. The caricatures from RheeWorld I could do without, especially when they start waving rolls of masking tape at us and pointing to our mouths…
Thank you for your posting.
🙂
…Someone commented that everyone always brings up the “medicine analogy”… i.e. just because we go to a doctor does not mean we should be setting medical policy etc…
Should doctors set medical policy or business men with no medical training? If “reformers” want to use this analogy, they need to be prepared to answer why they (instead of educators) should be setting educational policy.